Petition PE626 is by Mr Frank Harvey and concerns self-defence for teenage girls. The petition calls on the Parliament to take the necessary steps to ensure that all teenage girls are taught at secondary school how to defend themselves from attackers and how to swim. It was prompted by the petitioner's concern about the increase in the number of attacks on teenage girls and young women in recent years and by his belief that politicians have a duty to take effective action to protect such groups. He argues that girls in secondary education should be taught how to defend themselves from attackers and how to swim.Members will recall that we considered the petition on 3 September and agreed to write to the Executive. The Executive responded with details of a range of initiatives that aim to support the provision of swimming and physical education for all school pupils. It has said that it will prepare new guidelines for child protection in education that will recommend that all schools include in the curriculum opportunities for children to learn appropriate methods of keeping themselves free from harm. Are members satisfied with that response?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Education (Self-defence and Swimming) (PE626)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 7
- Helen Eadie Lab 4
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 2
- Linda Fabiani SNP 2
- Jackie Baillie Lab 2
- John Scott Con 1
- Sandra White SNP 1
The record
21 contributionsI am not satisfied with that response. I have read the Executive's letter, which clearly covers swimming lesson provision and personal and social development in the curriculum, but does not cover attacks on young people. That point applies not only to young girls, but to young boys. The petitioner talks about a concern that the public throughout Scotland highlight about how young people can protect themselves from violent attack. I would like people to focus a little more on that point. As a consequence, if other committee members agree, perhaps we could write back to ask the Executive to give more thought to that aspect.
I support that suggestion, although I am a wee bit reluctant to give any credence to the notion that the tabloid press sometimes advances that young women are somehow responsible for attacks on themselves and that it is their responsibility to defend themselves. My political emphasis is on the fact that it is society's responsibility to ensure that they are not attacked. The Executive's response does not address the petitioner's questions. The petitioner is really saying that young women have a right to such instruction through education.Whether the response about swimming lesson provision stands up also needs further exploration, because many school swimming pools are having to close and I am not convinced that the alternative arrangements are adequate. That aspect has not been addressed.
The situation is difficult, because we are going into the realm of whether committee members believe that such lessons should be provided in schools, which is not what we are here to decide. We cannot decide whether such physical education—I am talking about self-defence rather than swimming—should be part of mainstream physical education in schools, so we are really talking about whether we should pass the petition on to the relevant committee.I would be worried about the provision of self-defence lessons in schools; it would send a message about crime and violence that would convey the idea that our children are likely to be attacked at any time. There is a big discussion there. We should either keep clearly to what Carolyn Leckie and Helen Eadie have been saying about the matter's not having been addressed by the Executive and pass the petition on elsewhere to be discussed, or we should decide that the petition has been dealt with adequately and that we will take it no further. I am a bit worried about the realms that we are getting into.
link
I did not intend to say anything on the petition, but I have been driven to do so. I am satisfied that the swimming element of the petition has been covered. The matter now rests on whether self-defence has been considered adequately. I concur absolutely with Linda Fabiani's view; simply to suggest self-defence without reference to the wider pressures in society sends out the wrong message, so we need to be careful.I am much more comfortable with the suggestion in paragraph 4 of the Executive response that there are national guidelines for five to 14-year-olds that cover personal and social development. The paragraph mentions the key aspect of personal safety and says that it is up to the education authorities to decide the way in which they implement the proposals. I would prefer to say that the petition has been dealt with and that it is a matter for local authorities, in implementing an agenda such as this, to do what they think is best for their school community. The issues have been dealt with, and I recommend that there be no further action.
Paragraph 6 of the Executive response talks about the active schools working group, which is the global working group throughout Scotland. It says that the working group"was set up in April 2003 to produce a school-policy driven implementation plan which responds to the recommendations made by the Physical Activity Task Force, the Physical Education Review and the Sport 21 strategy and targets."I would be interested to know whether there is any reference to self-defence in those documents or in the work in which those task groups have been involved. I hear what Linda Fabiani is saying about sending out the wrong message to the public about the need to take steps to protect themselves. There is also the view that we already have the police and the military services; in other words that there are other people to protect us. However, the providers of education should take some responsibility for that in schools. It is important that a physical education strategy ensures that that facet—self-defence—is included in teaching practices in schools. We all know that if we shape people at the most impressionable stage of their lives it can help to make a difference. It is not only about expecting other people to consider an individual's welfare and defence; it is also about ensuring that individuals take responsibility for their own welfare and defence. That can happen in tandem with the authorities, which can help individuals to access support.The petitioner has a point. Many people go to karate and judo. My researcher has been to karate; his name is Dan Wynn, but he has a dan in karate. He values how important such skills are for young people and he has promoted those skills among young people. I will dig my heels in a bit about this.
You are more than entitled to do that. We have two different views, and it is clear that we are not going to achieve consensus. That is fine—it is legitimate for members to have different opinions.
We seem to have begun discussing the political merits of the petition rather than whether it has been dealt with. I am trying to be objective. From the facts that are before us, the petition has not been dealt with, but the political debate—on which I have my own views—should happen somewhere else.
I have a deal of sympathy with what Jackie Baillie says and a deal of sympathy with what Carolyn Leckie says. So that a wider debate can take place, should we consider referring the petition to another committee? We cannot have the debate here, because that would not be within our remit. However, the petition should perhaps be referred to the Education Committee or to one of the justice committees.
Perhaps we should send it back to the Executive and ask for more information on the points that have been made.
Yes, it would be good to ask for more information. Paragraph 6 of the Executive's response outlines all the work that is being done, but does not give any more information.
There is one sentence in the Executive's response that sums up the important issue. Paragraph 3 on child protection in education talks about"opportunities for children … to learn appropriate methods of keeping themselves free from harm."If we write to the Executive, can we ask what that means?
The petition is about self-defence lessons for female pupils. We all know that the Executive will not write back to us and say, "Yes, we are going to implement self-defence lessons for female pupils." We have to decide whether such lessons are worth considering. If we think that they are worth considering, or if we do not feel qualified to make a decision, we have no option but to pass the petition on for others to make the decision.
link
I think that the petitioner's main points have been addressed in the Executive's response. They have not been addressed fully in relation to self-defence for young women in schools, but paragraph 4 does address the points. If members disagree with that, that is another issue and there is a mechanism for pursuing it. However, because I feel that the points have been addressed, I propose that we take no further action. I was minded to compromise and say, "Yeah—let's give it to the Education Committee." However, I now want to propose that we take no further action. We should just go to a vote on the matter, convener. It will be fun.
I am happy to do that.
I want to make a counter-proposal, which is that we write back to the Executive and ask it to clarify what it means by "personal safety". We should also refer specifically to paragraph 6 in its response.
Jackie Baillie has made a clear proposal that we should accept that the issue has been dealt with. We will vote on that. If the proposal is defeated, the committee can then consider Helen Eadie's proposal.The question is, that we take no further action on the petition. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForBaillie, Jackie (Dumbarton) (Lab)Fabiani, Linda (Central Scotland) (SNP)Scott, John (Ayr) (Con) Watson, Mike (Glasgow Cathcart) (Lab)AgainstEadie, Helen (Dunfermline East) (Lab)Leckie, Carolyn (Central Scotland) (SSP)White, Ms Sandra (Glasgow) (SNP)AbstentionsMcMahon, Michael (Hamilton North and Bellshill) (Lab)Munro, John Farquhar (Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD)
The result of the division is: For 4, Against 3, Abstentions 2.It is agreed that we take no further action.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Oct 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 29 October 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 75
- New Petitions Petitions · 69
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 20
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 21
- Current Petitions Petitions · 21
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 1
- Anonymous Submission of Petitions Petitions · 12
- Convener's Report Procedure · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.