Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Air-guns (Ban on Sale and Use) (PE1059)

Tuesday 4 September 2007 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 30 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

30 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The first new petition is PE1059 by Andrew Morton, who is present today with the other key petitioner, Sharon McMillan. Tommy Sheridan, who is familiar to many on the committee, accompanies them. The petition calls on the Scottish Executive to support a ban on the sale and use of air-guns, except for certified pest control purposes or for use at registered gun clubs. Before being formally lodged, the petition was hosted on the e-petition system, where it gathered 189 signatures.I welcome Sharon, Andy and Tommy to the meeting. They have three minutes in which to make opening remarks. Before that, I indicate for the public record that a Mr Hatcher has tabled a letter to the committee that expresses his views on the petition and that copies of the letter have been given to committee members.I invite Sharon to make the opening three-minute statement. Members will ask questions after that and any of the three witnesses can respond.

Sharon McMillan
link

First, I thank the members of the Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee for inviting us to Holyrood to be asked questions on our tireless battle to ban air-guns.As you are probably aware, our son, Andrew, tragically died after being shot in the head with an air-gun pellet. Two days after he was shot, the doctors approached Andy and me and told us that there was nothing else they could do for Andrew, who passed away shortly afterwards. That tragic event happened on 2 March 2005 and by what would have been Andrew's third birthday, on 9 May 2005, we had put aside some of our grief and had stronger feelings about the menace of these weapons, so we started a campaign to ban air-guns across Scotland.Since then, we have collected more than 11,000 handwritten signatures in support of the proposed ban. We have been constantly linked with the media and any time that an air-gun incident happens we are asked our views on television and radio, and for the local newspapers. It makes us very angry when we hear of such incidents. Do people not learn? They must have heard that air-guns can kill and that one did so in our case. Since the death of our son, Andrew, we have had a campaign with the News of the World, the Daily Record and the Scottish Daily Mirror, and have been invited to the Scottish Parliament by Tommy Sheridan, who has backed a proposed bill for Parliament and who still works with us.The legal age for purchasing an air-gun has been changed twice: first, from 16 to 17, then from 17 to 18. However, that is not good enough for us. The man who shot our son was 27. The police issued a warning to all parents about air-guns and replica guns, asking parents not to let their kids play with replica guns. If the police could not tell whether a gun that someone was using was a real one or not, they would shoot to kill.The police say, however, that banning air-guns would not work because there are more than 500,000 of them in Scotland alone and the police would not be able to recall them. However, I feel that it would be a good idea to recall them. After all, the Government is recalling toys in their millions that were made in China because they could be harmful to children. Surely 500,000 items of the kind that killed our son can be recalled.We are not against registered gun clubs or farmers who have to use weapons for pest control, but why would someone need an air-gun in a housing estate or another residential area? All they do is cause a menace to the public, harm people, break windows or harm animals and pets.We have been joined in our campaign by Dr Mick North, who is the father of Dunblane victim, Sophie North, and by the Grimasons, who lost their son to gunshots over in Turkey. We have been asked to appear on the "This Morning" programme and we have even done a "Frontline Scotland" programme to deliver our message that guns kill. We will never give up until they are totally banned. Thank you for listening.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you, Sharon. Do members have questions?

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I have a huge amount of sympathy for the petition, but it is difficult to see what the Parliament can do at the moment because the subject of the petition is not a devolved issue. Have you had any contact with the Westminster Government and, if so, what did it propose?

Tommy Sheridan
link

Thank you, Rhoda. Sharon and Andy have asked me to try to field as many of the questions as possible. As I am sure you will all appreciate, it is quite nerve-wracking to appear as a witness at committee meetings.Sharon and Andy have met Home Secretaries. Not long after they suffered the tragedy of losing Andrew, they were given certain assurances by the then Home Secretary, Charles Clarke. They had great hope that a ban on air-guns would be part of Westminster legislation. A lot of the media coverage that led up to the passing of the Violent Crime Reduction Act 2006 suggested that that would be the case. In common with many people, they were gravely and sorely disappointed when all that changed were some of the restrictions, one of which Sharon mentioned. The fact that the age at which air-guns could be sold legally rose from 17 to 18 was as useful as a chocolate teapot to the people who want to restrict the circulation of such weapons.Just before the close of the most recent parliamentary session, I introduced a member's bill, which had the aim of getting the Parliament to take a position on a matter that is recognised to be outwith the parameters of the current regulations under the Scotland Act 1998, but on which it is possible that there could a reversal of position. If the Parliament takes a position on a matter that is outwith its legislative competence, Westminster must decide whether to support the Parliament or to refuse it the right to proceed with the relevant piece of legislation. In the current climate, it is clear that Westminster would not stand in the way of the Scottish Parliament being the first in Britain to impose a general ban on the sale of air-guns. It is in those terms that the petition's appeal to the Public Petitions Committee is couched. We feel that the timing is right, especially given the recent horrible tragedy in Liverpool involving a real gun. Air-guns are a big part of the culture of guns.I will quickly outline some statistics that Rhoda Grant might be aware of. In preparation for the consultation part of my member's bill, System 3 conducted an independent opinion poll in March of this year, which asked whether the people of Scotland would support a general ban on the sale of air-guns. Eighty-two per cent of respondents were in favour of such a ban. There was 94 per cent support for it in Glasgow and 93 per cent support in Edinburgh. The proposed measure is undoubtedly very popular.Significantly, the Fire Brigades Union, which represents emergency service workers, has backed the proposal forcefully because its members are the biggest targets for the misuse of air-guns in housing estates and schemes. The Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals has also come on board because there has been a rise in the number of attacks on pets involving the misuse of such weapons.Sometimes legislation is symbolic as much as practical. The banning of air-guns by the Parliament would be highly symbolic because it would tell people in Scotland as a whole that air-guns are simply unacceptable.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I reiterate that I have sympathy for the case that the petitioners make and can understand where they are coming from, but it might be better to pursue a United Kingdom-wide ban because I am not sure that it would be possible to police the supply of air-guns into and out of Scotland.Our briefing papers mention the use of air-guns for pest control. I would have thought that air-guns were not an effective method of pest control and would represent a menace to animals. Are such weapons used in any way for pest control?

Tommy Sheridan
link

During the consultation on the bill, some local authorities reported that they still used air-guns sparingly, for example in the culling of pigeons. However, farmers and most organisations that are involved in pest control have moved away from using them because they are unreliable and can be brutal and inflict a great deal of pain, unless the shot that is fired is extremely accurate. Andy and Sharon are making the point that legitimate pest control is fine and should be licensed, but a declining number of organisations are involved in the use of air-guns for pest control.

Angela Constance SNP Livingston
link

I thank Sharon and Andy for having the courage to make a presentation to the committee. Colleagues will be aware that the Government has commenced discussions about the Parliament's remit in relation to firearms legislation.Tommy Sheridan made the interesting point that legislation banning air rifles in Scotland would be hugely symbolic. I accept that point, given that 58 per cent of offences that involve firearms involve air rifles, but how would a ban make the streets of Scotland safer in practical terms?

Tommy Sheridan
link

Five years ago, 47 per cent of firearms incidents related to air-guns, but now that figure is 58 per cent. In other words, there is a growing problem. The problem is neither peripheral nor getting smaller. In 2005-06, the last year for which accurate statistics are available, 79 per cent of acts of vandalism in Scotland were carried out with air-guns. Air-guns are used in almost 80 per cent of the smaller acts of antisocial behaviour, which can have a high nuisance value and cause much damage.When I say that legislation would be symbolic, I am talking about sending out a message. If the Parliament is serious about getting to grips with a growing gun culture and the growing misuse of air-guns, grabbing the problem by the scruff of the neck and saying that the sale of those guns is now banned would send out a message to families and communities that air-guns are no longer acceptable. That would be in contrast to the current situation, in which we could take members to high street shops and markets in Glasgow and elsewhere in Scotland that sell not only air-guns but pump-action air-guns. Signs in the shop windows boast about how powerful the air-guns are. Selling them is perfectly legal and people are making an awful lot of money out of the trade. If the Parliament were to step into the breach and take action, air-gun crime would not end overnight, but over a period of two, three, four or five years it would begin to be accepted that these guns are no longer acceptable. They would certainly not be available on the high street and pushed in the markets as they are now.Andy and Sharon could tell you that not long after the tragedy of Andrew being shot, their other son was invited to try to purchase an air-gun weapon, despite the fact that he was under 18 years of age. He was able to purchase a very powerful weapon in the centre of Glasgow without any questions being asked.Everything that has been done until now is merely window-dressing: a ban is necessary if we want to tackle the gun culture in the long-term.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The debate between Government ministers in Scotland and the Home Office about the legislative framework continues. Some fairly strong stuff has popped up in response to the e-petition. Those who oppose the introduction of further legislation, restrictions or an outright ban argue that all the evidence shows that, even with more restrictions, there is still a major rise in the misuse of air-guns. As individuals who seek to outlaw the use of air-guns, how do you respond to the strongly held views of those who are involved in an activity from which they get enjoyment? They do not feel that they are threatening anybody else's right to live peacefully. They argue that there was an excessive case, which resulted in the tragedy that happened to Andy and Sharon's young son.

Tommy Sheridan
link

I will respond in a moment, but Andy or Sharon might want to respond to that question.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I understand the debate in relation to the setting in which the incident occurred, but people who live in other parts of Scotland outwith such urban settings say, "I have used an air-gun for the past 20 years. I have never caused any problems and I am a peaceful person."

Sharon McMillan
link

There is nowhere to use air-guns, bar the streets. There are no gun clubs or fields in which people can use air-guns. They use them on the streets and they cause damage with them. They even hurt firefighters—they get shot. The man who saved Andrew and let us have him for the two days was shot in the chest and in the leg. The police have been shot at with air-guns; I cannot see what good air-guns do on the streets.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am setting out the debate that needs to take place so that we can unravel the issue, irrespective of people's stance on it. Some people claim that the kind of incidents that have occurred could be dealt with by existing legislation on threats to human life and safety. If so, why would we want to introduce further restrictions on air-guns or to ban them, given that many people get a great deal of enjoyment from using them in other settings? All members of the committee will receive letters both for and against the petition. I am trying to explore that debate.

Tommy Sheridan
link

I have debated the issue with various gun clubs over the past 12 months. In the bill proposal that I introduced last year, I argued that gun clubs should have the right to hold weapons on their premises and that club members should have access to those weapons on the premises. Internationally, shooting is recognised as both an Olympic and a Commonwealth games sport. Whether people support its being a sport is irrelevant. However, you cannot make an omelette without breaking eggs; whatever you do will upset some people, as it is impossible to keep everyone happy. I cannot understand why gun club members should want to take their guns home. Having guns on lockfast premises that are secure and registered is one thing, but having them in wardrobes or under the bed in domestic settings is another.When we spoke to people in rural settings—farmers and farming communities—many of them made the point that they no longer use air-guns and that, if they use firearms, they are likely to have a shotgun licence. Under a strict licensing regime, only a minority would hold air-guns. We are seeking a ban on the general sale of air-guns, not to ban them for everyone. However, people would require a licence to have one, just as they need a licence for firearms.The growth in the proportion of firearms incidents involving air-guns is important. The figure has risen from 47 per cent five years ago to 58 per cent of incidents now. We are not proposing a magic wand; if we were, people would be right to say that we were talking rubbish, as our proposal will not solve the problem overnight. However, we are saying that it could be a big part of the solution. If people disagree with us, we are happy to debate the issue with them, but I find it difficult to accept that banning the general sale of air-guns would not affect the circulation, use or acceptance of those weapons.

Tricia Marwick SNP Central Fife
link

In the past, air-guns have been seen as not particularly threatening. Is that not one reason why we have so many of them? Do we not need to tackle people's belief that air-guns are not dangerous, given the tragic cases that are before us? Should we not work with the Westminster Government to produce legislation that suits Scottish needs?

Tommy Sheridan
link

On the way through from Glasgow today, I discussed that issue with Andy Morton and Sharon McMillan. As Sharon said, what is next once people have used and practised with an air-gun? It is part of the gun culture that everyone talks about and wants to tackle. I sincerely hope that this does not happen, but if in the next few days there is a tragic incident in Scotland involving the misuse of an air-gun and another child is either killed or seriously injured, much of this discussion will be accelerated and everyone will say that we need to do something. Should we wait for tragedies before passing legislation?We have had enough tragedies. There have been three fatalities and 1,156 serious injuries in the past six years; we should not wait for another serious injury or fatality. I hope that the Parliament will present a united front. During First Minister's questions before the most recent election, even Mr McConnell, who was First Minister at the time, accepted that there was a case for further action. He accepted that then and the case has grown stronger since, particularly given the incidents down south. The people of England and Wales would be very pleased if Scotland were to take the first step because it would not be long before Westminster followed suit.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Do we have any knowledge of the police's current thinking about the matter? I understand that the police have been against making further legislation in the past, but has there been any movement since? Perhaps we could find that out from them.

Tommy Sheridan
link

The police responded to the consultation document. Every local authority that responded—I think that 17 did so in the end—supported the proposed legislation. Voluntary sector organisations across the board supported it, too. The police said that they would implement whatever legislation was passed by Parliament, but they felt that simply banning the weapons would not end the problems. I think that we all agree with that.The police did not comment on whether legislation should come from Westminster or Scotland, because that was not their biggest concern; their concern was whether the legislation could be implemented and, if it could be, whether it would be properly resourced. They would have to have an amnesty period in which they appealed for weapons to be handed in. Then they would have to monitor markets and shops and ensure that sales were being recorded. They would also need the public's support. Given the support that was expressed in the System 3 poll to which I referred earlier—I am sure that we could get a copy to all members if required—the public's support and involvement would not be a problem.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We have had a good opportunity to hear from and cross-examine the petitioners. Members spoke about the need for greater clarity. One of the courses open to the committee is to write to the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland to get its definitive position on the material presented and the issues that have been raised.Depending on the dialogue with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and the Home Office, it might be useful if we were to write directly to both to find out their understanding of the current state of play, although that might be superseded by what is announced tomorrow about the programme for government. The committee should seek greater clarity, because powers and responsibilities for such weapons are a grey area with which we have all been grappling.Andy Morton and Sharon McMillan's petition is part of an on-going process and the committee regards the petition as pushing the issue further up the agenda. We recognise that other agencies are dealing with some of the issues that you raise at a much more senior level than ours. Do members have further suggestions about what we could do with the petition?

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

In order to be fair, we ought to look at the views of gun clubs.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

So you want to write to an organised gun club and ask it about the implications of an outright or partial ban.

Tricia Marwick SNP Central Fife
link

It would be extremely useful to write to both the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and the UK Government. It is important that we give them a copy of the petition as submitted to us by Andy and Sharon. We should ensure that the Home Secretary is also given a copy of the Official Report of this meeting so that she can get a flavour of our discussion. I think that the Scottish Government is willing to legislate on firearms in Scotland.If the petition is also given to the Westminster Government, that will make it clear that the people of Scotland expect legislation to tackle air-gun crime in Scotland and the banning of air-guns. That will add to the discussions that are currently being held between the Scottish Government and the UK Government.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Are there any other suggestions from committee members?

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Is there any way in which we can refer the petition to the Parliament at Westminster as well? It has a way of dealing with petitions that is quite different from ours. It would be a good idea to refer the petition to Westminster to raise awareness of the issue there. I feel that, in order to have sufficient impact, the matter should be dealt with on a UK basis. It should be simple to amend the existing firearms legislation. It will not require a huge amount of legislation to ban the sale and use of air-guns.

Tricia Marwick SNP Central Fife
link

My understanding of the petitions system at Westminster is that all petitions must be introduced by a member of Parliament. It is not a case of the MSPs on this committee referring the petition to Westminster; the petition would have to be introduced by an MP. There is also no requirement on Westminster to consider the petitions at all—they just sit there.The issue needs to be dealt with urgently, and Mr Sheridan is right to say that we must ensure that the promises that we have made about legislating on air-guns are kept. I see no merit in using the Westminster petition system; we should directly approach the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, as discussion is already going on between the two Governments. We should make the Home Office aware of the strength of feeling that exists here and say that, frankly, dragging of feet on the issue is no longer acceptable.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Given that the principal recreational use of air-guns is target practice, might we get a view from the manufacturers on whether it would be possible for them, at least in the interim, to make slugs with less penetrating power than they have at present? That may or may not be possible.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The problem is the velocity at which the bullets are fired. That is what has caused such damage, especially to young children. In young Andrew's case, the softness of the tissue in his head because of his young age meant that there was a greater chance of fatal injury. Nevertheless, I am happy for us to ask for a view on that.By writing to the Home Office at ministerial level and to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, we are raising the level of debate. We will say that the committee has heard from the petitioners and wants clarification regarding the proposed legislative framework, the timescale for that and the powers that could be introduced to deal with air-guns. There may well be dialogue in the next 24 hours or beyond, but at least the Public Petitions Committee will have said that it considers the matter important. The Government has a copy of the petition and has recognised the public concern about the issue, and the petitioners have done some background research and consultation to back that up.Those are the central issues. We can also write to two or three other organisations for views on the impact that an outright ban would have on the effectiveness of those organisations. I think that that covers most of the concerns that members have raised. We will wait to see what responses we receive to those letters. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I thank Andrew, Sharon and Tommy for coming along this afternoon.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 4 September 2007 Petitions · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 3
  3. Proposed Petition Petitions · 5
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 30
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 39
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 38
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. New Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. New Petitions Petitions · 11
  11. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  21. Referred Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.