Item 3 is consideration of current petitions. First, we will consider PE1098 and PE1223 together. PE1098, from Lynn Merrifield, on behalf of Kingseat community council, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to make provision for every school bus to be fitted with three-point seat belts for every school child passenger and to ensure that, as part of a local authority's consideration of best value in relation to the provision of school buses, proper regard is given to the safety needs of the children.PE1223, from Ron Beaty, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take all appropriate action—whether through amending guidance, contracts, agreements or legislation—to require local authorities to install proper safety signage and lights on school buses, to be used only when necessary when schoolchildren are on buses, and to make overtaking a stationary school bus a criminal offence.Ron Beaty made a contribution to the meeting earlier today. He is sitting in the public gallery for our consideration of the petition. I also welcome to the committee Stewart Stevenson, the constituency MSP for Banff and Buchan and Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change. He was present for our consideration of the earlier items and listened carefully and attentively to our deliberations. In respect of our consideration of PE1098 and PE1223, I welcome him in his capacity as the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change. We all have to wear different hats; I am sure that Stewart Stevenson's focus today will be on the petitions that are under consideration. There are two other MSPs at the committee today. I welcome Richard Baker, who is a regional list MSP for North East Scotland; and Lewis Macdonald, who is the member for Edinburgh Central—of course, I meant to say Aberdeen Central. Lewis Macdonald looked disappointed when he heard me say "Edinburgh Central", as he thinks Aberdeen Central is much more interesting.Members have a paper from the clerks. Unless you wish to make any opening remarks, minister, we will move straight to questions from the committee.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
School Bus Safety (PE1098 and PE1223)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stewart Stevenson SNP 13
- Frank McAveety Lab 4
- Bill Butler Lab 3
- Marlyn Glen Lab 3
- Anne McLaughlin SNP 2
- Richard Baker Lab 2
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Robin Harper Green 1
- Nanette Milne Con 1
The record
30 contributionsThe Scottish Government will shortly publish a road safety framework. What positive impact will the framework have on the two petitions that are before us?
What we will shortly publish will have an impact. It is important also to say that we are working on the subjects of both petitions in advance of publication. It is not necessary for us to wait for publication to respond to a problem. Indeed, we should congratulate Aberdeenshire Council on the considerable work that it has done on the subject. Although the road safety strategy will address a number of issues to do with road users generally, it will focus more on drivers. The two petitions that are before the committee today raise the specific issues of seat belts and safety in the vicinity of school buses.
What progress has been made prior to the publication of the road safety framework?
Aberdeenshire Council, Aberdeen City Council and Moray Council have been working together with us. We have sought to navigate on the basis of contemplating anything that we are not forbidden to do. For example, although I do not have the power to change the design of the sign on a school bus that says that it is a school bus, we have established that, in the legislation, there is no upper limit to the size that the sign may be. That might be an oversight, but it provides an opportunity that we are considering in order to increase the visibility of school buses.We are also pursuing with the councils, through the contracts that they have with operators, the appropriate use of the school bus sign. In other words, we want to ensure that the sign is not mounted on a bus when it is not being used as a school bus, so that people will not think, "Och, that sign is always on the bus." We want to ensure that the sign is on the bus whenever the bus is genuinely carrying schoolchildren under contract.We are considering what lighting there should be on a bus, including lights that flash. There are opinions for and against that. Some people think that flashing lights might suggest a bus in distress, which other motorists should overtake, although the message that we are trying to convey is rather different. There is more work for us to do in considering that option. Another option is for school buses to have dipped headlights on at all times.Aberdeenshire Council has also come up with a publicity campaign entitled one second, one life, reminding people that it takes only one second to end a life. With the council, we are looking at SeeMe technology, which will be piloted at certain locations to signal when there is a school bus in the vicinity. It uses a transponder system that pupils can wear, which says that school pupils are in the vicinity. Indeed, bus drivers could wear it as well.Those are a series of actions that can be taken in advance of the publication of the road safety strategy, and I am pleased to say that Aberdeenshire Council and the adjacent councils are working with the Government on those.
I am obliged.
Local authorities have responsibility for school transport. You have mentioned several local authorities. Are you satisfied that, in general, local authorities are meeting their responsibilities for school transport correctly?
There is no local authority in Scotland that would not want to have the highest standard of safety on its school transport for its pupils.The first petition is on the subject of seat belts. We have made it clear, through guidance and policy direction, that contracts should incorporate a requirement for seat belts. The petition asks specifically for three-point seat belts, but many of the buses that are in operation have two-point seat belts. I do not make a particular distinction between the two. It is also important to ensure that, where seat belts are fitted, they are actually used. Having them fitted does not save any lives; it is using them that makes the difference. In law, I do not have the power to say that seat belts must be fitted and used. However, the local authorities have the opportunity, when they renew contracts, to consider including that requirement in the contract. I strongly advise that they do so.I would make the point that school transport comes in all shapes and forms, including taxis, hire cars and scheduled buses, along with chartered school buses. We have a diverse set of provisions for wheeled transport. However, as I said, the authorities have the guidance that we issue and I hope that as many as possible will act on it.
You mentioned that some authorities use public service buses. Even on organised trips with children aged three to 16, there are no rules about seat belts for children on such buses. What can be done to close that loophole? How many councils use public service buses for school transport?
I think that it would be fair to say that almost all councils make some provision that relies on public service buses and, therefore, there are rules that govern that. Certainly, the major bus companies have at least two-point seat belts on most of their buses. The bus that I take relatively regularly from Aberdeen to Peterhead has a two-point seat belt, which I use, due to personal exposure to some of the consequences of not wearing a seat belt. However, I have to say that, almost invariably, I am the only person on the bus who does so. I suspect therefore, that we should focus on getting people to wear them equally as much as we focus on getting them fitted.As I said, we do not have the power to require bus companies to fit seat belts or to require that those that are fitted should be three-point seat belts. However, we are certainly of the view that it would improve safety if they were fitted and used.
Research is important, because we need to know the facts. Has research been undertaken to determine whether local authorities have revised their procedures in light of the good-practice guidance that was issued in 2007?
I am prepared to engage with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities on the issue. It is not for the Government to audit what councils are doing, but I would be surprised if local authorities did not want to take every possible action to ensure that there is the maximum possible safety for all passengers, and particularly school students.
I will take that as a no—there has been no research. We want research to be done so that we can base our work on facts and not on anecdotal evidence.
We have some basic facts on who has seat belts. We can make that available to the committee, but I suspect that that might lead to further questions, which I think it would be proper to address to COSLA.
I am conscious of our limited time, so I think that we should concentrate on our core questions.
You have answered a couple of the questions that I was going to ask, minister. One was about the size of the signage on the vehicles and the other was about removing signs when the bus is not being used to transport children to and from school. Has the Scottish Government commissioned any research on the pick-up and drop-off points that are used, or has it been involved in discussions with local authorities on the issue? One of the points that came up in our previous session on this issue was the danger that is presented by some of the pick-up points that operators are using. It seems that that issue involves as much danger as anything else in the school transport system does.
The member is quite right to focus on the pick-up points. The two sets of parents who have been with us in the audience today both lost children at pick-up points. We need to ensure that pick-up points are assessed for suitability. I know that the council in this area is involved in that. In rural areas, of course, there are extremely large numbers of pick-up points. In Aberdeenshire, there are either 400 or 4,000—I have temporarily forgotten which, but it is a large number either way.The SeeMe initiative that I referred to earlier is precisely targeted at trying to make pick-up points safer by making drivers who approach them when they are in use more aware that they are in use. We note that the technology has apparently been successfully implemented in Sweden.Strathclyde partnership for transport has commissioned MVA Consultancy to produce guidance on risk assessment for pick-up points, and has indicated that it is willing to make that available to councils. Aberdeenshire Council, which covers the area in which Mr Beaty lives and works is developing further work in this area.
If that research resulted in identifying at least the most dangerous pick-up points, one of the issues in the petition could be addressed, at least partially. It asks about a reserved matter, which is to do with whether drivers can be punished in the courts for overtaking stationary school buses. If those dangerous pick-up points were marked with the zig-zag lines that forbid overtaking in any case, that might assist matters. Would it be worth investigating that?
The member is absolutely correct. However, I hope that identifying the most dangerous pick-up points would lead to consideration of a range of alternative strategies such as relocating pick-up points, carrying out road engineering works or ensuring that the drivers of the buses work to some sort of processes and procedures.Although I do not necessarily think that this point is a huge impediment, I am not sure about our legal ability to paint those zig-zag lines in the places that the member describes. As a point of general principle, however, I should say that no idea should be ruled out of consideration, because I suspect that there is no single intervention that will magically transform the situation. It will almost certainly require a range of interventions that are different for different sites and, indeed, for different seasons.
If a council decides that it wants signs to be removed from school buses when the children are not on board, does it have the clout to enforce that if the bus company does not comply?
At the end of the day, the issue is to do with getting the right contract between the purchaser and supplier. Entering into a contract with the council is something that the bus company does voluntarily, and it is up to the council to lay down the requirements that it has of that service. If it were understood that the company would not get the next contract if it did not obey the rules on taking the signs down, that would be helpful. In civil law terms, it would be perfectly proper to incorporate that in a contract. Although legislative courses might be pursued, that is one of the key ways in which councils can take action in this area, and it is quite outwith the powers of Westminster or the Scottish Parliament.
I am heartened by what the minister said about research into pick-up points, given local concerns about recent tragedies. I know that the minister is well aware of them and has worked hard on the issue. It would be productive if the research and advice from Strathclyde partnership for transport could be made public and reported on to the committee and Parliament to see what progress could be made. Although no single intervention would make a key difference, such reporting would be an important measure.Although there has been a lot of local work on the issue, concerns have been raised recently about the standards of school buses more widely. I am keen to hear the minister's thoughts on that and to ask what dialogue needs to take place between the Scottish Government, councils and bus operators. I understand that he has given guidance to local authorities, but should these matters be considered as part of the single outcome agreements?
Strathclyde partnership for transport has said that it can make available the manual that it developed to any local authority that wishes it. I am sure that SPT will wish to make the manual as widely available as possible, but I am not entirely certain whether it would be possible to put it in the public domain, purely for the very narrow reason that I do not know what contract SPT had with the consultants that it used and it might be that an inhibition is involved. SPT could answer that question.The member spoke about the standard of buses. Like others, he will be aware that, as a result of action that was taken in Aberdeenshire recently, several buses that were being used for school services were identified as not being fit for purpose and not meeting the rules. Two of the buses were taken off the road at once. I welcome that sort of action while deprecating the fact that the buses were found not to be fit for purpose while being used. The collaboration by the Vehicle and Operator Services Agency, the police and the council has been useful and should be repeated as often as is necessary.The major bus operators operate services to very high standards. There are a few operators who are clearly not meeting the safety requirements or operating to the standards that we expect and we should come down hard on such people.
I welcome that answer, but any reporting back that could be done within reason to the committee or the Parliament on the issue of pick-up points would be helpful. Given what you said, it is a crucial point.
I will seek to facilitate that, although I emphasise that, as minister, I will not report back directly. However, we take a keen interest and will see what we can do.
I have a general question. I am pleased to hear the minister speak about a wide range of measures and say that there is no one-size-fits-all solution. One of the challenges facing the Scottish Government and the Scottish Parliament is that some of the measures that you come up with will be reserved to the UK Government, which will be asked to implement them. What if it does not do that? I am looking for an assurance that the Scottish Government will work imaginatively to find ways round the problem, although perhaps not on a legislative basis, and that if the UK Government does not want to implement changes, we will try to implement them anyway by taking a slightly different approach.
As I said in my opening remarks, with our partners in the councils we will contemplate doing anything that we can identify that could make a contribution and to which there is no explicit legal inhibition to our doing. I do not think that anyone expects this to be the outcome, but I have the legislative power, for example—and have exercised it—to change the design of a lollipop lady's lollipop, but I do not have the legislative power to change the design of a school bus sign. That is just the way the cookie crumbles.As I say, we have established that the upper limit of sign size is not restricted and will use every opportunity presented by that to do what we can. However, we are not able to legislate to make the sign twice the size that people have been using. Councils might be able to deal with the issue through contractual arrangements, provided, of course, that there is good evidence that a trial is worth carrying out and that evidence from the trial suggests that it is the right thing to do and should be taken further. We should always be driven by the evidence. There are lots of ideas out there, some of which, when examined, are not as clear cut as one might immediately think.
We have had a good question-and-answer session on this matter. As we wish to pursue certain issues, we will keep the petitions open. I thank the minister for his patience in sitting through this and earlier items, and I hope that we can make progress not only on the critical issue of seat belts in buses but on the even more important issue of road safety for children making their way to and from school.
I will be very happy to respond to further questions on these petitions and on the previous petition that Mr Rumbles spoke to. With regard to that petition, I point out that Mr Rumbles has previously been told that the numbers that were given for Laurencekirk junction were different because the questions were different. The numbers are actually the same, and I will be happy to confirm that in writing when you ask me about it. I have to say that I was somewhat surprised to hear Mr Rumbles, long after he had been told that the numbers were identical, repeating a point that he had legitimately made to me. As I say, the numbers were not different; it was the questions that were different.Thank you, convener.
Thank you very much, minister. I did not think that you would miss such an opportunity.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Mar 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Monday 30 March 2009 Petitions · 1
- Petitions Process Inquiry Petitions · 87
- New Petitions Petitions · 48
- New Petitions Petitions · 41
- New Petitions Petitions · 29
- Current Petitions Petitions · 30
- Current Petitions Petitions · 50
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1
- Petitions Process Inquiry Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.