We move on to PE812, which is from Caroline Paterson, on behalf of Stirling Before Pylons. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to acknowledge the potential health hazards associated with long-term exposure to electromagnetic fields from high-voltage transmission lines and to introduce as a matter of urgency effective planning regulations to protect public health.Several elected members have snuck up on me while I was looking the other way. Elizabeth Smith, Murdo Fraser, Gil Paterson and Richard Simpson are all here to discuss the petition, I think. No—three out of the four of them are going to have a wee bun fight, I see. That will be fun. They have all been nice to me, anyway, so I will give them a reasonable opportunity to contribute.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
High-voltage Transmission Lines (Potential Health Hazards) (PE812)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 3
- Liz Smith Con 1
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
- Nanette Milne Con 1
- Bill Butler Lab 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Nigel Don SNP 1
The record
10 contributionsThank you for the opportunity to make a brief submission in support of the petition, which I consider to be an important part of the essential scrutiny of the Beauly to Denny power line proposal. I am in no way a specialist on the scientific or health issues, but I have been assiduous, I hope, in reading the relevant documentation and listening to the deep concerns of the many constituents who live in close proximity to the route of the proposed power line. Many important questions remain over the potential health hazards of high-voltage electricity transmission lines. It is natural and proper that local people wish to be given a cast-iron assurance that the potential health risks have been fully investigated as openly and as transparently as possible. There is a serious concern that this high-voltage electricity transmission line—which would be routed close to many households—could have serious risk implications in relation to Alzheimer's and leukaemia conditions. For residents, families and communities living in the areas concerned, great care needs to be taken to ensure that the potential health risks are investigated on the basis of current evidence, rather than evidence that, in some cases, is three or four years old. Given that most of the newly available evidence has been gathered from among a fairly large population sample, it is absolutely essential that it is examined carefully before any decisions are made. That is why I ask the Scottish Government to undertake greater scrutiny of the petition.
The last time that I appeared before the committee I went into considerable detail on the health risks. I indicated at the time that my concern around power lines was a bit similar to my concerns around smoking—the evidence is growing year by year. Since I was last at the committee, a further paper on Alzheimer's disease has been produced in Switzerland. It has some interesting conclusions. The paper is not absolutely conclusive, but it points in the same direction as the evidence on leukaemia, which has become much firmer. On Alzheimer's, there is not only a response related to distance from power lines, but a response over time. The central core risk is about 1.24:1—people who live near a power line have an increased risk according to that ratio. If they live there for five years, the risk goes up to 1.51:1; if they live there for 10 years, it is 1.78:1; if they live there for 15 years or more, it goes up to twice the level of risk than would be the case otherwise. Some fairly large-scale studies have now indicated a trend in the same general direction. I must be clear, however, that apart from when longer periods of time are involved, the confidence intervals still go below and above 1, so we are not dealing with an absolute conclusion. However, the increasing body of evidence is strongly in favour of applying a precautionary principle. Other legislatures have also considered the matter, so we are clearly not alone. Germany has now introduced a precautionary principle at a federal level—the Government is no longer leaving it to individual Länder or to local government to make their own determinations. That follows decisions in Sweden, Switzerland, the Netherlands and Italy, and I understand that Austria is likely to introduce the precautionary principle, too. Even if we are not at a stage at which we can insist that existing lines are dismantled or undergrounded, it would be foolish in the extreme to make a major investment in something that is likely to have to last for a hundred years or more if, in three or four years' time, we have to underground large sections of lines that are close to communities. There is a further factor that the committee might wish to take into account. When the matter was being discussed originally, the proponents of the power line scheme suggested that the costs of undergrounding might be 10 to 15 times those of overground lines. The evidence today is that, in areas where lines are now being undergrounded, the long-term costs are about three to five times those of overhead lines. We are dealing with a reducing cost and an increasing health risk. I hope that the committee feels able to continue the petition and to convey to the Government that it would be taking some risks with the population were it not to insist on undergrounding those sections of power line that fall within 200m of any community.
link
In a rare outbreak of political consensus, I agree with colleagues sitting to my left and right and endorse what they said. However, I do not claim to have Dr Simpson's medical knowledge.The petition goes back to 2005, and I understand that members might be tempted to say that we have heard this debate before. However, the issue is still timely. The petitioners are affected by the proposed Beauly to Denny power line, and the reporters to the inquiry have yet to conclude their report. However, the report is imminent; it was supposed to be produced by the end of this year, although it will probably not go to Scottish ministers until early next year. The issue is important to the communities in part of Mid Scotland and Fife—Stirling and Perthshire—that are affected by it. The line will go through some densely populated areas and there is real concern about the health risks.As Dr Simpson said, recent studies, including one from Switzerland, suggest that there is a risk of increased levels of Alzheimer's disease among those who are affected by power lines. Every month that goes by, we seem to get more medical evidence. We are asking the committee to bear the precautionary principle in mind; we should not be putting people—and, in particular, their health—at risk from a new development such as the Beauly to Denny line. Strong representations must be made to Scottish ministers, who will have to determine the planning application next year.
I thank our three colleagues for their contributions, which probably cover many of the issues that we would have looked at.
I do not think that we should let the petition go. We should keep it going and get in touch with the Government to ask it to look at existing and proposed planning regulations to see whether those are really in the interests of the public and their health. We ought to look at the regulations very carefully. We also ought to ensure that the precautionary principle is adopted in relation to such issues. It is difficult to prove these things, but an increasingly strong case is being made.
I agree with Nanette Milne. I was struck by what everyone has said and, in particular, by Richard Simpson's concern that the cost of undergrounding is reducing but concerns about health are increasing. We should write to the Scottish Government on the two issues that Nanette Milne raised.We should ask whether the Scottish Government acknowledges that potential health hazards are associated with long-term exposure to electromagnetic fields from high-voltage transmission lines. We should also ask what the outcome was of the Government's discussions with the United Kingdom Government and other devolved Administrations on the measures that will be taken as a result of the report from the stakeholder advisory group on extremely low frequency electric and magnetic fields.
The petition hit the committee in January 2005, and a body of evidence has been presented over the past almost four years. Because we have taken such a lengthy time over the petition, more evidence has come forward on the health hazards of high-voltage transmission lines. We have to raise the issues with the Scottish Government in the hope that it will impress on the UK Government its strategy for the methods that we use for transmitting electricity. We need to ensure that we do not find ourselves in two or three years' time with conclusive evidence that there are real health hazards for existing and future residents.My concern is that it takes years for the evidence from studies to come through and, by the time the research is available, the dangers of exposure have already had an effect on young children who are born into the estates in the localities that are mentioned in the petition. We must impress on the Scottish Government and the UK Government the need to future proof such developments so that we do not find ourselves with a large bill not only for health but for changing energy transmission systems in Scotland.
I am grateful to Richard Simpson for reminding me about the matter. The last time that we spoke about the petition, he told us a lot about it. I recall suggesting that we needed to improve our understanding of science and to acknowledge that information builds up over time. I also recall saying that, sometimes, we can see something coming without being able to prove it statistically—a point that I am happy to repeat.Might we take the opportunity to write to the Minister for Public Health and ask specifically for the Government's view on the approach to precautionary science and how it evaluates emerging concerns? I am concerned that, if the Government looks only for effects that are demonstrated, proven and statistically significant at one in 20—or whatever the statistics say it should be looking for—it will miss a lot of tricks. However, if it takes the alternative view of seeing how information builds up as evidence emerges, we will get better answers rather more quickly. It would be nice to know whether that is being done because, if it is not, it is about time that it was.
Those are good comments, and they reflected the political consensus among the non-committee members who spoke to the petition. There are a number of unresolved issues that we want to keep pursuing and interrogating. I thank the members who contributed to the discussion. Does the committee approve the actions that members have suggested?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 16 Dec 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 16 December 2008 Petitions · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 13
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 19
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 32
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 15
- Review of SPCB-supported Bodies Evidence session · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.