Agenda item 3 is also subordinate legislation. This time, we have two negative instruments, on the identification and traceability of sheep and goats—our old friend—and on fees relating to the control of zoonoses. I invite Bill Wilson to correct my pronunciation of that.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Sheep and Goats (Identification and Traceability) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/559) Zoonoses and Animal By-Products (Fees) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/577)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 8
- John Scott Con 4
- Bill Wilson SNP 2
- Peter Peacock Lab 1
- Mike Rumbles LD 1
The record
19 contributionsFar be it from me to do that. I would not have the nerve.
As committee members will remember, SSI 2007/559 was deferred from our last meeting. Correspondence from the Scottish Government and NFU Scotland is provided in paper RAE/S3/08/2/3. I invite comments from members on the correspondence that we have received. The committee has various options in respect of the regulations.
The correspondence has helped to clarify matters. I do not think that we are in a position to oppose the regulations, because the Government would find itself subject to infraction proceedings. That said, the documents are public, and the committee should note the clear disagreement between the NFUS and the Government about the basis of the actual cost to the industry. I find the NFUS's arguments persuasive and factual.More important, for the sake of future preparation by the committee, we should consider the NFUS's point about electronic tagging becoming the big issue for the industry in the future. Perhaps we ought to write to the Government on the matter in advance. We have had notification from the NFUS on the issue, having asked it for its views, and we should begin to prepare ourselves for future changes.
I agree with everything that Peter Peacock has said. There is no real benefit in double tagging. The industry is utterly opposed to it. Even the letter from the minister implies that the methodology that is used in some of the calculations is, at best, suspect. The NFUS is not happy about the matter, from what I can gather.As I said, double tagging does not seem to provide any real benefits. The reason for its introduction is to improve traceability, but I am not even certain that traceability will improve—in fact, it may decrease as a result of the imposition of the new system. With those caveats, I must accept that, because of the possibility of infraction procedures, we cannot do anything other than allow things to go ahead.
I will try to be helpful. The 40-day period for the instrument expires on 6 February, which is the date of our next meeting. Therefore, today's discussion need not necessarily be the final cut. A draft report could be produced for consideration on 6 February.
I suggest that we simply get on with things, because we cannot responsibly put the Government in a position in which it would be liable to infraction proceedings being taken against it. It would be irresponsible for the committee to leave matters to the final day of the 40-day period, given the inevitability that is involved.I utterly agree with Peter Peacock that the electronic tagging system shows every sign of being a disaster—
But that is not what the—
I appreciate that, but I want to respond to the NFUS's letter. A full cost benefit analysis needs to be carried out. I do not think that the proposed scheme, as it is currently structured, will deliver any benefits. We need a scheme that suits Scottish producers.
There are various options that we can pursue, one of which is to write to the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment to invite him to respond to the points that the NFUS has made. The second option is to take oral evidence from the cabinet secretary and/or the NFUS. Obviously, we would have to schedule an additional meeting on 30 January to do that, but there is no guarantee that witnesses would be available within such a short space of time. The third option is to report to Parliament on the regulations. We would have to consider the draft report, which could include points that have been made, on 6 February. Finally, we could agree to make no recommendations on the regulations.
We should write to the cabinet secretary. Double tagging is essentially an interim measure before electronic identification is introduced in 2010, which is why it is not worth going to the wire on the matter, notwithstanding the inconvenience that it will cause. However, we need to get a response from the cabinet secretary to the concerns that have been expressed, and we need to find an electronic tagging system that will work for Scottish producers.
If we wrote to the minister, we would put the emphasis on electronic tagging, which is causing the concern. We cannot do much about the regulations because we do not want infraction proceedings, but we should push the electronic tagging issue.
Yes. Obviously, our report will be on the regulations, but I am sure that we can find a way of drafting a sentence or two in it that flags up our awareness of the pending changes. We shall write to the cabinet secretary and discuss a draft report at our next meeting, in February. It is clear that members do not wish to take further evidence.Do members agree not to make any recommendation on SSI 2007/559?
Members indicated agreement.
Do members agree to discuss the draft report in private on 6 February, as is our normal procedure?
Members indicated agreement.
Convener, I apologise for my late arrival.
That is okay. You are let off.No issues have been raised in connection with SSI 2007/577. Do members agree not to make any recommendation on it?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Jan 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Wednesday 23 January 2008 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 19
- European Union Scrutiny Committee business · 6
- Flooding and Flood Management Inquiry Committee business · 198
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.