Our next petition is PE602, on the recovery of abandoned private sector properties. Bristow Muldoon MSP has joined us, as he has an interest in the petition. The petitioners call for the Scottish Parliament to take the necessary steps to decentralise to local authorities the previously centralised authority that the Scotland Office held under planning legislation to recover abandoned private sector properties. The previous Public Petitions Committee considered the petition at its meeting on 25 February 2003 and it agreed to seek responses from the Scottish Executive, COSLA and the Greater London Authority. Responses from the Scottish Executive and the GLA have been circulated to members for consideration, but no response has been received from COSLA, despite several reminders.I invite Bristow Muldoon to add his comments.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Abandoned Properties (PE602)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 11
- Linda Fabiani SNP 10
- Bristow Muldoon Lab 8
- Mike Watson Lab 5
- Jackie Baillie Lab 2
- John Scott Con 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 2
The record
42 contributionsI have not seen the responses, so I look forward to hearing members' comments on their contents.The petition was initiated by Dedridge community council, which is in my constituency, but the issue affects several communities in my constituency and I am sure that it affects communities in the areas that other members represent. I am aware of several abandoned properties in the Livingston area that are in a poor state due to fire damage and vandalism. For whatever reason, the private owners choose not to bring them into a state of reasonable repair and the properties drag down otherwise good communities. They can result in structural damage to neighbouring properties and they become a target for vandalism by people who choose to indulge in such activities. I raised the issue with Margaret Curran before the elections last year and I have discussed the matter in detail with the senior housing manager in West Lothian Council. The view of the local authority is that the procedures that are currently in place are extremely time consuming and would result in several years passing before it could repossess a property.The sort of thing that the community council is looking for—which I support—is the local authority having the power to give a form of improvement notice that sets a time limit on a private owner bringing a property up to a reasonable state. If that notice were not complied with, the local authority would have the power to apply to the sheriff court to get approval to move towards compulsory purchase. The local authority would then get an evaluation from an independent evaluator, purchase the property at a fair price, undertake the work to bring the property up to a reasonable state and put it into its pool of rented properties. That is the sort of response that I am looking for from the Executive, to move matters forward. I look forward to hearing the responses from the various bodies.
The relevant point in the Executive's response is: "We do not feel it appropriate for the Scottish Executive to consider removing the requirement for compulsory purchase orders to be confirmed by Scottish Ministers."The Executive also says:"Since May 1999, local authorities have submitted 14 housing related compulsory purchase orders."I do not think that we have received an indication from the Executive that it wants to move along the road that you suggest.
link
I would like some clarification. The problem seems to be the timescale rather than who makes the decision—is that correct? Irrespective of whether the minister has the final say, something being done to streamline the process would allow the kind of regeneration activities that Bristow Muldoon says are needed when private owners abandon their properties. If that is the case, do not the housing improvement task force's work and the proposed private sector housing bill present the kind of legislative opportunity that is being sought to tidy all this up?
I agree with Jackie Baillie that the biggest issue is not who makes the decision, but the years of delay that can pass in the current process. I agree that there would seem to be legislative opportunities to streamline the process. My only concern, based on the convener's report of the Executive's response, is whether the Executive is willing to make such improvements. That would not seem to be forthcoming in the Executive's response.
It is important that ministers have the final say. I am totally in agreement with that; however, I agree with what you are trying to achieve. I am aware of situations in which derelict housing is left and is damaging to the fabric of the area. I am also aware that some local authorities perhaps do not look after their properties as well as they might. The question is who the arbiter is in all this. The decision must go as high as it possibly can, and Scottish ministers should have the final say.
I recognise clearly a number of the points that Bristow Muldoon makes, which chime with my experience in my constituency. In the light of that and of the points that Jackie Baillie made, which I understand and acknowledge, perhaps we could write to the Minister for Communities, asking for the Executive's view on empty homes and about the scale of the problem and the Executive's current policy on the issue. It would be helpful to have that information. I agree that we cannot tolerate properties being left abandoned year upon year with no end to the process. The situation blights communities, as people will not invest in an area and purchasers will not come and buy homes. I very much support the points that Bristow Muldoon has made.
There seems to be a gap between the scale of the problem that Bristow Muldoon reports and the number of applications that the Scottish Executive has received from local authorities. Is there a logjam in the processes at council level, too?
I think that because of the length of time it takes, local authorities do not proceed with the process and they try other means of persuasion to get the property improved. The problem is down to a small number of owners who refuse to upgrade their properties because they may require tens of thousands of pounds to repair the damage. The problem is far greater than is suggested by the figure of 14 properties that the convener identified in the Executive's response. I support Helen Eadie's comments. We should encourage the Executive to identify the scale of the problem by surveying local authorities for their knowledge of the size of the problem, and we should identify whether the Executive intends to streamline the process.In response to John Scott, my experience of abandoned and derelict properties in West Lothian is that none of them is owned by the council. Every single one of the derelict and abandoned properties that I am talking about is privately owned.
It is a matter of degree. Any decision on what blights an area is arbitrary. Sometimes one wants the decision to be taken at the highest level.
As the petition was dealt with by the previous committee, I seek clarification. Are we talking about houses that are owned but which have been dumped and the owners have disappeared, perhaps because they need extensive repairs? Most people who own a property have some form of mortgage, and the properties can be repossessed by the building society or the bank. Are we talking about cases in which that does not happen?
The circumstances vary but I know of a couple of properties that are badly fire damaged, for example. They have gaping holes in their roofs, the windows are boarded up and they require tens of thousands of pounds of repairs. I can only presume that the reason why no one is repossessing them is that they are fully owned.
Were they right-to-buy properties?
Either that or they were inherited from deceased relatives. Those are the circumstances that we are talking about. The fact is that the properties are so badly damaged that it would take a large investment to bring them up to a reasonable state of repair, and whoever owns them has chosen not to make that investment.
Perhaps the folk are not insured.
Absolutely.
A policy that repossesses something that someone owns has to be applied strictly, so I can understand that the Executive would be loth to decentralise the authority to 32 councils. I see that the average time taken to deal with a compulsory purchase application is 34 weeks. What Carolyn Leckie said is valid: councils are reluctant to get the ball rolling. I agree with Helen Eadie's suggestion that we should request information, but it might also be worth getting information on specific cases from West Lothian Council to discover why it has not bothered to address the problem.
I suggest that the committee corresponds directly with West Lothian Council, because it has been trying to pursue a number of properties. I find it disappointing that COSLA has chosen not to respond, given that the committee first dealt with the issue in March last year. It has had a considerable time to respond to the inquiry.
On Linda Fabiani's point in response to Helen Eadie's suggestion, I say that we cannot take up an individual case with a local authority. We do not do that. Bristow Muldoon's point is much more pertinent, because COSLA has not even responded to the petition. We could ask COSLA once again to comment in general terms, because, regardless of how disappointed we might be with the Executive, we have not even had a response from COSLA and the feedback is not complete without one.
COSLA should have details from across the board.
You would think so.
I was just seeking examples to back up what Bristow Muldoon is saying. I know of examples in my community. One home is owned by an American who has simply gone off and abandoned it. There was a big fire and nothing has been done to the house for at least four years. The same owner has abandoned tenement properties, some of which are totally neglected and are falling into a state of full disrepair. That pulls down the surrounding community.
The Parliament debated private sector housing about two weeks ago, because the Executive has received the housing improvement task force's report. It might be worth asking the Executive whether it has borne the issue in mind when formulating legislation on private sector housing, because it might well fit in with that.
I think that Jackie Baillie suggested asking the housing improvement task force about that.
I agree with that and with the suggestion in our briefing paper to seek the views of Shelter and other organisations about the legislative question. I am interested in whether such organisations want the authority to be devolved to local authorities.Like Bristow Muldoon, I am extremely disappointed that COSLA has not responded. We should write to COSLA to express our disappointment and to seek a response. We should also consider writing to every local authority to ask about its experience. I am worried about the gap. I do not understand what is happening in local authorities.
I understand what you say. We would not write to a local authority about a specific case, but there is no harm in writing to all local authorities.
The letter from Ken Livingstone mentions the Empty Homes Agency, which I had not heard of.
We have a similar initiative here.
Does the agency have a Scottish equivalent?
Yes. We have an empty homes initiative.
That is not mentioned in the correspondence. Has Bristow Muldoon contacted that initiative about the case?
The initiative does much work in Fife.
I understand that the empty homes initiative, which the Executive sponsored, has ended. It was a scheme under which the Executive made resources available to allow local authorities to purchase empty properties, which, generally, were transferred to housing association ownership. The problem with the empty homes initiative was that it required a willing seller. If someone was trying to sell a property, the council could buy it. However, I understand that, in several cases, sellers said that they would sell their properties only for the full market value, although £40,000 or £50,000 of repairs was required. Obviously, local authorities felt that that was not a prudent use of public money. If a local authority were to buy a property, it would take into account the level of disrepair.
I have the feeling that a bit of work still has to be done on the petition and that we will have to obtain answers from several places. The Empty Homes Agency might be worth contacting. We will write to COSLA, individual local authorities and the Empty Homes Agency.
I see that the Empty Homes Agency is a charity and is different from the initiative that Bristow Muldoon outlined.
To get a better picture, we still have issues to pursue.
Another issue is the proposed legislation on private sector housing.
We will also ask the housing improvement task force for its views.
The London letter says:"There are nearly 100,000 empty residential properties in London".Does the Executive or COSLA know the number of such properties in Scotland? Perhaps we should not bother with COSLA, as it will say that it does not collect such figures centrally.
Rather than writing to the housing improvement task force, we should ask the Minister for Communities for her views. I seek Jackie Baillie's approval that that is right.
link
The housing improvement task force has ceased its work. The minister needs to take the initiative. The Executive needs to be asked whether it intends to rectify the situation in the promised legislation, which would put it behind the eight ball.
We still need some answers. I thank Bristow Muldoon for his helpful comments.Do members agree with the proposed course of action?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Jan 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 21 January 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 53
- New Petitions Petitions · 23
- New Petitions Petitions · 79
- New Petitions Petitions · 32
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 42
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Mainstreaming Equality Committee business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.