Agenda item 2 is a brief discussion about our work programme in the light of what we have heard. We will not necessarily take final decisions today; we will discuss the issues in greater detail at our away day in the summer. I suggest that we spend until about 11:10 having a conversation about what we have heard.In summary, it seems highly unlikely that we will have to deal with legislation in the next 12 months. If we have legislation to deal with, it is likely to be a flooding bill, but given what the cabinet secretary said I would be surprised if such a bill is introduced within the next 12 months. That gives at least some clarity on the issues that the committee might want to discuss.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Roseanna Cunningham only · show everyone- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 16
- Peter Peacock Lab 8
- Sarah Boyack Lab 5
- Jamie Hepburn SNP 1
- Bill Wilson SNP 1
- Mike Rumbles LD 1
- John Scott Con 1
- Richard Baker Lab 1
Roseanna Cunningham’s contributions
16 contributionsThe list includes agricultural regulation, but you are talking about environmental regulation.
It might be useful to organise that early doors.To take a little of the burden off SPICe, it might be useful for us to make early bids for the research budget. Instructing research would allow us to begin an inquiry while we were doing something else. I am keen for us to consider that at the away day, because massive bids for the research budget will probably not be made in the early years of the session. We want to be first in.
SPICe may already have relevant information on some issues, such as the SNH and SEPA question. SPICe staff can look through their archives. As long as information is not too old, it may still be of major relevance.
There is no harm in the committee's reaching out to tell principal organisations what we have discussed and asking whether we have overlooked something. I see no problem with that, because opportunities are available.
It is worth our giving SPICe a stronger steer, because we have a pile of suggestions. I hope that SPICe has some of the information already and does not have to do separate research.I endorse the comments about flood management. A properly worked-up background paper on the current legislation on and processes for flood management would be extremely useful, because no part of Scotland is not affected by flooding.I confess that I thought that rural deprivation and rural housing would be good for pitching into the separate research budget on, because useful academic research on that might be able to run alongside what we are doing then be brought back into the committee. Going down that route might be fairer to SPICe, as such a piece of work would be likely to be big.I take the point about the Crown Estate, which is quite a heavy hand in parts of Scotland. Perhaps we could ask SPICe to provide a briefing that combines agricultural regulation and support with the role of the Crown Estate. Information on that might already be available.
Given what we have heard, if SPICe can provide a third briefing, it should probably be on food policy. I do not want to rule out work on waste management, but we have had to deal with the issue a few times during the past few years, so we are probably more au fait with it. SPICe could direct us to existing work on waste management. We probably need more of a work-up on food policy.We have suggested commissioning three substantial SPICe papers and asking SPICe to direct us to work that has been done in the past. Rural deprivation and rural housing, which we can discuss at the away day, is a more appropriate subject on which to commission research from outside the Parliament. Are members happy with that? I do not want to overburden SPICe.
An insubstantial paper? Okay, but SPICe asked us not to commission more than two or three briefings.
It is difficult. I do not want to overburden SPICe, but the committee must have as much information as possible. SPICe can direct us to information.It is easy to overlook a useful note on recent developments in the committee's remit, which is included in our papers. The note in last week's papers said that SPICe has produced new briefings on international polar year and biodiversity. Some of the briefings that we want have already been produced.
Okay. What we commission will not preclude discussion of other issues at the away day, but we need more information on the substantial matters that we are likely to have to deal with or that we want to consider.
I have heard that before.
The committee that I convened previously had a budget adviser.
I am strongly in favour of that idea—and I am particularly strongly in favour of putting in our bid early in the four-year parliamentary session, before the various pots of money start to run out. The earlier we put in bids for support, the more likely we are to get them accepted.I think that everyone has commented who wanted to do so. Your comments will be wrapped into plans for the away day, which is likely to take place on 14 August.
Which Richard? We have a Richard on the committee.
Yes—it could be the everything bill.
My understanding is that another committee will be the lead committee on the bill. Depending on the size of the bill, I expect that that committee will want to enlist the resources, time and expertise of other committees, to feed into its work. That would be a matter for negotiation with the convener of the lead committee. If the climate change bill becomes the everything bill, I cannot imagine the convener of that committee not wanting other committees to consider some aspects of it.I would have a slight concern if measures on flooding and waste were put into the climate change bill, as they are separate issues. Committees have considered bills with distinct parts—the issue is not insurmountable—but it makes the process more difficult. We will press for further information as early as possible. At this stage, that is the best I can say. I will raise the issues of the climate change bill at the Conveners Group. I suspect that the bill will involve more than two committees—for obvious reasons, it could involve the Local Government and Communities Committee, too.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Jun 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Wednesday 27 June 2007 Committee business · 1
- Scottish Executive Priorities Committee business · 62
- Work Programme Procedure · 34
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 21
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.