Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

HMP Peterhead (PE667 and PE675)

Wednesday 26 November 2003 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 20 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

20 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We still do not have the petitioner to speak to PE677, so we will go on to PE667 and PE675. We will take them together, because they are fairly closely related. PE667 is about alleged discrimination against convicted sex offenders and PE675 deals with conditions at Her Majesty's Prison Peterhead. Stewart Stevenson has joined us this morning to speak to the petitions. The very nature of the Public Petitions Committee means that some of the petitions that come before us raise media attention. That is fine and we should not complain about it. We should not shy away from issues that become the focus of media attention. That is not the purpose of the committee or of the Parliament. However, I am disappointed that two MSPs, Nicola Sturgeon and Margaret Mitchell, acting in their capacities as their parties' shadow spokespeople for justice, saw fit to respond to press coverage by suggesting what we should do with PE667 and PE675. It is not appropriate for any MSP, regardless of their role in their party, to instruct the Public Petitions Committee on what we should do before we sit down to deliberate the petitions that come before us. It was totally inappropriate for them to go to the media and make the comments that they did. I would not tell any other committee what it should do, whether that be one of the justice committees or the Education Committee. I do not believe that it is right for members of those committees to instruct the Public Petitions Committee on what we should consider and what we should decide in respect of the petitions that come before us. Regardless of the source of petitions, if they are valid, they will be heard by the Public Petitions Committee. We will deliberate on them and make our decisions. Interference from MSPs from outside the committee is not welcome and I will not tolerate it.Petition PE667, which was submitted in the name of Mr R Carruthers, calls on the Scottish Parliament to investigate alleged discrimination against convicted sex offenders who are held at HMP Peterhead. The petition was prompted by the petitioner's own experiences. He is 64 years old and claims that, even though he is medically unfit, he is being denied a transfer to an open or semi-open prison. The reason given is his refusal to undertake the sex offender treatment programme in 2000. He describes conditions at HMP Peterhead as Victorian and lists slopping out, no power or television in the cells, continual cuts to the food budget and no pension for the elderly or disabled. He also argues that it is inappropriate for social workers to conduct risk assessments.Petition PE675, which was submitted by Mr Robert Moffat, calls on the Parliament to investigate the suitability of Peterhead prison for the long-term imprisonment of convicted sex offenders. Again, the petition draws on the petitioner's experience as a prisoner and raises similar concerns about poor conditions at the prison. Mr Moffat also says that prisoners are being refused transfers to other prisons and that they are bullied to undertake prison programmes with threats of the refusal of parole. Mr Moffat further suggests that only 24 of the 300 prisoners at Peterhead are enrolled on the STOP programme. Members might wish to note that Mr Moffat claims in PE675 that he was told that he would be severely dealt with if he approached other prisoners to ask them to sign his petition for the closure of Peterhead prison.In 2002, Her Majesty's chief inspector of prisons reported that the conditions in which some prisoners were being held at Peterhead were among the worst in Scotland. By 2003, the situation had not improved. Indeed, there was an increase in the number of prisoners who double up in cells that are suitable for only one prisoner. Furthermore, due to limited availability, most prisoners are not undertaking the STOP programme. Given that Peterhead is the main prison in Scotland that deals with long-term sex offenders, opportunities for transfers to mainstream prisons in the central belt are limited. Members are reminded that the committee is unable to become involved in the individual cases of the two petitioners. However, their evidence, together with the conclusions of the most recent report by Her Majesty's inspectorate of prisons for Scotland, suggests that there may be a need to consider some of the general issues that are raised in petitions PE667 and PE675. As no member of the committee has any comment to make on the petitions, I invite Stewart Stevenson to speak to them.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

For the avoidance of doubt, I will split my remarks into two parts. I will preface them by saying that, although I have had communication with these prisoners, as I have with many others on many other aspects of the running of the prison, I am not before the committee at their request. My objective in being here today is to inform the committee and supplement what is before you so that you are able to make the decisions that are rightly and properly yours to make.First, the two prisoners make the point that slopping out continues and that there is no power in the cells. They state that the location of the prison discriminates against prisoners from the central belt. They raise the refusal of requests to transfer and the lack of protection for prisoners in the prison. They also make reference to multiple occupancy of the cells. They mention prisoners being blackmailed into taking part in the STOP programme and other programmes—there is a wide range of programmes in the prison. They say that they want to choose the communities into which they are released. They make various comments about social workers, particularly in relation to top-end prisoners who are heading for release. Finally, they express their general concerns about the parole system.I will now move to my observations. The prison was built in 1888—it is certainly a Victorian prison. The physical structure remains sound but, clearly, it does not have the facilities that we would want to have in a prison that is suitable for the 21st century. Like other prisons, Peterhead's role is to protect society from offenders by implementing the sentence of the court. Most critically, however, it is also supposed to reduce the risk of reoffending by prisoners following their release. It is fairly well recognised that Peterhead plays a substantial role in achieving that in relation to sex offenders. Of course, it is a prison within which only long-term sex offenders—those with sentences of more than four years—are incarcerated. The Scottish Prison Service has just commenced a £1 million programme to put power in the cells. That will take a year to achieve. During that year, conditions will worsen in many ways, because cells will have to be taken out of commission and doubling up will therefore increase. It might be that a committee of the Parliament will want to consider that.Until recently, there was no doubling up in the prison. However, there is increasing pressure on the Prison Service in relation to sex offenders. It is worth pointing out that it is believed that, in France, more than half of prisoners have a sex offending element to the offence for which they are incarcerated whereas, in Scotland, the figure is under 10 per cent. However, the number of sexual assaults in Scotland has risen by something like 50 per cent in the past 10 years. The problem is increasing. On matters of fact, one of the petitions makes the point that 95 per cent of prisoners in Peterhead are from the central belt. That is not the case; they are from all over Scotland and the proportion from the central belt is substantially lower than 95 per cent, although it is the majority. Members should consider that many of the sexual offences have been committed against members of the offenders' own families and that families often desire the removal of the offender from the immediate area.Finally, I will deal with the point that is made about my colleague Mr Salmond and an agreement that was achieved with the Prison Service on the discharge of prisoners. Prisoners are returned to the communities from which they came, which means that the community in Peterhead takes back those offenders who come from Peterhead but does not end up with a disproportionate share of such offenders, which might happen if they were all discharged into Peterhead. Wherever the prison is, that measure is an essential part of ensuring that the facility is accepted in the local community. I am clear that the petitions have some merit and I continue to campaign for the building of a new facility in Peterhead as that will be necessary to deliver the facilities that are required for any prison in the long term. The key test, however, is whether Peterhead, in its current state, can deliver public safety through its programmes. It has some difficulties in that regard, but it does extremely well.Incidentally, there is one matter that I have so far failed to address. Given the fact that prisoners are at Peterhead for a very long time, the number of them who are doing programmes at any one point is comparatively low. However, over the period of their sentence, very nearly half the prisoners will do serious programmes to address offending. The two prisoners in question are both from B hall, which contains the prisoners who do not wish to acknowledge their crimes and who therefore do not wish to address their offending behaviour by participating in programmes. I hope that that background information will help the committee in its deliberations. I will be happy to answer any questions that I am capable of answering.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

You seem to be aware of the percentages for where prisoners are from. Could you give us an indication of those?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

I would dearly love to but, unfortunately, I could not locate the relevant bit of paper this morning. I will pass that information to the committee later. A breakdown of where prisoners have come from by local authority area is available.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Would it be accurate to say that the majority of prisoners come from the central belt, but that that majority is not as high as 95 per cent?

John Scott Con Ayr
link

Much of what we have heard is not very relevant. What is absolutely relevant, however, is the terms of the petitions. Despite the dreadful nature of the crimes that the prisoners have committed, the prison conditions, which are essentially medieval, are unacceptable. The petitions address the suggestion in the inspectorate's report that the conditions at Peterhead are among the worst in Scotland, and we should concentrate on that point. I am flabbergasted to learn that there is no electric power and no night sanitation in the cells. We really need to invite the Executive to look into that.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

If I may clarify, there is electric lighting in the cells, but there are no 13 amp sockets to power radios, televisions and so on. However, the Executive and the SPS are undertaking a programme that will deliver that facility within about 12 months from now. That particular provision is in course.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

This is not really a question for Stewart Stevenson, although I would welcome any comments that he has to make in response. The two petitions before us deal with different things. In PE667, Mr Carruthers refers to discrimination against convicted sex offenders. Our briefing on the petition says:"Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Prisons Report (2003) stated that most prisoners are not doing STOP due to the limited availability of the programme."That is different from Mr Carruthers's point. He says that he does not want to do the programme, and I understand that individuals are allowed to opt out. If the programme was introduced because it seemed that it would be beneficial to offenders, I would be concerned about its limited availability, and I think that we should take up that point with the Executive. There is also the question of the coercive nature of programmes. Are prisoners freely able to decide whether to participate in the STOP programme? If they decide not to participate, are they discriminated against as a result? In PE675, Mr Moffat asks for Peterhead prison to be closed, which is rather odd to see. He asks for prisoners to be moved to a new sex offenders unit in the central belt. I recall the campaign that was started when the Executive and the Prison Service announced that they wanted to do that. There was a huge local outcry and, ultimately, the Executive changed course and decided to retain Peterhead. If there was a proposal to build a sex offenders prison in the central belt, there would be even more outrage there than there was in Peterhead at the suggestion that that prison would close. If there is a community that wants to keep a sex offenders prison in that community, that is positive. For that reason alone, the central-belt argument would fall. I do not think that the area that the majority of prisoners come from should be the issue. As Stewart Stevenson said, the prisoners are from all over Scotland, and the important issue is what is done in the prison and the treatment that prisoners are offered there. Perhaps that point ought to be made in response to Mr Moffat. We need to get indications from the Executive of when the sort of changes that Stewart Stevenson mentioned—the provision of power points in cells—will be completed. Stewart Stevenson might have hit on a related issue: what will happen when the cells are being modernised and the prisoners have to double up? That could have implications that should at least be thought about. There is potential for problems there. Peterhead has had trouble with prisoners in the past, although perhaps not in that block. Members will recall demonstrations, rooftop occupations and so on.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I will take that as a recommendation that we write to the Executive and ask those questions.

Linda Fabiani SNP Central Scotland
link

Mike Watson has covered most of what I was going to say, but I emphasise that I am shocked that the availability of the STOP programme is limited, because I was under the general and mistaken impression that, as Peterhead is a centre of excellence for such treatment, the programme was available to all prisoners apart from those who refuse for various reasons to go into it. I want to emphasise that to the Executive and ask for further information on that point.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Is everyone happy with that? Mike Watson has recommended that we write to the Executive asking for a time scale for the improvements.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I will not go over what Linda Fabiani and Mike Watson said—I was going to raise those points as well—but one of the other issues, which I think Mr Moffat raised, was that the prison authorities would deal with him severely if he asked any other prisoner to sign the petition. That issue is separate from what we have already mentioned, but could we ask whether there is any truth in it?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Without any evidence to that effect, it is an allegation, and I wonder how we would be able to obtain any information, whomever we wrote to. I am not against the idea of asking the question, but the committee cannot ask a question about every allegation that comes before it. We were in the same situation a couple of weeks ago when we asked for information about allegations that could not be substantiated, and we must be careful not to set a precedent that, every time someone makes a claim to the committee, we try to find out the substance of the claim. It is for petitioners to prove the substance of their claims before they make them to us.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

It is a worry if it took place, Sandra, but what evidence is there that it happened?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

It is in the petition—it is there in black and white—so would the Prison Service not wish to reply to it?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We could ask for a general comment on the allegation.

Linda Fabiani SNP Central Scotland
link

I was going to suggest that. We could say that the allegation has been made to us and that the committee would be concerned if there was a culture of prisoners not being allowed to petition us—I was going to use the word "freely". No matter where people reside, they have the right to petition the Parliament and should not be stopped, so we should make a general comment in our letter to the Executive.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Is everyone happy with that?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 26 November 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 24
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 11
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 20
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 11
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 10
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  17. Inadmissible Petition Petitions · 13
  18. Convener's Report Procedure · 23

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.