Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Television Coverage of Scottish Football (PE1026)

Wednesday 17 January 2007 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 54 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

54 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Our next new petition is PE1026, by Stuart McMillan. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to exert all its political powers upon BBC Scotland to ensure that the corporation provides television coverage of every Scotland national football team match, and notes the sporting and cultural importance of the national team, which should ensure that the issue is highlighted every time that the Scottish Executive meets representatives of BBC Scotland. Before being formally lodged, the petition was hosted on the e-petition system, where it gathered 604 signatures. Stuart McMillan will make a brief statement in support of his petition.

Stuart McMillan
link

I thank the committee for allowing me to speak today. I also thank the clerks for their assistance when I was putting the petition together.The basis of the petition is not some attack on the Executive. My concern is genuine. I felt that a petition was the proper way to highlight an important issue affecting Scotland. There should be parity among licence fee payers in the United Kingdom, but licence fee payers in Scotland could be considered to be second class. That point has been mooted in various discussions that I have had and in e-mails that I have been sent in support of my petition.One evening a few months ago, Scotland were playing Lithuania in Lithuania. I was working in the house and, because the match was not being covered on television, I was listening to it on the radio. After the match finished, I put the TV on and did some channel hopping. BBC1 was showing an England match—I cannot remember who England were playing—and BBC1 Northern Ireland was showing the Northern Ireland match against Spain. I sat back and thought, "Wait a minute, this seems a wee bit unfair." It was great that the England and Northern Ireland matches were on, but it was unfair that the Scotland match was not being shown as well. Being quite sad, I stayed up for the highlights on BBC1 that evening. There were highlights of the England match, highlights of a Wales match and highlights of the Northern Ireland match, but nothing of the Scotland match, which was really disappointing.This is not simply about sport and culture; there is also a social inclusion issue. There are Scotland supporters who, either through choice or because of the question of affordability, do not have Sky. There are Scotland supporters with mobility problems who cannot get to matches, whether at Hampden or away. There are also housebound people for whom the only opportunity to see Scotland matches, if they do not have Sky, is on the BBC.I appreciate that broadcasting is a reserved issue, but sport and culture are devolved. I also appreciate that the Executive is limited in what it can do at the moment, but it could highlight the issue to the BBC in the discussions that I am sure they have from time to time.I am not asking for live coverage of every single Scotland match on the BBC—that would be utopia, and I am a wee bit more realistic—but there should at least be a highlights package of every single Scotland match on the BBC, bearing in mind that the BBC is the public broadcasting corporation. We pay the licence fee in Scotland, just like our friends and families do in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. If the BBC can show live in Scotland a Bury against Weymouth match, as it did only a month or so ago, it should show Lithuania against Scotland or any other match involving the national team.The outcome that I hope for is that the Public Petitions Committee writes to the Executive to highlight the various points and issues that will be raised today. I would also like the committee to consider highlighting those points and issues in the chamber of the Scottish Parliament, so that all MSPs have the opportunity to consider them. I would like the committee to pass on the petition, and the points and issues raised, to the Department for Culture, Media and Sport and to the Culture, Media and Sport Committee at Westminster, so that they can note and consider the issues. I would also like the Scottish Executive and the Scottish Parliament to encourage the DCMS to consider a review of the current classification bands for national sporting events.As I said, the BBC is the national broadcaster, and it has a duty to the licence fee payer. Scottish licence fee payers should expect the same level of service that people in England, Wales and Northern Ireland receive.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Thank you very much.I want to clarify something before committee members ask questions. You talked about whether the issue is devolved and the BBC's responsibility as the public broadcaster, and you have examined various avenues in exploring where responsibility lies, but you did not mention the Scottish Football Association, which organises the matches and holds the rights to them. The SFA is a commercial enterprise and is therefore responsible for getting as much money as it can to run Scottish football. Is it not the SFA that determines which matches are shown and where they are shown? If it sells match rights to Sky, Setanta or ITV for the best commercial price, that is a matter for it and not for the BBC. The BBC may want to show a match, but if someone else outbids it and obtains the rights to show it, the SFA rather than the BBC will have been responsible for deciding who has the rights.

Stuart McMillan
link

You are correct to say that the SFA is the main body involved and that it owns the rights to matches. That is another avenue to explore—the SFA can be contacted and it can consider the matter when bids are submitted for the next round of matches. I will certainly contact it. However, in the short term, I contacted the BBC, which responded in a letter to me that it shared and sympathised with my concerns.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Could it have said that because it was outbid by a private company in its bid to buy match rights?

Stuart McMillan
link

Obviously, the SFA wants to get as much money as it can, and everyone hopes that that money will then be fed into the sport at the grass-roots level. The BBC, Sky and many other organisations submit bids. I understand the SFA's position and that it wants to bring in as much money as it can, but the BBC is and should be the public service broadcaster. As such, it has a duty to provide the best-quality service to licence fee payers throughout the United Kingdom.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Should the Government force a private organisation to sell its rights to a public service broadcaster?

Stuart McMillan
link

As I said, I am not asking for the BBC to cover every Scotland match live; that would be utopia and such a request would be unrealistic. However, it should have rights as a result of legislation or the classification process—there are classification grades for different sporting events. There could be a mechanism so that the BBC had the right to show Scotland, England, Wales and Northern Ireland national matches in the relevant nations, although the packages might be only highlights packages.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I apologise to Mr McMillan and the committee for having to leave the meeting, although I will return.I confess that I am torn by the petition, not least because my other half is a member of the tartan army and would probably whole-heartedly support the sentiment behind the petition. However, I also confess that I would not regard wall-to-wall coverage of football as utopia. I suspect that a substantial part of the population would agree. There is, perhaps, already enough coverage of football. That said, I am genuinely interested in the petition.The convener raises an interesting point. Obviously, the SFA generates considerable sums of money from this coverage. Do you know how much is generated? How would the SFA replace the lost income? As you said, it helpfully channels the money back into football development. If we were to take that income away from the SFA, what should be done to replace it?

Stuart McMillan
link

I am not saying that the income should be taken away. My suggestion is not that the BBC should get the rights for nothing; it should have to pay for them. Another question is involved: should all the matches in a tournament be lumped together, sold individually or sold in groups of two or three or whatever? Obviously, the question is for another time. The BBC should pay for the rights to show matches, which means that the SFA would continue to accrue money.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Do you know the scale of the money that the SFA generates from selling the rights to games?

Stuart McMillan
link

To be honest, I do not have that information.

Stuart McMillan
link

Yes.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

This is one of those subjects that we can almost have a wee giggle about, but it is also interesting and worthy of serious consideration. Jackie Baillie said that her idea of utopia is not wall-to-wall live Scotland football matches. If that were to happen, I can see her in a wee tartan Jimmy hat, joining the tartan army and getting into it all. Even if we are not talking about live broadcasts, it would be a huge benefit if more people were able to watch Scotland football matches. It would inspire our young and up-and-coming talent by giving them their own role models and heroes. In this country, we want our young people to look up to other Scottish people, not just to David Beckham. We should give our young people—and people like me—more access to Scotland matches. The SFA has a huge responsibility in that regard. I am glad that the convener teased out the point, as I was also going to suggest that we write to the SFA.I would like there to be a members' business debate on the subject. A lot of interest could be generated in that way. It is only when big events such as the world cup happen that we get peaks of coverage, then everything dies down again. We do not know who plays for the team, where it is at or how it is doing until something happens, such as Walter Smith abandoning the team, and suddenly the Scotland team is all over the telly for a while, before disappearing off our screens again. Our national team has its own magnificent world-renowned support. Given that it can generate such loyalty, our team deserves better. Having more coverage of its inspirational players would bring more of our young people—girls and boys—into football. I would like more coverage of women's football, too.I am sympathetic to petition PE1026. I am concerned that Westminster might have a say on this matter, as it does not feel the same way that we do on the subject. As I said, the SFA has a huge responsibility in this regard. I hope that the Official Report of today's debate is sent to the SFA. It should consider how to give everyone more access to coverage of our national team.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I am not sure whether—

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I am not sure whether that was a question or a comment, Rosie.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

In that case, we will go to Sandra White, who I think has a question.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I am sorry for butting in, convener. I thought that you were about to sum up. I take your point about the SFA, convener. On reading through the papers, I wondered who was most responsible for the situation.Stuart McMillan spoke about the different categories of event. I note that the Scottish cup final is classified as a category A event, whereas category B events can be shown on pay TV providing that sufficient secondary coverage, such as highlights and delayed broadcasts, is made available to free-to-air broadcasters. From the petition and other evidence, it seems that, although the BBC can show highlights and packages, the SFA can sell the rights to Scotland matches to the highest bidder. I agree with Rosie Kane. We should write to the SFA on the matter. If highlights and delayed broadcasts are made available to free-to-air broadcasters, are category B events always shown on pay TV? Does that happen to the same extent in England, Ireland and Wales, or does it happen only in Scotland? Do you know what percentage of other national matches is shown via pay TV?

Stuart McMillan
link

No, I do not. However, I know that ITV has the rights to some champions league matches and that, at times, when a champions league match is live on a satellite channel, there is a delayed highlights package on ITV later in the evening. However, I think that the contract stipulates that it must be shown after 12 o'clock at night, so the programme usually starts at about 5 past 12. That aspect exists on ITV, but not on the BBC.

Stuart McMillan
link

No, only ITV and the satellite channels have the rights to champions league matches.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Again, that is a commercial decision. If the BBC outbid ITV for the rights, it would be entitled to show the games.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I take your point, convener, but I want to clarify an issue about category B events—perhaps the clerks or somebody who knows about football can do so. Our briefing states:"Category B events can be shown on pay TV, provided sufficient secondary coverage (highlights, delayed broadcast, etc) is made to free-to-air broadcasters."I just want that to be clarified. Does that mean that such events are free to the BBC and ITV, because they are in category B?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

So they are not free to channels that broadcast them, such as Setanta.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

If such an event was shown on Sky or Setanta, either ITV or the BBC would be entitled to show it. However, which of those two channels got the rights would depend on which one bid the most money.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

Thank you for that clarification. I ask Stuart McMillan whether the situation in England, Wales and Northern Ireland is the same as the one in Scotland, where, as far as I can see, the SFA sells the rights to the highest bidder.

Stuart McMillan
link

Do you mean for highlights packages?

Stuart McMillan
link

In the highlights packages that I have watched, usually all the home nation matches have been shown. However, on the evening that I mentioned, there was no coverage whatever of the Scotland match.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

The issue is serious, although some people may laugh about it. I quite like football, but not wall-to-wall football. The Executive's response on the issue was that the BBC is an independent body. It may be independent, but it is a public body that is paid for by the public through licence fees. Therefore, I do not accept the Executive's point.Am I allowed to make a recommendation now, convener?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I will give other members a chance to comment first.

Charlie Gordon Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I draw attention to my entry in the register of members' interests, which states that I am a director of Hampden Park Ltd, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of the Scottish Football Association. The company basically operates the stadium as a venue, not just for football, but for rock concerts, conferences, weddings, bar mitzvahs and so on. That is the end of the advert. We have no involvement in negotiating the fees to broadcast football matches at Hampden, which is done by the main SFA board.The right to broadcast Scotland matches live is, in effect, put out to tender. In the past couple of years, most of the matches have been on Sky. However, the arrangement is that, within the United Kingdom framework and given the category of the matches, there should be a free-to-view highlights package. The catalyst for Mr McMillan's petition was a match with Lithuania, for which he says there was no highlights package. He might be right about that—I do not know, as I am past the stage of staying up until 5 past midnight waiting for a highlights package, especially if I have to get up early in the morning to come to Edinburgh. It is possible that Mr McMillan is mistaken about that, but it is also possible that he is not mistaken and that there was no highlights package. However, he will probably concede that that was unusual and that, if a Scotland match is live on Sky, the BBC usually has a highlights package much later that evening. Mr McMillan is talking about a pretty unusual set of circumstances. I do not think that the issue is a UK broadcasting matter or a devolved culture and sport matter for the Scottish Executive.It is true that political intervention was involved in rescuing from its previous incarnation the company on whose board I serve, but the broadcasting rights for Scotland matches are principally a commercial issue for the Scottish Football Association.You could reasonably take the view that the BBC, with its public service responsibilities, should find the resources to cover all Scotland matches. However, the problem is that the other companies that tender to broadcast Scotland matches would decide that, if the BBC, subsidised by the UK taxpayer, was going to show them, they would not tender to broadcast them live. That would deprive the SFA of substantial income—I do not know exactly how much, but we are probably talking about millions of pounds every year.Although the SFA is notionally a company, it is more like a not-for-profit organisation, as its income goes back into promoting the interests of Scottish football, including the national side. I worry about the law of unintended consequences kicking in. If Scottish football got into financial difficulties corporately—I am talking about the SFA and the national side rather than individual clubs—it would come knocking on the doors of the Scottish Executive and the Scottish taxpayers to bale it out.Perhaps you said that you have already done this, but it could be worth inquiring of the BBC why it did not show highlights of the Lithuania match. I am clear that, under the existing UK framework, it had a responsibility to do that. It was not a situation in which we could not have a highlights package. As I understand it, if a live game is put out to competitive tender, the showing of free-to-view highlights by another television station, for example the BBC, is a requirement. I imagine that, if there was no highlights package of the Lithuania game, the UK regulatory authorities could call the BBC to account for that.

Stuart McMillan
link

I was not mistaken: there was no coverage on that evening. The BBC had someone reporting from Lithuania, with a picture backdrop of somewhere in Lithuania, but that was it.

Stuart McMillan
link

No.Also, the programme did not start at 5 past 12, as the champions league programmes on ITV do; it was on at about half past 10.To be honest, it was possibly an oversight on the part of the BBC. You are correct that there are usually highlights packages of Scotland matches, which is acceptable to most people. I go to the vast majority of home matches, and I have been fortunate enough to go to one or two away matches, but I cannot afford to do so all the time, and not many people can. I am a genuine supporter and I do not want to sit at home watching the match; I would prefer to go to it, because you get a better atmosphere. However, I recognise that, as there was no highlights package on that particular night, perhaps because of an oversight by the BBC, people may have missed out.

Charlie Gordon Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Did the BBC explain why it had not shown the game?

Stuart McMillan
link

It just said that it did not have the rights to the match.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Probably everyone in the room acknowledges the importance that football has to the lives of people not just in Scotland but in the whole of the UK—rightly so because it is a great sport.The committee is always concerned to see what work has gone on before a petition comes here. I note that you have only sent a letter to Jeremy Peat, the governor of BBC Scotland. Given that that is the only place that the issue has gone, I am concerned that we seem to be the first—or, in this case, second—port of call, rather than the last port of call.The subject of your petition is a matter for Westminster. Given that we have Westminster parliamentarians in Scotland, why have you not asked one of them to take up the issue? Why have you not raised the issue with Ofcom—the Office of Communications—which has some part to play in such matters? Although it is controlled by Westminster, it is still obliged to give people in Scotland an answer. Will you respond to those two points?

Stuart McMillan
link

Certainly. I did not write to the Westminster Parliament because I hoped that if I wrote my petition in such a way that it incorporated a sport and culture element and lodged it in the Scottish Parliament, it would be accepted. Thankfully, it was. My petition is about more than just broadcasting; it deals with a sporting issue in that it relates to the Scottish national football team. That is why I directed it at the Scottish Parliament.I did not contact Ofcom because I felt that the BBC was the most important organisation to contact. To be perfectly honest, I thought that it would then be best to come straight to the Parliament.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

My main concern is that you have not sought the help of your Westminster parliamentarian, because it seems that discussion between your Westminster parliamentarian and Ofcom and the BBC could have a direct influence. However, I hear what you say.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The committee is joined by Stewart Maxwell, who would like to make some comments.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

I thank the convener for allowing me to do so.I will pick up where Helen Eadie left off. It is fair for anyone to bring a petition here because the Scottish Parliament is unique in having a facility that allows members of the public to lodge a petition. That is great. Given that there is no public petitions committee at Westminster, it is entirely reasonable for someone to bring their petition here.When bidding for matches, the BBC in England and BBC Scotland operate separately, so it is not necessarily the case that the issue should be raised with the BBC. Going to BBC Scotland and then coming here seems an entirely reasonable route for the petitioner to take.I understand that Mr McMillan has stated that his petition is about parity for all licence fee payers and I agree with that. We pay our licence fee along with everyone else in the United Kingdom and some of that money is used to buy the rights to show football matches. The BBC in England has used some of our money to buy coverage of all the England team's qualifying matches for the European championship, but BBC Scotland has failed to do the same for Scottish football fans.Sandra White asked which games are being shown and which are not. All England's games are being shown by the BBC, but very few of Scotland's games are being shown. There is a clear difference. The Scotland v Lithuania game was not shown, even as part of a highlights package. I was very peeved that night because I had assumed that highlights of the game would be on. On the back of that, I too wrote to the BBC and got the same answer as Mr McMillan, which was that the BBC did not have the rights to show the highlights of the game. I do not know whether Charlie Gordon's point about the match being a category B event is correct because the BBC seemed to think that it did not have the rights to show highlights of the match.The suggestion that restricting coverage of the matches to the BBC could result in a loss of income does not hold water. We already restrict coverage of many sporting events—including the Olympics and cup finals—on the basis of national interest and, in my view, football games involving the Scottish national team should fall into the same category. If they are not shown live, they should at least form part of a highlights package so that all people in Scotland can have free access to them. That should apply to all such games, but the fact that that has not been the case shows that coverage of Scotland games is not being protected.I have a specific question for Mr McMillan. Do you know how much money the BBC in England bid to show England's qualifiers for the European championship and how much BBC Scotland bid for the Scotland games?

Stuart McMillan
link

No.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

I do not know either, but I would not be at all surprised if the amount of money that the BBC in England bid for all the live England matches was much higher than the amount of money that BBC Scotland bid for the Scotland games. The commercial market is such that England games cost more, because England is a bigger country, with more fans and so on. I would be very surprised if what we were seeing here was not a commercial decision by the BBC but a decision based on the level of importance that BBC Scotland placed on securing the Scotland games, compared with the level of importance that the BBC in England placed on securing the England games.BBC Scotland has a case to answer, to explain why the BBC in England went the extra mile to ensure that it got the England games for all its viewers yet BBC Scotland did not do the same for Scotland. I would have thought that the England games would be much more expensive, although I, like the petitioner, do not know the price. I am not a member of the committee, but I suggest that you ask BBC Scotland how much it was willing to spend to secure the Scotland games, as opposed to how much the BBC in England was willing to spend to secure the England games. That comparison would be interesting.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The discussion is interesting—football supporters in Scotland have it regularly. It is possible that BBC Scotland understood that there probably would not be any highlights in a Scotland match, given our recent history, although I have to say that on the occasion in question we beat Lithuania, so there would have been highlights to show. Kenny Miller scored that night and I think that the BBC would want footage of a Kenny Miller goal in its archives.We can have our football-minded discussion about the whys and wherefores of the Scottish national team, but we have to take this broadcasting issue seriously. I thank Mr McMillan for bringing it to our attention. The question whether to bid for a members' business debate is for members to decide. Perhaps Mr McMillan could get his MSP to lodge a motion to discuss the issue in the Parliament, which would be legitimate. I invite suggestions from members on how to proceed with the petition.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I agree that the issue is serious and that supporters throughout Scotland would want us to take it seriously. I reiterate my concern that the committee should be seen not as the second port of call but as the last port of call after a lot of other endeavours—I will let that point stick to the wall.We could copy the petition and the Official Report of this meeting to the SFA, Ofcom and Ken MacQuarrie of the BBC. He never ceases to write to us all seeking our views on the performance of the BBC, so we should feed back to him our views on this issue.Given that we all recognise that Westminster has a responsibility, we could write to the all-party group on sports at Westminster and to our own cross-party group on sport, which Dennis Canavan has convened for some time. Last but not least, we should write to the Minister for Tourism, Culture and Sport, who might be able to highlight the issue with her colleagues at Westminster.I am not sure that we can do much more than that as a committee. I suggest that, having made all those representations to ensure that word of the concerns in Scotland gets through to the relevant people, we should close the petition.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I agree with some of what Helen Eadie said, but I disagree with most of it. The Public Petitions Committee, which has won numerous awards, is one of the best committees in the Scottish Parliament. If the public of Scotland want to submit a petition, it is their right to do so. The committee is not the last port of call. I am sure that people think hard and deeply about whether they want to submit a petition and I find some of the comments that Helen Eadie made at the beginning unforgivable. The Parliament should be proud of the Public Petitions Committee and encourage people to petition it.However, I agree with Helen Eadie on a couple of things. She suggested that we should copy the petition to the SFA. We should do that and we should send it to the UK Government Department for Culture, Media and Sport. The DCMS is considering various other ways of approaching football coverage in 2008, so it should be made aware of the petition. I also agree that we should write to Ken MacQuarrie. However, we should not only send him the petition but follow Stewart Maxwell's good suggestion—I did not see Stewart coming in, for which I apologise to him. I asked how we can make a comparison to find out whether there is fairness and parity, so I would be interested to find out what is happening. The petition should be kept open until we get answers to those questions back, because they are interesting. I do not think that only one person is to blame, but I would like to know exactly what is going on so that I can make up my mind what to say about it.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

I agree with what Sandra White and other members said. I am sure that somebody mentioned the SFA in all that. It looks to me like a case of national versus commercial interests at the moment and I am keen to be sure that the BBC is representing the best interests of the viewing public and the licence fee payer in the bidding process. I would like the BBC to have first refusal on coverage so that we can get access on what my daughters like to call cooncil TV but the rest of us call mainstream telly. It is an important question whether the BBC is involved in the process, making bids and getting opportunities for the viewing public. As long as we are writing to the SFA and the other aforementioned organisations, that is good.In my view, Mr McMillan and others do not have to trawl round the houses before they come to the Public Petitions Committee. If we are the first port of call, so be it. We are here for him.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We have had a number of suggestions of organisations to which we could write. We should keep the petition open until we see the responses to those letters and let Mr McMillan have access to them. That is the only disagreement that I have with Helen Eadie. We are entitled to have a discussion on the petition and should keep it open until Mr McMillan has the opportunity to see the responses that we get from the organisations to which we will write. We would then welcome his comments on those responses. I thank him for bringing his petition to the committee.

Stuart McMillan
link

Thank you, convener. I thank the committee.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 17 January 2007 Petitions · 4
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 72
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 54
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 18
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.