Our first new petition is from William Perrie. PE726 calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Executive to appoint an independent body with responsibility for the regulation and training of returning officers for local government elections and a complaints procedure to deal with any irregularities concerning those elections.William Perrie is present to give evidence in support of his petition and is accompanied by Councillor Derek Mackay.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Local Government Elections (PE726)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- William Perrie 11
- Michael McMahon Lab 10
- Councillor Mackay 8
- Linda Fabiani SNP 7
- Mike Watson Lab 5
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 4
- Jackie Baillie Lab 3
- John Scott Con 3
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Councillor Derek Mackay Renfrewshire Council 1
The record
54 contributionsGood morning. My petition is based on our experience after the May 2003 election, when it was found that more than half of the marked registers for the Paisley North constituency had been lost. Various inquiries that were carried out revealed, in my opinion, a failure of the returning officer to comply with the recommendations of the Electoral Commission. The deeper I delved into the situation, the more I realised that it was difficult to have those points dealt with without taking legal action, although individuals, and even political parties, cannot always afford that. In any event, not all the actions are criminal, but they reflect on the democratic process that we are so proud of in this country. The fact that those failures have been highlighted has brought the process into disrepute. We have a problem with people turning out to vote as it is, but the inability to bring people to task for those failures demeans the democratic process even more, especially when people are advised that, if they have a problem, their only recourse is legal action.I believe that the Electoral Commission is in an ideal position to take on the tasks of regulating the returning officer and staff, and of dealing with any problems that may arise because of a failure to comply with its recommendations. It obviously does not make recommendations lightly, and those recommendations are put to the Parliament for approval. That is why I believe that the Electoral Commission is an ideal body to regulate independently of everyone. That is one of the few areas in which we do not have an ombudsman to deal with complaints from members of the public.
Thank you very much, Mr Perrie. Mr Mackay, do you have anything that you wish to add?
Yes. The position in Renfrewshire is that many of the elections were never technically concluded. As politicians, you will all be aware that, if there are no marked-up registers, you cannot cross-reference those who have said that they have voted and those who have not voted. Half of the marked-up registers in one parliamentary constituency disappeared, and it could be argued that there is no verification of my being elected as a councillor or of Wendy Alexander's being elected as the MSP for Paisley North. We were concerned that that election was not brought to a proper end.Not only were there failures in practice with regard to the checklist that is provided by the Electoral Commission, but there was a failure in statutory duties. There is no recourse for anyone, other than through the courts. In a democratic system, that excludes the poor and the less well-off. If your argument does not fit into the tight legal framework for what would constitute grounds for rerunning an election, you cannot challenge major issues such as the fact that ballot papers and checklists disappeared, marked-up registers were never there and receipts were never received from the sheriff's office. There is nowhere to take the problem, so we are asking the Parliament to seriously consider regulating returning officers so that our system is transparent from start to finish. The elections in Renfrewshire were never concluded, and it was only because of our scrutiny and vigilance that we discovered the problems. Although the Electoral Commission has made recommendations that the system be reviewed, there is already a rigid checklist of things to do at an election. Those instructions were not followed, but there is nothing that can be done about it. That is the position that we are in.With elections tomorrow, it is clear to us that elections must be transparent and perfectly run if people are to have faith in the democratic system. However, there is still a big question mark in Renfrewshire and people have grievances about that.
Thank you for bringing that information to the committee. I would like to make one technical point. Councillor Mackay referred to the Scottish Parliament election, but we are not technically responsible for anything to do with the Scottish Parliament election. We can address only those issues that relate to local government elections. That is a technical point, but it is one that we must bear in mind.
link
I found your presentation interesting and I have a couple of questions. First, are you looking to substitute the role that the courts have, or are you looking for something in addition to the role that the courts have?
We are looking for something in addition to that role. My point is that not all the action was criminal. People have recourse to the courts if they can prove that there has been a criminal action, but where there is a non-criminal failure of someone to do the duty that they are expected to do, there is no recourse. We expect staff to carry out their duties as laid down, but if they do not carry them out as laid down there is no recourse.
link
Some people would argue that recourse can currently be achieved through the courts. If you are poor and have few resources, you would qualify for legal aid in a case such as you describe. Is that not correct?
In many legal cases, we fall into the trap that the legal system works for people only if they are rich enough or poor enough. The majority of people, who have some income, do not qualify for legal aid.
link
With respect, Councillor Mackay made the point that poor people would not get access to the system, which I was challenging. I understand that the conclusion of an election is not the point at which marked registers appear, but the declaration of the result. Can you comment on that? I understand that the petition is based on a point of clear principle. That being the case, I am concerned that Councillor Mackay does not intend to stand down if he has not been elected, as he seems to be suggesting.
I will happily set a challenge. On the train, we were speaking to Wendy Alexander. If she stands down in Paisley North, I will not hesitate to stand down in the Blythswood ward. With a majority of more than 500 votes, I feel reasonably comfortable, but perhaps it was a dodgy election. If you said to President Bush that events in Florida gave him a mandate in which he could be absolutely confident, some people would be a little surprised.The declaration is the point at which a politician is named as the winner and as the elected member. However, the process does not end until one year after polling, when the ballot papers and marked-up registers are destroyed. It is a legal requirement for those to be available. There is no point in our having laws if we do not stick to them. That is the technical end of the democratic process. The ballot papers and marked-up registers are supposed to be destroyed one year after the election, but that is not what happened in this instance.I return to legal aid. Not only are a number of people excluded from legal aid, but the Scottish Legal Aid Board would be very unsympathetic to taking on a case of this nature. It would be extremely difficult to find a solicitor who is an expert on electoral law and could deal with a case such as this, on an issue that has never before been challenged in Scotland. People are being denied the opportunity to demand the transparency that they deserve. We have a legal requirement that is currently unenforceable.
I was interested to read the background information that you submitted. It seems that the whole process was a disaster. I have two questions. First, was it the first time in your experience that this had happened? Secondly, you say that"Many questions remain unanswered"and that you would have to go to law to discover the answers to them. You mention "various enquiries". What were they, and how far do the recommendations of the Electoral Commission currently go?
What was your first question?
To your knowledge, has this happened before?
This was the first election in which I have been involved—previously, I was excluded from involvement in politics. Before the election, we decided that, regardless of the result, we would check the marked registers afterwards, just for future reference.I turn to the things that went wrong. One point that was highlighted to me was that the Electoral Commission recommends that all these important papers are stored in clear plastic bags, but we were told that the marked registers were left in a room in black plastic bags. The common image of a black plastic bag is that it contains rubbish. No one has been able to explain to me why important papers such as the marked registers were put into black plastic bags.We were also informed that the registers and ballot papers were left on the Friday after the election, without a full check having been carried out. The staff returned on the following Tuesday, but failed to check which items were still there. Had a check been carried out on the Tuesday, there would have been an opportunity to find the items, even if they had been taken to the landfill site. That opportunity was not taken. The marked registers were taken to the sheriff clerk's office and deposited there. No check list was produced of those items. When we went to check the marked registers, no one was sure what was there, because the items were simply dumped at the sheriff clerk's office.
Who instigated the inquiries that were carried out? Did you have to push for inquiries to be made in the first place? What inquiries were made and what were their results?
The first inquiry was made by Renfrewshire Council at the behest of the Scottish National Party group, which asked for an independent inquiry. The council decided that it would get its chief auditor to carry out an inquiry. A difficulty that I have with that is that the auditor is still an employee of the council. A completely independent inquiry would have been of public benefit. There was no one there to do that.I complained to the fiscal, who had a police inquiry carried out. The difficulty is that the police do not really have the expertise to conduct inquiries about a political exercise. That is where things fell down. In my opinion, the body that should be able to carry out such inquiries is the Electoral Commission, because it recommends the various procedures that should be followed. It knows not only what should be done, but why it should be done. The involvement of the Electoral Commission would emphasise the fact that the process was independent of everyone who takes part in the political exercise.
Did the inquiries decide that what happened was just the result of incompetence?
At the end of the day, the blame was put on the town hall's cleaning staff. It was decided that, inadvertently, they threw out the black plastic bags, which were then taken to a landfill site and disposed of.
So it was just one of those things.
I think that that was the expression that was used.
The arguments that you have made this morning are overwhelming. It is incumbent on us all to deal with the issues and to put aside party-political interests. I have a question that follows on from Linda Fabiani's. Has the returning officer accepted that what you have told us in your evidence this morning actually happened in the specific instances to which you refer?
Yes.
Right. Everything that has been said is factual. I suppose that the question is what the course of redress is. I want to clear up what you are looking for in the final paragraph of your submission. It seems to me that, even if you were able to pursue the matter through the courts, the law as it stands would not allow you to cry foul on the election, unless there was evidence of criminal activity. At the moment, there is nothing that would give you a basis for requesting that the election be rerun. You ask that "an organisation … be charged with the duty to oversee the running of all elections and where necessary invoke procedure to rectify malpractice".Do you envisage that that would include calling foul on an election and rerunning it? What sort of procedure and timescale do you envisage for that?
We spent many hours and days on what is an extremely technical debate. I will focus purely on the local government elections. The courts would continue to have overall responsibility in cases in which the rerun of elections was being sought. In conjunction with the police, the courts would also be best placed to deal with cases in which there were any suspicions of electoral fraud, which is an extremely serious matter. However, the Electoral Commission should be able to investigate cases in which, although it would not necessarily be possible to prove that there had been fraud or wrongdoing, it would be possible to prove that there had been incompetence that called into question the outcome of the election.There is also the issue of responsibility. At every election, the responsibility rests with the returning officer. Our returning officer took very little responsibility, even though, ultimately, he must do so. Blame was put on the cleaners and they were frightened of losing their jobs. A bonus is paid to returning officers for the work that they do, and they are invariably the chief executives of councils. Should they not be penalised financially, through performance-related pay, for causing an electoral process to become a shambles? There should be some sort of penalty for people who do not do their job properly; people in the democratic process—electors—who feel aggrieved should have the option of challenging the result of an election in cases in which the records are not correct or have not been kept. The police have a role to play in cases of fraud and the courts have a role to play if there is enough evidence that an election should be rerun. However, the Electoral Commission should have a role to play in deciding whether an election has been run properly and has met all the recommendations. Bill Perrie will cover exactly what he seeks through the petition.
My aim is to ensure that the people who are appointed to run our elections, whether local government or whatever, are competent to do that job and are not simply placed in that position because of their full-time job. Currently, no one has power over such appointments when the returning officer is the chief executive of a local authority. I want the Electoral Commission—I keep referring to that body because it is an independent body that was appointed to make certain recommendations; it would be a small step for it to take on other duties—to be able to assess a returning officer, tell them, if necessary, that they are not up to the required standard for running elections, move them aside, and bring someone else on board. I believe that that approach should apply right down the line to the staff that are used for an election. Returning officers cannot do all the duties themselves. They must appoint various staff. Some blame can be apportioned to a returning officer if something goes wrong. However, at the end of the day, the staff are also in good positions and they also get a bonus to run elections on our behalf. If they cannot do so, they should not be allowed to continue in that job.Timescales are obviously an issue. The law currently requires marked-up registers and ballot papers to be available for a year. If someone can prove within that year that something went seriously wrong with the procedure, the Electoral Commission should be able to set in motion a procedure to allow a rerun of the election. Ultimately, we are trying to gain the public's confidence so that they come out and vote. If people do not have confidence in the system, it will fail. We can give confidence only by showing the public that we work to the highest possible standards. If the people who are entrusted to do such work cannot do it, let us have a procedure to move them aside.
I would not agree with you on performance-related pay, but perhaps chief executives are paid too much. I might agree with that. Obviously, there is a question of accountability and I share your concerns about that. It is abhorrent that cleaners end up getting the blame for something that we would imagine the returning officer, who is the chief executive of a council and on a salary of £100,000 a year or thereabouts, is accountable. It is disgraceful that he can publicly blame low-paid staff.On recommendations, we should move to get the Executive's views, come back to the petition and take it seriously.
I will take that on board, Carolyn.
I preface my remarks by asking whether the contested votes affected the outcome of the election for an individual ward within the council or for overall control of the council. My knowledge of Renfrewshire politics is limited.
I lost the seat that I contested by five votes; another seat was lost by 10 votes; another was lost by 14 votes; another was lost by 23 votes; and I think that another was lost by 63 votes, give or take one or two. The figures are on the record. Therefore, in that election, five seats were lost by fewer than 100 votes, which I think anyone would agree is a tight margin. For the vote to be as tight as that without there being confidence that everything was done properly raises doubts in the public's mind. That is the biggest concern.
Has that situation or anything similar happened previously in Renfrewshire Council?
We could not check the marked-up registers. We do not think that that has happened previously, but we do not know. We discussed the matter with colleagues around the country and it appears that one or two marked-up registers have disappeared in other authorities, but there has been nothing on the scale of what happened in Renfrewshire.
That was going to be my next question. Are you aware of this happening in any other part of Scotland?
Yes, it has happened in other counties across Scotland, but it is most concentrated in Renfrewshire, where more than half of the marked-up registers have disappeared.
That is important, convener. Obviously, we cannot get involved in the specific case, although the information that we have had today is quite worrying, particularly the issue of the black bin bags versus the clear bin bags. If there is a duty on returning officers, then there has been a clear failure of that duty. To try to blame cleaners for putting bags out really misses the point. Cleaners would probably be blamed if they did not put black bin bags out.I have concerns about returning officers. I remember the City of Edinburgh Council election in 1999, when votes went missing. I am also concerned about the fact that we do not have a postal vote in Scotland tomorrow, because returning officers claimed that they could not get their act together in time, whereas parts of England were able to have one. There are issues about the role of returning officers and oversight of them which, as you said, does not exist at the moment, apart from the courts.On the basis of what we have heard, there is some substance to the suggestion that there should be greater scrutiny of returning officers. Although I do not want to get involved in the issues that have been raised about Renfrewshire Council, whatever else we do—and we should ask the Electoral Commission and the Executive what they think of the suggestion—we should write to Renfrewshire Council and ask what proposals it has to ensure, at the very least, that the things that happened at the last election do not happen at the next one. At the end of the day, the returning officer—who presumably is the chief executive—will be involved in United Kingdom parliamentary elections and Scottish parliamentary elections, because the same person tends to be involved. They may even be involved tomorrow.
Has any research been done on why local government elections and procedures relating to all the other elections were excluded from the provisions of the Scotland Act 1998? Do you know why that is the case? Perhaps there was a good reason. Perhaps they were not relevant to the act.
The Scottish Parliament regulates local government elections and the Scotland Office regulates all other elections in Scotland, so it is probably down to who is in control, rather than for any other reason. I dare say you can take that up with the Scotland Office.
If local government elections were to be included in terms of the Scotland Act 1998, that might—
If it were concluded that we could have proper monitoring of local government elections, and if good practice were set for those elections, I am sure that that would be replicated for UK and Scottish Parliament elections.
On your elections in Renfrewshire, Mr Perrie said that the results for five seats were all within 100 votes. I presume that there were several recounts, and that people were content with the outcome.
That is correct. In my case there were three recounts. The process of being able to check the marked registers ensures that everyone who has voted is entitled to vote. That is especially relevant nowadays with the rolling electoral register, which is updated monthly, because if someone moves away they may not be entitled to vote. Human nature being what it is, although people are not supposed to do such things, they take opportunities as they arise.
When you are at the count you can scrutinise the ballot papers, but you have no idea what is happening with the marked registers. You do not see them until after the count. That scrutiny comes post-declaration, which is when we discovered that something was seriously wrong.We are not looking for a judgment to be made on Renfrewshire Council. We have discovered that there are serious flaws nationwide, and that is what we want to address. The debacle in 1999 was resolved by the returning officer going, but no such thing happened in Renfrewshire. We are not looking for a judgment, we are looking for a national framework and a system to ensure that elections are fair, proper and transparent.
On the basis of what the petitioners are looking for, Carolyn Leckie has suggested that we at least take the matter to the Executive. Mike Watson has suggested that we go to the Electoral Commission and Renfrewshire Council. Should the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities be included, so that we have a broad sweep of all those who are involved, since the issue is a general one? Are members happy that we write to all four bodies?
My suggestion was that Renfrewshire Council should be asked to comment on the points that have been raised, because its reply will help us to decide whether to take the matter further.
I do not know the answer, so does anybody else know whether chief executives and returning officers have a professional association to which we could also write?
It is the Society of Local Authority Chief Executives and Senior Managers.
Do members think that that is worth doing?
Why not? They are entitled to say their piece. We can treat it like a trade union.
I do not think that SOLACE is quite that.
I suggest that we write to the Electoral Commission.
It is not always the chief executive who is the returning officer, so we could include the professional association for the legal officers and the head of law and administration—I do not know what that association is called.
It is the Society of Local Authority Lawyers and Administrators.
If we seek views from the Executive, the Electoral Commission, COSLA and SOLACE, and if we ask individual councils to answer specific points in relation to the conduct of their elections and their inquiries, we will get a broad range of answers on which to deliberate. Is everyone happy with that?Members indicated agreement.
I thank the petitioners for bringing the matter forward. We will let you know the outcome.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Jun 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 9 June 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 54
- New Petitions Petitions · 74
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.