Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Children's Services (Special Needs) (PE853)

Wednesday 22 June 2005 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 37 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

37 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The next petition is PE853, which is on services for children with special needs. The petition, which is by Ken Venters, on behalf of the Carronhill action team, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to introduce legislation to require all proposals to close or alter facilities and services for children with special needs to be referred to the Executive and to require detailed consultation with the parents of the affected children. The petition also calls for the implementation of a moratorium on the closure of special needs schools until such legislation is in place. The petitioner is a representative of the Carronhill action team, which was set up in response to the proposed closure of Carronhill School in Aberdeenshire, which provides education for pupils with additional needs.Members will recall that, during our consideration of PE725 and PE753, which related to rural school closures, the Minister for Education and Young People, Peter Peacock, said that he is not in favour of a presumption against the closure of rural schools or any category of school. The Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Act 2000 introduced a general presumption of mainstream education for pupils with special educational needs.We are joined by Mike Rumbles, who has an interest in the issue.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

The background to the issue is that Aberdeenshire Council is working to upgrade and improve its whole school estate and has come up with options that could improve schools through the £200 million or thereabouts that will become available when the next tranche of money comes from the Scottish Executive. However, the council did not produce a plan and then consult on it; if it had done so, everybody would be in uproar. Instead, sensibly, the council produced options and has consulted on them.One of the options that the council has produced is for the closure of Carronhill School. So far, there has been zero response to the consultation from people who want the school to be closed—everybody wants to keep it open, as far as I can see. No one backs the option to close the school. Indeed, one of the options now is to upgrade and refurbish the school. That option was not on the cards originally; it is a reaction from Aberdeenshire Council. I whole-heartedly support the option to refurbish and upgrade the school and not to close it.The petition points out what I consider to be a loophole in the legislation in relation to closing schools. The convener mentioned that the minister does not want a presumption against closing rural schools, but we are not talking about a rural school—Carronhill is a special needs school in the town of Stonehaven. The petitioner points out a loophole in relation to the closure of special needs schools—normally, school closures have to be referred to the Scottish Executive. That is an important issue that must be addressed.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

For clarity, I point out that I referred to rural schools in connection with PE725 and PE753, which were specifically about rural schools, but which led us to consider the guidelines, which affect special needs schools, rural schools and all other categories of schools.Petition PE853 is about a special educational needs school. Mike Rumbles's comments caused me a bit of confusion. He said that he had concerns because there had been no consultation, but he then said that there had been no support for the proposal in the consultation.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

No. People have criticised consultations in the past because a council or health board has come up with a plan and then consulted on it. Aberdeenshire Council came up with a variety of options—A to E—and put them out for consultation. I support that, but there is a reasonable fear among the parents and the population of Stonehaven that the plan is to close Carronhill School. However, there is no plan to close Carronhill School; that is just one of the options. The idea behind that option is that money could be invested in special units in other local schools. The local community is completely against that, but it is just one option. What I am trying to say is that the result of the first tranche of consultation has shown that nobody supports the closure of the school. I find it inconceivable that the council would choose that option, having consulted and found nobody in support of it.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

You said that various options have been offered. Is the status quo one of those options?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

No. There is nothing wrong with the school's structure, but it needs to be refurbished. As a result, one of the options is to keep the whole school estate where it is and to refurbish it. I have to say that that was not one of the original options; it came about as a result of the first part of the consultation, which showed that there was no support for the option to build special units in local schools.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

And I presume that, although the school is in Stonehaven, pupils from a much wider area attend it.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

If the school were to be closed, what would be the nearest available school for the parents of those children?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

The other option is St Andrew's school in Inverurie. However, as it is in the same education authority area, I suppose that we could say that it is also under threat. In my view, there is no real option for the parents and children of Carronhill School other than to keep and refurbish it—which, as I have said, is one of the options.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

If St Andrew's school closes, what would be the option for the Aberdeenshire area?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

The difference between St Andrew's school, which is in Nora Radcliffe's constituency, and Carronhill School is that St Andrew's real estate is just not up to scratch. Basically, it needs to be demolished and rebuilt somewhere. Options face all sorts of Aberdeenshire schools, including these two special needs schools. However, closing Carronhill School would leave the parents and children there with no facility.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

So is Aberdeenshire Council proposing to send the children into mainstream education?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

You must remember that this is an option, not a proposal.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

If the status quo is not an option, there must be something else.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

The other option is to build special units that are attached to mainstream schools.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Before I bring in Jackie Baillie, I should point out that we are here to discuss the petition, not to interrogate Mike Rumbles.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I am just here to support the petition.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I should also point out that we have to be careful here. After all, we do not judge a local authority's decisions. Mike Rumbles has told us that there is an on-going process that will allow the parents and the rest of the local community who are involved in Carronhill to have their say. It would be wrong of us to begin to examine that issue. Instead, we have to consider whether there is a problem with the consultation or the guidelines. We are focusing on generalities not on the specific question whether this or that school should or should not close.Does that leave you anything to ask, Jackie?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

That leaves me lots to say, convener. You cannot shut me up quite so easily.This process, which is going on to different degrees in different local authorities, should take into account a number of ingredients such as the structure of any given building, the projection of population or future need and educational advantage. I am keen to know whether any of those elements is taken into account in the range of options that Aberdeenshire Council—or, indeed, any council—places before parents. Secondly, would it offer any comfort to Mike Rumbles's constituents not just at the school under discussion but across the entire patch to know that ministers take into consideration any school whose roll exceeds 80 per cent of its capacity? Indeed, does the example that you have used to illustrate the whole give such comfort?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Aberdeenshire Council's consultation, which is on the whole plan for Aberdeenshire schools, has focused on this matter, particularly in my constituency, because it is the big issue there.I agree that many issues have to be taken into account. Carronhill School and St Andrew's school in Inverurie are both special needs schools. However, it has been recognised that the St Andrew's school building is not up to scratch and must be replaced. The idea is perhaps to get rid of it and to attach special units to mainstream schools instead. The same option has been suggested for Carronhill, but there is nothing wrong with the building. That has led to another option, which I support, of upgrading the school itself.However, you are right to say that the council has to take a wide range of issues into account. It knows that it is responsible not only for using public money well but for educating its children properly, and I realise that it has to consider all the available options. I come back to the point that the council is consulting not on a particular plan but on a series of options.We have to recognise parents' genuine concern about the presumption in favour of mainstream education for special needs children. The worry is that there are kids with severe special needs in Carronhill School. Having seen that school for myself and talked to the parents and children, I am convinced that moving them all into special units attached to mainstream schools would not work.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I do not think that that is the Executive's policy; such measures are proposed only when they are suitable for the child. However, let us not debate that here. Does the specific point that I made about schools that are at 80 per cent capacity offer any comfort in this situation?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I do not think that the school is at 80 per cent capacity. I do not want to mislead the committee because I do not have that information, but the attractions of Carronhill School include the site, the facilities and the classrooms. It is probably not at capacity, although I am not sure about that.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

As I said at the beginning of the meeting, I think that the kids and their parents should have given us evidence. Mike Rumbles is right—the problem is not just with this school. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to look at the"facilities and services for children with special needs".It does not ask for that to be done for Carronhill School and it is the general point that what we are debating today.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

So why did we need to hear from a specific school to understand that?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

Specific people lodged the petition, but it does not ask for action to be taken on Carronhill School. I do not want to labour that point, but I raised the matter at the beginning of the meeting because it concerned me. Had the parents been invited to give evidence, we might have found out from them whether the school was at 80 per cent capacity. It is a shame that we did not do that. However, we have to look at the bigger picture, which is not just about Carronhill School; it is about children with special needs being put into mainstream schooling. Mike Rumbles is absolutely right to look at the petition in light of the whole education system. I understand the guidance that is set out in the Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Act 2000, which mentions children with learning difficulties. The three exceptions to the presumption of mainstream education are where it"would not be suited to the ability or aptitude of a child;"where it"would be incompatible with the provision of efficient education for the children with whom the child would be educated;"and where it"would result in unreasonable public expenditure being incurred".That last exception comes back to money. I would like the petition to be referred to the Education Committee because that committee is reviewing education provision. The petition is about children with learning difficulties being mainstreamed in school and deals with a bigger ball-game than just one school. I am sorry that I did not ask you any questions, Mike.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Mike Rumbles is not here to answer questions. Sandra, I could not agree with you more that the problem is general. The issue with which we are dealing is to do with whether the guidelines offer protection to communities for their schools and the services that are provided. We have guidelines on that, but if they are breached in this decision or if the criteria for permission to close schools are breached, that is something that the Scottish Executive will have to look at; it is not for us to judge whether that has been the case. That is not the role of this committee. We have to ensure that the issues that are raised in the petition are properly addressed in terms of what we can do by asking the Executive or the Parliament to address them. I was on the Equal Opportunities Committee when we looked at the Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill and we discussed mainstreaming. Mainstreaming was introduced for good reasons: far too many young people who could easily have gone into mainstream education were put into special educational needs schools. The bill moved the emphasis away from a presumption against a young person going into mainstream school towards ensuring that the young person's needs were taken into account and that they were supported in mainstream schools if possible. If that is not what is happening in this case, we have to find out whether the guidelines are tight enough to offer that type of protection. We have to write to the Scottish Executive.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

The petition calls on the Parliament"to urge the Scottish Executive to introduce legislation requiring all proposals which relate to the closure or alteration of facilities and services for children with special needs to be referred to it".We should write to the Executive and ask whether it has any plans to introduce such legislation. As far as I can see, it is unlikely that it will have such plans. It is important to manage expectations, because I do not think that the Executive will change its position readily or easily. The petitioner seeks a change to the existing legislation, and we have to address that point.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I am happy with that. We should write to the Minister for Education and Young People, both to address that point and to establish whether the protection that the petitioner is evidently seeking exists. Secondly, we should write to Aberdeenshire Council to get its view. That will also draw the council's attention—if its attention needs to be drawn—to the fact that the petitioners are here today.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I agree with that. I also wonder whether, if it is not too soon to do so, we should send the petition to the Education Committee, which has a review of schools in its future work programme. Alternatively, perhaps we should wait until we get responses to our letters.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I think that we should wait for the responses so that we know exactly what we are sending to the Education Committee. When we send petitions to other committees, those committees are happier if we have a specific purpose behind doing that, rather than simply seeking a way for the petition to be addressed. If we wait for the responses from the Executive and the local authority, we can then pass them to the Education Committee for consideration as part of its future work programme. We will ask the Executive whether it believes that the current guidelines are working or whether there is potential for new legislation.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

I have another question for Mike Rumbles. From the discussion that we have had, there seems to be no suggestion that Aberdeenshire Council is doing anything other than acting entirely properly. Is that right?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

That is correct. In my view, the process is absolutely correct. As I said earlier, the council did not produce a plan and say, "Let's consult on it." It did things the other way round. It said, "Here are the options that are before us. Let's consult on them." Obviously, one of the options was to close the school, and that obviously upset the parents because it is a very good school. I emphasise the fact that none of the responses to the consultation supported the school's closure. As far as I am concerned, Aberdeenshire Council is behaving in absolutely the correct way.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Do members agree that we should write to the Executive and Aberdeenshire Council?Members indicated agreement.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I apologise to David Davidson. When he joined us, we were already concluding our discussion.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 22 June 2005 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 11
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 64
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 58
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 37
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 13
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.