Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Village and Community Halls (PE1070)

Tuesday 20 November 2007 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 36 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

36 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The first new petition for us to consider is PE1070, by Sandra Hogg, on behalf of the Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to recognise the importance of village and community halls in rural Scotland; to create a Scottish halls fund to refurbish or modernise community buildings in order to increase the level of community use of them and improve the range and quality of the services that are provided; to fund a village halls support service; to create a fair relief scheme for water charges for charities that will maintain the exemption beyond 2010; and to work with appropriate partners to cut regulatory burdens and support the interests of hall committees.I think that Claire Baker wants to make a declaration about previous interests.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Before I was elected to the Parliament, I worked as a policy manager for the SCVO, and I know the two witnesses.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I thank you for your courtesy and honesty.We welcome to the meeting Sandra Hogg and Norman MacAskill. They know the procedure—they have around three minutes for a presentation or to comment on the petition. I hope that what is said will elicit a question-and-answer session with members. I understand that Sandra Hogg will lead off.

Sandra Hogg Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

Thank you for the opportunity to speak in support of PE1070.The Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations raised the petition in response to a growing concern in communities in rural Scotland that village and community halls were dropping down the agendas of policy makers, funders and the Government. The response that we received to the petition from communities throughout rural Scotland convinced us that village and community halls are a key issue that needs to be addressed. Today, we have delivered a further 5,000 paper signatures in addition to the 1,250 signatures on the e-petition.People tend to talk about land management and agriculture when they discuss rural development. Of course, land management and agriculture are important, but rural communities need community space to survive. Village and community halls provide that space and play a pivotal role in the life of rural communities.The SCVO has estimated that there are upwards of 3,000 village and community halls in Scotland. Those halls are incredibly valued in rural communities as a focus for activities and services and encouraging community well-being. Play groups, youth clubs and senior citizens' clubs meet in them, and they host birthday parties, weddings, sporting activities and dramas, for example. I could continue that list. In addition, village and community halls are increasingly filling gaps in service provision as post offices, shops, libraries, learning centres and health services are lost.Research that the SCVO undertook in 2000 showed that more than half of halls have poor external structures—poor roofs, for example—and that more than a third have toilets and kitchens that are not fit for purpose. Many halls are cold and damp and need substantial investment to bring them up to 21st century standards.In the past, there has been access to a range of possible funding sources for village halls, which reflected their public value and contribution to active communities, but far fewer funding opportunities are now available. For example, the Scottish Executive's rural partnership fund was a major source of funding for hall building projects through its local capital grants scheme. The fund was closed in 2005, subject to review. That left many halls high and dry, as they had already agreed support from their local authority in match funding.Lottery funding is another example. Whereas the previous Community Fund enabled many halls to modernise, the growing community assets strand of the investing in communities programme will not fund community buildings as general purpose meeting places or for sporting provision. That compares badly with England, where the Big Lottery Fund is investing £50 million in community centres and village halls. Together with the reductions in local authority support and in European funding, that means that there are just not sufficient funds available for halls to modernise. We believe that a national village halls fund is required to bring halls up to standard.Village halls are largely owned by communities and run by volunteer management committees. Running a hall is a complex operation. Hall committees must—to mention but a few issues—keep abreast of changes in legislation, apply for relevant licences, comply with regulators, understand building regulations and meet the demands of funding bodies. However, in comparison with England and Northern Ireland, support for hall committees in Scotland is poor. Although some good work is done by local authorities, councils for voluntary service and federations of halls, there is a need for a national support service that is available to all halls.In summary, the SCVO believes that village and community halls in Scotland have had a poor deal over the past few years. We recognise and welcome the opportunity for funding halls in the Scottish rural development programme, but that will not be enough. We need a whole-hearted political commitment to long-term support for halls through a national village halls fund and a support service.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Does Norman MacAskill have anything to add?

Norman MacAskill Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

No. Sandra Hogg's presentation was very comprehensive.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Having heard the presentation, do members have any questions?

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Is there any way of accounting for the difference between the Big Lottery Fund's attitude to funding halls in England and the attitude that is taken in Scotland? Has that been explained?

Sandra Hogg Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

I do not think so. I think that there are just different priorities in the different countries.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I know that, for village halls and other charitable organisations, the potential impact of the withdrawal of water rates relief in 2010 is an issue. What financial benefits does the present water rates relief system provide? What is the impact of that on new-build halls?

Sandra Hogg Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

At the moment, halls need to meet about six different criteria to qualify for water charges relief. Some halls managed to meet those criteria, but new-build halls qualify for the relief only if they have remained in the same premises. New buildings do not qualify for the relief, so such halls automatically start paying charges. Those halls that were not registered in the required period do not get the relief either. Water charges relief does not apply across the board. The system is iniquitous.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

As things stand, the relief will disappear for all halls after 2010. Is that right?

Sandra Hogg Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

At the moment, that is correct.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Who owns the village and community halls that we are talking about?

Sandra Hogg Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

In the vast majority of cases, the halls are owned by the communities themselves.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Do you want water rates exemption to be applied to all village community halls rather than just those that are in community ownership? For example, many halls that act as a vital hub to small communities are technically owned by the local authority. However, communities very much desire such halls to be run as community facilities rather than to be seen as part of the local authority's outreach work. Do you want the relief to be extended to all halls, including those that fall into that category?

Sandra Hogg Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

That question is difficult, because it asks where we draw the line. The SCVO's position is that all charities should be exempt from paying water charges. Charities are also exempt from paying local authority rates. However, not all halls are charities. Relief would encourage halls to become charities, which might be good for them from several points of view, including accounting to the public. However, deciding where to draw the line is difficult. To say that all charities should receive relief might be the easiest way to proceed.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

It strikes me that the challenge that you raise in the petition is about whether decision makers discuss with one another a strategic vision for community halls. Anyone who has been to a community hall will know of a similar nervousness about who dances first.I accept that an on-going issue has been a lack of coherence nationally. Pressures that relate to grant mechanisms are thrown up in local authorities or the voluntary sector any time that we have a new budget. Irrespective of where we as political representatives stand on that budget, how funding is accessed raises issues. What discussions have the SCVO and others had with key decision makers in national politics or in lottery funding bodies about a coherent national strategy for hall development?

Norman MacAskill Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

We have had individual discussions with many people who are involved in village hall funding and support. One proposal that we are running in parallel with the campaign is for a village hall summit that would bring together not primarily village hall users, but people who are involved in providing funding and support, for the purpose that you described—to ensure that they are all dancing the same dance—and to reduce the burden of difficulty on village hall committee members, who have to fill in dozens of funding applications with different reporting requirements.A priority for us is setting the issue in the context of the new funding that will be available through the Scottish rural development programme, which Sandra Hogg mentioned, and refocusing the emphasis of trusts and other funders on providing coherent and joined-up funding for halls.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

In discussions, we are all unravelling the recently announced budget. From looking at the budget, do you have a sense of avenues in it that would assist the debate, or has it made that more difficult?

Norman MacAskill Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

To be honest, I have not been in a position to study the detail of the budget. We are glad that the Scottish rural development programme, which awaits signing-off in Brussels, includes a measure on community and leisure facilities. That is by no means ring fenced for village halls, but it represents a pot of money that will be available for village halls to make bids to through rural development contracts or LEADER. We are happy with that, but on the detail of the budget and joining up with other funders, we are watching this space.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

You suggest a Scottish halls fund. Do you have a ballpark figure for how big that fund would have to be to satisfy basic demand?

Norman MacAskill Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

One problem is that we do not know the number and condition of village halls and how much funding will be needed to refurbish, repair and, where necessary, rebuild them. We are loth just to pluck a figure out of the air, but we have brainstormed it a bit. What is on the table for the next six years of the rural development programme is potentially £32 million. We did our sums and reckoned that if the figure were taken up to about £50 million for that period, that would probably approach sufficiency to address the needs. However, we do not want to say that with one figure, the problem will be sorted. The Government or somebody else should do serious research to assess the condition and needs of village halls.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I want to try to get the ballpark figures. You are saying that £4 million or £5 million per year would get the £32 million up to £50 million. Joined-up, coherent discussions are an issue. Discussions with the likes of the Big Lottery Fund in Scotland could result in matching funds. Have there been any discussions about extending the exemption scheme for water charges? Such discussions would be complex for anybody at ministerial level to deal with. Is the door totally closed on that matter, or is there still willingness to talk?

Norman MacAskill Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

Our colleagues in the SCVO have been pursuing that matter. The issue was included in our petition because it is a great concern to people in many village halls, but it is obvious that that concern stretches much wider—it is a concern for charities and the voluntary sector. We have not led on the matter, but the SCVO is certainly pursuing it.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I would like to expand the debate slightly. Community ownership of community facilities is an issue that is dear to my heart. In that context, I should have declared an interest earlier, as I have been working with a group in my constituency to take ownership of community facilities that the local authority currently operates.If we are pushing for more voluntary sector community ownership of local facilities, the figure of £50 million that has been mentioned may be an underestimate, as many local authorities have the drive and ambition to offload to local communities facilities such as community halls that they currently own and operate. In essence, the petition deals with rural Scotland, but much wider issues are involved. For example, a number of community facilities in Glasgow are effectively run by the community while the council has tacit ownership of them. If there are more developments towards transferring the ownership of community facilities, more resources and more support to communities that wish to take on responsibility for and ownership of those facilities could be required. Is there an expanding programme of community ownership of facilities?

Sandra Hogg Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

It probably is expanding. In England, a fund that is delivered through the Big Lottery Fund was announced this year. The money that is involved is not the Big Lottery Fund's money—I think that it is Government money. I cannot remember the details, but the money supports local authorities giving communities their buildings and funding the refurbishment of those buildings. A specific fund has therefore been opened to allow communities to take ownership of community buildings. A fund also exists that helps them to bring buildings up to standard, as many have been badly neglected over the past few years.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The Big Lottery Fund in Scotland is discussing with different communities the transfer of community assets that are currently under local authority control to create an equity base for community halls. As you can imagine, the issue is fraught with complexities, but a commitment to do that certainly exists.You raised the global issue, which is how to knit together all the different agencies to build up a much more credible initial sum to make a difference to village halls. That is the petition's dominant thesis. However, many of us who represent urban areas know that there are wee post-war local halls in their areas that are connected to what happened overseas. Such halls have received council revenue funding, but the voluntary community has run them.

Norman MacAskill Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

The need for a nationwide support service that would help to bring together diverse funding and support and consideration of many issues should be emphasised. We envisage that as a resource not only for hard-pressed village hall committee members spending a Friday night trying to fill in funding applications or get architectural advice, but for people who want to find the most appropriate ways of delivering funding and support. The support service could work in both directions. It would not cost a huge amount of money for the Government to fund, but the benefits would be enormous.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We have heard the petitioners and had the question-and-answer session. Do members have any recommendations about how to proceed with the petition?

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

One key issue is the continuation of water charge exemptions. It would be worth writing to the Scottish Government to ask for its views on that and on what it sees as the future of the exemptions for village halls post 2010. We should ask whether the Government envisages a continuation of the exemptions and what its plans are.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

In view of the fact that none of us really has a handle on the budget proposals that the Parliament debated last week, I presume that we need to write to the Government to ask where it thinks the funds that we have been talking about might be in the current budget proposals.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

We should write to the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. Many village and community halls provide vital services in communities. We have discussed rural post offices and alternative avenues for certain services. Village halls provide many facilities that are normally picked up by local authorities or health boards, so it would be useful to get a view from COSLA on the future of the village halls programme and its possible expansion.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

The water charge issue is clearly a major concern for many charities. If we are writing to the Government to ask about the water charge exemptions, is it in our remit to extend the query to include churches and town halls, even though the petition is clearly about community and village halls? I do not know about other members, but a significant amount of the mail in my mailbag is from churches, which have a major concern about water charges.We should try to get more information from the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment about the rural development plan. In response to a recent parliamentary question, Richard Lochhead referred to funding from the new rural development plan. We do not yet have details of that, but we should try to find out as soon as we can just what that covers and what the possibilities are for organisations such as community groups.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

On Nanette Milne's first point, the clerk advises me that, because her suggestion is not within the scope of the petition, it would be difficult for us to refer to those points in our letter. The member, like many of us, has had letters from churches that allow church halls to be used by groups other than church ones. We can continue to pursue that as individual members or perhaps as a committee when that is appropriate, but the structure of PE1070 does not allow the committee to do so at present.Nanette Milne's point about the rural development fund is worth exploring. We should ask the Big Lottery Fund about what dialogue it could have with the SCVO or others to try to create coherence between its funding and potential Government funding, so that we get a more structured approach that at least matches in. Three points arise. First, to be blunt, basic research is negligible. Secondly, there is a mismatch in the funding of existing hall provision—it is funded through charitable trusts, local authority grants and various other fundraising activities. Thirdly, if we do not do something structured in the next five or 10 years, the quality of what many halls offer will be diminished or they may not be able to provide anything because of the lack of investment in infrastructure. We need to deal with that.As well as being a rural development issue, this is a cross-Government issue, as many such issues are. For example, I imagine that the communities ministerial team would need to take a view. Perhaps in our letter we can ask whether the Government is working across portfolios and ministerial responsibilities to find ways in which to address the issue. To be fair, I point out for members who represent more urban areas that it has been suggested that some halls fit into the category even if they are in small towns or in neighbourhoods in cities.I ask the clerk to pull together those five or six suggestions. We will follow through the suggestions, and through the committee clerks and public information the petitioners will see the responses that we receive. We will bring all the responses back to the committee for final consideration of what we would like to do with the petition. We will decide at that point what we can do to help address the issues that are raised in the petition. I know that before the petitioners came to today's meeting they lobbied individual MSPs and other decision makers—they should continue to do that. Thanks for your time.

Norman MacAskill Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
link

Thank you.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 20 November 2007 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 36
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 52
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 12
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  10. New Petitions Petitions · 7
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  18. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.