Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

State Hospital (PE730)

Wednesday 26 May 2004 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 30 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

30 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Petition PE730 from Patricia Ann Mallaby calls on Parliament to urge the Executive to ensure the closure of Carstairs state hospital. I welcome to the committee Ms Mallaby, who is present to give evidence in support of her petition. You have three minutes in which to make a statement, after which we will ask questions.

Ann Mallaby
link

I had requested the presence of Mr McCardle, who is being held unlawfully in Carstairs state hospital, to answer any questions that members may have about the hospital. As Margaret Curran MSP said on "Newsnight" last week, particular attention should be paid to people who have first-hand experience. Today's meeting presented a good opportunity to hear from someone with first-hand experience of Carstairs.I have observed Mr McCardle in court. He is intelligent, observant and articulate, although he is under the constant threat of forcible injection.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I am sorry to interrupt you, Ms Mallaby, but I think that the clerks advised you that we cannot consider the circumstances of one case. Please focus on the petition and the general issue that it raises. We cannot hear allegations along the lines of those that you are making about an individual case. We must know the purpose of the petition and why the general issue should be addressed.

Ann Mallaby
link

I was pointing out that Mr McCardle had a valuable contribution to make to any debate on the use or misuse of mental hospitals and of Carstairs in particular. Mr McCardle, the patients advocacy service and I made every effort to obtain his attendance today, but I was informed that parliamentary adviser Dr McDonald did not wish Mr McCardle to attend. That is all that I have to say on the matter.Members of the public have the serious concern that whistleblowers and victims of organised crime such as Mr McCardle are being silenced in our mental hospitals to protect some individuals. It is significant that the Home Office has not ordered a public inquiry into that. As for the alternative to Carstairs hospital, mental institutions and psychiatry in general, I refer the committee to the extensive research that the Citizens Commission on Human Rights is undertaking. Its findings are that psychiatry is an abuse of human rights, that the current regime should be abolished and that proven alternatives are available. I suggest that the committee should invite the commission to attend its next meeting to discuss the proposed closure of Carstairs hospital, possible alternatives and the need to repeal mental health laws that allow state psychiatrists to authorise abduction and compulsory treatment of whistleblowers.

Linda Fabiani SNP Central Scotland
link

The convener might tell me that this is not a question that I should ask. Am I right in thinking that you have been to the committee with a petition previously?

Ann Mallaby
link

Yes.

Linda Fabiani SNP Central Scotland
link

Was that petition about women who were being held unlawfully in prisons and who were suffering abuse?

Ann Mallaby
link

No.

Ann Mallaby
link

The petition was about land rights.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

You have given one example of a case. We are not here to examine individual cases, but your suggestion is that such practices are rife in Carstairs hospital. Do you have any other examples?

Ann Mallaby
link

From Carstairs or from other hospitals?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

From Carstairs, because you ask for that hospital to be closed.

Ann Mallaby
link

Personally, I have no more examples.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Later, we will consider another petition that relates to Carstairs. That petition complains about the lack of suitable treatment for people who have mental health problems. It seems to be rather strange that you suggest that Carstairs should be closed when there is a clear need not just for Carstairs, but for the other establishments that might accommodate people who are released from Carstairs before they return to the community. Closing the hospital would be a drastic step, whatever the rights and wrongs of the case that you have brought to us. Are you aware of a country in the world that does not have a state mental hospital or an equivalent establishment?

Ann Mallaby
link

I was pointing out that there are alternatives, which is why I suggest that you ask the Citizens Commission on Human Rights to speak to you.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Are you saying that there are alternatives for people who have been what you term whistleblowers, or for everybody who has mental health problems, has committed offences and who requires to be detained?

Ann Mallaby
link

I mean everybody with mental health problems.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I cannot quite understand that point. People in hospitals such as Carstairs are there for a variety of different reasons. How can one take the blanket approach of closing the hospital and accommodating all those people in different ways? That does not sound feasible.

Ann Mallaby
link

I suggest that the committee examine possible alternatives to Carstairs.

Campbell Martin SNP West of Scotland
link

If the authorities are acting as you suggest they are—seizing people off the streets and incarcerating them—how would the closure of Carstairs sort that out? If the state was doing that, would it not simply put such people elsewhere?

Ann Mallaby
link

I am sorry—will you repeat that?

Campbell Martin SNP West of Scotland
link

If the state or authorities are seizing people off the street and incarcerating them, as you suggest they are, would not it be the case that the state would continue to do that and to put those people elsewhere if Carstairs were closed?

Ann Mallaby
link

Possibly, but if there were an inquiry into Carstairs, it might lead to a review of all mental health hospitals.

Campbell Martin SNP West of Scotland
link

But your petition calls for the closure of Carstairs.

Ann Mallaby
link

Yes—as a start.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Do members have suggestions for what we should do with the petition?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

We do not have any evidence to allow us to pursue the petition further. I do not support taking any further action because we have not been given examples. I am unclear about what the petition seeks—is it the closure of Carstairs state hospital or something much wider? If there are alternatives to Carstairs, they should be brought to the committee rather than our being invited to get somebody else to make suggestions. We should simply note PE730 and take it no further.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

If members have no other views, are we agreed that there is nothing that we can do in relation to the petition?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 26 May 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 3
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 32
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 30
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 38
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 21
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 26
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 16
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.