Agenda item 2 is our work programme. This is our first review of the programme since it was agreed at the summer away day. Paper RAE/S3/07/10/2 sets out our progress in the various programme tasks that we undertook.We have probably got through more than I expected, because we have managed to deal with some of the smaller issues. I was not confident at the summer away day that we would get as many of them done as we appear to have done. Of course, the Crown Estate issue became bigger than we had expected.Members will see from the table on the back page of the briefing paper that we have committed to a lot of work for a significant amount of the available time in 2008. We will take oral evidence on flooding in January, February and March. We are doing our budget report just now. We will put out a call for written evidence on rural housing and take oral evidence on the issue in May and June. We will also deal with various other issues, including fishing. We flagged up previously that we wanted to deal with aspects of fishing early, so we have pulled back the evidence taking, particularly on scientific evidence, to June instead of doing it at the last minute in December, as we typically would.I point out to John Scott that we will have an evidence session on ticks in May. I do not know whether the group for whom John is the reporter will be in a position to make it sensible to have an evidence session then. However, we wanted something for that time, so we pencilled in a session on ticks. We thought that it would be appropriate to discuss that issue at that time of year.We will do the flooding report in April, following oral evidence, and we will do the rural housing report in September, following evidence. We must also kick off the agricultural regulation inquiry by putting out a call for written evidence in May; we will take oral evidence on the issue in September and October. We have yet to get to grips with the detail of the agricultural regulation inquiry.We can put a number of ticks—Laughter. Sorry, what can I say?A number of potential areas for scrutiny have been mentioned. Sarah Boyack suggested the local food issue. We chose at the away day not to proceed with it, but we might return to it. We could undertake post-legislative scrutiny of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, but I am not sure when the Snowie case in Stirling will be decided: it would be useful to wait for that decision before we take a further view on such scrutiny. Scrutiny of the Scottish Agricultural Wages Board could be part and parcel of the agricultural regulation inquiry.Peter Peacock suggested that we investigate green space in urban Scotland; I do not know whether last week's debate has changed his mind about that. I suggested that we examine the application of the waste electrical and electronic equipment directive and Des McNulty raised the general issue of waste management. He also requested a sea fisheries inquiry, but I wonder whether the new way in which the committee has decided to deal with sea fisheries obviates the need for that.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Roseanna Cunningham only · show everyone- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 17
- Mike Rumbles LD 5
- Des McNulty Lab 4
- Peter Peacock Lab 3
- Jamie Hepburn SNP 3
- John Scott Con 3
- Karen Gillon Lab 1
- Bill Wilson SNP 1
Roseanna Cunningham’s contributions
17 contributionsAs for the petition that is before the Public Petitions Committee on mechanical vibrations through wind turbine installations, our best bet is to wait for that committee to decide what it will do.Our paper says that Mike Rumbles has proposed a review of wildlife crime legislation, but I have just been handed a note that says that he does not know where the quote that was attributed to him came from.
Mike Rumbles has also suggested scrutiny of the pig industry. Other topics are the less favoured area support scheme, nitrate vulnerable zones and the common agricultural policy health check.Not too much thought is needed to realise that we will be unable to cover all those subjects, so we need to decide what we can reasonably do before the 2008 summer recess, given the time constraints to which we are subject. When we receive the evidence on ticks, that will deal with another issue that was raised at the away day.We must decide which of the other topics are more or less important. The common agricultural policy continues to be an issue, but I am not sure how it could be incorporated into the available evidence sessions—we do not have a huge amount of time. We will take oral evidence on flooding from January to March. We do not have to confine ourselves to taking evidence purely on that, but I remind members that it is difficult to take evidence on two different matters at one meeting—it is not easy to manage. We have done it, but I do not recommend it as a standard course. What are members' views?The big issue that is hanging over is what we do about the Crown Estate, on which we have done quite a lot of work. We need to decide our next steps on that.
Yes—some of the suggested topics can be put together.
I should have said that what we need to do today is to discuss the shorter term stuff, for January to April. We have already agreed inquiries that will continue after the summer recess into late 2008.My view is that we should have an away day in an off week before the summer recess. If we make decisions at an away day, it is useful to have at least one meeting shortly afterwards so that we can action some decisions. I propose that we hold one in early June, rather in the summer recess. That will give us the long-range discussion that will take us into 2009. Peter Peacock is right that some topics are amenable to much bigger inquiries. However, I am not sure that we are best placed to decide on those in the next seven minutes. Today, we need to think about the next three or four months. If the committee agrees to hold an away day in June, we can take the long-range decisions then.
We have canvassed legal advice on the Crown Estate. We got into a slightly circular argument because the first response to our request was to ask in what context we wanted such advice. It was considered that such advice could not be supplied unless we were to hold an inquiry. The situation is a little bit circular—we may have to go back and have another discussion on that.
That is not a formal committee paper. As we are in public session, I point out that people who want to find that paper will not find it on the committee's web page because it is not a committee paper.
Yes, there are a number of ideas. I will mention one of mine after we have heard from John Scott.
This is a very consensual committee.
I will ask for contributions from Karen Gillon and Des McNulty, but then I want to wind up the discussion, because we need to get through the rest of the agenda.
It might be possible for the Scottish Parliament information centre to provide some of that information.
Can we focus on what we will do in the early part of 2008? Some of the issues that you have raised must be considered over a much longer term.
Okay, but I find it difficult to see how we can do a waste management inquiry in the first half of 2008. We need to think about the slightly longer term, because members are forgetting that as well as conducting an inquiry into flooding and flood management, we will have to deal with a bill on flooding. Our first year is relatively legislation-free, but that will not continue.I want us to think about an idea that I mentioned at our away day. We are holding an inquiry into rural housing, and it would be useful to plan an arc of rural development inquiries that we will undertake during the four-year parliamentary session, so that we consider which inquiries slot together and produce a substantial body of work on rural development over the four years. However, we cannot do anything about that between now and the summer recess.I refer members to the first bullet point of paragraph 38 of the work programme paper, which invites us to review progress on our current programme. We have done that quite well so far. We have not yet discussed the second bullet point, which concerns how we might deal with evidence, not just on the flooding inquiry but in any oral evidence sessions that we hold. At the end of each such session, we could discuss our views and impressions in private immediately following the oral evidence. That would allow the clerks to begin to draft, as they go, some of the framework for any reports that might eventuate. I have had experience of that in other committees—it works extremely well, and it cuts down on some of the time that is needed for reports at the end of the process. With members' agreement, we will do that when we take the oral evidence on flooding.I detected no interest in pursuing the Scottish index on multiple deprivation at the moment. We have had a good discussion about the Crown Estate programme, and I propose that, at the end of next year, we take evidence from the Crown Estate. In the meantime, we will explore further the issue of the legal position of the Crown Estate and how the devolved-reserved split actually works, on which we will try to get some clearer views.We have discussed the CAP health check—at this stage, I have not detected any overwhelming desire to do anything between now and June, but we can try to keep it in mind. We have noted the various options for inquiry topics and flagged up some new issues, and we have agreed to have an away day in June, which we will organise. In respect of the potential for one-off meetings, they might be possible—at this stage, it can only be a "might be". If we can identify some available time, we will perhaps consider one or two issues. Does John Scott want to come in very briefly?
We can discuss that at greater length in June, when we have some background information. Mike Rumbles has made a case for having at least one session on the pig industry. The slight difficulty that I have with that is that the paper presents the issue as if it is an immediate crisis, and I do not know whether it is possible for us to fit in an evidence session before the summer recess. I do not know how members feel about that. Would it be useful?The clerk is advising me that we could have SPICe examine the situation and see whether we can find a basis on which to proceed.Mike, I do not want to extend this any further, as we are already running 15 minutes behind.
What do committee members feel?
Okay.
That is the point that I was making about SPICe. We will also find out what the Government is doing and what its timescale is for producing a package of recommendations.That is one potential inquiry, if we can fit it in. Is there anything else that committee members feel we should consider, if it can be fitted in, before we have an away day? I cannot see anything else that is amenable to a straightforward single meeting. I take on board John Scott's comments that events often overtake us and it is never advisable to pack the committee's workload to such a degree that we do not have the capacity to address issues as and when they arise, for example the crofting report. It is advisable for us to keep some flexibility.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Dec 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Wednesday 19 December 2007 Committee business · 1
- Rural Housing Seminar Committee business · 14
- Work Programme Procedure · 37
- Petition Petitions · 3
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.