Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Gulf War Syndrome (PE709)

Wednesday 8 December 2004 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 44 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

44 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The next petition is PE709, from Alexander Izett, and calls on the Parliament to initiate an inquiry into the health aspects of and other devolved issues related to Gulf war syndrome.At its meeting on 15 September 2004, the committee considered a response from the Minister for Health and Community Care, together with an appended report entitled "The UK Government's Policy on Gulf Veterans' Illnesses: Response by Ministry of Defence". The committee noted that the UK Government's response stated:"There is scientific evidence that some Gulf veterans report a large number of multisystem, multi-organ, non-specific, medically unexplained symptoms as well as recognised medical conditions.

However, the overwhelming consensus of the scientific and medical community is that Gulf veterans' ill-health cannot be characterised as a discrete ‘Gulf War Syndrome' because the multiplicity of symptoms they report are not the same in every case and such symptoms/illnesses are common in military personnel who did not serve in the Gulf."The committee noted that the response does not examine whether the symptoms were caused by the cocktail of drugs that was used and requested that the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Defence, the minister for veterans, comment on the matter.The committee requested the petitioner's views on the minister's response:"I have made clear that Gulf veterans' illnesses is an issue that I and the UK Government take very seriously and, as one which has always been a Ministry of Defence responsibility, I can see … no merit in the committee pursuing this matter any further."In response to the Minister for Health and Community Care's letter, the petitioner states:"I am delighted that the Minister has responded in such a positive way and I sincerely hope that he will indeed look into any shortcomings regarding the NHS treatment offered to veterans in Scotland."He also states:"I fear that we will never receive a detailed explanation from the MoD as to what exactly was contained within these somewhat controversial inoculations."Do members have views on the matter?

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

For the record, I find the response from Ivor Caplin MP a little bit cheeky and irritating. He needs a wee Public Petitions Committee smack on the wrist. He says that he expressed to Jack McConnell"serious reservations about the Public Petitions Committee's ability to address a ‘non-devolved' Defence related issue."The issue was brought here in good faith by an individual and I do not like the cheeky tone of Ivor Caplin's letter. He says that Alexander Izett contacted him but I know that Alexander has had little or no response or explanation from the minister. I want to put it on the record that he is not being appropriate, either in his letter or to Alexander Izett.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I share Rosie Kane's views regarding the minister. He describes the issue as a"‘non-devolved' Defence related issue"but it is a health issue and, obviously, health is devolved to the Scottish Parliament. I can see merit in the committee pursuing the matter, even if he cannot. That is just a comment on the letters that we received from a minister at Westminster, which show how much he thinks of the Scottish Parliament. I hope we can prove him wrong.Mr Izett mentions in his letter of 30 November that he wanted to submit to the committee"further evidence of no fewer than a few hundred pages"but he was told that he could not do that and that he should summarise it. He says that that information would help us in our deliberations. I would like to see that information, because this is an important issue. Although the petition is signed by one man, the issue affects others and many MSPs have had letters from and contact with other sufferers. We should examine this serious issue, so I would like the petition to continue until we have seen the additional information.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I was not going to rise to the bait, but I will. I have a problem when we start to get slightly stroppy about Westminster ministers who say, "Actually, this matter is reserved to Westminster" when the issue is indeed reserved. I would have a problem if Westminster ministers, or for that matter MPs, started to consider and comment on devolved issues. We need to understand what we are responsible for and take action on it. The petition is about the health service and treatment within it, which is something that we are responsible for and should therefore comment on. I do not associate myself in any way with the remarks that were made by my two colleagues about the minister for veterans' response.I am pleased with the Minister for Health and Community Care's response because, as the petitioner acknowledges, it is positive. He makes a commitment to address any of the shortcomings that have been identified. I do not see how much further we can go, so I recommend that we close the petition.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I have nothing to add to what Jackie Baillie said. I agree with her and I support her suggestion that we close the petition.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

I too recommend that we close the petition, but nonetheless I believe that the issue is not being adequately addressed. I was interested to hear Jackie Baillie's point that English MPs at Westminster should not comment on Scottish matters. I trust that she will take that up with her colleagues Robin Cook and George Foulkes.I do not think that there is much more that we can do as this is a Westminster issue. I concur with Jackie Baillie in that regard.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I do not wish to be adversarial, but I will be. The fact is that a huge amount of work has been done on the issue. A constituent came to me about it early in my time as a parliamentarian and I found that a huge amount of work has been done in the House of Lords, the House of Commons, in America and throughout the world on the global issue of Gulf war syndrome. Massive efforts are being made by scientists, doctors and politicians to address it. Perhaps John Scott's point is that such work is not being done by the Scottish Parliament but, as Jackie Baillie said, there are reasons for that. A huge amount of work is being done—I have an enormous file on the issue in my office. It is unfair to say that people throughout the UK have not been interested. We are committed to supporting our troops.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

In the interest of letting the committee get on, I will let you have the last word.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

It will not be the last word, because Campbell Martin wants to come in.

Campbell Martin Ind West of Scotland
link

There is an easy way to sort out any problems between Scotland and Westminster and it is called independence. If we had independence, we would have a normal Parliament with real powers. I would prefer us not to close the petition yet because the petitioner's response raises a pertinent question on health, over which this very limited Parliament does have powers. He says:"I fear that we will never receive a detailed explanation from the MoD as to what exactly was contained within these somewhat controversial inoculations."If our health service is to deal adequately with the health issues, surely we must know what was in those inoculations. Perhaps the slightly arrogant and unhelpful minister for veterans could provide a detailed explanation. He is the relevant minister in the MOD, so perhaps he could provide a detailed explanation of what went into the inoculations.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I do not think that there is a real issue in the committee. We recognised at the outset which matters are reserved and what the point of the petition is, and we took up only the health issue, which is a devolved matter. The views of the minister for veterans are his and he is entitled to them. If we believe that information can be gathered from Westminster that will help us in our deliberations, we will pursue it. I am not perplexed about the minister's views on our ability to write to Westminster on reserved matters. We will continue to do that as and when we see fit. That is not the point of the petition.As Campbell Martin and others said, the petition is about what the Scottish health service is doing to address the health of Gulf war veterans. On that, the petitioner said that he welcomes the positive response from the Minister for Health and Community Care. If we focus on that, I do not think that there is any disagreement. We can ignore or take seriously the letter from the minister for veterans as we see fit, but it has no bearing whatsoever on our deliberations on the petition. If we can agree that the petitioner is satisfied with the positive response from our Minister for Health and Community Care on the health issues, we can close the petition.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

What about Campbell Martin's point? How can the health service deal with an unknown—

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

It will still have to get that information from the Ministry of Defence, but that matter will continue regardless of whether we take a view on it. The information will come from the MOD at the behest of the health service. The Minister for Health and Community Care outlined what he is doing in respect of the health service and the petitioner said that he thought that that was a positive response. The MOD situation will take its course. As the minister said, Gulf war syndrome is a serious matter that the MOD is looking into. We have no influence over that. If we agree that Westminster will take care of its business and we will take care of ours, we can close the petition.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I concur with everything that was said about health, but I would like to see the further evidence that the petitioner mentions in his letter of 30 November. He was told that it was far too big for the Public Petitions Committee to look at.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

If you want to read the report, you can write to the petitioner and ask for a copy. I do not think that receipt of a 100-page document on medical evidence will help the committee to deliberate on the petition. If Sandra White is interested in the technical details, that is fine; she is entitled to write to Mr Izett and ask for the information. I do not think that the committee would benefit from having the report.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I raised the point because I thought that it would benefit the committee to receive the report.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I do not see how it could benefit the committee. We are not investigating Gulf war syndrome; we are considering how the Scottish health service deals with Gulf war veterans. That is what Mr Izett asked us about and that aspect of the petition has been addressed. If you want to know more about Gulf war syndrome, you should take the matter up with the petitioner.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I still put forward my original suggestion, that we should continue consideration of the petition until we have seen the report.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

You can push the matter to a vote, but you are dividing the committee and there is no reason to do so. If you want to see the document, you can write to Mr Izett and ask for a copy. I would rather that you did not divide the committee on the matter.

Campbell Martin Ind West of Scotland
link

There remains a question about what went into the inoculations. The convener says that Westminster will deal with the matter, but we cannot conclude consideration of the petition while that question is still out there. Surely the committee could ask the Minister for Health and Community Care to ask his Westminster colleagues—if that is the appropriate procedure—about what went into the inoculations, so that the Scottish health service can deal with the situation.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Your suggestion would be a good one if we had not already done what you suggest. We already put that question to the minister and received a response—

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We know that the Minister for Health and Community Care's response was described by Mr Izett as "positive".

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

That is not a matter for the committee.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I do not want to get bogged down in the issue. The petition did not ask the Parliament to consider that matter. We wrote to Westminster to try to get as much information as possible from the Ministry of Defence. The MOD responded in its way, but the Scottish Executive Minister for Health and Community Care said that he has looked into the issue, which he takes very seriously. Given what the petition asked us to do and that the response from the Minister for Health and Community Care satisfied the petitioner, I see no purpose in keeping the petition open so that we can have a dialogue with the MOD.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

That is not what the petition sought. You can take the issue to a vote, but I would rather that there was consensus round the table about the fact that the petition did not ask the Parliament to investigate Gulf war syndrome, because it does not have that authority. It asked that the health service in Scotland tell Gulf war veterans what it is doing to address their concerns. If we accept that fact, we can close the petition. If members want to take the petition down a different route, we will have to divide the committee on the matter.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

My position has nothing to do with the letter from the minister for veterans. He is entitled to say what he has to say; I am entitled to say what I have to say. Mr Izett said that the report contains"ALL available evidence relating to the ill-health of Gulf War veterans".Health is devolved to the Scottish Parliament. The petitioner says that the MM National Gulf Veterans and Families Benevolent Association thinks that the report should be provided to the committee in support of the petition. I am sorry to push the matter to a vote, but we should continue consideration of the petition until we have seen the report.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Sandra White proposes that we continue the petition while we ask that specific question. Do other members want to close the petition?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I move that we should close the petition, but I think that a straight vote on Sandra White's proposal will suffice.The petitioner's response falls into two parts. First, in relation to the response from the Minister for Health and Community Care, the petitioner says:"I am delighted that the Minister has responded in such a positive way".That deals with the health service aspect of the matter. Secondly, the petitioner says:"I fear that we will never receive a detailed explanation from the MoD".That is the point that divides the committee. We have addressed the health matters and the petitioner is happy with that. On that basis, we should take no further action on the petition.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We will vote either to close the petition or to keep it open and ask the MOD about Gulf war syndrome. Does the committee agree about what we are voting on?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

No. My proposal was that we should keep the petition open until we see the report, which Mr Izett said would be helpful in support of the petition. The petition called for"an inquiry into the health aspects"of Gulf war syndrome.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I know what you are saying, but it amounts to the same thing. We are voting either to close the petition or to keep it open.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

Yes, but not for the reasons that you mentioned.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Okay. Campbell Martin made a separate suggestion. If we keep the petition open, we must do so on the basis that two reasons for doing so have been given, one by Sandra White and one by Campbell Martin. If we vote to keep the petition open, we will proceed with it on the basis that members have asked for two things to happen.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The proposal is, that we close the petition. Are we agreed?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

There will be a division.

ForBaillie, Jackie (Dumbarton) (Lab)Eadie, Helen (Dunfermline East) (Lab)McMahon, Michael (Hamilton North and Bellshill) (Lab)Scott, John (Ayr) (Con)Watson, Mike (Glasgow Cathcart) (Lab)AgainstKane, Rosie (Glasgow) (SSP) Martin, Campbell (West of Scotland) (Ind) Munro, John Farquhar (Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD)White, Ms Sandra (Glasgow) (SNP)

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The result of the division is: For 5, Against 4, Abstentions 0. The petition is closed.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 8 December 2004 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 45
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 63
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 38
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 12
  6. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 44
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.