I thank everybody for their patience, as we are resuming a few minutes later than intended. The next petitions are PE1086, which calls on the Scottish Executive to issue new guidance to health boards to remove excessive charges for car parking, preferably for those staff who work shifts and for whom public transport alternatives are limited; and PE1091, by Mary Murray, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the levying by NHS boards of car parking charges at NHS hospitals, such as that proposed by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde at Stobhill hospital.With us today are Tom Divers and Billy Hunter, on behalf of Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board, and Gerry Marr and Brian Main of NHS Tayside. Thank goodness I was at the optician recently so I could read those names with reasonable accuracy.The petitions have been before the committee for a considerable period. As convener, my concern on behalf of the committee is that charges were introduced—especially by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde—even though the petitions had been lodged. Part of today's discussion will be an exploration of the background and rationale behind the issues.Paul Martin, who is the member for one of the affected areas, is also present.Today, we are trying to find out why charges have been introduced in acute hospitals across Scotland, particularly in the greater Glasgow and Clyde area. The three fundamentals are: first, the principle behind charging and whether it is acceptable—committee members wish to explore that; secondly, the impact on not only hospital grounds but residential areas adjoining hospitals, about which MSPs and members of the public have raised concerns; and thirdly, the impact on staff or their personal safety, especially the disproportionate impact that charges may have on the staff in many parts of the NHS who get by on relatively low incomes.Those are the issues that have come to our committee through the petitions process. I invite individuals from the health boards to make opening statements or comments on any of them. After that, I will invite questions from members.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Parking Charges (Hospitals) (PE1086 and PE1091)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tom Divers Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board 25
- Frank McAveety Lab 23
- Gerry Marr NHS Tayside 16
- Billy Hunter Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board 11
- John Wilson SNP 10
- Brian Main NHS Tayside 7
- Rhoda Grant Lab 6
- Paul Martin Lab 6
- Nanette Milne Con 4
- Robin Harper Green 3
- Angela Constance SNP 2
- Bashir Ahmad SNP 2
The record
115 contributionsI will say something briefly. From the guidance that we were given, I did not expect that we would have the facility to make opening statements.
I am a nice guy.
As ever, convener.The fundamental reason why we embarked on charging arrangements was that patients, their relatives and visitors were not getting a fair crack of the whip. We received a number of complaints from individuals who were unable to get to clinic appointments or who drove around a number of our urban sites trying to get parked and were late for appointments or visiting times. We concluded that we needed to introduce arrangements within the urban setting in Glasgow city to redress the balance and to try to ensure that patients, visitors and relatives got a fairer crack of the whip—a fairer share of access to the available parking spaces.The reality is that there is simply not enough on-site parking capacity at the hospitals in Glasgow to accommodate even the numbers of staff who wish to park on the sites, let alone to give patients, visitors and relatives a fairer crack of the whip. We embarked on charging to try to address that imbalance and we sought to develop criteria as fairly as we could, particularly to recognise staff who required access to their cars as part of their continuing clinical commitments. Those staff had commitments at more than one hospital site, had commitments within hospital and community settings, or were required to visit patients at home.There was previously much debate at the committee about the charging structure. Initially, we introduced a maximum daily charge of £7, not because we wanted to charge anyone £7 to park but to try to ensure that the staff who parked on site had permits and were entitled to park there. In our financial modelling of the affordability, we made no material assumptions that we would derive a lot of income from a £7 charge.When the committee dealt with the petitions previously, we were asked to defer implementation of the next phase of the plan, which covered the introduction of the charging arrangements at the Stobhill and Southern general hospital sites. We did that until the interim guidance was issued in the form of the chief executive letter. Then we adjusted our charging arrangements to take account of the interim maximum charge that the letter introduced. We also reconsidered our access criteria for staff, to reflect points that were made in that letter, and submitted the necessary initial compliance statement to reflect the fact that we had done that. Our arrangements have moved on substantially since then.Paul Martin has been in correspondence with me again recently about one of the other points that you raised with me, convener—the impact on those who live in the locality. It would be fair to acknowledge that, although our original consultation covered community councils and some other locality interests, my sense is that we paid less attention to some of that interaction than we might have done with benefit, so we have sought to step up our game. Billy Hunter has recently been involved in the locality meeting with the local police and the community councils around the Southern general site to talk about the issues and concerns that residents there have raised. We would be happy to pick up similar arrangements in other parts of the city.
There is a slightly different history in Tayside. There are two chargeable parking areas there—at Perth royal infirmary and Ninewells hospital. Chargeable parking has been the subject of a private finance initiative contract, which was set for 30 years in 1998, so it still has another 20 years to run with respect to the Ninewells site.A year ago, we asked for an independent review of car parking arrangements on the Ninewells site, which was undertaken by the retired chief constable of Tayside Police, Bill Spence. Significant findings emerged. For members who are not familiar with the site, there are two car parks adjacent to its entrance. There was clear evidence that the parking spaces were being abused. Staff were using them and leaving their cars in them for their entire shifts. Indeed, people were parking their cars on the site and jumping on buses to go to their work in Dundee city. The 250 spaces that were meant to be for patients and relatives were therefore not turning over.We maintained the £1.60 charge that applied across the NHS Tayside area, including at Ninewells, but applied a punitive penalty of £10 if a person stayed for more than four hours. That was deliberate, because we wanted to make the car parking spaces available to our patients and their relatives. As a consequence of that decision, the car park spaces, which we have monitored, now turn between three and four times a day, and, for the first time in recent years, patients are getting access to car parking as a priority.The other issue for us was disabled parking. We involved disabled groups in the review. They wanted more disabled parking and better access, but they were content that we would continue to charge for disabled spaces.Bill Spence's group also reviewed our travel plan. We have a well-developed travel plan on the Ninewells site, which has a bus terminus and good transport links. Our travel plan is geared towards encouraging cycling and walking through providing more footpaths in the hospital, encouraging car sharing and trying to minimise the number of cars on the site. We work closely with the council, because on-street parking is a real difficulty for residents in the areas around PRI and Ninewells, as it is in Glasgow. We are working hard to minimise its impact, but it would be disingenuous to say that it is not a significant problem for residents near those hospitals.
I open up the discussion to questions or comments from members of the committee.
I presume that the staff in your hospitals arrive in shifts. Many staff may arrive at 1 o'clock in the morning and another lot may arrive at 3 o'clock or 4 o'clock or whenever. Have you developed travel plans for them that encourage car sharing? I presume that such plans would nicely free up spaces.
That is one of the initiatives in the Ninewells travel plan. We have become a joint subscriber with Dundee City Council and the University of Dundee to the web-based liftshare.com car-sharing initiative. This week, we are analysing the results of a travel plan staff survey. We carried out such a survey four years ago and another one last month to find out whether there has been a shift in how people travel. The early indications are that fewer single-occupancy cars are coming on site and that car sharing has increased, which seems to be helping us.
Are you encouraging that in any specific ways?
We publicise the scheme in NHS Tayside staff newsletters. We focus on the Ninewells site, but taking part in the lift share scheme is open to anybody in NHS Tayside.
We operate a lift share system in greater Glasgow and Clyde, too. It has been operational since earlier this year, and it operates in a similar way to the one in Tayside. On uptake, several hundred people have logged on to the site. I am not sure how successful things have been with shared journeys, but we do operate the lift share system. We have also considered other incentives, such as a bike loan scheme, reduced-rate ZoneCards and other travel cards. We are working closely with Strathclyde partnership for transport to consider other benefits that we could make more affordable and accessible to staff who need to access our sites at various times of the day.
Do you have figures showing the percentage of staff who now travel by car and what improvement there has been over time?
We are working on that. We have been working closely with the Energy Saving Trust, and a company called JMP has recently audited all our acute sites. We are forming and rationalising our travel plans now, and we will consider the detailed audit document—which arrived only this week—as we decide how to take forward its recommendations. The document goes into particular detail on localised journeys and how staff go to and from work.
We will be happy to go over that information with the committee once we have had the opportunity to analyse it and ascertain what improvement has been possible.
Have car parks always been oversubscribed, and is that why charges were introduced? Are there other reasons for introducing charges?
The history of the situation in Tayside goes back some time. The decision to charge for car parking was not based on income generation—there was no income generation for the health trust, as it used to be. We estimated that if car parking was not charged for, there would inevitably be a cost to the NHS in running the car parks efficiently and effectively. In Tayside, we reckoned it would come to about £0.5 million a year. It was decided in Tayside in 1998 to offset the cost to the NHS of administering car parking and to make the money available for patient care. That was the basis of the decision at the time.
As I hinted earlier, the best ratio of available spaces at any of our urban sites in greater Glasgow and Clyde where we introduced the policy was 1:1. That covered staff parking alone. The worst ratios were 5:1 and 6:1. We were oversubscribed before we started to make arrangements for fairer access for patients, visitors and relatives. As a working principle, when we embarked on the arrangement we considered a ratio of something like 60:40 for spaces for patients, visitors and relatives as opposed to spaces for staff. We have had to tune that figure, because of the different levels of capacity at individual sites. It is fair to say that a substantial body of responses to the original consultation exercise that we embarked upon in greater Glasgow before we introduced the original policy acknowledged that it was unlikely that we would be able to improve things unless we introduced more managed car parking arrangements. As Gerry Marr said in respect of NHS Tayside, none of the arrangements that have been put in place in greater Glasgow has been about generating income per se. All of the income that will be generated will be explained and laid out in an annual statement and it will be reinvested in further improvements to the scheme. Given that we were oversubscribed before we started on each site, we concluded that charging was an inevitable step that we had to take to effect improvement and put in place a better-managed arrangement.
I want to be quite clear about that. Are you saying that at every site where car parking charges have been introduced there were difficulties in getting parked because too many people were using the car park?
Yes—at each site that has been covered in the roll-out thus far. As I said, our entry point into the exercise was that patients, visitors and relatives were not getting fair access to parking and we needed to change the balance. Immediately on changing the balance, even the site that had the greatest number of spaces was substantially oversubscribed.
There is much shift working at hospitals, and public transport is not always available at the end of a night shift or the start of an early shift. The health service's workforce is predominantly female. What risk assessments have been performed and what steps have boards taken to ensure that staff are safe when they make their way to and from work?
We were fortunate in getting European funding for our integrated travel plan a couple of years ago. On the Ninewells hospital site there is comprehensive public transport infrastructure—it is like a bus station. We work closely with Dundee City Council to match the timing of buses to our shift patterns. That is where we have concentrated our efforts, but there is always room for improvement.In addition, with the parking management company we have invested significant income to improve pathways, lighting and security on site, particularly in the evenings. If a female member of staff requests an escort, she can be escorted by one of our portering security staff. We take the issue seriously on the Ninewells and PRI sites. Staff have not complained or drawn our attention to the issue through our staff partnership forum: they seem relatively satisfied with the arrangements that are in place.
I understand that you take steps on site, but the bus will probably not take everyone to their front door—or anywhere close to it—and people might have to take a bus to the town centre to catch a connection, which are disincentives for people who have to travel alone late at night. Have you considered such issues?
The bus interchange at Ninewells, which is outside the front door, is completely undercover. It is all glazed, so it is virtually internal. We have fitted it with intensive closed-circuit television coverage, to try to give confidence to staff—
Sorry, but that is not what I meant. I understand that you have taken steps on site, but given that the buses that come to Ninewells do not deliver everybody to their door, people probably have to travel into the city centre to catch a transfer that takes them home. Have you given thought to people's safety while they are hanging round the town centre bus station late at night?
We work closely with the Tayside and central Scotland transport partnership and we are in close discussions with bus operators at bus strategy meetings to try to get operators to make changes. It is clear from responses to our travel survey from people who travel from outwith Dundee that buses from Blairgowrie or Forfar tend to go to the city centre before they go to Ninewells. We suggested to the bus operators that buses should go to the hospital before going to the city centre. We are fairly confident that the operators are looking favourably at changing schedules to save staff from having to pick up connections.Another big success is that from the start of the month we introduced our hospital bus link, which is an hourly scheduled bus service between the two main acute sites—PRI and Ninewells. The service is operated by Stagecoach and the journey takes 40 minutes. Quite a lot of staff, patients and visitors are using the service between the two centres. Stagecoach is also working with us on a salary sacrifice scheme that will encourage staff to use the bus and provide them with some savings on their bus travel.
link
I prefix my questions by saying that I am vehemently opposed to hospital car parking charges, which I believe are a tax on the sick and on those who work with and visit them. Such charges go against the founding principle of the NHS, which is that services should be free at the point of delivery. That view is based on my experience of car parking charges at St John's hospital in my constituency. I cannot comment on experiences in Tayside and Glasgow, of course, but I would be interested to know what thought was given to ways of controlling access to car parks other than by the imposition of fees.A few times this afternoon we have heard that car parking fees are not used to generate income and that money raised in that way will be reinvested. How will local stakeholders be able to scrutinise information about the income that is generated by car parking charges? How will that money be reinvested? Will car parking charges that are raised from a particular hospital be reinvested on that site or will they be used to subsidise other services, such as transport to other hospitals? At St John's hospital, car parking charges are used to fund transport to take people to the Edinburgh royal infirmary, which has proved to be politically unacceptable locally.One of the gentlemen from Tayside said that not imposing fees would have led to a cost to the NHS of £0.5 million. Why are car parking facilities different from other aspects of the NHS estate? All aspects of the NHS estate, such as buildings, store rooms and so on, generate a cost. Why is car parking treated differently from other activities?I am also interested in the issue of cost to staff. Cleaners and nurses are paid less than consultants and I would be interested to know how that is taken into account.
We have tuned the levels of charge to reflect different levels of salary and, indeed, the fact that some people work part time. One of the issues that has been raised and will be considered as part of the review is whether the differentials are at the right levels to ensure that those who are the highest earners pay sufficiently more for their space than others do. In the implementation of the policy, we have sought to recognise those differences in income and have set the charges accordingly. On the issue of the transparency of the information that is made available to stakeholders about the income that is raised from parking charges, we have made it clear, since the inception of the charges, that we will publish a detailed annual account of the charges that have been levied and how that income has been used to pay for the maintenance of the existing arrangements or, indeed, their enhancement, as our sense is that there are bound to be enhancements that need to be made in the course of a year to improve the arrangements. Such transparency and the publication of that separate set of accounts will make explicit how that money has been directed and the fact that the charge has been levied for no purpose other than that of providing that service.Gerry Marr touched on your fundamental point in his introduction. We have faced the issue for years—nay, decades. A colleague embarrassed me in the margins of a meeting a few months ago by showing me an article from the Health Service Journal in 1982, when I was the administrator of Glasgow royal infirmary, which showed a picture of me and my deputy and said that we were discussing the car parking problems at that hospital. Over decades, we have tried many ways—from employing attendants to using barriers—of achieving some control, but we have been unable to introduce a system that gives patients and others fairer access and allows staff who have a priority claim to park without having the managed set of arrangements.Like Gerry Marr, I think that if we used mainstream NHS resource to fund such arrangements, that would be at the expense of providing direct care. In our society, we pay for car parking in many other parts of our lives. Our sense is that if hospital car parking became a charge on the public purse, that would drain spending that should be made on providing direct patient care.
Very similar arguments were advanced in Tayside. In 1998, the Ninewells decision was governed by the opportunity to obtain, through a PFI contract, significant capital investment that had not been available to the health board. The PFI contract was not about just car parking charges, but about building an infrastructure for car parking, which included a multistorey car park.We are absolutely able to be transparent about what happens at Perth royal infirmary, because that is not a PFI scheme—we run it, so we can show the books openly. However, the perennial problem is that the PFI contract restricts our ability to make a similar disclosure about the Ninewells site. We require the company to disclose to us the income level and we work with it so that it returns sufficient money monthly to allow us to release about 2,500 spaces a month to high-priority patients, such as those who use renal services or who have cancer. The company works closely with us to regenerate funding and we declare that openly and transparently, but we are restricted by the PFI contract with that private company.As Tom Divers said, people adopt a position in the debate and that must be respected. We take the view that the convention of charging for car parking provides one way to offset costs, which allows money to be released for direct patient care. We stand or fall by that argument.
I do not know the Glasgow hospitals at all; I know the Grampian ones best and the Tayside ones reasonably well. The system in Grampian is not dissimilar to that in Tayside—the first half hour of parking in Grampian is free, then £1.50 is charged for up to about five hours, after which the price goes up. I visited Ninewells two or three weeks ago and was relieved to find a parking space close to where I wanted to be. When I was there, I was struck by the turnover. When I parked my car, I saw three or four cars leave that bit of the car park, and when I returned to collect my car, the same thing happened. I accept what has been said about turnover, which was obvious from my short visit.I am interested to know whether you have a system in place to cope with the revised Government guidelines that have been issued recently about concessions, free parking and so on. The guidelines say that concessions must be provided to people on low incomes and to frequent attenders, such as visitors to long-stay patients. In Grampian, as far as I know, the ward sister or someone in the office can issue a voucher so that people can get their money back, but I am interested to find out how you are managing to cope.
In Glasgow we have worked closely with our clinical colleagues and out-patient departments to identify those categories of patients who would qualify for concessionary parking, which is free. Whether they qualify depends on the nature of their care and is detailed in the Executive guidance. We have also worked closely with the company that manages our car parks and we link that with the clinical service to issue a permit either for a single journey or a group of journeys, so that a range of patients—whether oncology, renal or other patients—receive free parking. That arrangement is extended to cover visitors of patients who are in intensive care units, cardiac care units, or who are receiving longer-term care. We also have arrangements in place to cover people who are in receipt of low-income benefits. We manage that through CP Plus, ensuring that the arrangement is made available to users of our sites as they come and go. That has worked successfully and, as it stands at the moment, that has been a particular success of our operational policy.
Is it seen to be hassle free by the people on the receiving end?
Yes, it is absolutely hassle free. To be fair to us, we put a lot of effort and time into making it a success—it did not happen by accident. Prior to the implementation of the policy, we spoke to our clinical colleagues and we identified the key groups of people who would be affected so that we could have in place the mechanism and the policy at the front end to help us on our way. That particular aspect of the policy has been successful.
Regarding your point about turnover, we have sought to be sensitive to that in the way in which we have structured the pricing charges. For the first two hours we charge a flat rate of £1. You were struck by the rapidity of turnover—for a lot of the high-volume attendances, not least the out-patient clinics, two hours will cover a significant majority of attendances. We have sought to do that, and as part of our earlier review we stepped back from levying charges overnight and reduced weekend charges to a flat rate of £1 to reflect the fact that there was lower pressure on access and utilisation. We keep each of those elements under review as we move forward with implementation. As members of the committee will know, each of the NHS systems in Scotland is required to produce a material report by 30 June this year, in relation to the implementation of the arrangements.
In Tayside, we have similar arrangements for patients who need free permits. We work closely with our clinical colleagues, clinical team managers and senior charge nurses. The patient population that benefits from the permits is mainly oncology and radiotherapy patients, renal patients and such like. Those departments almost get a regular supply of permits—they know what patients are coming in. Other clinical groups can ask for permits as and when they are required; equally, they can recommend and request free-parking permits for relatives of patients who, for particular reasons, have long stays or need particular care. It works very well—although I did wonder how it could work without being abused, because as soon as a system is put in place, someone is on to it and trying to work a fast one.If any of you have been to the fair city of St Andrews and tried to park your car, you will know that you need to buy a wee scratchcard from a shop. We thought that that was a good idea and we went ahead with it in conjunction with Vinci Park UK Ltd. The company does the printing and provides us with approximately 2,500 vouchers per month. We issue them to the clinical groups and pass them on to patients. We give a week's supply to relatives who need them: seven cards for seven days. In order to use them, you scratch a card, after which it becomes invalid. The system has worked a treat for patients who are in regular receipt of permits.We examined whether we should have fixed criteria. For example, we could have decided to give a card to an applicant who ticked the box for six out of 10 conditions. The clinical groups decided that there could not be hard and fast rules and that the merits of each individual patient's situation had to be considered. They wanted to take responsibility for trying to manage the system with us and that has been one of the great successes of our systems.Gerry Marr mentioned that we consulted disabled users about charging for car parking, because they were fed up with folk abusing their space. People were parking all day using blue badges that did not belong to them, which meant that disabled people could not get to park. Although we have a PFI contract with Vinci Park UK, it did not want to be associated with any increased profit or income from charging disabled people to use the car park, so we have a clean set of books in which that income is declared and we have used it to fund free permits for other patients and relatives. In addition, we introduced a new hospital mobility system similar to those in shopping malls where disabled people can sign up as members of the scheme to use electric scooters. People can phone ahead and book a scooter or order one online so that when they arrive at the disabled car park at the main entrance they can pick up an electric scooter. The car park is manned all day by a supervisor. All those benefits, including free permit parking, have come from that. It has been a good result for us.
Have you carried out any customer satisfaction surveys?
We use them a great deal. A patient partnership group, consisting of members of the public, regularly comes to Ninewells to carry out surveys and speak to relatives and visitors on a range of subjects. We usually encroach on the group and ask them to include a few questions on car parking. There has been a vast improvement in the response from patients and, especially, visitors, since we introduced the changes approximately a year ago.
Paul Martin has also raised this issue and he has attended the committee a number of times for that reason. I invite him to ask a question.
I wish to take Tom Divers back to his earlier remarks to the effect that the inspiration for the introduction of car parking charges was due to the number of complaints received from both patients and visitors. Can he provide us with the number of complaints in respect of Stobhill? I would not like to think that he introduced the charges as a result of anecdotal evidence, but that the decision was evidence based.
I do not have the numbers with me today but I am happy to get them. Many of the complaints from people who have had difficulty parking are handled by the clinical staff who see patients at a clinic or patients' visitors. I have received a small number of approaches and letters. I am happy to get further evidence.This is not a trivial issue. It relates to a range of clinics where individuals had repeated difficulties getting there in time for their appointment. One of the most distressing aspects is that further upset and anxiety was created for patients and their relatives beyond the anxiety that many of them already experienced in attending for a hospital appointment. I am happy to source further figures.
That is an important point. For any professional organisation to implement a policy it would need to be evidence based; it cannot be anecdotal. It has always been expected of me that I would return to your office with evidence of complaints that I receive. You cannot provide anecdotal evidence alone to the committee—that is not sufficient. We need evidence of how many complaints have been received and of other difficulties. My experience of Stobhill hospital, both as a local resident and as a user, is that until the construction of the ambulatory care and diagnostic facility there were never any car parking difficulties. Prior to the ACAD project, I received no complaints about parking at Stobhill and never wrote to Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board about the issue. I am not aware of other elected members having received such complaints.
The concentration of major capital projects around Stobhill has been greater than that at any of the other sites in greater Glasgow. Ideally, we would not have planned for four significant developments to be under way at the same time. We examined whether there was an opportunity for us to stagger the developments, without having a detrimental effect on the service improvements that we were keen to make, but that was not possible—not least because the prioritisation at United Kingdom level of the new Marie Curie hospice by one of the major funding partners, Marie Curie Cancer Care, was dependent on funding being accessed at a particular time. I know that Paul Martin is in touch with that development. The combination on one site, at the same time, of four major projects was always going to be substantially disruptive.
With the convener's indulgence, I will ask two further questions concerning the local community. You referred to a public meeting on the south side of Glasgow. I understand that that meeting took place at the behest of the local community and was not initiated by the health board—representatives of the health board were asked to attend the meeting. I am not sure whether you were trying to make that clear.What is the point in contact being made with the local community after the policy has been implemented? Surely the matter should have been discussed with the local community prior to the implementation of the charges. Have you not dealt with the car parking problem on the Stobhill campus by dumping it on the hospital's neighbours, as traffic has been transferred from the Stobhill site to the community surrounding Stobhill?
I would hate it to be thought that we were dumping the problem on anyone. The policy is a really important aspect of the provision of high-quality patient care and is designed to provide patients and their relatives with better and fairer access to the hospital. In my opening comments, I sought to acknowledge that in the original consultation that we undertook prior to the policy's introduction we may have underestimated the importance of engaging with community interests. It is not the case that there were no such interests—we received comments from a number of them—but the situation that has unfolded since implementation has given me pause for thought about how we can conduct such interactions better in the future.As an example, I mentioned the recent community engagement that took place south of the river. The meeting was held at the behest of a community group, but from 2002 I recruited a community engagement team to NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. Paul Martin knows that, because I did so partly at his request and at the request of other elected members. The team spends much of its time engaging with community interests and is actively engaged in the debate about car parking charges. We need to raise our game on the issue, because it is not our intention to dump on local residents. We must ensure that we find the best solutions—solutions that meet the requirements of both parties.
The health board said that it has introduced these charges partly because of the green transport policy. However, how does reducing the charge to a maximum of £3 help to implement that? Given that that is what a return bus journey to the south side of Glasgow costs, surely the volume of traffic to Stobhill hospital—I have been using that as an example, but I am sure that the same can be said of the Southern general and other hospitals—will remain the same. Such a reduction is simply a token gesture. After all, if the aim is to implement the green transport policy, the charge might as well be reduced to zero.
The green transport policy is simply one part of what has driven the development of this strategy. As Paul Martin, who has closely followed our regular briefing sessions on the implementation of various service strategies in greater Glasgow, will know, we have been required to submit a campus plan for all the sites in the city of Glasgow that are covered by our acute services plan. That also involves meeting the requirements of the green transport policy. However, that is but one aspect of what has caused us to take this route.We settled on the figure of £3, because it was the interim maximum charge. As I have said, we have aimed to ensure that patients, relatives and visitors get a fairer crack of the whip, to calibrate our charges for visitors and staff to reflect that and to continue to give staff who need permits and access to their car during the day the facility to move on and off site.
But do you accept that the volume of car traffic going to and from the hospitals will remain the same? Making the parking charge the same as the cost of a return bus journey will simply not prohibit people from taking their cars to the hospital.
I am not in a position either to accept or to disagree with your point. As we made clear earlier to Mr Harper, we are still weighing up evidence from a series of measures.Obviously, we will regularly review the arrangements not just to find out how the income raised has been used but to look at—and, if necessary, recalibrate—the balance between the number of permits given to staff and the number of spaces that have been made available to patients and relatives. Members would properly expect us to undertake such on-going calibrations, and to review what is happening on different sites at different points in time to find out, for example, whether a situation in which four major building contracts are under way at one time requires a materially different set of arrangements from a situation in which there are no such contracts.
As the witnesses from both NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde and NHS Tayside have made clear, the health boards came up with the idea of car parking charges after considering alternatives, such as introducing parking restrictions at car parks. However, as Angela Constance has pointed out, the move does not sit well with the principle of the health service being free at the point of delivery. Why was it felt that there was no option other than to introduce such charges? Indeed, according to certain statements, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde initially considered charging £7 a day for parking. In that light, is the £3 maximum, as set out in the revised guidance, delivering dividends for NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde? I realise that I have asked a couple of questions, but I hope that they can be dealt with.
In Tayside, the issue is straightforward. The decision to charge for car parking and to do so through a private finance initiative was taken to mobilise significant and rapid capital investment on the Ninewells site and to free up capital for schemes for direct patient care. That was absolutely the reason for mobilising the contract.On the ideological aspect, I will advance our argument, with which you will either agree or disagree. Our view is that we are making an overt charge. The public are familiar with the convention of paying for parking. We do not view the charge as an additional tax because, in reality, if there were no car parking charges, we would have to spend £0.5 million and that money would be drawn from the health float, so members of the public would still pay for car parking. The issue is whether we should use an overt charge to free up money for other resources. That is the argument that we advance and, as I said to Angela Constance, it is the argument that we will stand or fall by.
As I said, the £7 charge was, in essence, a deterrent. We did not want to charge anyone £7 a day for car parking, but we wanted to ensure that staff who did not have a permit did not bring their cars on site. As I said, the fact that the interim maximum charge has been set at £3, whereas we had £7 in our policy, has not impacted materially on the financial model that we developed, because we had no expectation that we would collect large numbers of £7 charges and no desire to do so.I had an interesting talk to David Hastie earlier about the challenge that a maximum levy of £3 may pose for us. There is now evidence from some sites, not just in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, that patients are finding it difficult to access spaces. As part of implementation of the arrangements, we will continue to consider whether we can, by some means, create more protected zones in which patients can park.
We imposed a £10 surcharge in Tayside—we have now removed it because of the new guidance—because of the evidence that surcharging stops people parking. We were determined to put our patients and their relatives first and foremost. The evidence from our patients and their relatives is that that was enormously successful.
I will follow that up, as it leads me straight to the issue about the permits that have been issued to staff. I take on board Mr Marr's point that it is vital that patients and relatives who visit hospitals have parking spaces, but it is also vital that some staff who work in hospitals have access to parking, where necessary. Although there has been movement on pay scales in the NHS, it still has some of the lowest-paid workers in the country and charges are being levied on their low wages. I am concerned about the proportional impact on those individuals of the permits that are being issued. Do health boards take into account the type of workers when permits are issued? Is an economic impact assessment made when NHS boards levy charges from staff who work in hospitals, to ensure that the lowest-paid workers are not adversely affected?
I take on board that comment, but we have not yet considered that issue in NHS Tayside. We apply a flat-rate charge of £1.60 for parking for the day. We have 1,400 staff permits and the monthly charge is £25. We have not differentiated between low-paid workers and higher-paid staff. However, I would not rule that out; it merits some examination.
Earlier on, we discussed how we apply our permit charges. We have permit charges that start at £5 per month and go up to £25 or £40 a month, depending on an individual's earning capacity. For people who earn up to £10,000, the maximum charge for a permit is £5 per month. In addition, we acknowledge that many of the low-income staff on our sites do not have a business need to travel between sites and so that group of staff are less likely to need a permit to fulfil the requirements of their post. That is part of the allocation criteria and, so far, the logic that we have applied has appeared to be reasonable and fair.
I have another question for Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board on travel between sites. I recently spoke to someone who travels between sites, although not between hospitals that currently have car parking charges in place. They said that travel from the Western infirmary to the dental hospital could be charged at a taxi rate. I know that this is outwith the issue of parking fees, but it goes back to Robin Harper's point about greener transport. Has the board considered getting people who are working off site to take public transport between sites rather than clock up car mileage? That might have an impact on who would require car parking spaces at various sites.
In certain parts of the board area we operate shuttle buses between various sites. Those buses are managed to a rigorous, tight time schedule and run frequently. There are good connections between the majority of our acute sites. Staff can access those services and thereby avoid the unnecessary use of cars or taxis. We also have in place a shuttle bus that connects certain sites with Glasgow Central station. That is another mechanism to reduce the need for car journeys. We are focused on that. We are looking at improving the car-share scheme and rolling out a pool-car system across certain sites to reduce the need for taxi travel and encourage shared journeys between sites.
We have piloted a pool-car scheme at Ninewells, which has been a great success and which we plan to expand. People do not have to come to work by car; they can use public transport, but there is a car available if they need to travel between sites. We have even put in two pool bicycles, but we are still waiting for the first one to go.
I have another question on the Ninewells PFI car park. The figure of £0.5 million was mentioned. Would that be the cost per annum to the health board?
Yes. Because of the nature of the contract—which I was not involved in—we reckon that the penalty for buying out the PFI scheme would be a one-off payment of somewhere in the region of £10 million.
Is that because the scheme still has 20 years to run?
Yes.
I see that £3 per day is the cost for a full day's parking at hospitals in Glasgow. What is the minimum?
The minimum charge is £1 for the first two hours. Then the charge rises on an incremental scale to a maximum of £3 for more than four hours, up to 24 hours.
Just so that we are clear, is it correct to say that Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board charges by the hour, in effect?
The first two hours cost £1; between two and three hours costs £1.50; between three and four hours costs £2.50; and more than four hours costs £3.
That is because the rates are capped at the moment; it is not the rate that you initially wanted to introduce. If a patient attends a clinic that runs late, the patient will be penalised for the clinic, not them, running late. Is any account taken of the late running of clinics when a patient has waited longer than the designated time or has been directed to another clinic while they visited the hospital?
Yes. That could happen daily. The car park service is managed by our facilities staff, who are closely linked to our management company, which is called CP Plus. We recognise any detrimental effect on the patient or visitor in the event of a clinic overrunning or the appointment schedule running late and we ensure that no punitive measure is taken as a consequence of it. We manage that through our internal communication system.
Are patients notified that penalty charges can be claimed back or they can be exempted from them, whichever is the case?
Yes. Patients are notified at the point of service, generally by our clinical colleagues. If a clinic is running late, we tend to be informed by other colleagues and we pass the information on to CP Plus. If there was a slippage of communication for some reason, we would look favourably on any patient on whom a penalty was applied and ensure that we withdrew it.
The only element of our charging regime that was changed as a consequence of the CEL was the maximum daily charge, which was reduced from £7 to £3. The other elements of the pricing structure remain, including the fact that the charges do not apply beyond 9 o'clock at night. We have now altered the weekend position.
I have been quite patient today and I have allowed lots of questions to be answered, but I have a wee list myself. Is there any acute hospital site at which Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board does not charge?
We apply charges to all the sites in Glasgow. That saw us through phases 1 and 2. We are now considering phase 3.
That is the city of Glasgow, at this stage.
The guidance that you have from the Government says:"The Review Group concluded that the provision of car parking at NHSScotland hospitals is a service for patients and, in general, should be provided free of charge."However, there is no hospital parking free of charge in the city of Glasgow—or there is unlikely to be.
The assessments that we have carried out on each of the sites thus far show that each has a level of car parking pressure that is not replicated in a number of the other non-acute hospitals. Between 45,000 and more than 80,000 patients come to their accident and emergency units each year and, between them, they have more than 1 million out-patient attendances. They are heavily used sites. As we work through the programme, the guidance requires us to carry out a structured appraisal on every site for which we believe that that is necessary. We will follow the guidance in the later stages of the process.
You and the other witnesses represent greater Glasgow and Tayside, so my worry is that citizens in our two poorest cities will be going to hospitals where there is charging. That is the reality of the evidence that we have heard, although I understand the history and why we have arrived where we are, due to a combination of assumed free access and the impact of the PFI programme. My second question is: what income does charging generate? You are not charging to generate income, but what income do you get as a percentage of your overall annual spend?
NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde is running a monthly trading account and we are looking at expenditure versus income. As of the year end, our surplus was just short of £90,000. That—
I am sorry to interrupt; I will rephrase my question. If you were to provide parking free of charge, how much would it cost as a percentage of your overall budget? The figure must be pretty low.
It is. It is £1.3 million against £1.8 billion.
Okay. I am not very good at counting, but I think that that is not a big figure in percentage terms.
It is 0.1 per cent.
But—
I am sorry to talk over you, Tom, but charging is an issue. Our case load as elected members tells us that.
It is an issue, but there is also what else we can do for direct patient care with £1.3 million.
I concede that point, but only as a debating point. You, as the health boards, and we, as elected members, are getting grief and all for £1.3 million. Surely the good will that free parking brings is part of the glue that binds people to the health service. As Gerry Marr said, the debate is an emotional and philosophical one. You have had to come before a parliamentary committee to defend a spend of only £1.3 million. We are interrogating you because our constituents are—rightly—interrogating us on charging as a percentage share of overall budgets. Given what constituents have told me and other members, what patients are telling you, and what staff have said in the submissions that we have received from trade unions, is charging really worth while?
Contrary to public perception, guys such as Gerry Marr and me do not set out to create upset and unhappiness. That is not what brought us into these roles.
Thank God for that.
You are right about the merit of the point as a debating point—£1.3 million is a significant sum. Our view is that it should be used to deliver direct patient care. I say that notwithstanding the fact that, as you said, I and Gerry Marr have responsibility for some of the poorer parts of Scotland. Our policies are designed so that we do not penalise those who are on income support or incapacity benefit. We try to make our policies as sensitive as possible to the issues. However, £1.3 million buys a lot of direct patient care.
I endorse what Tom Divers said. We have implemented car parking charges on the two sites in Tayside that require intensive traffic management—which is an issue that must not be underestimated. Other sites in rural parts of the region or city-centre psychiatric hospital, learning disability or elderly units do not require the same level of traffic management. We have restricted charging to car parks where traffic management is required. The question is: do we provide such traffic management on the NHS or by levying a charge? As I have said, we determined that we should do it by way of a charge, and that decision has released funds for, for example, somewhere between 70 and 80 hip replacements a year.
Okay, but surely £1.3 million is not an overwhelmingly significant figure given overall NHS expenditure on bureaucratic elements such as administration. What would you say if you were engaging with Government ministers on the subject? In Wales, the Administration has chosen to go down the path of not having charging at hospitals. Would you welcome the Scottish Government making that commitment if there was no impact on your overall budgets?
We would be placed in severe difficulties because of the nature of the PFI contract.
But you could seek discussions with Government on how to address that over a long period of time. For example, it could be managed through the grant allocation. Have you raised that with ministers?
We have not raised that as yet.
Should you?
This is the first time that the issue has been raised with us. I need to reflect on it, although I do not discount the suggestion. You make a valid point, convener. We need to consider it.
When I was a student, I worked at Stobhill during the summer holidays. My mother was a cleaner and my father was a porter at the hospital, so I have an emotional interest in the debate. One of my duties was to work as the gateman, which was a fantastic overnight shift, given the slice of life that one encounters in Paul Martin's constituency. We had a boom system. My duty was to ensure that no one whom we did not know got in or out. I know that you will say that that was 25 or 30 years ago, but the important point is that good behaviour was expected of residents and visitors when they entered hospital grounds.The tragedy is that to stop on-street parking in Stobhill you have spent a fair amount of money to install high-quality bollards from the bottom end of the hospital to the hospital gate, next to Springburn park. Never mind the fact that they are unsightly; punters say to Paul Martin, other members and me that a lot of money has been spent just to stop people parking there when more imaginative solutions could have been tried. I am repeating a point that my mother has made to me and that I promised to raise in Parliament.Stobhill hospital is different from the Royal hospital for sick children and the Victoria infirmary, which affect my constituents. Can there not be more flexibility in the system?
Car park charging is an essential component of intensive traffic management. We know what the volume of traffic is. When I left Ninewells hospital to come here this afternoon, I drove past cars that were queueing to park. This morning I was at PRI, where I drove past cars that were queueing to park. I have no doubt that if we did not have car parking charges, the car parks would be full before the first patient arrived for a 9 o'clock out-patient appointment. I see car parking charges as part of a traffic management system.
We are having a notional debate about car parking. Is the important issue not managing access to the space, which need not include an element of charging? The point is for your structures and for the staff who are employed at the hospital to have the capacity to manage access. I am thinking aloud. The period to which I referred may have been a golden age, but management by staff prevented excessive misuse of car parks.
We are keen to learn from the Welsh experience. We are intrigued by how the Welsh have managed to address the issue. I know that many car parking schemes in Wales were private finance initiative schemes, so I would be interested to find out from those in the Welsh Assembly how the measures that have been introduced were managed fiscally, which must have been a significant challenge. We do not have that information.
It was important for me to put to you the questions that I have asked, as those are the questions that the public ask us all the time. People see accessing hospitals as different from accessing multiplexes and other public spaces. They have a powerful sense that when they are trying to visit people who are unwell, they should not be harassed by guys in yellow coats.Members have no further questions. Would you like to add to the comments that you have made so far?
I do not think so. I hope that our exchange has been of value to the committee. We acknowledge entirely that car parking charges are a difficult, sensitive issue. I hope that both of us have indicated that we will keep the arrangements under review. I have promised to follow up on one or two specific issues that Mr Harper and Mr Martin raised. I am sure that the committee will look forward with interest to the series of reports that NHS Scotland will make early in the summer.
Are you obliged to respond to the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing by 30 June?
That is the point to which I was alluding.
I reinforce Tom Divers's comments. We are grateful to have had the opportunity to rehearse the debate in public during this afternoon's exchange. We will take members' comments on board.
Thank you for your time this afternoon. I hope that your car parking charges have not expired.
Not on the train, convener.
Your office is right in the city centre.We have spent a fair amount of time on these petitions. How do members wish to take them forward, based on the information with which we have been provided this afternoon?
link
It is important that we continue with these petitions. In my experience—I say this with no disrespect to the gentlemen before us today—getting transparency on the income and expenditure associated with car parking charges at hospitals has been rather fraught and difficult. Collectively, we would be doing a good service to our constituents if we were to give the issue some scrutiny. All NHS boards have to reply to the minister by the end of June, so it would be good to get a flavour of that and to find out how the minister responds.
Could we find out from Wales how the matter is managed there? It must have the same problems with the size of car parks, the number of people trying to park and people using the free parking at hospitals as cheap parking for the day while they go off elsewhere, because there are usually good bus services. We cannot take those issues lightly, and it would be good to find out how people in Wales have overcome, or are working to overcome, such problems.
The discussion will be in the Official Report, but we need to ensure that the Government gets the complete record of what has been said this afternoon, so it can consider that as part of the review.
We must pursue with vigour the issues that Mr Divers assured us he would follow up on, in respect of the complaints received. I am concerned about how he will present his response to us. I do not have any difficulty with his providing a copy of the complaints and redacting the names and addresses of the individuals. I would like committee members to see quality evidence that large volumes of complaints about car parking were received. I am not saying that I do not believe Mr Divers, but he must provide the evidence.On Angela Constance's point, I submitted a freedom of information request for the contractual arrangements for enforcement, and was advised that I would not be provided with a copy of the contract. The contractual arrangements for enforcement have an impact on the possibility of the health board having to meet a possible deficit, which is probably unlikely, but cannot be ruled out. That is where the examination of successful tender documents comes in.On community engagement, I do not know how the committee would take this forward, but it is not good enough for witnesses to come to the committee and say, "You know what? We've implemented this policy, but we're happy to have a chat with the local community about it." On what terms will engagement take place? Will Mr Divers consider reversing the policy, or is it just about having a cosy chat with the local community? I am not sure whether he will get such a chat, but if so does he hope to advise the community or to persuade them that car parking charges are the way forward? People want to see genuine engagement.The issues must be taken forward, and the Health and Sport Committee has a role in managing that and in scrutinising the actions of the Welsh Assembly.
Paul Martin is right—we need to get some indication of the level of complaints that brought about the introduction of car parking charges in greater Glasgow. We also need information on the level of usage of the car parks, because we need to get that in proportion to the level of complaints. It is easy enough to say that a number of complaints were received, so car parking charges were introduced.On Paul's other point about public consultation, the issue concerns not just the user groups—the people who use the hospital and the staff who work there—but the wider impact. Convener, you indicated that a substantial amount of money was spent on erecting bollards to stop on-street parking. Who is paying out public money for that—the health board or the local authority? These decisions have consequences; indeed, in some cases, the consequence might be that another body—in Glasgow's case, the local authority—has to pick up the charge. Unfortunately, the witnesses have gone, but it would have been useful to find out more about discussions within the health boards about the introduction of charges and whether anyone was aware of the impact that the decision might have on surrounding communities, for example, in relation to on-street parking in the area around the hospitals. The health boards claim that they have resolved their problem, but the fact is that they have simply transferred it to the communities living around the hospitals, and we need to find out whether those communities were fully consulted.
Those suggestions are helpful.The first point that I want to make is that the existing guidance explicitly indicates that the preferred option is that there should be no charges; however, in our major conurbations, charging seems to be a regular feature. We should raise that issue with the Government, particularly in view of the 30 June deadline that the cabinet secretary has set.Secondly, the cities under discussion—Dundee and Glasgow—have some of the most economically disadvantaged communities in the country. Although there might well be a lower rate of car usage and ownership in those areas, charges still have a disproportionate impact on those people.Thirdly, as John Wilson and Paul Martin have made clear, there has been no formal impact study of this issue. All we have heard so far suggests that any such studies have been informal.Fourthly, Gerry Marr raised an interesting point about the consequences of PFI contracts. No matter where we stand on PFI, the fact is that aspects such as buy-out clauses will have an impact, and the question is how such matters can be managed by the grant authority, the health board and the health directorate. However, I am sure that those people can find some intelligent way of managing out such matters without impacting on patient care. In fact, it struck me that the major driver for the key executives is that they do not lose any money that could notionally be spent on patient care.We should also highlight the percentage share of the budget that charging accounts for compared with the impact of such matters on public confidence. As Angela Constance pointed out, what about the feelings of people who have to go to hospital either as patients or as visitors? It is one of the last places where you want someone to put a price on things. As Nanette Milne said, we must submit the core of today's discussion to the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing, members of the Health and Sport Committee and the rest of the Parliament.
Hospital car parks are being misused. As one of the witnesses made clear, if there are no charges, the car parks will simply fill up before the first patient turns up. The fact is that the management of the car parks is not working properly; if it were, we would not have this problem.
Have I missed anything in my summary? I hope that the evidence session has been useful. This is one of those issues that tend to bop around without anyone getting a chance to examine how we reached this point.The clerk has made a note of the various points, which we will pursue with vigour. We should work to the 30 June deadline so that we can submit evidence to the process. In the meantime, we will be happy to receive any information that members such as Paul Martin—who I am sure will continue to pursue the issue locally—get from local residents and staff.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Apr 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 15 April 2008 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 29
- New Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 22
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 115
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1
- Commonwealth Games 2014 (Consultation) Committee business · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.