Agenda item 2 is current petitions. Petition PE558, by Pauline Taylor, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to include a bypass for Elgin in the programme for improvement to the A96 as a matter of urgency.At its meeting on 1 October 2003, the committee noted that the minister, during a members' business debate on the matter, did not rule out a bypass as a long-term solution to the volume of traffic in the town. The committee therefore agreed to ask the Executive where such a bypass falls in the strategic roads review. We have received a further update from the Executive, which states:"In relation to the future strategic review of transport projects, which we are committed to begin work on before 2007, I can assure you that we will take account of the desire of Moray Council, and the local community, to see the Elgin Bypass included."We are joined by Margaret Ewing, who has an interest in the matter. I invite her to advise us and give some information.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
A96 Improvements (Elgin Bypass) (PE558)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Margaret Ewing SNP 8
- Michael McMahon Lab 4
- John Scott Con 4
- Sandra White SNP 2
- Jackie Baillie Lab 2
The record
20 contributionsI must say that I have enjoyed being here for the past wee while. It has been interesting. The fact that a bypass has not been ruled out and that the Executive will "take account" of the desire for one does not seem a positive response. After all, in the strategic roads review in 2003 Nicol Stephen made it clear that the Executive's aim is"an accessible Scotland, with a safe, reliable and sustainable transport system."The case for the Elgin bypass is subscribed to by all 26 councillors in Moray, along with commercial and residential interests. It is important for us to have more than just weasel words—I hesitate to use that term, but that is what they sound like to me, because to "take account" of something is not to make a positive decision. I ask the committee to ensure that we get a positive response that says that the bypass will be included in future strategies.
Thank you. Do members have any comments on the information that we have received?
The petition has been open for a long time, as we can see from the amount of times it has been considered; it was lodged in 2002 and it is now 2004. I am not an MSP for the area so I do not know that much about it, but I take on board what Margaret Ewing said about the fact that the bypass is not included in the roads programme. Can we write to the Minister for Transport and ask him to say whether the bypass will be included in the strategic roads review, given that the current response says just that it might be?
I dare say that Margaret Ewing is aware that a transport study has been carried out. Apparently it found that a bypass would not provide any significant benefit to through traffic for the people of Elgin because local traffic is the main cause of the problem. Perhaps she might be able to shed some light on the findings of that survey, but it does rather detract from the strength of the case. She might wish to contradict that, perhaps not unreasonably; it would be helpful to hear her views on it.
A considerable amount of research has been undertaken by various organisations in the area. Our estimate is that there would be a 25 per cent reduction in the amount of major traffic that goes through Elgin. Anyone who has an office in Elgin, such as me, knows that one diverts through all sorts of cul-de-sacs and strange lanes in order to avoid the heavy traffic. Because of the nature of the trunk road between Inverness and Aberdeen, which covers an area that represents a significant part of Scotland's economy, we have a lot of heavy transport. Without the addition of better rail services such as the Orton loop we will continue to face problems. A 25 per cent reduction in the amount of through traffic would be worth while not only in terms of the economy but environmentally. We talk about reducing the environmental impact on the area—
Has the proposed bypass been subject to the Scottish transport appraisal guidance—or STAG—procedure?
Yes. The Babtie Group Ltd undertook an extensive appraisal, which I think was submitted to the Public Petitions Committee and the Executive along with other documents. The evidence is there and it would be wrong for us to turn our back on it, particularly given that it shows that the Elgin bypass is a priority improvement to the main trunk road between the capital of the Highlands and the capital of the north-east of Scotland. We also need to bear it in mind that the Fochabers bypass has been an issue in the Moray area for more than 30 years. People are concerned that the Executive's overall strategy ignores the whole of the A96. I would welcome an assurance from the Executive that the Elgin bypass will be included in any future road strategy—indeed, all and sundry would welcome a clear forward commitment on the issue. I am not making a party-political point; support for the petition is cross party and cross organisation.
link
It is true to say that every MSP could identify a piece of road that causes problems in their part of Scotland. In some cases, however, independent studies have been done, and I want to return to the independent study that was commissioned not by the Executive but by Moray Council. My understanding is exactly the same as John Scott's understanding, which is that the study found that a bypass was not the answer to the congestion problems. The study made a number of recommendations for improvements to the existing road network, which were felt would be better at reducing congestion. The council has said that, instead of pursuing a bypass option in the short term, it will pursue the recommendations for road improvements, and that it is in dialogue with the Executive. Is that not sufficient to deal with, in the intervening period, the congestion problems that we all want to deal with?
Perhaps I should have distributed a map to members of the committee. The most recent proposal was for traffic to be diverted via Wittet Drive and Wards Road on to the trunk road. The proposal was rejected on planning grounds because the demolition of houses was involved. Members can imagine that there was a strong reaction to the idea.Moray Council says that its long-term aim is to have a bypass. Although a little tinkering around the edges might resolve some of the problems, the council continues to support the concept of a bypass. Jackie Baillie and John Scott wrongly interpreted what the council said. It has not reneged on the long-term aim of the people in the area, which is that the Elgin bypass should be included in the Executive's strategy.
link
I do not want to suggest that Moray Council has reneged on that long-term objective. However, we understand that it has taken the study, looked at it and, in the short term, will follow through on some of the study's recommendations for improvements to the existing road network. In that way, the council hopes to resolve at least part of the problem.
Perhaps Margaret Ewing has not seen the Executive papers. There is no reason why she should have done so.
No, I have not seen them.
With the committee's agreement, I think that we should do Margaret Ewing the courtesy of making those papers available to her. That would enable her to take the debate further. Would that be helpful?
What I do not want to see is the Public Petitions Committee dropping the objective of getting the bypass. Members of the committee have received information from the Northern Scot and Moray & Nairn Express on the action that is required, some of which was interesting in terms of pointing out the realities involved. It would be wrong for the committee to say at this stage, "Well, the Executive has given its response and the council has said that it doing things. That is fine; we can leave it alone." I do not want PE558 to be left alone; I want it to be continued. I recommend that, in addition to allowing us to see the papers that have been submitted to the Public Petitions Committee—and probably to the Local Government and Transport Committee—further discussions take place.
In its response, the Scottish Executive says:"we will take account of the desire of Moray Council, and the local community, to see Elgin Bypass included."Quite correctly, Jackie Baillie and John Scott have picked up on the study that was done. In its response, Moray Council"makes clear that a bypass will still be pursued as a long term objective."That suggests that the council has always wanted a bypass. Because the Executive has decided not to include it in the strategic roads review, the council is prepared to take action at the moment to make the road network safe. However, in the long term it is looking for the bypass to be built. That is why it is recommended that we write to the Executive, or the Minister for Transport, to ask whether the bypass will be included in the strategic transport projects review of 2007. That would give the people of Moray and Moray Council more information than the statement that their views will be taken on board. They still do not know whether the project will be included in the review.
We have papers from the Scottish Executive that state that the project will be included in its considerations. John Scott has suggested that we provide Margaret Ewing with the papers that give us that information, as it is obvious that she has not been privy to it. I suspect that the petitioner has not been made aware of it either. Perhaps we should keep the petition open and invite a response from both Margaret Ewing and the petitioner to the information that we have received.
That is very satisfactory.
We can keep the petition open until the petitioner and Margaret Ewing have had a chance to examine the information and to respond to us.
We will certainly respond to the committee and to the Minister for Transport.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Nov 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 10 November 2004 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 66
- New Petitions Petitions · 14
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- New Petitions Petitions · 25
- New Petitions Petitions · 25
- Current Petitions Petitions · 20
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.