Welcome to the sixth meeting of the Public Petitions Committee in 2005. We have received apologies from Mike Watson and Sandra White.Our first new petition, PE827, is from Hugh O'Donnell. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to amend its code of conduct to ensure that members of the Scottish Parliament are required to commit no less than two thirds of their working week to their parliamentary duties and that the code of conduct contains appropriate sanctions to deal with a member who is found by the standards commissioner to be in breach. Hugh O'Donnell will make a brief statement to the committee in support of his petition.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Scottish Parliament (Code of Conduct for Members) (PE827)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Hugh O’Donnell 27
- Helen Eadie Lab 14
- Michael McMahon Lab 9
- Campbell Martin Ind 6
- Hugh O'Donnell 5
- Jackie Baillie Lab 5
- John Scott Con 3
- John Farquhar Munro LD 1
The record
70 contributionsI thank the committee for taking time in its busy schedule to accommodate my contribution.The primary objective of the petition is to generate debate in the Parliament about the activities of MSPs outwith their parliamentary and constituency responsibilities. Having followed the progress of the Scottish Parliament since its inception, I have been particularly impressed by the way in which the committees work. I have noticed that we are not following the Westminster pattern and we do not have huge numbers of MSPs with other occupations. However, the absence of any guidance in the code of conduct leaves a window open for us to develop as Westminster has. For instance, within the past 12 months, at least one MP earned more than £1 million from external interests. It is reasonable for the people of Scotland to expect being an MSP to be a full-time occupation, whether the work relates to parliamentary duties within the parliamentary complex or to constituency duties.My petition does not suggest that any MSPs are doing less than working hard. However, there is a loophole in the code of conduct that, unless addressed, could lead to MSPs following the same road as Westminster MPs. As we all know, historically, MPs were not paid and that was why many of them continued to have outside interests. However, given the rates of remuneration and the workload of elected members, the code of conduct should in some way reflect the expectation of the people of Scotland that members of the Scottish Parliament are fully occupied in the duties and responsibilities pertaining to that office. I accept that that is a matter not for me but for the Parliament to decide.
You say that two thirds of MSPs' time should be spent carrying out their official functions. How many hours does that relate to?
I recognise the difficulty of quantifying the number of hours. My primary purpose is to identify a forum for MSPs to decide that question. MSPs are not paid an hourly rate or for a 48-hour working week. However, if the European working time directive applies across Scotland, it would be less than fair if our MSPs were exempted from having a 48-hour working week. As a starting point for debate among elected members, we should look at the 48-hour working week.
That would prevent me from doing my job in the way I want to do it. It is no secret that you work for an MSP; you must know how many hours he works. Any MSP working 48 hours in a week would probably find that a drastic cut in his or her hours. Are you telling us that you would consider two thirds of 48 hours to be an acceptable working week for an MSP?
No. I have deliberately not specified a number of hours because, as you rightly point out, due to the nature of my employment I am well aware of the hours that can be and often are worked by elected members. Through the vehicle of the petition, I seek to highlight a potential loophole that could be exploited should an individual choose to do so. I take on board the point about the number of hours that you and other elected members work, but, equally, the other side of that coin is that there is nothing to state what MSPs are obliged to do once elected, or for how many hours they are obliged to do it.
This is one of those questions like, "How long is a piece of string?"
I realise that.
If someone enters into an election campaign stating, for example, that they have a second job, and the electorate chooses to vote for that individual, is it not a matter for the electorate whether they are content with the number of hours that the MSP or MP works on their behalf?
I do not disagree with that in any way.
I do not have a second job and I have no intention of having one. My question follows on from the point that the convener just made. Could it not be a strength for constituents to have an MSP who has particular expertise? Surely that would keep the MSP's skills and knowledge in a particular area up to date. I am thinking in particular of the legal profession.
You are thinking of the legal profession. That would depend on what the MSP thought the substantial part of their constituency to be. Any outside expertise is surely valuable, but given that the majority of Scotland's population is in blue-collar and white-collar occupations, it might be more relevant if the elected member's experience was as a front-line staff member in an accident and emergency unit or in care work. I have no knowledge of the extent to which people in the legal profession—lawyers, solicitors and so on—learn about real working life.
Let us say that the member was a consultant. The work of the Parliament's Health Committee could be well informed if one of its members was a hospital consultant. However, as we know, there is a dire shortage of hospital consultants right across Scotland. Would it be a problem if a consultant were to be an MSP?
That might be true, but I wonder how much our health service would benefit if one of its consultants were to serve in the Scottish Parliament as opposed to in the operating theatre.
Some hospital consultants might have a view. We could ask Dr Turner for her views on the matter.What is your understanding of a parliamentarian's job?
It is to represent the electorate.
You work for a member of the Scottish Parliament. Can you describe exactly what a parliamentarian's working week is like?
A full working week will range from committee work, such as the work in which you are currently engaged, to constituency work, case work, debates in the chamber and visits to organisations that may have information that is relevant to the member's work on a committee or to an interest that they have, perhaps for a member's bill. The parliamentarian's working week is diverse.
Yes. Would you like to say which member of the Scottish Parliament you work for?
Yes, if you wish me to do so. I work for Mr Donald Gorrie.
Can you tell me how many hours a week he works?
I have not calculated it exactly. It is hardly my duty to do so. However, in an average week, I estimate that he works in the order of 60 hours.
To me that would be part time. How many hours do other MSPs work each week? Have you undertaken a survey or research on the subject?
No, I have not.
So you have come forward with a proposition without having done the research.
I came up with the proposition by identifying what I perceived to be a loophole in the current code of conduct. As I said—I am reiterating my opening statement to some extent —my position is that there is a loophole in the code of conduct. The Scottish Parliament has been assiduous in avoiding a replication of many of the mistakes that happen at Westminster. This matter was overlooked because of all the other things that required to be done. Again, as I said at the outset, I am looking to engender debate on the issue among the elected members whose decision this must be.
The convener mentioned the European working time directive a few minutes ago. Let us assume that an MSP starts their working week on a Monday and works straight through to the Friday of the same week. If they worked 13 or 14 hours a day, their total working week would be around 70 hours, which is well above the time limit that is laid down in the directive. What should the member do about the hours that are required on the Saturday and Sunday to fulfil any number of constituency engagements—whether they be garden fetes, tours around the Parliament or surgeries—and to do the additional reading that must be done in preparation for up to three committee meetings in the following week?
They would make a decision based on the extent to which they viewed those as being their responsibilities as an elected member.
What about the enforceability and the policing of the European working time directive?
If I remember rightly, the convener referred to the matter in terms of what constitutes a piece of string. The directive is difficult to enforce and there are exemptions, which I believe are about to be done away with. As I know about the nature of the job to some extent, I was careful not to specify a number of working hours because that would be difficult to quantify. My main consideration in submitting the petition is to try to address what I perceive as a loophole in the way in which the code of conduct currently operates.
You say on the one hand that you want us to follow the European working time directive, but on the other hand you say that it is as long as a piece of string. In effect, you are saying that the European working time directive does not apply to MSPs.
No. I cited the directive as an example; that was all. It would perhaps be a starting point.
Either one lays lay down a code of conduct, which there is an expectation that MSPs will follow, or one does not.
Yes. As with the rest of the code of conduct, what the expectation is would be a matter for MSPs to decide.
In effect, you are saying that you want the Parliament to set down rules but at the same time you are saying that you want MSPs to make their own decisions.
Within the framework set down by the code of conduct—as they do with everything else.
Do you accept that there are very few occupations in respect of which the general public get to pass judgment on the performance of the person in the job, but that an MSP is one of those? If an MSP is not performing well and the general public get a chance to pass judgment on his or her ability, that judgment would include whether they think that the individual commits sufficient time to the job of being an MSP.
I accept that there are a number of jobs in respect of which the general public have the right to pass judgment on performance. In the case of MSPs, there is an opportunity every four years for constituents to make some sort of assessment but, as you are probably aware, for the most part, the voting system in Scotland and in the United Kingdom is such that, by and large, people will vote for a political party.
Not necessarily.
There are rare occasions in some constituencies where there is an independent, non-aligned member, but broadly speaking—I accept that it is a generalisation—
You would accept that the general public have the ultimate sanction. They can remove a person from the job of being an MSP.
Yes, ultimately they can remove an elected member from their job as an MSP, but the caveat that I would add, as I was about to say, is that, for the most part, elected members—at least when they initially become a member of this Parliament or any other—are affiliated to a political party, and the political party is what most people vote for. In general, that is the ticket on which an elected member stands. The electorate's view about whether they want to remove a particular individual as opposed to a particular party might subsequently be influenced and they might choose to remove a member.
Most people would call that democracy. If there is a problem with the electoral system, perhaps that is what you should seek to change.I wonder why you submitted the petition. You were motivated to submit it, so can you give an example of an MSP who you consider is not committing themselves sufficiently to the job of being an MSP?
I do not feel that it is appropriate to individualise a petition on this matter. I am primarily motivated by the potential that the current code of conduct has for us in Scotland—having done so well in so many ways to do things differently from Westminster—to end up with no means of dealing with a replication of some of the more extreme examples in the House of Commons.
Do you have concerns about any MSPs in particular?
I do not believe that it would be appropriate to pick out individuals.
What proportion of the 129 MSPs do you think is covered?
Again, it is difficult for me to quantify that without making it possible for you to extrapolate and individualise the figures. I am not comfortable with doing that and I will not do it.
link
I think that you would agree that it is important that we have this Parliament and that some of its hallmarks are openness and transparency. I am absolutely delighted that we have established that you do not just follow the Parliament but work in it. Equally, you would want to avoid the suggestion that you submitted the petition only because you happen to be a candidate in the Westminster elections. It would be helpful to get that on the record because I would not want the Parliament's Public Petitions Committee to be abused in that fashion.On the substance of your petition, you have acknowledged that it is a luxury for any MSP to work a 48-hour week. Is it equally a luxury for a researcher to work a 48-hour week?
I cannot remember the last time that I worked so short a week.
link
Indeed.
On your opening remark, the issue of the Westminster election has no bearing, because the petition process was started long before I was approached or selected in relation to the forthcoming events on 5 May. The petition was not submitted for that purpose.
link
My goodness; I always thought that Liberals did things early but I have been proved wrong.
Not necessarily in central Scotland.
link
Ah. I shall learn from that remark.Do you accept that many people could sit for a long time giving the appearance of working and some people can achieve in a short time what others might take hours to do, so that using two thirds of a working week as a definition is a bit of a nonsense?
I take on board the point that activity does not necessarily mean productivity, as we know from our experience. The question is a difficult one and I make no bones about it. I keep coming back to where I started. There has been a variety of negative media coverage about the elected members of this Parliament. Everyone here knows that journalists start out with a white page and nothing to write and if they can find something to write, they will write it. I am concerned that we should close the loopholes in the code of conduct because the press and the public might perceive that there is an opportunity for—I use the word advisedly—backsliding. For example—and again I hesitate to personalise—had there not been individuals who had senior partnerships in organisations in which they were still active while being elected members, making comments about conflicts of interest would have been less attractive. The ministerial code requires that ministers remove themselves from all that, but the current code of conduct does not protect MSPs sufficiently as far as that is concerned.
link
The more you carry on, the less sympathy I feel. I think that you are trying to resolve a problem that, by your own admission, does not exist. Instead of talking about parliamentary duties, you are now straying into issues of conflict of interest to which we are all subject because we have all lived long lives. It is hard to define the basis for the petition; it is trying to resolve a problem that does not exist.
By and large, I agree that the problem, per se, does not exist. I do not have a difficulty with that. However, it has the opportunity to exist and prevention is often better than cure. I refer you back to my observation about the lack of coverage of those matters in the code of conduct and the potential for that to be abused in the longer term. Given the success that we have had in addressing so many of Westminster's failings, I think that the matter should be examined.
Returning to an earlier point, I declare an interest as a farmer and chairman of the Scottish Association of Farmers Markets. I feel that it is vital that the Parliament continues to have as broad a range of skills as possible and that all members bring what extra skills they can to the job. Are you not prepared to accept that argument?
At no stage have I said that I do not accept that, regardless of age, social background or economic activity, we all bring a range of skills to the Parliament. Indeed, it is no less vital for elected members to do so.
But you are saying that people should not maintain those skills.
I am saying that we need to have a debate on the extent to which such activity should take precedence over members' parliamentary and constituency duties.
By your own admission, the problem does not exist, so why should it need to be debated?
But it has the potential to exist. As I said to Ms Baillie, the approach should be prevention rather than cure.
I now seek members' recommendations on what we should do with the petition. I have to say that I am a bit concerned about it. The committee has already made proposals to the Procedures Committee about changing who can or cannot submit petitions. I do not want to bring this petition into that category, but I wonder whether, like me, committee members feel uncomfortable that such a petition has been submitted during the election period. It might have been more conducive to taking the issue forward if we had held the debate outside such a delicate time.I am more than happy to find a way of resolving the petition, if members can suggest any. However, I do not believe that members agree that the issue requires to be addressed.
If we take into account the way in which the Parliament was established, its various codes of conduct, the introduction of the standards commissioner and Campbell Martin's point about accountability to the electorate, I think that they all take care of Mr O'Donnell's point. Given that such checks and balances exist, I am not minded to take the matter any further forward.
Mr O'Donnell, you said that there was no other way in which you could raise the matter. I suspect that that might not be the case. For example, if you are concerned about a specific issue, you can use the code of conduct and take the matter to the standards commissioner. Fourteen complaints about the accessibility of MSPs have already been made, and the commissioner has dismissed all of them.Moreover, MSPs can raise such issues. After all, you work for an MSP, and if you believe that a particular issue needs to be addressed, you can take it forward in other ways. I do not believe that the Public Petitions Committee has heard anything this morning that would lead us to conclude that the Parliament should address your concerns. Are members agreed?Members indicated agreement.
I just do not think that there is anything more that we can do with your petition, Mr O'Donnell. I appreciate your bringing the matter to the committee for discussion, but I think that we should close the petition at this point. Are members agreed?Members indicated agreement.
If the code of conduct is currently under review, would there be any merit in forwarding the petition to the Standards and Public Appointments Committee?
I suggest that Mr O'Donnell could make direct representations on these matters to the Standards and Public Appointments Committee. Are members agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Apr 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 20 April 2005 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 70
- New Petitions Petitions · 63
- New Petitions Petitions · 13
- New Petitions Petitions · 20
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Proposed Petition Petitions · 2
- eEurope Awards for eGovernment Good Practice 2005 Committee business · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.