Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

National Planning Framework

Wednesday 10 December 2008 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Committee business 44 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

44 contributions
Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Item 4 is an approach paper on the national planning framework. We are considering the paper before the national planning framework has been published, so we are working based on guesswork a little, although we are fairly sure that the national planning framework 2 will be published tomorrow. Had we waited, we would not have had time to consider our approach before our Christmas recess, which could delay too much the process into which we need to feed.The lead committee is the Local Government and Communities Committee: we are a secondary committee. The suggestion is that we will take evidence on economic development aspects and energy issues and it is proposed that we hear from two panels at our meeting on 14 January. The suggested witnesses are in the paper. Are members content with that approach? Do you have other suggestions?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I simply have a question. Is Ofgem relevant to panel 2?

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Ofgem will give evidence to the committee on 10 February—

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I suspect that the proposed panel is sufficient and I am not sure whether we need Ofgem.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I simply look for guidance—I do not know. I presume that Ofgem regulates connection to the grid.

Stephen Imrie Clerk
link

To a degree, Ofgem is relevant to the process, but its primary interest is in transmission charging. The committee is primarily considering consenting and planning, in which Ofgem is less of a key player. As the convener said, Ofgem's chief executive still plans to appear before the committee on 10 February. That is consistent with the overall timetable for consideration of the national planning framework. If we start to count the 60 days from the end of this week, Parliament must complete consideration of the NPF by 6 March. That means that the committee could still make further views known to Parliament if anything that was specific to Ofgem arose.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I know from dealing with regulatory matters that we would not want the answer from the panel to a question to be that the matter was not for any of the companies that were represented.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

We will check. If Ofgem can send somebody along and its doing so will be useful, we will arrange that. The trouble is that the Christmas recess makes the timetable tight for consulting various groups.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I will raise an associated issue. Forgive me—others might have read the minutiae of what Stephen Imrie circulated on the guidance on thermal power generation. We heard today that the section 36 process involves two aspects—one is carbon capture and the other relates to heat. The matter is largely tangential to the national planning framework, but could somebody in the Scottish Parliament information centre do a brief note on that for us, so that we do not lose the issue about what the guidance says and what we might recommend?

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I have asked the minister to keep the committee informed of what is happening with that consultation.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

When that arrives, it will no doubt be impenetrable to read, but some worthy person in SPICe could summarise briefly whether the situation is developing.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

The SPICe researcher looks really enthusiastic about the prospect of providing us with a note on the matter.

Dave Thompson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Could Community Energy Scotland attend as part of panel 1? It deals with small-scale community energy, but it raised several issues about grid connection for community energy schemes.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I am sorry—do you mean panel 2?

Dave Thompson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Community Energy Scotland could be part of either panel.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I am concerned about our restricted time. When panels are too big, they become unmanageable. We must be careful about that.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Do we need to hear from the Beauly-Denny landscape group?

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

The aim is to provide an alternative to views on how the new planning framework should operate. It would be remiss of the committee to take evidence from only one side of the argument.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I am sorry, convener—I did not quite catch that. The Beauly-Denny landscape group has a view on the landscape between Beauly and Denny. The question is whether it is the relevant alternative voice on electricity and energy needs and on whether such projects should be a national priority. The group might have a view on the proposed development—

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

You took the words out of my mouth.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

The Beauly-Denny landscape group has an interest in one of the schemes that we think will be part of the national planning framework document. We felt that it would be appropriate to hear an alternative to the view that is likely to be presented by Scottish and Southern Energy, Scottish Power and National Grid on the aspects that should be taken into account. We must hear contrasting views.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

Does the group include local authority and other organisations that have objected to the development?

Stephen Imrie Clerk
link

I do not believe that the group includes local authorities as such; it is an umbrella body for non-governmental organisations and environmental organisations such as the John Muir Trust, RSPB Scotland and others that have been vocal about the Beauly to Denny power line.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We are attempting to consider what is in the planning framework, not to rerun the inquiry into the line.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I quite agree, and that point will be made clear to the people who give evidence. We will not be rerunning the inquiry; we will be considering how the national planning framework will deal with energy projects. I will certainly rule out any attempts by witnesses to rerun the inquiry into the specifics of this particular scheme. However, we will have to hear from people with experience of schemes, and get their views on how the national planning framework will operate, which is why we have to invite a group such as the Beauly-Denny landscape group, which is an umbrella organisation.

Dave Thompson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I would like to press a point about Community Energy Scotland, which is a new body for the whole of Scotland.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

We have not ruled that body out, but we have to consider the time that will be required to take evidence, and whether anyone will be available.

Dave Thompson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I accept what you say about the Beauly-Denny landscape group and about how you will rule certain questions out of order, but I would be amazed if the group did not make serious attempts to get stuck in.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I am sure that it will.

Dave Thompson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Is having the group on the panel wise if it could disrupt the whole meeting?

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

The committee has a responsibility to take a balanced view. An argument could be made that we do not need to invite all the power organisations. We might ask Scottish Power and Scottish and Southern Energy to agree that one or other of them could present their point of view. That would reduce the number of panellists, which might be helpful.However, we also need an organisation to present the other side of the argument—as long as it understands that we are considering not the merits of the Beauly to Denny line or the inquiry, but how such schemes would come into the national planning framework.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I agree. I also generally agree with having round-table discussions, but with the national planning framework document we have one group of people who say that it should go further because it does not go far enough for them to get consents through—the energy companies—and another group of people who say that it goes too far and who want local views to prevail. So that our recommendations can be clear, we need two panels. We have to ask people, "Are you happy or are you not?" That will allow us to get clear views on the published document. We should not have a woolly round table at which people pretend to agree. The fundamental question for us is which side of the argument the document should come down on.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

If the committee would prefer to have two separate panels, that is easily done. The meeting would probably be slightly longer.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

We would need self-discipline. Two panels would give us clarity. We could say to the first one, "Has it gone far enough?" And we could say to the second one, "Where has it gone too far?" The committee could then adjudicate.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I believe that the Beauly to Denny line is not in NPF 2.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We do not know? So, having a specific group on the Beauly to Denny line—

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I still think that we should split the witnesses. There will be a constituency in Scotland that thinks that power should remain local, and then there will be the energy companies which will say that we need to consider national priorities. We should be honest about separating the two issues, because we have to reach a judgment on whether the NPF gets the balance right.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

The national planning framework will be published tomorrow, so we will reconsider panels in the light of the framework and assess whether any of the proposed witnesses are not relevant to what we want to consider. The committee can leave it to the clerks and me to do that.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

If it turns out that Rob Gibson is well informed, then clearly we may have a meeting on why the Beauly to Denny line should be in the national planning framework.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

It might just be that where the Beauly to Denny line was in the system meant that it was too late to put it in the national planning framework. I do not know. However, we will find out tomorrow when the framework is published. Do members agree with the proposal, subject to changes being made to it following consultation between me and the clerk after the planning framework is published?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 10 December 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Energy Inquiry Evidence session · 90
  3. Council of Economic Advisers Committee business · 123
  4. Energy Inquiry Committee business · 25
  5. National Planning Framework Committee business · 44
  6. Credit Crisis and Banking Reform (House of Commons Committees) Committee business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.