Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Hospital Closures (Public Consultation) (PE643) Health Service Configuration (Consultation) (PE707)

Wednesday 31 March 2004 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 11 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Petition PE643 relates to public consultation on proposed hospital closures and PE707 relates to consultation on the configuration of health services. Petition PE643 calls on the Scottish Parliament to take the necessary steps to improve public consultation on any proposals to close hospitals for which additional public funding has been provided through fundraising and other donations. Petition PE707 calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to consider a new legal framework for consultation on the configuration of health services that would include advice on the proper use of guidelines and an independent process for the selection of expert advice, particularly where the provision of national services is affected, and to create a process for the establishment of integrated maternal and child health services. On 4 February 2004, the committee considered PE643 and agreed to seek comments on the issues raised in the petition from the Minister for Health and Community Care. The committee expressed particular concerns regarding apparent flaws in consultations on proposed hospital closures by health boards across Scotland, as illustrated by the petitioner in relation to Greater Glasgow NHS Board. The committee took the view that the consultation process employed by all health boards should be more meaningful than it has been and that all submissions to such consultations should be publicly available. The committee also asked whether the Executive plans to introduce guidelines on consultation procedures for health boards as part of the National Health Service Reform (Scotland) Bill. The committee expressed concerns regarding the configuration of maternity services and sought the Executive's views on the apparent lack of strategic planning as regards the location of maternity services in Scotland. At its meeting on 3 March 2004, the committee agreed that, given the similarities between the points raised in PE643 and PE707, we would ask the Executive to address the specific points raised in PE707 as part of the response to PE643. Specifically, the committee requested the Executive's comments on the petitioners' claim that, during the consultation process, Greater Glasgow NHS Board "provided misinformation to the public and misquoted National Guidance documents, including EGAMS and BAPS".The committee also agreed to seek the views of Greater Glasgow NHS Board. The committee has now received responses from the minister and from Greater Glasgow NHS Board and I would like to hear the committee's comments on those responses.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I did not comment on the previous two petitions because I will get a chance to do so when they come before the Health Committee. On petition PE643, I have received a copy of the draft guidelines on consultation that, I believe, have been sent to all MSPs. I think that the consultation period ends at the end of April. As far as consultation is concerned, that is one of the most crucial documents that we have had to deal with in the five years of the Scottish Parliament. We must express our views on the document and urge the wider community to do likewise as the guidelines will set the pattern for the future.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Although petition PE643 says that it is about additional public funding through fundraising, the petitioner's presentation was nothing to do with that. It would therefore be helpful if we could set that issue to one side. I welcome many of the assurances given by the minister. My colleague Pauline McNeill, who sends her apologies for not being here as she is convening another meeting, is of a similar view and would like the petitions to be sent to the Health Committee.However, a number of issues remain unresolved, not the least of which is that, although the EGAMS report is quoted, no evidence has been provided of regional planning and it is not evident that the health board has taken on board a substantial body of opinion. That comes back to the issue of preset agendas. My colleague Pauline McNeill, who has been actively involved in the issue, and I suggest that we should send the petitions to the Health Committee because they fit into wider issues about maternity services that the Parliament needs to address.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

At present, health boards throughout the country appear to take decisions in isolation from elected representatives. Although there is cross-party opposition to the closure of units, health boards ignore elected members' views and proceed. I can speak specifically only for Ayrshire, although I suspect that the same is true in other areas. The issue is almost a constitutional one. Health boards take such action despite unanimous cross-party opposition.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

That point will be taken on board.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

Although Dorothy-Grace Elder's petition relates to fundraising, it also mentions the fact that the Queen Mother's hospital and Yorkhill hospital have a good location. Without fundraising and money from the public, those hospitals would not have Ronald McDonald House and other facilities. Dorothy-Grace Elder argued that, because money from the public is involved, a separate consultation process should be carried out. I do not agree, but I wanted to mention part of the reason why Dorothy-Grace Elder lodged the petition. The public have gladly given millions of pounds, but that money will disappear if the health board swallows up the hospitals. However, I agree with members that we could not have a separate consultation process.I agree with Jackie Baillie about the reply from the minister. The minister's reply is not unwelcome, but I do not see anything positive in it. He says that he will make his decision after 20 April when the health board has made its decision. I hope that we can persuade him to take action either before or after that. I agree also with Jackie Baillie that, although the minister mentions regional planning, the EGAMS report has not been taken on board. As I said to Jamie Stone and George Lyon, the health board seems to be working with the EGAMS report, but there are two reports, which are as good as each other. Both the reports mention that strategic planning and regional planning should take place. However, such planning has not been carried out at all, as can be seen from the number of petitions on hospital closures that we have received over the months.I have several points about Professor Arbuthnott's reply. I submitted written evidence to the health board. He mentions the EGAMS report and he is good enough to mention that two versions of the report were produced. However, the health board did not tell anybody during the consultation process that there were two versions. He goes on to say that both versions have equal weight. The health board's working group said that the EGAMS report was everything, but that is not the public's perception. I question the validity of the documents that were produced on that issue.Professor Arbuthnott admits that there was an error about the British Association of Paediatric Surgeons guidance in the consultation documentation, which we have been saying since that documentation was produced. However, that did not stop the health board producing documents based on the BAPS guidance—I think that 35,000 papers were sent out with what I call misinformation. Professor Arbuthnott has kindly mentioned that there was one error about the BAPS guidance. That might have been minor to the health board, but it certainly was not minor to the people who looked at those documents.Professor Arbuthnott mentions that the advisers were part and parcel of the consultation process. One of those advisers, Dr Barker from Sheffield, did not come up to Glasgow to have a look and the advisers who came were in Glasgow for only half an hour. It is unacceptable that the person who had the most input into the health board's decision—Dr Barker—did not even visit the Queen Mother's hospital or the Yorkhill hospital.I shall finish on this final point, because I know that there are other points that people want to raise. The reply mentions the fact that the consultation mentioned the safety of all maternity patients; it also mentioned services at the sick children's hospital. When I gave evidence to the board, Margaret Reid told me that the Queen Mother's hospital was a separate issue from the Yorkhill hospital and that I was not to refer to the Yorkhill hospital again in the same context. She said that the Royal hospital for sick children was a separate issue, yet Professor Arbuthnott's reply to us mentioned the fact that Yorkhill was looked at closely when the decision was taken regarding the Queen Mother's hospital. When I gave evidence to the working party, however, I was told in no uncertain terms not to raise Yorkhill because it had nothing at all to do with the issue—I was even told not even to call the hospital Yorkhill, but to call it the Royal hospital for sick children. I find all those contradictory facts in Professor Arbuthnott's reply not puzzling or surprising but quite disgraceful. I certainly know for a fact that half of the stuff that he has sent back to us is still blatantly wrong. I shall obviously wait to see what the committee has to say regarding a recommendation to do with all the health services. I am glad that we have the replies back, but I am still not satisfied with them.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

It is quite clear that all four petitions raise concerns. It was mooted earlier that we should send the petitions to the Health Committee, and I know that Sandra White has said that the issue should be referred back to the Executive. We have now reached a point at which we have gathered together a lot of information about concerns with regard to the reviews and consultations, and I think that it would be useful to pass that information on to the Health Committee and ask it to consider the issue in a wider context.

Carolyn Leckie SSP Central Scotland
link

I agree. Professor Arbuthnott's response illustrates one of the big issues. It states:"There is no evidence that the pre-consultation Working Group failed to take into account the views of current Yorkhill staff". Such assertions are made, but there is no opportunity to examine the basis on which they are made. Even in some of the consultations on secure units, people have had complaints about how they have been carried out, but the criteria and the scoring exercise have been reasonably transparent. The public has had no opportunity to weigh the various submissions that have been made against the conclusions of the health board in relation to maternity services. We have no opportunity to trawl through the evidence that has been submitted and to get the health board's rationale and its explanation why it favoured certain evidence and discounted other evidence. We need to be able to scrutinise that process independently but, at the moment, we do not have the facility to do so. That is the big question that needs to be addressed in the review of consultation. We need to ask exactly what consultation is, and there is no point in having a consultation if all the facts and evidence are in the domain of only a select few.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

That is a valid point. There are specific concerns about all the reviews and consultations as well as concerns about the generalities. Are members happy that we draw out all the main points, send the four petitions— PE718, PE689, PE643 and PE707—to the Health Committee and ask that committee to look at them specifically?Members indicated agreement.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 31 March 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
  2. Items in Private Procedure · 2
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 66
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 45
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 34
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 17
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 22
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  15. Committee Event Committee business · 17

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.