Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Institutional Child Abuse (PE535)

Wednesday 25 May 2005 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 20 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

20 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Our first current petition, PE535, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to inquire into past institutional child abuse, in particular of those children who were in the care of the state under the supervision of religious orders, to make an unreserved apology for those said state bodies and to urge the religious orders to apologise unconditionally.At its meeting on 16 March 2005, the committee considered a response from the Catholic Church and agreed to invite the views of the petitioner on that response. The committee also agreed to write to the Scottish information commissioner, seeking an update on his examination of the Scottish Executive process to trace and open up files that relate to abuse in children's homes and residential schools.The responses that we received from the petitioner, the In Care Abused Support/In Care Abuse Survivors group—INCAS—and the Scottish information commissioner have been circulated to members. Does any member have a view on PE535?

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

The e-mail that we received this morning from John Deighan gives a full response, in which he says explicitly what Cardinal O'Brien did. On the basis of that response, it is reasonable to close the petition.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

Chris Daly called me this morning before I came to the meeting to say that he had received by post to his home a letter from John Deighan. He told me that he was not happy with the content of the letter and attempted to e-mail it to me so that I could distribute it. However, I did not receive the letter so I cannot distribute it.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

What we have is a copy of the contents of the letter—John Deighan has advised us of what he put into his letter to Chris Daly.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I think that Jim Johnston, our clerk, will be able to help us.

Jim Johnston
link

Sorry, Rosie. I spoke to John Deighan this morning. He said that the e-mail that he circulated, which has been tabled for members, is a copy of what he sent to Mr Daly.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

Okay. Although I could not look at the whole letter, I know that Chris Daly is not content with it. Chris Daly, David Whelan and many others are having difficulty in getting access to the records to which they were promised access. They have been told on numerous occasions that there were fires or that records were lost in transit, but that has not been proven; they have seen no record of a fire.Is it possible for Kevin Dunion, the Scottish information commissioner, to meet Chris Daly, David Whelan and others around a table so that he can reassure them on the issue? Chris Daly, David Whelan and others feel as if they are banging their heads off a brick wall. They are happy about how far things have gone and about how much they have achieved, but they are struggling. INCAS has very few resources. They have made a monster; they are a victim of their own success. A discussion between Kevin Dunion, Chris Daly, David Whelan and others would help to get some answers to the question of what is happening about the files. We do not want to have what in Australia is called "shredgate", with files going missing willy-nilly. In that meeting, Kevin Dunion could allay concerns and explain where the files have gone. If there was a fire, surely a fire alarm would have gone off. If Chris Daly and others could be shown a record of that, it would help them to deal with the loss.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The first thing that strikes me about what Rosie Kane is asking for is that an independent commissioner would not take kindly to an instruction from us for him to do one thing or another. We would have difficulty if we were to get into that line of debate with him. From what we see from the correspondence, the issues have not been addressed. If we are to ensure that the questions are answered, we have to go to the Executive, as it was the Executive that set up the format under which the information was to be sought. If there are problems, we have to find out from the Executive what is going on.There is another, separate issue, which is whether the Public Petitions Committee or the Parliament can instruct an external organisation on the format of an apology that it is to give to an organisation. Chris Daly may well be unhappy with the apology that has been offered to him through John Deighan, but I do not know whether we can sit in judgment on whether the apology is acceptable.If the wording that I have seen this morning is what was sent to Chris Daly, that seems to me to be an unreserved apology, but it is for Chris Daly to judge whether or not he accepts the apology, and I do not know that we can go to the Catholic Church and say, "Chris Daly doesn't accept your apology so we want you to change the wording so that he is prepared to accept it." We asked for the church to issue an apology. It has tried to clarify that it issued an apology and it has reiterated that apology. I do not know that this committee can say whether that apology is suitable or not. We have to accept the fact that Chris Daly says that it is not suitable, but that is a matter for Chris Daly, not for us. We have to keep the two things separate. We can consider what we can do in terms of getting information, which INCAS and Chris Daly think is not forthcoming, but that is a separate matter from our examining the apology that is being offered by the Catholic Church.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I have the e-mail in front of me, and if you read just the one sentence it looks like an apology, but if you read it in the context of the whole letter it is perhaps not so apologetic, as Chris Daly has pointed out. However, that is a different issue, as the convener said. I am concerned about the progress that is being made. I think that the committee did a fabulous job in getting people in and holding a debate in Parliament, and we were assured by the minister that the ball would start rolling and that people would be interviewed and would be able to get their records. However, it appears from speaking to people that there has been no movement on that. We had people from INCAS here just a couple of weeks ago, and there had been no movement and we were no further forward. I would like to write to the minister and get an update on progress, if there is any, and find out exactly what is happening. I see nothing happening at all. I think that it was only last week that Linda Fabiani asked a parliamentary question of Peter Peacock and the answer was that something would happen in a couple of weeks' time, or something like that. I cannot remember the exact words, but certainly nothing was happening, as far as I can recollect. I would like to write to the minister for an update on progress.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

I support your view, convener. There are two definite issues that need to be addressed. We are beginning to lose sight of the real issue in worrying about whether or not the quality or level of apology from Cardinal O'Brien is sufficient. That is not the issue. In my view, he has apologised. The real issue is that which the minister undertook to address. I am disappointed to hear Sandra White saying that, despite the undertakings given in the debate last year, the minister has not progressed those matters further, as he promised. That is something that we should be much more outraged by. That is what we should address and it is also much more within our remit to tackle that problem.

Campbell Martin Ind West of Scotland
link

I have not spoken to Chris Daly, but I think that what is bothering him is the context in which the cardinal's apology was given, as it was given as part of a general television interview. If we consider the apology that was given on behalf of the nation by the First Minister, what was happening there was unmistakable. The First Minister made a clear apology about the issue, and the Catholic Church has it within its power to do that too. It could come out and make a specific, distinct and unmistakable apology. Its press department, or whoever was appropriate, could do that, rather than the apology being made as part of a television interview about other general issues. It is true that there are two specific issues involved. One is the issue of apology, which has been addressed partly by the First Minister and which should be addressed by other organisations. The other is about closure and what happened to those people so many years ago. That is where the minister comes back in and that is why we should seek an update from him on what has happened since the debate in Parliament.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I appreciate the point that you are making. I spoke to John Deighan about that point myself, because I was interested in the interpretation given in the letter from INCAS, which said that the original highly publicised apology was that of Father Gilhooley, and that there was an add-on apology to all other victims. That is one aspect of the petitioner's concern. They then went on to say that the subsequent apology was not covered very well in the media, and was therefore not so publicly recognised as the original apology. However, John Deighan assures me that both apologies were put out to the media in the same way, and that it transpired that the media chose not to cover them to the same extent. You cannot hold the Catholic Church responsible if the media do or do not cover an apology prominently. For INCAS to say that the apology is not sufficient because the media did not cover it is not the same as saying that the apology was not publicised. I do not want to sound as though I am defending what the church is doing, but I spoke to John Deighan and got from him answers to the questions that I put, which were the same as those that you posed, Campbell. His response to me was that the apologies were put out through the same sources, and that the church was not responsible for the subsequent media coverage.

Campbell Martin Ind West of Scotland
link

I think that it is in our notes that INCAS asked for a meeting with the Catholic Church or John Deighan and got no response. If they had a meeting, perhaps that would be the time and place for the Catholic Church to make an unequivocal apology.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I do not disagree, but are we on this committee capable of saying whether they should or should not have a meeting? We have no authority over the church to order it to conduct any meeting, although I would encourage it to do so. I have spoken to John Deighan and encouraged him to do other things, but it is for the church to decide what it wants to do. However, John Scott is right that we must stay focused on what we can do.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I agree. The last time that we discussed an apology from the church our concern was that it was not made by the most senior cleric in Scotland at the time. However, the letter that we have received from John Deighan, which was addressed to Jim Johnston, states unequivocally that a clear and specific apology was made. The petition is in two parts, and as an apology has been made we should lay that part to rest. It is right that Michael McMahon and others are making representations in the background to encourage other actions that will help to bring comfort and closure to the individuals concerned. However, for the purpose of the committee, the call for an apology has been satisfied.With regard to Cardinal O'Brien, we need to think about the sense of the man, who would be very genuine in his response. There is no doubt whatsoever that the apology was sincere and unequivocal on behalf of the Catholic Church. I am not a Roman Catholic, but I say that because I know him and his connections with the constituency that I have the privilege of representing.I was unaware of the points that Rosie Kane raised. She has brought new information to the committee and on that basis I withdraw my support for closing the other part of the petition, because it is entirely reasonable to maintain pressure on the Minister for Education and Young People, Peter Peacock, to ensure that the assurances that he gave to the committee and the Parliament are fulfilled.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

To be clear, convener, it is not only the Catholic Church that has not come through, it is Quarriers and others. We have focused on the Catholic Church, but that is a slight smoke screen, because other organisations were involved.As you can imagine, there has been a big reaction and people are contacting INCAS. I do not know what I am asking for. We need to resolve the problem of accessing the files, and address the resources that INCAS needs for the professional scrutiny that it is involved in, but in which its members are not trained. I wonder where dialogue can take place. I do not know whether it should involve the forthcoming reporter.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

When the debate took place in November the files were not available, and they were not subject to the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002, which came into force at the beginning of January. I am sure that INCAS will have considered that, but if it has not it certainly has new rights to request information under FOI that it did not have before.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

I said in that debate that it would be good if Peter Peacock or the Parliament were able to say that from this day on it would be illegal to get rid of files or to lose pocket-money books and anything else that might assist the journey of children through different organisations. We have done so well that it would be a shame to thwart that amazing work. I am just wondering whether anyone knows where the final bits of the jigsaw fit in.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I agree entirely. We have to start asking questions about that, to get those final pieces to come together and to get some satisfaction for those who need that information. Apologies have been issued by the First Minister, by Quarriers and by the Catholic Church, and it is down to those who were affected whether they accept those apologies. I do not know that there is any more that we can do in that respect. There are more questions that we can ask about the information and about the work of the group that is considering the issue. Do members agree that we should write to the minister?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 25 May 2005 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 67
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 35
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 13
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 20
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 14
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 11
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 8
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 20
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.