Item 2 on the agenda is current petitions, starting with PE841 from the Curran family, who call on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to amend the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 to provide for mandatory inquiries in cases of road deaths that are caused by careless driving.At its meeting on 8 September 2005, the committee considered responses from the Minister for Justice, the Lord Advocate and the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents. We agreed to invite the views of the petitioner on the responses and to write again to the Minister for Justice and the Lord Advocate. Responses have been received and circulated to the committee. We have been joined by Elaine Smith MSP and John Swinburne MSP. I invite Elaine Smith to comment.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 (PE841)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 4
- Elaine Smith Lab 1
- John Swinburne SSCUP 1
- Helen Eadie Lab 1
- John Scott Con 1
The record
8 contributionsI am grateful for the opportunity to speak in support of PE841, which is from the Curran family, who are constituents of mine. Members of the committee will remember that I wrote to them about the case in September. I am aware that the Currans have responded to the replies from the Minister for Justice and the Lord Advocate.My constituents have been dignified and eloquent in putting their case to the committee, so I do not want to repeat all the points that they have made. Suffice it to say that the current system—in which victims' families can be left in a horrendous limbo in which they feel that justice has failed them, that they have been given few answers to questions about why their loved one died and that there has been no official recognition of the death—is completely inadequate. It is not good enough to say, "We're sorry, but that's just the way the justice system works." There must be ways to improve the situation in Scotland: making a fatal accident inquiry mandatory when death has been caused by careless driving might be a way forward.I acknowledge that the Lord Advocate has said that action is being taken to ensure that communication between procurators fiscal and victims' families is improved—in that regard, it is clear that the revision of the guidelines and training on death investigations is a good thing. However, as my colleagues will be aware from their casework, procurators fiscal and their staff deal with an enormous workload, which means that it is reasonable to question how much time they and victim information and advice officers would be willing or able to commit to addressing the concerns of affected families, especially when a case has already been resolved through criminal proceedings or when, in the eyes of the law, there is no victim acknowledged. That is a vital point. I question how much detail is made available to victim information and advice officers on police investigations. For example, the Curran family still do not know why adequate evidence was not found to prove that the driver whose car hit Gillian's car was speeding, in spite of the fact that considerable damage was caused to Gillian's car. In such cases, families need hard facts so that they can be satisfied that the investigation has been sufficiently thorough. Unless they are given such detailed information, it is unlikely that families will be satisfied with vague reassurances from procurators fiscal or victim information and advice. Only a fatal accident inquiry would provide the necessary reassurance. The Lord Advocate states that families' views are sought on whether there should be a fatal accident inquiry, but I invite the committee to consider asking him to elaborate on how proactively that is done and, indeed, on why such action is taken at all, given that families' views are not considered to be decisive in determining whether such an inquiry should take place. A mandatory fatal accident inquiry system in which the procurator fiscal took into account the views of families who did not want such an inquiry to be held would be more satisfactory. It might also be an improvement to enhance families' access to fatal accident inquiries. The Currans are involved in the lengthy and expensive process of applying for a discretionary inquiry. If permission is granted to hold such an inquiry—we hope that it will be—it will cost them thousands of pounds.The point that my constituents are keen to make is that they are not being dogmatic in their petition. They want Parliament to seek ways of improving the system sufficiently to ensure that no other family experiences the trauma and aggravated distress that they have experienced.
I am here as an observer and to support the Curran family. I thank Elaine Smith for being succinct in making all the points that I would have made.For 25 years I travelled the road on which the accident happened. I have spoken to the family and my heart goes out to its members because they cannot get closure. A fatal accident inquiry might bring the matter to an end for them, so I hope that the committee will consider the petition favourably.
Members have heard what has been said this morning. I am keen to hear what they think of the responses that we have received.
The family wants provision to be made"for a mandatory inquiry in the case of a road death caused by careless drivers."That does not tie in with the responses from the Minister for Justice and the Lord Advocate. Given that the matter is complex and raises many other issues, there is a case for it to be referred to one of the justice committees for more detailed consideration. It is good to note that it appears that amendments to the Road Safety Bill that is being considered at Westminster will seek"to introduce a new offence of causing death by careless driving in Scotland, England and Wales, with a penalty of up to five years imprisonment."That is indeed progress, but I do not think that it provides what the Curran family is after in its petition, which is why I would support our passing the matter on to one of the justice committees.
I agree. The answers that we have received from the Minister for Justice and the Lord Advocate clearly define the role of FAIs. They do not regard FAIs as being the right vehicle for recognising the circumstances of such cases. The petition should go to one of the justice committees for that reason. I agree wholly that families need that recognition, if they wish it, but perhaps a vehicle other than FAIs has to be found because, as I have just said, such inquiries' terms have been clearly defined by both the Minister for Justice and the Lord Advocate. We cannot avoid those definitions and the reasons behind them. It should now be up to another committee to consider the petition, I hope sympathetically.
Although I understand the view that the Lord Advocate and the Justice Department have taken towards FAIs, I cannot understand their rationale behind dismissing the Curran family's request for one. They say that FAIs do not always satisfy the people who are looking for an answer. At the same time, the Lord Advocate has admitted that there has never been an FAI in a case such as this. I do not know how he can say that the outcomes do not always satisfy the victims' families if that has never been tested: there has never been an FAI in such circumstances, so there has been no opportunity to make that judgment. I understand the rationale behind calling for an FAI, but I cannot understand the Lord Advocate's reasoning in dismissing that call.We need to consider what the petition is asking for. The family are asking for recognition of the fact that there was a victim following the accident. If an FAI is not the way to achieve such recognition, the Justice Department must come up with some way to ensure that there is recognition when someone dies in a car accident. It cannot be acceptable to anyone that a court case can take place, a person be found guilty and the court determine that a death took place in that accident, but that it cannot be found anywhere in the records that a fatality took place. That is the bottom line. I have not yet seen an answer from the Lord Advocate or the Minister for Justice that explains how the outcome that the Curran family is seeking can be achieved.We need to ask one of the justice committees whether it can find a way forward. I do not think that we can close PE841 without knowing that all the possibilities have been examined. The proposed changes to the road traffic legislation will not achieve that and the Scottish legal system needs to find a way to ensure that, when a fatality takes place in an accident, regardless of the circumstances, there is some recognition that someone died in that accident. That is fundamental to the petition. If we send the petition to one of the justice committees, we should do so with the recommendation that it should try to find a way forward in that respect. Are members happy with that?Members indicated agreement.
I thank our visitors for coming this morning.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Dec 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 21 December 2005 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 89
- New Petitions Petitions · 29
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- eEurope Awards for eGovernment Good Practice 2005 Committee business · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.