The next petition is PE445, from the Scottish Peoples Mission, on the Skye bridge. This petition came from Robbie the Pict, who made a presentation in support of it on 25 June 2003. The petition argued that no lawful tolling regime is in place, that any attempt to demand tolls is a criminal offence, and that there is no basis for prosecution of the public. Having listened to the petitioner, the committee agreed not to pursue his concerns on the legal status of the documents in question, on the basis that the courts had ruled that they were valid. However, we agreed to write to the Executive to ask it to provide details of the proposed review of bridge tolls in Scotland, and to ask it how it proposes to approach the issue of negotiations to end the toll regime for the Skye bridge.The Executive has responded, indicating that initial discussions have been held with Skye Bridge Ltd to"outline the proposed review and to explore … options for the future of tolling."It says that "detailed financial information" provided by the company is now being considered.The Executive makes clear its commitment to examining"all the possible options for ending the existing toll regime"and to finding"the best possible solution in terms of both Bridge users and the wider Scottish public."The Executive is also"considering the implications for the other tolled bridges in Scotland."It says that, although it is"too early to speculate about the eventual outcome of the review",these matters are being taken forward"as a priority".
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Tolls (Trunk Roads) (PE445)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 7
- Helen Eadie Lab 3
- John Farquhar Munro LD 2
- Sandra White SNP 2
- Jackie Baillie Lab 2
- Linda Fabiani SNP 1
The record
17 contributionsThe petitioners have made their case over many years and have not succeeded in getting the courts to agree that the documents are not legal. This has been through every court in the land. We have heard the petition previously at the committee and we now have the response from the Executive, which is taking this forward "as a priority". At our previous meeting, we decided that we should leave it to the Executive to take negotiations forward. We should maintain that position.
I hear what John Farquhar Munro says. We have been considering this matter over a number of years and the petitioners have gone to every court in the land to try to get questions over the legitimacy of tolls resolved. We have now passed that stage. When he says that the Executive is considering this, I wonder whether John is suggesting that we should also keep an eye on this petition as it goes through the Executive's process, so that we can learn whether anything comes up regarding costs. You mentioned "detailed financial information", convener. I suggest that we certainly should keep an eye on the petition, although I do not know whether John was suggesting that too. I would like to know what comes out of consideration of the financial information that the company has provided.
We are now hearing different recommendations. One is that we monitor the petition and the other, from John Farquhar Munro, is that we should say that that is that. I am sure that, as the local MSP, John will keep an interest in the matter. It is not that we will not hear about it again. The question is whether the committee should take action.
I support John Farquhar Munro's position. It is always important to pay particular regard to the local member when he or she is involved in something such as this. The committee has undertaken a lot of work on this subject—in the previous session as well as this one—so I think that we should draw a line under it. We should agree with John's recommendation.I come over the Forth road bridge every day so I am glad that the Executive is also committed to considering the implications for other tolled bridges in Scotland. I presume that someone is going to come in and say the Erskine bridge—
link
The Erskine bridge.
We said that in chorus.
link
Indeed.
Interesting effect.
I am content with what John Farquhar Munro proposed. I will support that view.
Do the rest of the committee concur with that view? I know that Sandra White takes a different view of the matter.
No. I was simply seeking clarification of what John Farquhar Munro said.
In case there is another point that needs clarification, I will take Linda Fabiani before I ask John Farquhar Munro to clarify.
What the Executive has come back with is all fine and well, but it does not relate to the basis of PE445, which is concerned with the legal basis of the ability to charge tolls. There is no merit in the committee pretending to maintain an interest in the original petition by asking the Executive to keep us informed about its progress on the abolition of tolling. Rightly or wrongly, our consideration of PE445 has reached a natural end. There is nothing more that we can do. I hope that MSPs such as John Farquhar Munro who represent the local area and other MSPs who deal with transport issues will scrutinise what the Executive does about the tolling regime on the Skye bridge. As the process develops, further information could be released that might relate back to PE445. If so, that could be taken up at the time. There is no merit in our pretending to continue the petition when the Executive response does not reflect the basis of the petition. To do so would only be patronising.
Do you want to make another comment, John?
No. At its previous meeting, the committee made the point that PE445 has been considered fairly extensively by the Scottish Executive, by our parliamentary committees, at Westminster and in the courts. That position has been repeated today. Every time we consider the issue, we end up in a situation in which there is no acceptance of the illegality of the tolling regime. That is the position in which we have found ourselves over the past four or five years. If we were to continue down this road, we would find ourselves in the same position again in three or four years' time. As everybody knows, the partnership agreement contains a commitment to address the issue of tolls on the Skye bridge, and on other bridges. I keep asking the Minister for Transport about the current position. His answer is similar to that which is set out in the Executive response to the petition, which is that a debate is on-going.Nobody will say how much it will cost to buy out the toll regime. Indeed, it would be remiss of the Scottish Executive or the Scottish Parliament to put a definitive figure on it at this stage while negotiations continue to be held. I suggest that we adhere to the position that was stated previously and accept the recommendations that are presented to us today.
Does the committee agree with that position?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Sep 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 17 September 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 16
- New Petitions Petitions · 29
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- New Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 17
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Convener's Report Procedure · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.