Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

NHS Consultant-led Services (Rural Areas) (PE774)

Tuesday 5 October 2004 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 47 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

47 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Petition PE774 is from Sandra Casey on behalf of the Belford action group. The petition calls on the Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to ensure the provision of acute 24-hour-a-day, all-year-round consultant-led services throughout Scotland, including rural communities. John Hutchison is accompanied by Stuart Maclean and Patricia Jordan and they will give a brief statement in support of the petition. I welcome you all to the meeting. You have three minutes, after which we will discuss the petition.

Patricia Jordan
link

Last year, 2,800 people turned out at a public meeting in Fort William because of their fears that 24/7 acute services were going to be withdrawn from the local hospital. They came from all over Lochaber, including the small isles and Knoydart. Those rural areas are not suburbs of the cities—they are the outreaches that are many miles and anything from two to three hours from the nearest town and hospital. Sea journeys are required for some people. Roads can be wet, icy and dangerous in winter and journey times are even longer in summer as a result of the large number of tourists.In the documentation, one woman states that without consultant services in the Belford, we would be living dangerously in the peninsula. She speaks for many people who live and work in the Highlands and Islands. Increased travel time on roads of a poor standard creates stress and is a factor in patients' recovery. Patients should not be miles away from their friends and families—that puts strain on them in their time in hospital and on their pockets. There is growing resentment in remote and rural areas that our right to needs-led service provision is being ignored and there is a feeling that we are being penalised for living in the countryside.

Stuart Maclean
link

I would like to say something about economic effects. The negative impact on the fragile economy of a rural community that the downgrading of hospital facilities causes far outweighs any additional costs that arise from meeting regulations, including the European working time directive. Businesses and potential recruits are not attracted to areas that do not have reasonable hospital facilities. We even have difficulty in retaining general practitioners when they do not have the back-up of an acute hospital. A reduction in such an important element of a community's infrastructure runs contrary to the Government's policy of decentralisation of Government departments and it reduces the effectiveness of economic development funding that is provided to rural areas.We all know that many rural communities depend on tourism. There is high-risk tourism in Scotland. At one end of the scale, young people are pursuing active outdoor pursuits; at the other end, more elderly constituents are demanding health services, too. Hospital services are required out of hours and at weekends.For the reasons that Patricia Jordan has given and because of the economic arguments that I have outlined, rural communities must become directly involved in the on-going work of the national advisory group on service change, which is under the chairmanship of Professor David Kerr. In that regard, I commend the solutions process that has been set up by NHS Highland and NHS Argyll and Clyde, which included representation from all sectors of the community. John Hutchison will now talk about that.

John Hutchison
link

Any downgrading of rural hospitals has implications for bigger hospitals—we have high-quality research to show that. The solutions group has now defined the role of a rural general hospital. The rural general hospital has European Union-compliant rotas and will be able to import patients, export skills or collaborate if that improves the service to the patient. It will also be a training resource for students who may then be able to consider a career as a rural general consultant. Quality standards will be maintained by managed clinical networks and rural general hospitals can develop specialisms in their own right, such as mountain trauma at Belford, which is one of only two hospitals in Scotland that meet all seven of the audit criteria set by the Scottish trauma audit group.NHS Highland believes that the rural general hospital model will have far-reaching implications for rural Scotland. At a press conference on Friday, it asked the royal colleges and the medical schools to lead the change to allow a new health service for rural Scotland. We, too, ask the Scottish Parliament to lead that change. What our small team has been doing is extremely relevant to the rest of the country. There is a different way. Consequently, we ask leave for our team, which will include clinicians, to present to the Health Committee as soon as possible.Is e rud glè chudthromach airson ar dùthcha. Tapadh leibhse. That means, "This is important for our country. Thank you." Thank you for inviting us.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Thank you for the information that you have brought to the committee. Do members have questions for the petitioners?

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Good morning, folks. Although I was not involved in the campaign that was orchestrated by the Lorn and Islands district general hospital in Oban and the Belford hospital, I am aware of the fear in other parts of the Highlands that diminution of the services at the Belford would have a knock-on effect for the small community hospitals around the Highlands. When you conducted your research in the west Highlands, what sort of information did you obtain on that possibility?

Stuart Maclean
link

On what possibility?

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

On the possibility of a reduction in services at the small community hospitals.

Stuart Maclean
link

The Highland Council, Highlands and Islands Enterprise and Highland NHS Board have appointed a group to consider the issue from an economic standpoint. Its preliminary study says that the cost of the hospital staffing and additional ambulances that will be necessary is around £1.52 million. That compares with a figure of under £100,000, which is what the solutions group says will be needed to resolve the problem in Lochaber. I emphasise that the study is at the preliminary stage; we are not expecting the final report for another month. The comparison is between £2 million and £100,000.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

What sort of people were involved in the inquiry group that reached its decision last week? Were they based mainly in the west Highlands or did they come from all over Scotland?

John Hutchison
link

They were based entirely in the west Highlands. They included representatives of the community, the two NHS boards, consultants from each speciality in the respective hospitals, local GPs, the two local authorities and the two health councils. In fact, I have brought 10 copies of the solutions group's report for members of the committee, in one of the appendices to which the membership is detailed.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

You must forgive me, because I have watched the situation develop from a distance and have received the occasional e-mail from Sandra Casey, so I am aware of some of what has been going on in the background.How much of the present situation is down to the willingness and imagination of the consultants that you have at the moment to think creatively and to put the patient at the centre? If you are relying on that, how fragile is the solution that is in place? You referred to Professor David Kerr's advisory group, which is considering the level of service that it is appropriate to deliver locally, regionally and nationally. Do you think that the work of the solutions group will feed directly into that?

Stuart Maclean
link

Absolutely. The concept of a rural general hospital that is spelt out in the group's report addresses what the committee was talking about when it dealt with petition PE772. It specifies what operations and what staffing levels would be required in a rural general hospital in future. We are addressing the Lochaber issue, but we believe that there are national consequences. Your question leads to consideration of the national framework and the royal colleges, which will have to tackle the provision of training for generalists to staff rural general hospitals.

John Hutchison
link

Sandra Casey is very vexed that she cannot be here today, because she is on a pre-planned holiday. The issue is wide—it is about more than the hospital consultants and the GPs who want to create a high standard of service; it is about a range of people who love their community. As well as thinking that it is a super place to live, they want it to be vibrant and healthy and to have a sustained economic future.As Patricia Jordan mentioned, travelling times are at stake, because if we do not have acute services in a hospital such as the Belford, people will have to travel for two or three hours to get to an acute hospital; sometimes that will involve a sea journey. Events such as the mountain bike world championships in 2007 will not come to a rural area if there are no consultant-led acute services. A range of people, including health professionals, the community, the local authority, the local enterprise network and the business community, are interested in that sort of success.

Stuart Maclean
link

To refer back to the committee's consideration of petition PE772, mention was made of cross-border co-operation between NHS boards. The solutions group's report is again at the forefront, in that it calls specifically for collaboration between NHS Argyll and Clyde and NHS Highland on elective daytime operations and for a review of a pilot for cross-cover overnight. This might be the first time that there has been a constructive cross-border situation between health boards.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

It is nice to have the chance to learn a little more about your initiative, which has received a lot of press coverage during the past few days. How would your strategy cope with a scenario in which you were particularly short of consultant radiologists, anaesthetists or venerologists—if that is the right term for the doctors who specialise in veins? How would you overcome the problem of missing pieces in the jigsaw puzzle?

John Hutchison
link

You raise a few questions. In recent years there have been developments in teleradiology that enable radiographers who are based in a rural general hospital to have access to a radiologist through a video link. Such a system has operated for two or three years between the Belford hospital and Raigmore hospital, to make specialist advice available at a distance.The general issue about which specialisms will be available in a hospital will depend on the interests and professional skills of the general surgeons and physicians who work there. Inevitably, although many of us are generalists in our professional lives, we have particular specialisms and interests, which need to be encouraged. For example, a surgeon in the Belford hospital is a specialist in laparoscopic surgery, which is not currently available in Oban. Stuart Maclean talked about making such services available to the north Argyll community. Similarly, in Fort William there is no physician who specialises in respiratory problems, but there is such a specialist in Oban.The unique position of the anaesthetist as the person who would lead the intensive care team emerged from the rural general hospital model that we have been developing. The situation will depend on the extent of the collaboration that develops with the neighbouring hospital in Oban—or between any rural general hospital and its neighbouring hospitals—but we recognise that the anaesthetist will be a key person in leading and managing the way in which the patient is supported. More anaesthetists than consultants from other specialisms will probably be needed.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

In one health board the possibility arose that the vein specialist might not be available for an operation. What would happen in that scenario?

John Hutchison
link

I am not a clinician, as you might know, but I think that your question relates to a planned operation, or what clinicians call elective surgery. In that situation, a person is referred by their GP to a specialist and a decision is taken about where the operation will be performed. If the operation falls within the remit of the activity of the RGH as defined in the strategy, it will take place at the local hospital, but a more specialised operation, whether it involves veins or something else, might be performed at the nearest appropriate hospital. I guess that an approach along those lines would be taken in the scenario that you describe.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I understood that in any health board area a situation might arise in which the fact that a particular consultant was not available could pull the rug out from under the plans for all the other surgery that might be carried out. In the case involving the health board to which I refer, interventions were made to the chief medical officer. I understand that there is a real shortage of vein specialists.

John Hutchison
link

Your question relates in particular to elective surgery, which is why I gave the answer that I did. A key requirement of rural general hospitals is that they should be able to deal with accidents and emergencies of the type that are relevant to the area, whether they relate to sailing, diving or mountaineering. In our community, a person who needed specialist care could go to Inverness, Aberdeen, or Glasgow. In the past, patients have even gone to Newcastle.

Stuart Maclean
link

In rural communities people are used to travelling for elective surgery.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I will raise two points. My first point might seem slightly naive, but I hope that it does not come across that way. In your petition, you mention that the proposed changes could cause"loss of life, detrimental effects on recovery times"and"unnecessary stress".Given that the proposals flow from a decision by a health board whose job is to protect and promote health care, what do you think is its motivation? Why do you think that such proposals have come forward? Presumably, if you know that they might have the effects that you suggest and that they might cause loss of life, the health board must know that as well.

Patricia Jordan
link

That did not come out during the initial research. During the past six months, it has come out strongly, through the solutions group, that the Belford hospital is important in relation to trauma and emergencies. A lot of people who come to our area are involved in outdoor pursuits; at one time the hospital's trauma unit was quoted as the second busiest after the unit at Chamonix. Moreover, we have a busy road and we still travel on the right side—or the wrong side—of the road. We have a huge number of foreign tourists each year who go from single-track roads to ordinary roads and we have a lot of head-on collisions. Our numbers swell in the summer and the accident and emergency unit at the Belford hospital is an integral part of the services that we offer our tourists. It is also an integral part of our community. Some people have to travel for up to two hours to get to the Belford in the first place. I am sure that you are all parents and that you all have elderly parents. There are cases in which people would not have lived if they had not been stabilised at the Belford—we have to recognise that fact. The Belford provides an important service, as the figures show.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I am not denying that. You have done your research to produce your petition and you have used your life experience, particularly from the height of the tourist season. However, if you can reach that conclusion, why do you think that the health board has reached a different conclusion or reached the same conclusion and said, "Tough," which is unlikely? Why has the health board reached a different conclusion from yours? Is it financially driven? What is behind it?

John Hutchison
link

Initially, there was a lack of recognition of the role of accident and emergency services in some hospitals. There was a well-intentioned perception that someone who is involved in an accident that involves trauma can be dealt with by a paramedic and taken to a more senior and specialised hospital within a couple of hours' travelling time. However, the key role of the accident and emergency team in stabilising someone who comes down from a mountain, before they are passed on to the Southern general or Raigmore for further treatment, is now well recognised. I am sure that our clinical colleagues could talk most robustly about that. There was a perception that trauma can be dealt with by paramedic teams, but the big role of accident and emergency teams in stabilisation was not spotted.

Stuart Maclean
link

There has been a steep learning curve for NHS Highland. As we speak, it is debating the solutions group report in depth for the first time. We hope that we will get a decision within the hour and that NHS Highland will accept what the solutions group is saying. It has not made any recommendations until today. It rejected the previous detailed report and formed the solutions group—we expect a result within the hour.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

My second point is not so much a health issue as an economic development issue. In your petition, you talk about the potential effects of the proposed changes, such as difficulty in attracting people to the Lochaber area and the loss of general practitioners and medical staff. It seems to me that those issues would be of great interest to Highlands and Islands Enterprise, given the benefit of tourism and outdoor sports to the area—it is great for Scotland to host the mountain biking championships, which is the only world cup event that we have. Has HIE entered the debate? Has it made a submission to the board on the potential economic effects of the withdrawal of services?

Stuart Maclean
link

It has been closely involved in the solutions group and, with Highland Council, it sponsors the economic review.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

Mike Watson went to where I was going when he talked about your local knowledge and life experience. I take on board what you said about the need for people who are in hospital to stay in contact with their families and to have visitors. That is part of their recovery and their well-being. Is this an issue of democracy, the right to access services and community?

Patricia Jordan
link

Perhaps for the first time, we have been involved in choice, but the issue is not only about choice; it is about a needs-led service. As we have said, everyone in the community was involved in the solutions group. I was involved as the chair of the association of Lochaber community councils, which represents 29 community councils, and I reported back regularly. A lot of issues came out and were discussed in the solutions group. Our work was not so much about discussing the emotive subjects and saying, "We need X," as about getting the information, pulling the data together, having the figures in front of us and being able to give answers.We are in a remote area that relies heavily on incoming young families and on our bringing our own young families back into the area. We often lose our young people when they go off to university or college and we need them to come back to increase our local skills and to keep our economy going. However, they will not come back because of the answers to the two questions that people always ask when they want to bring a young family into an area, one of which is about education and the other of which is about health. If we do not have good health facilities, we are automatically constricting our future economy.

John Hutchison
link

As far as the democratic process is concerned, we were facing serious difficulties that were about to arise from the previous west Highland project, but there is no doubt that 2,800 people turning out in Fort William stopped that process dead and caused a bit of a rethink. That led to the establishment of the solutions group, which has been a harmonious experience, with the council, enterprise network and NHS boards working closely together and striving to find a joint solution. All parties have learned a great deal from that and we have moved forward together.

Stuart Maclean
link

That is why we are calling for direct involvement in the drawing up of the national framework strategy document. I understand that the group that is drawing up the strategy does not include any hands-on rural consultants or members of the community. Such people must become involved.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We are joined by Fergus Ewing and Maureen Macmillan, who have expressed an interest in the petition. Fergus, do you have anything that you want to add or any questions that you wish to ask?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak. As has been mentioned, Highland NHS Board is as we speak considering the work and recommendation of the solutions group. I suspect that it will give that recommendation the thumbs-up rather than the thumbs-down because, were it to be the latter, there would not be 2,800 people meeting in Lochaber; there would be a gathering of clans involving almost everybody in Lochaber.I hope that it is in order to praise the solutions group and the Belford action group—which is known by its acronym TBAG—for the work that they have done, which has been a model for any campaign. It has had the support of all political parties and members of no party, as well as active input from the clinicians, which has proved invaluable as a means of providing the necessary information to justify the proposals. Were Belford hospital to cease to provide consultant-led care round the clock, it would be rather like someone in Edinburgh having to travel to Carlisle for emergency surgery—perhaps that puts it in perspective. No less than 1.1 million visitors pass through the area, many of whom stay in Lochaber, which indicates the huge number of people apart from the local residents who depend on the service.I will raise some points that may pose longer-term challenges in relation to rural hospitals in Scotland. I hope that those general points will be able to be answered by the witnesses and, perhaps, considered by the Health Committee. Members of this committee have raised some of them already. I am particularly concerned about the influence of the royal colleges and their unwillingness to recognise general surgery in rural hospitals as a speciality; the impact and role of NHS Quality Improvement Scotland; recruitment and retention issues; and the importation of elective surgery from one area to another. Do those longer-term issues need to be addressed nationally?I have two further, specific questions. First, what would be the impact on larger hospitals of downgrading consultant-led 24/7 rural general hospitals to cottage hospitals? A far greater number of patients would have to go to Inverness or other cities in Scotland. Secondly, will the witnesses explain managed clinical networks and why they are important to rural general hospitals?

John Hutchison
link

The royal colleges undoubtedly need to be involved in the process. One of the fundamental reasons why we presented the petition was to encourage the Scottish Parliament to be involved, with the royal colleges, in leading the change. I believe that Highland NHS Board will this morning consider how to become involved in the process.You asked about the effect of the downgrading on larger hospitals. Appendix 5 of the report that I have given to the committee shows the results of a 12-week audit at the Belford hospital, which was carried out professionally by local GPs, surgeons and physicians. They examined every case that came in the door—both planned and emergency admissions—and assessed how each one would have been handled if the hospital had been downgraded to what we call a consultant day hospital, which is one that is open 9 to 5, Monday to Friday. The crucial issue was whether overnight or weekend care would be provided for patients who had undergone a procedure.The net result of the assessment—after we had extrapolated the results to get the figure for a year—was that, under the proposed changes, there would be more than 1,000 extra emergency or planned admissions per year to Raigmore hospital in Inverness. We understand the argument for centralising the specialisms and decentralising generalists, but there is a big issue about the effect on what we might call the city hospitals of the downgrading of rural hospitals. We are not certain that that work load issue has been taken on board properly. The survey was done professionally and the data are in the report that I provided.Managed clinical networks help consultants in rural general hospitals to maintain their skills. They are arrangements whereby a consultant in a smaller hospital is in touch with a team of consultants in two or three tertiary hospitals. The consultants can discuss cases and join one another for operations—consultants from the smaller hospital go to the larger one and vice versa. The networks aim to achieve consistency of standards, keep up skills and allow consultants to learn from experience. Although some might regard rural general hospitals as isolated, they are supported by those networks. The networks exist, but they need to be reinforced and strengthened.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Much has already been said, but I want to congratulate TBAG on bringing the petition to Parliament and on the hard work that it has done in the past months to raise the profile of the Belford hospital and its future. I have been a patient in the Belford hospital in my time—one of my children was born there—so I know it well and I have affection for it. I do not wish it to be downgraded in any way, particularly the accident and emergency service, which is crucial to the life of the area. The service is important economically, because we need to support the outdoor activities that take place in Lochaber.The solutions group has done an excellent job. If NHS Highland ratifies what the solutions group has proposed, how best can it support that and how can the Executive support what the solutions group is proposing? In other words, what support do we need to give you in future to ensure that the recommendations are carried out?

Stuart Maclean
link

One of the key recommendations is obviously the employment of a physician, which I hope NHS Highland can approve today. Reaching further out, we are talking not just about the Belford, but about national considerations. All our reference points have been the Belford and Lochaber, but there is a national issue and that is why we are here today. The two most important aspects of the national debate are the national framework—the major document that will be produced in March—and the royal colleges. We are asking for the rural areas to be involved in the national framework and for the Parliament to lead the royal colleges in the direction of generalist surgeons for rural general hospitals.

John Hutchison
link

I endorse that point. I am glad that Stuart Maclean emphasised the fact that we see this as a national issue. We were greatly encouraged by the debate that was held last Thursday, when the Minister for Health and Community Care said, in response to a question from Jamie Stone MSP, that travelling time would be a factor in future clinical decisions. If the Parliament endorses that principle, that will also be important in conditioning the colleges' thinking.

Patricia Jordan
link

It is important that we start to do something fairly quickly, because staff morale is now very low in remote and rural hospitals. The staff are not sure about their future and we need to be able to do something quickly to ensure that we keep the staff that we have got and that we encourage other clinicians to work in those areas.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The petitioners have specifically asked us to refer the petition to the Health Committee. Perhaps Helen Eadie can tell us whether the Health Committee's inquiry will cover the matters raised in the petition.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I think that some of the issues that have been raised this morning would be relevant to the work of the Health Committee. I hope that the committee will get a copy of the report that the petitioners have brought with them today. I was going to suggest that we might also write to the royal colleges, but the Health Committee will be interviewing witnesses from the royal colleges. A lot of emergency provision is being closed because of the lack of accreditation from the royal colleges, so I am sure that the Health Committee will pick that up.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I think that the royal colleges are probably among the most effective trade unions that I have seen in operation and perhaps some of their members should be challenging them. That aside, I suggest that we also send a copy of the petition to the national advisory group on service change, which is convened by Professor David Kerr, and to the Minister for Health and Community Care, commending the solutions group report as a model that could have wider application.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Do members agree to that course of action?Members indicated agreement.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Thank you for bringing your petition to us this morning.

Stuart Maclean
link

Thank you very much indeed.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 5 October 2004 Petitions · 2
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 35
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 28
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 47
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 24
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.