Item 4 is an affirmative instrument. I welcome Christine Grahame MSP, who has joined us for items 4 and 5. She is the convener of the cross-party group in the Scottish Parliament on animal welfare, so she has a particular interest in this subject area.I remind members that these amended regulations replace the regulations that were withdrawn by the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment at the meeting of this committee on 25 June 2008, on the basis of concerns raised by members. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has made no comment on the amended regulations.Members can ask questions about the regulations before we move to the formal debate, which is item 5. Officials can respond to questions now, but will not be able to participate in the formal debate. I invite the minister to make a brief opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Licensing of Animal Dealers (Young Cats and Young Dogs) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ian Strachan 6
- Maureen Watt SNP 4
- Liam McArthur LD 2
- Christine Grahame SNP 2
- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 1
- Rhoda Grant Lab 1
- Elaine Murray Lab 1
The record
21 contributionsThe impetus for these regulations came from Christine Grahame's member's bill of some years ago; the regulations are the culmination of a process that she started.The regulations aim to address serious concerns about animal welfare in the trade in young cats and young dogs under the age of 84 days. Dealers who intend to sell such animals in Scotland will first have to obtain a licence from the local authority, which will remain in force for a maximum of three years.Many such young animals are acquired by dealers from puppy farms outwith Scotland and are often in poor health because they have not been given proper care and attention. The regulations will require licence holders who take possession of such young animals to keep them separate from all other animals for 10 days and to have them examined by a veterinary surgeon in the first day of that separation period. That will ensure that treatment for any health problems can be administered before an animal is resold.The regulations will secure the welfare of kittens and puppies that are sold in Scotland. They also address the concerns of the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and other organisations, which have received complaints from the public about the health problems of puppies and kittens that dealers have sold.As the convener said, the committee considered the original regulations in June last year. I hope that the committee accepts the Subordinate Legislation Committee's verdict that the new regulations will do what they are supposed to do and are drafted properly. All the points that that committee raised have been fully addressed and I am happy to re-present the regulations for consideration.
Do committee members have questions?
I understand and welcome the aims of the regulations. What impact will they have on individuals who do not breed animals for sale but who, once in a while, have one or two puppies of a pedigree dog to sell? Would such individuals be required to be licensed?
Anyone who breeds such puppies or kittens will be exempt from the regulations. We have also exempted anyone who sells up to two puppies or kittens in a 12 month period. We deliberately included that exemption to allow for someone who buys a couple of kittens and discovers that doing so was a mistake because the kittens climb up their curtains.
Will the regulations cover rescue kennels and catteries, which sometimes have puppies and kittens to rehome?
No, those establishments are exempted. We exempt rescue sanctuaries, animal sanctuaries and rehoming centres, because whether they are asking for a rehoming fee or selling animals is an issue.
link
I will follow up Rhoda Grant's questions. I have a dog that came from a recognised breeder in Orkney. The breeder's dog is still a family pet, but breeding is perhaps more regular and routine than was suggested in Ian Strachan's response to Rhoda Grant.Nobody disputes the seriousness of the problems. Perhaps the issue comes down to scale as much as anything else. Grey areas exist when breeders are involved in producing quite a number of puppies but when no welfare issue has been raised in the past. How is that being managed?I was slightly concerned to note that the individual from whom we got our dog—that person is fairly well-informed and breeds puppies fairly routinely—was blissfully unaware of the regulations. The consultation appears to have been extensive, but one organisation that is not named as a consultee is the Kennel Club. Was it involved? Did it submit evidence and did it correspond with its members?A limited number of licences is likely to be issued in my constituency. The problem with cost recovery is that recouping the base cost of the licensing structure is far more difficult when the number of people involved is low than when more people are covered by the regulations.
I think that the first point was about dog breeding. Someone who is dog breeding on a commercial scale, which means five or more litters a year, is covered by other dog breeding legislation. The problem was that no legislation covered people who trade in dogs and kittens rather than breed them. People buy litters of puppies from breeders, then sell them on. The dealer was not covered by legislation, but these regulations will plug that gap.The regulations do not stipulate a cost for a licence. We leave it to each local authority to set its own licence cost. The cost needs to be appropriate and reasonable, but it should cover the cost of inspecting, policing and monitoring the scheme. As the minister said, the licence can last for three years, so it will be a one-off cost every three years.
link
I accept what you say, but it almost makes the point about local authority areas with low numbers of dealers, where the cost per licence could be significantly higher than that in other areas. I am not aware of any great incidence or history of dealing in kittens or puppies in Orkney, for example, but I am aware of any number of instances whereby licensing systems have been put in place that are more costly to set up and run in smaller local authorities.
The inspection of pet dealers' premises will be similar to the inspection of dog breeding premises. Although there will be few pet dealers, a number of local authorities will have pet shops and dog breeding establishments to inspect. I anticipate that the licence cost will be on a par with costs for those.
I feel like giving evidence on this issue, having lived with it for a long time. I very much welcome the regulations. I put on the record my thanks to Ross Finnie, a previous minister, who had meetings with me and undertook to produce regulations that would subsume my proposed bill, which is now happening. I also thank Ian Strachan for his tolerance and persistence. We had a number of meetings on the issue.I have one question for clarification, which I am sure I will regret asking. Regulation 6(2) states:"The licensing authority must, before reaching a decision as to whether or not to grant, renew, vary or refuse an animal dealing licence, consider a report made to the authority by an inspector, unless–(a) the applicant does not have premises in Scotland on the date the application is received, in which case no report will be required as no inspection will be carried out".That is obvious. However, regulation 7 states:"The licensing authority may grant or renew an animal dealing licence which must be in writing and must state … the address of the premises where the animals must be kept during the period referred to in regulation 15(1)".If there are no premises, how can there be an address? I am sure that there is a straightforward answer, but I just wondered about that point.
That aspect is to deal with dealers who do not have premises in Scotland but who have premises elsewhere, for instance in Ireland. It was not possible under European legislation legally to construct a regulation to insist that dealers had premises in Scotland. However, we wanted to ensure that, if dealers had premises in Ireland, for instance, the conditions that applied to those premises were the same as the conditions that would apply to premises in Scotland. Although it will not be practical for the licensing authority—in this case, the City of Edinburgh Council—to visit premises in Ireland, nevertheless the dogs must be kept at those premises, which will be detailed on the licence.In addition, the dogs will still have to be seen by a veterinary surgeon within the first 24 hours of the dealer taking possession of them, and be kept in quarantine for 10 days at those premises. The paper trail with the dog will specify the name and address of the vet who conducted the initial examination and the date of the examination.
That is quite interesting, because you are really extending Scottish jurisdiction—strike that from the record! You have found a perfectly legal method of having some kind of regulation. This question may follow on from that. Will there be, or has there been, any kind of co-operation with the southern Irish Government? Are we looking to it to go down the same route? As we know, the evil starts in the euphemistically called puppy farms.
We have had no discussion with the Republic of Ireland Government on the issue. However, as an aside, we have had informal discussions with Republic of Ireland officials on their proposals to introduce new animal welfare legislation, which they are keen to base on the animal welfare legislation that we introduced in 2006.
Item 5 is formal consideration of the motion to recommend approval of the draft regulations. I remind members that officials cannot participate in the debate. I invite the minister to move motion S3M-3502.
Motion moved,
That the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee recommends that the draft Licensing of Animal Dealers (Young Cats and Young Dogs) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 be approved.—Roseanna Cunningham.
Motion agreed to.
I thank the minister, officials, Christine Grahame and members of the public for their attendance.
Meeting continued in private until 12:09.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Mar 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Wednesday 18 March 2009 Committee business · 1
- Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 111
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 10
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 21
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.