Agenda item 4 is on our "approach to developing a work programme". It is a splendidly general item that we can discuss briefly.I suggest that it would be a good idea to organise an away day during the recess, as it would allow us to spend a bit more time in an informal setting talking through the many issues that are likely to present themselves over the next couple of years. Obviously, an away day discussion would not prescribe the committee's work for the next four years, but it may be useful as a means of developing our work programme over a shorter period.We can make decisions at our meeting next Wednesday, when, I understand, we will have subordinate legislation business to deal with. We may as well start as we are obviously going to go on. It might be useful to get either the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment or the Minister for Environment along to next week's meeting, even if only for a brief period, to talk us through the issues that they regard as being particularly current. I have made an informal approach, and I think that if we formally invite the cabinet secretary, he will be able to be here, albeit not for an entire morning. I think he has about 45 minutes available. That would be a useful slot for the committee to continue its consideration of what we might do over the next wee while.I invite the committee to agree to an away day in principle. We will never get unanimous agreement on a date, so we will just have to go for the best one. Do members agree to have an away day?Members indicated agreement.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Roseanna Cunningham only · show everyone- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 18
- Sarah Boyack Lab 6
- Mike Rumbles LD 5
- Peter Peacock Lab 3
- Bill Wilson SNP 1
- Richard Baker Lab 1
- John Scott Con 1
- Jamie Hepburn SNP 1
Roseanna Cunningham’s contributions
18 contributionsDo members agree to invite the cabinet secretary to the next meeting?Members indicated agreement.
I think that that is right, particularly with respect to the potential timing of legislation. When we plan our business, it is always useful to know when a lump of legislation will be launched at us, because we will need to factor that into the timetable.Of course, we also have budget scrutiny to put into the diary. We are still trying to ascertain how that will work this year because, as I understand it, it is later coming from Westminster, so the process will be a bit later in the year than it would usually be. We must ensure that anything we decide to do will also fit in with budget scrutiny.This meeting is an opportunity for members to put on the table anything that they are particularly interested in and would like to have considered. We will have another such opportunity next week and a third opportunity at the away day. The plan would be to formalise our programme of business at the very beginning of September, so that we have a work programme that takes us through to Easter, if not up to the summer recess.The previous committee's legacy paper has been circulated to members—at least one member of the committee was on the previous committee: Sarah Boyack was instrumental in taking forward its work until the last few months of the session—and we have various papers from the Scottish Parliament information centre that give us a heads-up on some of the other things that are coming up.I invite members to indicate whether there are any particular matters that they want us to take on board.
Do you have a specific example in mind? I am sure that Sarah Boyack will not mind.
You are referring to the sustainable development work?
Does anyone else want to raise specific issues?
Anyone else?
That could be dealt with as part of the regulatory issue.
That is right—there will not be a shortage of work for us to do; the difficulty will be deciding our priorities.
Thanks; that was useful. Do you have another point to make, Sarah?
Have you not? I am sorry.
That would be useful. Flood management is on my shortlist of issues against which I put a question mark, because it is a continuing problem in many areas in Scotland. The problem is symptomatic of a much bigger issue.The methods of working that one or two members mentioned are important. In the committee on which I served most recently, we used many approaches, including public debates, events in the chamber, external meetings and many round-table discussions. We should discuss the appropriateness for this committee of all such approaches, which are useful. There is no doubt that in some cases we can get more from a round-table discussion than we could get from a formal evidence-taking session. I hope that we will continue to use different mechanisms.For the benefit of new members, I say that, as far as I am aware, budget scrutiny has been a bone of contention in every committee during the past eight years. I hope that we can get budget scrutiny on to a better footing, but it is always a problem. Sarah Boyack talked about the problem of tracking issues across many areas of the budget. It is very hard to follow the money—indeed, the budget almost seems deliberately designed to avoid the possibility of anyone doing so. We will see whether the process is different this year.It is unlikely that there will be as much legislation as there has been in the past, so the committee will probably have a little more freedom—or at least freedom from the strict timetables that were the bane of committee life—to follow up issues that arise from the legacy paper.We may have to consider a marine bill. I say may not because there might be no such bill—there will definitely be a marine bill—but because we need to clarify the remits of the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee, the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee and the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. Those three committees will consider matters that, arguably, any one of them could consider, so we need to ascertain into which committee's remit issues that we might consider will fall. For example, the Environment and Rural Development Committee in the previous session conducted an inquiry into developments in the biomass industry, but I am currently unclear whether such an issue would fall within this committee's remit or that of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. We are still trying to ascertain the parameters.I take the view that a Rural Affairs and Environment Committee is entitled to consider a wide range of issues under the broad umbrella of rural affairs and environment, notwithstanding that such issues might cross over into other remits. There are, obviously, important issues to do with showing courtesy to other committees, but if we discuss rural affairs without discussing, for example, rural housing, rural transport and other such things, only farming will be left.My view is that we should look at cross-cutting issues—and our cross-cutting abilities should be asserted right from the start, so that we do not find ourselves too boxed in to narrow areas of concern. At the moment, we are ascertaining which are the lead committees for legislation. There will be lead committees, but I propose that we take a broad view of the subject areas we wish to discuss.
That is correct. In talking about rural affairs and the environment, we could talk about virtually anything.
I have been asking questions about land reform as well, as I am interested in where that is going at the moment. However, to get a feel for that area, we may have to wait for a couple of court decisions. A second decision is expected in about three weeks' time, in Stirlingshire, and I am not sure how appealable the first decision is. We will just have to wait and see, but that is an area in which I would be actively interested.There are one or two other items that the committee may wish to pursue. In eight years, the committee has never really considered forestry. Like biodiversity, it is a subject that we have not really touched on. There is also a slightly more controversial issue. As far as I can see from the SPICe briefing, a household waste prevention action plan is due to be published this year. As we know, several councils have either tried to move to, or are seeking to move to, a different way of dealing with household waste. As politicians, we are well aware that that will be immensely controversial when it happens. That is another issue next to which I have put a question mark. The waste inquiry that was conducted by the previous committee focused more on non-domestic waste than on domestic waste; domestic waste will be the next big battleground.There are also some live public petitions. We will continue to work with any petitions that are lying on the table, and there will be some new ones. The COAST petition from the Isle of Arran, which Sarah Boyack mentioned, is still on the committee's agenda and must remain so.The big issue that remains—which, given the announcement of a marine bill, we might also want to think about—is the marine environment inquiry that the previous committee conducted. I confess that I have not had enough time to read the report on that inquiry, but if we are to make an early move for time for a committee debate in the chamber, it might be useful, given that there will be a marine bill, to request a debate on that report, albeit only one member around the table was actively involved in the inquiry. I take it that Sarah Boyack was still convener of the Environment and Rural Development Committee when the marine environment inquiry was being conducted.
Okay. So nobody around the table—
That work is the one thing that I would want to pick up directly from the legacy paper, and progress. There is every likelihood that, even if this committee is not the lead committee on the marine bill, it will feed into the lead committee. From this committee's perspective, it may be useful to get work up and running on the issue anyway. We do not have to take a decision on that today, as there is no chamber time for committee debates before the recess. We can leave the matter lying, but I fully intend to read the previous committee's inquiry report, as it will obviously be germane to work that we must do.There are many things for the committee to do. This discussion has allowed us to think about them, and we can now individually and in conversation begin a process in which priority issues will emerge. Next week, we have an opportunity to hear from the minister; what is said then may throw up more things that we would like to do. We will also have an away day, which we will organise as quickly as possible. It is likely that it will be around the third week of August—I am working on the basis that nobody wants to come back in July if they can avoid doing so.
Nobody wants to have an away day in the final week of August, which is close to when members must return to the Parliament. There are school holidays in the first two weeks of August. I am trying to find a slot that works for us.
We could always have it on a Monday.As there is nothing else that we need to discuss and no other issues that members want to raise, I close the first meeting of the committee in this session. I will see everybody next week.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Jun 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Wednesday 20 June 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 9
- Convener Procedure · 7
- Deputy Convener Procedure · 8
- Work Programme Procedure · 37
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.