PE749 calls on the Scottish Parliament to seek a moratorium on the spreading of sewage sludge, pending a full inquiry into the safety of the practice by a parliamentary committee. Depending on the outcome of the inquiry, the petition also calls on the Parliament as a minimum to initiate legislation at the earliest opportunity to discontinue the current exemptions for spreading sewage sludge and to ensure that it is subject to planning control, including a public local inquiry.At its meeting on 10 November 2004, the committee agreed to write again to the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, the petitioners, Sanquhar and district community council and David Mundell MSP to invite their comments on the responses from the Minister for Environment and Rural Development, Scottish Water and SEPA. The committee has also received a response from Envar. The responses have been circulated to members.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Sewage Sludge (PE749)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 3
- Mike Watson Ind 2
- John Scott Con 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Susan Deacon Lab 1
The record
10 contributionsSEPA's response states that it is Scottish Water's responsibility to provide evidence that will reassure the public and SEPA that its activities are not harmful. However, there is no evidence that Scottish Water has done that—I am sure that SEPA would have told us if it had had such an assurance. We should ask Scottish Water to do that. I also want to mention the issue that was raised in the late submission that we received from an organisation called Envar of which I was not aware before I read its submission. Envar seems to draw a distinction between treated and partially treated sewage sludge. In the response that we received, Ross Finnie, the Minister for Environment and Rural Development, said:"almost half of Scotland's sludge is co-incinerated … Most of Scotland's remaining sewage sludge is recycled".Can we ask the minister to clarify whether he is talking about all sludge or just treated or partially treated sludge? It might be a fine point, but Envar seems to be saying that there are different types of sludge, yet the Executive seems not to differentiate between the two.
I am not sure when we received Ross Finnie's response. Committee members might or might not be aware that the practice of burning sewage sludge in pelletised form has been stopped. Previously, Scottish Water and Scottish Power had an arrangement under which pellets were being burnt at a power station. A very real issue is involved if we cannot burn treated sewage sludge, put it in landfill or spread it on agricultural land. The Environment and Rural Development Committee needs to examine the issue. At the same time, I pose the question of how we are to dispose of the material. Although I would not dream of trying to tell a committee how to do its work, as part of its investigation, the Environment and Rural Development Committee should take on board David Mundell's comment that SEPA is not taking a proactive enough role in the matter. The issue that David Mundell raised is also worthy of investigation.
David Mundell has sent his apologies; he had hoped to be at the committee this morning, but he cannot make it. Unfortunately, that means that we cannot question him directly on the point. Do we ask the Environment and Rural Development Committee to consider the information that we have at the moment, or do we wait for a response to Mike Watson's questions before sending the information on to the Environment and Rural Development Committee? I leave that question hanging.
We should get answers to the questions that Mike Watson has posed. I read the e-mail from Envar last night, which seems to suggest that the process that is going on in Newcastleton is not safe. As for any other health and safety issue, one would want an immediate prohibition of the practice, pending further investigations. The right environmental people should become involved so that a prohibition notice can be served on the developer, pending the outcome of any discussions. I agree that we should seek a response. If we have the powers to do so, we should ask SEPA to stop the process until we have the information that we seek. My reading of the Envar e-mail tells me that something irregular is happening at Newcastleton. It should not be happening and we should move to try to stop it.
Colleagues on the Public Petitions Committee will be aware of my unhealthy preoccupation over the years with matters relating to sewage. There is a link between the area in which I have a particular interest, which is the processing of sewage at waste water treatment plants and related odour problems, and the subject of PE749. I note that in his response the minister made reference to legislative change. I am not sure whether the reference is to the late inclusions that we managed to make to the Water Services etc (Scotland) Bill that were linked to odour control. I know that odour is only one aspect of the petition, but it is an important aspect nonetheless. I am instinctively sympathetic to much of what underpins the petition, which is the need for the issue to be taken more seriously. I am instinctively unsympathetic to calls for moratoriums, but that is another matter.The Environment and Rural Development Committee is well placed to say what is the current state of play on the panoply of sewage processing issues and to consider the associated problems. That ties in with what I have said before about the fact that we seem to keep revisiting the same questions but not moving on.I remember that the Environment and Rural Development Committee has considered the matter, as I am sure the Public Petitions Committee has. In the first session, the Transport and the Environment Committee produced a very good report on the issue and the Executive has done work subsequently. The question to which I would like to know the answer is whether that has made a difference, so that the matter is moving forward, or whether everybody just keeps exchanging letters and thoughts on the issue and not doing anything to address the concerns of the petitioners. That is a long-winded way of saying that the work that has taken place does not preclude our getting answers to the questions that Mike Watson has raised. I am attracted to the idea of the Environment and Rural Development Committee considering the matter, because of its accumulated expertise and insights.
I agree that the Environment and Rural Development Committee should certainly consider the matter.I add, by way of clarification, that I said in my initial comments that it was the Envar submission that raised the different types of sewage: in fact, I have now noticed that it was Mrs Diana Johnson who did so in her e-mail to the committee. I think that she is from the Blairingone community group. For the record, that is where the point was made, although the issues that relate to it remain the same.
I was interested to hear Susan Deacon's comments. There is a huge issue that needs to be investigated again. We need solutions and I do not know that we are getting them. We perhaps also need to examine whether SEPA is playing a sufficiently proactive role. Solutions could perhaps be found with better guidance from SEPA. SEPA's role in all of this is that it is currently preventing solutions from being found to the problem. I refer specifically to the burning of pellets as fuel under an agreement negotiated between Scottish Water and Scottish Power. That is a huge problem for Scottish Water. Jon Hargreaves, the chief executive of Scottish Water, has raised the specific issue with me. He is wringing his hands as to how to address it. It was SEPA that brought the action.
The key point that Diana Johnson makes in her e-mail—she is right to highlight it—is that when the Public Petitions Committee conducted a major inquiry, it took that role on board. We heard evidence from SEPA and various witnesses.The point that Diana Johnson makes about partially treated sewage and Dr Curnow's recommendation should now be urgently addressed. She states:"Dr Curnow's recommendation is well supported by 16 Professors of Public Health and Soil Science from the National Academy of Science in America".She goes on to state that a report concluded that spreading sewage to land was based on "outdated science".It would be right for the Environment and Rural Development Committee to take the matter on board. It would also be helpful, for our own purposes, if we could get the information that Mike Watson has called for in the meantime.
I was going to suggest that we do that. If we get the petition into the system with the Environment and Rural Development Committee, we can pass on the recommendation that it should take on board the specific points that Mike Watson has raised. If we send the questions to the specific bodies, we will be able to send on the responses to the Environment and Rural Development Committee when they come back, but consideration of the petition will be in that committee's system. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 16 Mar 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 16 March 2005 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 79
- New Petitions Petitions · 26
- New Petitions Petitions · 7
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 84
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Proposed Petition Petitions · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.