The next petition is PE775 by Lois MacDonell on behalf of the Highland Movement Against Water Fluoridation. The petition calls the Parliament to take on the necessary steps to prohibit any artificial fluoridation of the public water supply.At its meetings on 1 October 2003 and 26 November 2003, the committee considered PE649, also by Lois MacDonell on behalf of the Highland Movement Against Water Fluoridation, which called on the Parliament to take the necessary steps to prohibit any artificial fluoridation of the public water supply. The committee agreed at its meeting on 26 November 2003 to take no further action on the petition on the basis of the Scottish Executive's response of 11 November 2003, which said:"Subject to Ministers' decisions, we expect to publish the report of"an analysis of consultation responses"together with a statement of the Executive's future policy, before the end of the year".In response to a parliamentary question that asked on what date the Scottish Executive would publish the conclusions of "Towards Better Oral Health in Children: A Consultation Document on Children's Oral Health in Scotland" and announce its decision on fluoridation of drinking water, and which asked for the reasons for the Executive's position if no such date had been set, the Minister for Health and Community Care, Malcolm Chisholm MSP, said:"The views expressed during the consultation process have been independently analysed and are being carefully considered. The outcome will be announced as soon as our consideration is complete."—Official Report, Written Answers, 26 May 2004; S2W-8282.Concerns over the lack of progress have prompted the petitioners to submit PE775, which is identical to their earlier petition. Do members have any comments?
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Public Water Supply (Fluoridation) (PE775)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Scott Con 5
- Sandra White SNP 3
- Helen Eadie Lab 1
- Rosie Kane SSP 1
- Mike Rumbles LD 1
The record
12 contributionsI honestly thought that Lois MacDonell would speak to the committee today; I talked to her when I entered the room. A similar situation occurred with a petition about a health board and hospital closures, on which petitioners were not allowed to speak because a similar petition had been presented before. The committee took no decision and I remember raising the issue at that time.I plead with the committee to let Ms MacDonell speak, even if that is for just two minutes, to give us an update. If she had submitted a different petition, she would have been allowed to speak, but she has submitted the same petition—a year later and with a different number. It has been a long time, so to refresh people's memories, I request that she be allowed to speak.
I am sorry, but the convener has agreed who will speak and we cannot breach the rules. I am sympathetic to what you say, given that the petitioner is here, but we do not want to set precedents. PE775 is exactly the same as PE649, so we have heard what the petitioner has to say. Her making the same comments would not be of benefit.
I understand what you say. I do not wish to cause an argument—I was accused of doing that the last time that I mentioned the subject. I bow to the wishes of the convener and the clerk.
Thank you.
The Conveners Group has discussed the matter, although we in the committee knew nothing about that.It is a long time since PE649 was submitted and since we received anything from the Executive. I declare an interest, as I am in favour of what the Highland Movement Against Water Fluoridation says, so anything that I say will be in favour of the petition. Members do not want to hear me rambling; I am sure that they would prefer to listen to Lois MacDonell or somebody else. I just ask the committee to send an urgent letter to ask the Executive what is happening. Many people out there are terrified that fluoridation will come along and that fluoride will be slipped into the water without people's knowledge and without a full consultation. It is time to hear from the Executive what is going on.
I agree that we should write to ask the Executive what the outcome of its consultation was, what the timetable is likely to be and when it expects to make an announcement one way or another. We have all received many representations over a long period and it would be good to have a decision on the issue fairly soon. That action would help to progress the issue.
I would like to declare my support for the opposition to water fluoridation in Scotland. I have been involved in the issue for a long time and I agree with the stance taken by the petitioners. It is incredible that something that cannot be dumped anywhere can be dumped in the mouths of the people of Scotland, but that is another story for another day.The lack of progress and the length of time that the consultation has taken make me a tad suspicious when I look at the huge hoo-hah about the consultation on smoking in public places and the massive coverage that it has received. This is clearly a major health issue, regardless of which side of the argument you are on. I am agitated and angry about the length of time that the process has taken. I would like to know why it has taken so long and when the Executive will announce its decision.
We can confidently express that view, not only to the Executive but perhaps also to the minister.
I am also against the fluoridation of water; I think that it would be wrong. My party is against it, but we would have an unwhipped vote on the issue if it came to a vote in the Scottish Parliament.The petition calls for the prohibition of the fluoridation of water, but I think that there is slight confusion. If any legislation comes forward in the Scottish Parliament as a result of the consultation it would surely be to allow fluoridation. I do not think that the Scottish Executive would produce proposals to prohibit fluoridation of water, because it is not currently being fluoridated. If health boards wanted to fluoridate the water they would have to come to the Scottish Parliament to ask Scottish politicians to allow it. There is a subtle difference.
Yes. It is not an existing problem, therefore it does not necessarily need attention, which might explain—not that I am here as an apologist for the Executive—the delay in replying to us or at any rate taking action on the matter. Would the committee be happy if we were to write to the minister directly to chivvy him along? Would that be an adequate response from the committee?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Oct 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 27 October 2004 Petitions · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 38
- New Petitions Petitions · 36
- New Petitions Petitions · 64
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.