Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

High-voltage Transmission Lines (Potential Health Hazards) (PE812)

Tuesday 19 February 2008 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 23 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

23 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I welcome Keith Brown MSP and Dr Richard Simpson MSP to the committee. They have joined us for our consideration of the first current petition, PE812. The petition is by Caroline Paterson, on behalf of Stirling Before Pylons, and calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to acknowledge the potential health hazards associated with long-term exposure to electromagnetic fields from high-voltage transmission lines, and to introduce as a matter of urgency effective planning regulations to protect public health.We have debated the petition at previous meetings. Today's discussion allows us to give an update on the progress of the issues that are raised in the petition. I invite one, or both, of our guest elected members to comment on PE812, before I open up the discussion.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you for allowing us to speak on the issue. We will be brief because we know that you have a full agenda.I draw to the committee's attention the parallels between the health hazards in this area and those of smoking. In 2001, when Kenny Gibson and I sought to introduce a member's bill to ban smoking in public places, there was not a great deal of evidence on passive smoking. However, within a few years there was significant evidence on the subject, and the Parliament introduced a ban. The situation with transmission lines is almost identical. Evidence on the health hazards associated with such lines is growing day by day. The report of the cross-party inquiry into childhood leukaemia and extremely low frequency electric and magnetic fields by the United Kingdom Parliament indicates that children living within 200m of high-voltage overhead power lines have an increased risk of leukaemia. Within the past month or two, evidence has been published to support the previous anecdotal and poorer evidence that transmission lines are associated with Alzheimer's.If transmission lines cause identifiable increases in the level of childhood leukaemia, the effect of such lines on children throughout their growth is likely to be significant. Further associations may be identified in the future, but by that time it will be too late, if we have already erected the lines. The committee needs to consider the issue carefully. It should invite the Government to examine the most up-to-date evidence, especially when it considers the report of the public inquiry into the proposed Beauly to Denny line, which is now closed. The inquiry will consider issues relating to the Cairngorms national park, but the proposal raises health issues in my constituency and that of Keith Brown that are more serious.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I endorse Richard Simpson's comments. We hope to enable Scotland to consider directly and extensively the scientific evidence, through a reasonably competent authority, so that we are not required simply to trust the Health Protection Agency report on the issue.Richard Simpson mentioned the Westminster cross-party inquiry into childhood leukaemia and ELF EMF, which in a parliamentary context has made serious, concrete recommendations for action that could be implemented. The most notable of those is that we should not build within 60 to 200m of power lines. The inquiry's recommendations match what is now common practice in many countries. I could list those countries, but I know that the committee does not have a great deal of time. However, public concern about the issue is evidenced by the fact that 14,000 people signed objections to the Beauly to Denny proposal on the ground of health alone.This is a long-running petition that has been on the books both here and at Westminster for some time. Given that the public inquiry into the proposed Beauly to Denny line, to which both Richard Simpson and I gave evidence, has now closed and a decision on the proposal is due this year, there is a pressing need for us to address the matter. We hope that the committee will see fit to continue examining the evidence.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I thank both members for their contributions.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I hesitate to congratulate a doctor, because I am not one, but Richard Simpson made a hugely important scientific point that I have not heard articulated recently. If I understood him correctly, he was saying that, over time, research builds up a body of information from which, eventually, even the most blind can deduce what is totally obvious. The risk is that Governments and other organisations will wait until the evidence is totally overwhelming, when—possibly reluctantly—they are overwhelmed.I endorse Richard Simpson's suggestion that we should consider how evidence is building up and recognise that, if work is generating more evidence that points in a particular direction, it is perfectly reasonable for us to deduce what is probably over the horizon. If we hang around long enough, enough evidence will be built up, but by that time it will be too late. We need to encourage the Government not to look at what the evidence adds up to at the moment but at where it may reasonably point. It should look over the horizon and draw the correct conclusions about what we might well see there.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I endorse those comments, and those of Dr Simpson. There are uncertainties. This has been a grey area and until fairly recently there was no proof of detrimental impact. As work goes on, it is likely that there will be more evidence of harm. At this stage, the precautionary principle should apply. It is incumbent on Government to consider up-to-date information before it makes decisions.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Keith Brown mentioned that other countries have set minimum distances between new buildings and high-voltage transmission lines. It would be interesting to know whether their approach is precautionary or based on an appreciation of a growing body of evidence.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

Examples come from the Netherlands, Switzerland, Sweden, various American states, including Tennessee, and Lower Saxony in Germany. In Sweden, a cost benefit analysis was done, in which consideration was given to potential child deaths from leukaemia but not to the cost of non-fatal illnesses. That analysis concluded that there should be an avoidance distance of up to 100m from the highest-loaded lines. The approach in Sweden is about money. In other areas the precautionary principle, to which Nigel Don referred, has been adopted instead of the procrastination principle, whereby we wait until there is overwhelming evidence.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I presume that those countries have identified enough evidence to enable them to decide that they need to take precautionary regulatory measures.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The problem is that the number of people who are close to lines is small and conditions are rare—unlike the situation in relation to smoking, which used to be almost universal in this country. Therefore, getting evidence is difficult. However, the amalgamation of evidence during the past three or four years has certainly shifted my view. Five years ago I would have said that there was only anecdotal evidence. There is now probably sufficient evidence to justify the application of the precautionary principle, to save lives. Nigel Don's point should be reinforced. The evidence about leukaemia is almost clear; the evidence about Alzheimer's disease is getting clearer; and there is a list of other neurological conditions, many of which are very rare, which might be related to transmission lines—in which case, the cost of the lines that we put up would be very high.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I am aware of how the issue raised in the petition was regarded in the past. When planning applications were being made for mobile telephone masts and so on there was little response from local authorities or national Government, who just said that according to professional advice such structures produced no harmful emissions. However, the recent report suggests that there is a possibility of damage to public health from such structures. How seriously is the Westminster Government taking the report?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I think that the report of the cross-party inquiry into childhood leukaemia and ELF EMF is being taken seriously, but nothing has happened yet. The report was produced in July 2007 but still sits with Dawn Primarolo, the Minister of State for Public Health in Westminster, whose response is awaited. The issue was certainly taken seriously—I think that Michael Connarty was one of the main people involved in the inquiry. Of course, given pressing concerns about the proposed new Beauly to Denny transmission line, we need a response quickly. I understand that the report was well received in the medical community.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Telephone masts are a separate issue, to which careful consideration was given by the Stewart independent expert group on mobile phones.The high-voltage lines have a very high set-up cost and are really problematical once they have been set up, because taking them down afterwards will be a very expensive business.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

The argument is quite topical at the moment because of the proposed Beauly to Denny high-voltage transmission line. I have seen various reports on that issue that suggest that there are no harmful effects. Something must have changed drastically if we now have a report that says that there is a possibility of damage to public health. The local authorities or planning departments are not obliged to respond to that report at present. When they make a decision on a planning application, will they have to consider the report that Dr Simpson mentioned?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

The report was eventually received into the inquiry's evidence, but not at the crucial point. Much of the evidence that came to the inquiry early on was of the type that you suggested—that the lines had no harmful effects. As a result of assiduous attempts by the protesters and objectors, more evidence was taken in and put on the record, but it was not heard during the inquiry.Interestingly, although John Farquhar Munro is right to say that there was not a lot of response from local authorities in relation to telephone masts, they regularly refused telephone mast applications throughout the country on the basis of perceived concerns about health. Sometimes we are behind public opinion in these matters.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I detect a consensus among committee members that we should respond constructively to the petition. Obviously, broader decisions will have been made on the relevant areas at the Government and planning levels. Today's debate is about the precautionary principle, which we are edging towards. How do members want to respond? I know that guidelines are out for consideration at the moment. I am looking for members' views about how we can respond and take on board the submissions from the petitioner and parliamentarians.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Perhaps we could write to the Executive to ask for some clarification of the advice on the precautionary principle. In terms of telecommunications masts, as has already been shown, local authorities can use the precautionary principle; I remember sitting through the previous Transport and the Environment Committee's debates on the subject some years ago. However, we have a new element now and perhaps the Government should be asked if it is prepared to give clear advice on the use of the precautionary principle, and what its approach would be to accepting guidance from relevant organisations, such as the National Grid, the Health Protection Agency—Interruption.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I remind folk of our general expectations in relation to mobile phones. A nearby mast obviously has a communication for someone in the public gallery.We need to send a strong letter to the Government to say that we are keen to explore ways in which minimum recommendations on the precautionary principle could be made. Ministers would then have to decide whether they wanted to consider a possible legislative framework and, if they were so inclined, to find a window of opportunity. From what committee members are telling me this afternoon, my instinct is to send the Scottish Government a strong letter saying that we have heard evidence and think that there is a need for greater caution around these issues. We should also say that perhaps support should be given to councils that might well be inclined to use the precautionary principle, but are uncertain about whether they would receive broad governmental back-up during the appeal process, in which applicants might find themselves caught between a rock and a hard place. We can accept that as a broad principle, but do members want to add anything else?

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Could we bring it to the Government's attention—if it does not already know—that more up-to-date research might be available and that that might be taken into consideration?

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Obviously, we would like to know if the Government is looking at engaging with the research. As our two guest parliamentarians have said, our dilemma is that the body of research will be fairly narrow, given the proximity of populations to pylons, unlike the evidence in the passive smoking debate, which related to members of the public, on a social night out or in another enclosed public space, encountering smoke. This situation is a bit more difficult. Perhaps we should draw attention to that, but the fundamental issue is about encouraging a debate around erring on the side of caution.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

We should take on board Richard Simpson's point, which Nigel Don backed, that we should canvass what research has been done in other countries. That is important. Cases are comparatively rare and we need a critical mass of evidence, so we should look for the evidence as soon as possible rather than waiting for it to accrete over a number of years. The Government should consider what research has been done elsewhere in the world as a matter of urgency to get that critical mass of evidence.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We are fairly consensual on the issues. Are we happy to accept the recommendations and try to progress some of the issues in the petition?Members indicated agreement.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I thank the petitioner and the parliamentarians who have taken time to support the petition.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 19 February 2008 Petitions · 1
  2. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  3. Current Petitions Petitions · 23
  4. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  5. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  21. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  22. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  23. Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  24. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  25. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  26. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  27. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  28. Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  29. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  30. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  31. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  32. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  33. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  34. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  35. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  36. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  37. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  38. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  39. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  40. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  41. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  42. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  43. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  44. Current Petitions Petitions · 18
  45. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  46. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.