In a slight change to our agenda this morning, the next petition is PE692, which is on traffic commissioners and is in the name of Alec Hayden, on behalf of Trans Consult Co UK. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to investigate the Executive's role in the appointment of the Scottish traffic commissioner and consider whether road freight and passenger transport should be the responsibility of the Scottish Parliament and whether it can debate alleged discrimination against Scottish businesses by traffic commissioners. The principal petitioner, Mr Hayden, is present to give a brief statement. Mr Hayden, you have three minutes and then we will ask questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Traffic Commissioners (PE692)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alec Hayden Trans Consult Co UK 11
- Michael McMahon Lab 7
- Jackie Baillie Lab 6
- Linda Fabiani SNP 3
- John Farquhar Munro LD 3
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 1
The record
31 contributionsThe best way for me to start is to give you the background to how Trans Consult evolved. It was set up to assist smaller vehicle operators, such as farmers, fishermen and small manufacturers who need to run vehicles under the operators' licensing system. We also set up the same system for dangerous goods safety advisers. Three or four years ago, the Scottish traffic commissioner, Michael Betts, sent a directive to all traffic commissioners in England saying that having part-time transport managers was illegal and was not needed or wanted. The commissioners in Scotland and England started a campaign to discriminate against part-time transport managers. They stated clearly in the press and at many public inquiries that a transport manager must be employed and paid directly by the operator. Trans Consult is a management services company that administers the application for the licences and the on-going protection of the licence. If a client of ours is having difficulties, we are able to help them and see them through those difficulties. After writing many letters to all commissioners over the past two years asking for guidance and constructive criticism, we have come up against a brick wall. At the beginning of the year, we started lobbying the Scottish Parliament, Westminster and Brussels and it is fortunate that we have gained good support from different parties. Mrs de Palacio, who is the traffic commissioner for the European Parliament, stated clearly in June or July last year that there was nothing in EU directive 96/26 or in the Goods Vehicle (Licensing of Operators) Act 1995 that states that a transport manager must be employed by the operator. Even so, we continue to face the same problems. I have on my books 20 Scottish transport managers who wish to find work as part-time transport managers, looking after small businesses with one or two vehicles. They would be able to do that for many operators. We have large operators in this country with hundreds and hundreds of vehicles that have one person running them from one remote part of the country.The Dutch courts and the European Commission both confirmed that two operators' licences in Holland were legal and proper. One of the transport managers lived in London and the other lived in Scotland. We are not allowed to put transport managers in place if they are based more than an hour away and every time we offer the services of independent self-employed transport managers, they are turned down or brought to public inquiry. We have administered in excess of 500 operators' licences. Not one of our operators has ever been brought before a public inquiry for disciplinary reasons to do with maintenance of hours and records on tachographs and so on. Every time that operators are called to a public inquiry, it costs the public purse about £7,500. The situation is frivolous and illegal.
Thank you for your evidence. Before members ask questions, I should point out that many of the areas to which Mr Hayden has referred are reserved or specific to his company. However, his petition talks about the Scottish Executive's role in the appointment of the traffic commissioner, which is not a reserved issue. Only those issues that relate specifically to freight are reserved, so it is legitimate for us to discuss the petition.
link
I thank the convener for that clarification, because I wondered what the petition was doing in the Scottish Parliament.I want to pursue the petition's first point, which asks that we investigate the Scottish Executive's role in the appointment of the Scottish traffic commissioner. As I understand it, responsibility for the appointment lies with the Secretary of State for Transport down in Westminster. From our perspective, the Executive simply nominates an official to sit on the interview panel. Why does that not meet with your approval?
The other candidates for the post of Scottish traffic commissioner did not, I believe, have the support of the Scottish Executive. I understand that the current Scottish traffic commissioner has had several roles within the Government, ranging from being a failed electoral candidate through to sitting on an employment tribunal, being a prison complaints commissioner and now being transport commissioner. That is not a personal opinion whatsoever.If this country needs traffic commissioners, they should be fully qualified in transport. They should understand the workings of freight and passenger transport systems. They should understand the difficulties that hauliers, farmers, fishermen and others face on the roads and the difficulties that they have with the licensing systems.The punishments for small businessmen are very harsh. I have seen many operators who, after investing many thousands of pounds, have been messed around for months before a simple licence was put in place.
link
I note that the traffic commissioner is also responsible for passenger transport. Is that right?
Yes. The commissioner is responsible for passenger transport.
link
I just wanted to clarify that the range of the transport commissioner's duties goes much wider than just freight.
Yes, although the commissioner does not deal a lot with passenger transport. He deals mainly with road haulage and goods vehicles.
link
It is also the case that all public appointments, irrespective of which body the appointment is to, are governed by a code of practice that is monitored by independent commissioners for public appointments. There is a huge amount of transparent scrutiny of the process, in which politicians are—quite properly—not involved. Does that give you any comfort?
No. One of the biggest problems with the traffic commissioners' remit is that there is no proper appeals system. In any other walk of life that I know of, people can go through an appeal and adjudication system if they think that a wrong decision has been made. That is not the case for the operators' licensing system, especially in Scotland.I am not a lawyer or an advocate or barrister, but during our eight years of campaigning we have simply represented the damaging situation concerning the remits of the commissioners and of the Transport Tribunal. The Transport Tribunal says that it is part of the court services, but it is not; nor is it part of the Department for Constitutional Affairs. We also have a situation in which we have a Lord Chancellor who is not Lord Chancellor. Instead, we have an elected member who is leader of the Department for Constitutional Affairs who is not a Queen's counsel.If an operator in Scotland wishes to appeal the transport commissioner's decision, he is told to make that appeal through the Scottish Executive and the Secretary of State for Scotland. However, the Secretary of State for Scotland is the person who wears three hats, as he is also Secretary of State for Transport. We feel that there is a conflict of interest involved in that.
link
Like you, I am not a lawyer, an advocate or a barrister, but I wonder whether this might not be a matter that ultimately rests on appeals in the courts.
Operators do not have the ability to go to the courts. If a wrong decision has been made, the only place where they can go is to the Transport Tribunal, which costs around £15,000. If the decision of the commissioner is upheld, the operator will walk away without their licence and livelihood. If it is not upheld, it will still have cost them £15,000 to appeal a decision by someone who is not part of the judiciary.
Earlier, you said that the transport commissioner should be fully qualified in aspects of freight and so on. Is a similar level of expertise required of the other traffic commissioners?You also said that your problem with that appointment was that the Scottish Executive person who sat on the board was not happy with other applicants. Are you saying that the Executive had decided who they wanted in place in Scotland and that there was therefore no point in anyone else applying?
I understand that the present commissioner for Scotland was endorsed by the Executive and that no other applicant was. A colleague of mine applied and was not afforded the same privilege. What was your first question, again?
I might have picked you up wrongly, but I think that you said that the commissioner for Scotland should be a fully qualified and experienced person. Is that the case for the six commissioners in England?
None of the commissioners comes from a transport background apart from the commissioner for the eastern counties, who sits in Cambridge. Some are solicitors—
So the situation in Scotland is no different from that in the rest of the UK.
That is correct.
The petition that you have presented makes some interesting comments, but I wonder whether it is quite up to speed with the current situation. You say that buses are allowed to be overcrowded with children due to the "three for two" policy.
John, that is a different petition. As I pointed out, we have changed the order in which we are dealing with the petitions today. We are dealing with PE692 at the moment.
The suggestion that schoolchildren should at all times be transported—
John, we are dealing with a different petition. We have changed the order in which we are dealing with the petitions. At the moment, we are dealing with PE692. We will deal with the petition on school transport next.
I see. I beg your pardon.
This petition highlights a bizarre effect of the workings of the Scotland Act 1998 in relation to who is responsible for what and so on. You said that the Scottish Executive had a representative on the interview panel and that appeals would be made to the Scottish Executive and the Secretary of State for Scotland. To help me understand the matter better, could you comment further on the lines of accountability and so on? If this is a reserved matter but there is Scottish Executive participation at various levels, to what extent is the process accountable to the Scottish Parliament?
That is one of the conundrums that we uncovered some months ago. In England, appeals are heard at the Transport Tribunal. We have been told in writing by the Transport Tribunal that Scottish hauliers must appeal to the Scottish Executive and the Secretary of State for Scotland. Since devolution, a judge has come from London to Edinburgh to hear appeals—once they are ready to be heard, which is three months down the road—sitting at the Lands Tribunal for Scotland. I understand that the president of the Transport Tribunal cannot sit in Edinburgh, because the matters are devolved. In that case, the Transport Tribunal appeals that have been heard since devolution may possibly have been illegal. The person who has made the decisions has not in fact had the power to make those decisions. That is the problem in Scotland.We have had correspondence from the Court Service, which now maintains that it has absolutely nothing to do with the Transport Tribunal, yet that correspondence was on Transport Tribunal-headed notepaper, from Chancery Lane in London. The Court Service is responsible for the traffic commissioners, yet it now states that it is not responsible for the Transport Tribunal. A new phrase came to our attention only a few days ago: "the tribunal group directorate". I had never heard of that before—that is a new one on me. I have a note here from 5 January, which says that we spoke to Alan Wells of the Court Service's customer services department in London. As the note says, we were advised that the Transport Tribunal is nothing to do with the Court Service. It goes on to say that the Transport Tribunal is administered and controlled by the tribunal group directorate. That begs the question whether the Transport Tribunal at Chancery Lane has powers over Scottish businesses.
If I may, I will try to help to clarify the matter. I have been dealing with an issue of concern relating to the traffic commissioners, which has helped me to identify some areas of concern. Things are clear as far as which areas are devolved and which are reserved: road freight is reserved, and it is as simple as that; passenger transport or public service issues are a matter for the Scottish Executive. My interest in the petition comes under paragraph (c), on the alleged"Traffic Commissioners' discrimination against Scottish businesses". We need to clarify that, and I am concerned about the matter. A constituent of mine—a businessman—was denied a licence by a traffic commissioner. He took the case as far as the Court of Session, which ruled that the traffic commissioner should not have denied him the licence. Rather than then award the licence, as should have been done according to the Court of Session's ruling, the traffic commissioner decided to set up a public inquiry to look into whether the ruling was right or not. The only person who could look into whether the traffic commissioner was acting against that businessperson was the Scottish public services ombudsman, because it was a public services issue. The petition raises issues about a lack of clarity as to who is responsible for these issues, and I think that it has some merit on that basis. However, it is quite clear that Mr Hayden's issue is to do with road freight, for which the lines of responsibility clearly lie with the Department for Transport at Whitehall. The committee should ask the Executive to clarify its responsibilities and to indicate where people can raise concerns about the behaviour of the traffic commissioners. Do members have any comments?
link
I am happy to follow the convener's recommendation.
Okay. Do members agree that we should ask the Executive to clarify those specific points and to respond to the matters that the petitioner raises?Members indicated agreement.
Thank you, Mr Hayden. We will get back to you when we have received an answer from the Executive.
Thank you very much.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Jan 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 7 January 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 87
- New Petitions Petitions · 40
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.