The next petition is PE1180, from Tom and Josie Wallace, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that students with complex needs are supported in achieving further education placements and that appropriate funding mechanisms are provided to enable such placements to be taken up. The petitioners had the opportunity to bring the petition directly before the committee and Alex Fergusson, in his role as the constituency member, has spoken on it at the committee on a number of occasions. We have also had a private briefing on the issue. Alex Fergusson would like to comment on the petition today. After he has done so, we will try to pull together a response.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Further Education (Students with Complex Needs) (PE1180)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 5
- Alex Fergusson Galloway and Upper Nithsdale 2
- Nigel Don SNP 2
- Rhona Brankin Lab 2
- Robin Harper Green 2
- Nanette Milne Con 1
- Bill Butler Lab 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
The record
16 contributionsI am just here to see where your deliberations are leading you on the petition. As you know, I have taken a considerable interest in the petition ever since it was originally sent to the committee. Having spoken to Mr and Mrs Wallace this afternoon, I understand that there are a few questions that are yet to be satisfactorily answered. However, I am not here to say anything today as I have nothing further to add since the last time that I was here. I might have something to say if you decide to close the petition, but I am very happy simply to listen to your deliberations, if I may.
As always, I listen carefully to any representation that you make, Presiding Officer. Hopefully, we can keep the petition open.Do members have any comments? I know that many members have commented on the matter before. I think that we should keep the petition open, as I know that members feel that we have not received a full and proper response to a number of questions.From the information that we have received from the family, we know that the case is a difficult one, and that the family has felt quite a lot of frustration while trying to navigate the further education opportunities for their growing son. Do members have any suggestions about whom we might wish to take up certain issues with?
The silence in the committee represents the fact that we face a little bit of a structural problem. Clearly, this is one of those petitions that came from an individual case but which recognised that that individual case was only one of many around the country and that there was therefore a general principle that needed to be addressed. At this point, it appears that the individual case is being progressed, which is good. We recognise that there is a general issue, but it is perhaps so general that it is difficult to know quite how to take it forward without going round the houses and discussing the whole thing. I am therefore looking for a bit of help from my colleagues with regard to which bit of the petition we should be progressing. Perhaps the issues have grown so wide that we should be kind of closing the petition, although I do not particularly want to close consideration of the whole issue. Alternatively, perhaps we should try to focus on a particular issue that now appears to be more important than the generality.
I am at a loss to know whom we should go to for answers. It is clear from the Equal Opportunities Committee's inquiry into barriers facing disabled people in education that there is a lack of residential colleges, that further and higher education providers are not well prepared to take disabled students and that support is not consistent across the country. There are many questions that could be asked along those lines. We should perhaps write to the colleges or the Government to ask how many residential places have been created since 2006 and how many more will be made available in the next few years. We should ask how higher and further education providers are preparing for disabled students, because providers are supposed to be proactive rather than to react only when a disabled student comes to them. We should also ask about how consistent provision is across Scotland and whether there is any proof that students with additional support needs are finding the system more accessible.I am not 100 per cent sure whom we would ask those questions of, but I will be guided on that.
I do not think that we should close the petition. We were wondering what questions we could ask, but it seems that there are many questions to pose. I think that most if not all of the questions that have arisen should be posed to colleges and the Government, so that we can get information about what is really happening in institutions as well as what the Government thinks is happening. The last time that we considered the petition, Alex Fergusson drew attention to the possibility that a postcode lottery exists in relation to funding for such placements. We could ask the Scottish Government whether it can demonstrate beyond question that there is no postcode lottery for opportunities to access funding to secure further education placements. What statistical evidence can the Government present to support its contention that there is no such postcode lottery? What is the longer-term perspective for those people who have very specific needs, as outlined in the petition? We should not close the petition, as there are a number of questions that we can ask.
To what extent are the Government and others aware of the level of compliance with the various pieces of legislation and guidance that currently exist? In the first instance, we should ask the Government and other governmental and non-governmental bodies their views on the extent to which FE and higher education institutions comply with legislation and guidance—and we should ask them how they know.
We could scope the possibilities for setting up a specialised residential college in Scotland. There are residential colleges in England, which I believe are extremely successful. Such a college here could be based on an existing one, but it would have specially designed accommodation and teaching courses. Such facilities would be of considerable benefit. The demand for such a college would probably exceed the Government's expectations. The all-round advantages by way of efficiencies, expertise and quality of education would be enormous.Let us cut to the chase: we should be asking the Government to scope the demand and assess the possibilities for a dedicated residential college.
We are beginning to clarify the issue, and I support what Robin Harper has said. We should now be asking for the relevant statistics. What does the Government know about the number of youngsters with considerable disabilities who need further education? The Government will say that the information is not held centrally and that it is for local authorities to make their own provision. We know that. Having asked that question, we must follow it up by asking whether the Government is bothered that it does not know the answer because only local authorities know it. It bothers us, at any rate, so could the Government find out, please?
I did not put what I said a minute ago exactly as I wished. The Government should scope the potential demand. Not enough people are demanding such facilities, because they are not available—people have the sense not to ask for things that they know are not there; they are put off from demanding it. However, the Government should scope the potential demand, and then it should provide for it.
There is substantial capital investment in new colleges in Glasgow and the west of Scotland. The proposals reflect a different way of designing facilities and services to make them more amenable and accessible to individuals with complex needs. I do not have the answer; I just know that a £350 million investment programme is expected for those colleges, all of which will serve a wide geographical area. We will need to see how that is factored in. I know that Glasgow College of Nautical Studies in my constituency is looking at that issue. Because it is a nautical college, it has always had a residential element. How does it factor that in as part of a wider federation of colleges? If a college is doing residential development anyway, could it factor in two or three units that could be much more adaptable, given the needs that we are talking about?We have to pull all this together. There are three or four key points. I do not know whether members wish to add anything. We want to keep the petition open. We want to explore these issues. As ever, I will leave the final wise words to the Presiding Officer.
You are a sensible man, convener; I have always said so.Rhona Brankin is absolutely right: there is already legislation and guidance. However, the cold reality is that people such as my constituent's son are just not being picked up and are in effect being abandoned by the system. The comments that you have all made are right. Central Government will say that this is a local authority responsibility. It is, but local authorities do not have the resources necessary to provide the £60,000 a year that this child needed to go to the residential establishment that everybody said would best suit him. He went there for one year and it suited him best—he had never been better. He is now at home, having been abandoned by the system, and is backsliding—that is the only way that I can describe it. The petition resulted from an individual case, but there is a national impact, which is exactly what such petitions have to be about. The questions that you are going to ask are hugely relevant if we are to address this properly in future. That is what we must aim to do if we are to live in an equal and just society.
I know that Rhona Brankin was alluding to the variety of different acts that further education establishments—and any other operational facilities—have to abide by. We need to drill down and ask a series of questions of the Government and the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council about how they are addressing the issue.
This is slightly difficult for me, because I was not involved in looking at the petition previously, as I have only just joined the committee. It strikes me that one of the key issues is funding. The fact that a local authority could have two or three young people with immensely complex needs that can be met only by intensive and expensive support systems leads us to look at whether there are different approaches to take. South of the border, funding can follow the individual. That raises issues that are fundamental to how we support young adults who have complex additional support needs, which we need to address.
I have said this before but, as I understand it, educational establishments, as well as public bodies, come under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995. It might be worth writing to the Equality and Human Rights Commission in Scotland to find out how many approaches it has had about access to further and higher education. We need to look at higher education establishments as well as further education colleges in relation to access to opportunities for all students who wish to progress their academic careers. Although I agree with Robin Harper, who talked about residential provision in the further education sector, we should not limit the opportunity for anyone in Scotland who wishes to pursue an academic career at whatever level. We need to ask questions not only of further education principals but of the universities. Some of the brightest brains in academia today have experienced disabilities, and continue to contribute to meaningful debates on a range of issues. We need to broaden the debate.
It appears that members wish to keep the petition open. We will continue to pursue the issues that it raises and our dialogue with the petitioners.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Nov 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 17 November 2009 Petitions · 1
- Interests Procedure · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 77
- New Petitions Petitions · 76
- New Petitions Petitions · 61
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 21
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- New Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.