Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Organic Waste Disposal (PE327)

Tuesday 11 March 2003 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 219 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

219 contributions · showing 1–200
John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The next agenda item is Dorothy-Grace Elder's report on PE327, which was presented on behalf of the Blairingone and Saline Action Group, on spreading sewage sludge.I congratulate Dorothy-Grace Elder and Dr Curnow on their excellent and useful report, which we will consider page by page. The clerks have raised some matters, which I will mention. If members have any points that they wish to make, they should halt me as I go through the report.There are no points to make on the contents page. Do members want to say anything about paragraphs 1 to 5?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Paragraph 4 mentions transparency, which is one of the main reasons behind the report.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The clerks have asked whether paragraphs 6 and 7, which mention the environmental hazard investigation team are in the right place. There are several references to the team in the report. Would it be better to bring together those references in one section?

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Perhaps we should take that advice. The EHIT report and the Transport and the Environment Committee's report do not tie up—they are entirely separate. The committee report was put together and totally ignored. The EHIT was set up and proceeded with its work oblivious of anything that the committee had said. There could be clarification.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I mentioned the matter at the beginning of the report and referred to it a couple of times to remind people of it. Andy Kerr produced an excellent report for the Transport and the Environment Committee. Points relating to the EHIT are in the conclusions, anyway. There should be some guidance for people reading the report.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

If members agree that Dorothy-Grace Elder, in consultation with the clerks, can redraft the report so that references are brought together and things are tidied up, there will no problem. We should emphasise what Phil Gallie said.Do members have any other comments to make on the page that we are discussing?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It is interesting to see what other countries do. They all seem to act better than we do.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Blairingone has been put on the map.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is suggested that paragraphs 14 and 15, which again deal with the EHIT, should be put together with other material in a coherent passage.Do members want to make any comments on the page that begins with paragraph 18?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The unsatisfactory way in which the matter has been dealt with is outlined. There has been secrecy.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is suggested that everything that is mentioned on the page will be put together in one paragraph.The next page begins with paragraph 18n.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I am scanning through the page, but I cannot find what I am looking for. When I read the report, I was struck by the fact that George Reid's list of individuals went missing. Although the fact is mentioned that the list went to senior figures in the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, who suppressed it, there is no comment on that. I would have thought that SEPA would have wanted to ensure that such information moved on. I am not sure where the matter is covered in the report. I strongly feel that the director of SEPA should be called back to say precisely what happened to the information that he had and why it was not presented.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

You heard the evidence session on 11 February when we practically had to use forceps to get the information out.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are we talking about the page that starts with paragraph 18? Paragraph 18d says:"Mr Reid stated that he had sent the list three times to SEPA and had spoken to Mr William Halcrow of SEPA about it."Is it agreed that we make Phil Gallie's suggestion into an additional recommendation at the end of the report?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We are back on the page that starts with paragraph 18n. Is there anything to say about that page?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It is very disturbing. The issue of odour seems to be missing from our pollution control. Noise is included, but odour is often worse than noise.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Susan Deacon brought that point out very well when she was discussing another petition last week.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Okay. If no one wants to have anything changed on that page, we will move on to the page starting with paragraph 25.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I agree with all the points that Dorothy-Grace Elder has made on the EHIT.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We move on to the next page, which begins with paragraph 31. The clerks have identified paragraph 35 for consideration. There is a reference to the fact that the type of meningitis involved could not be linked to the environment. Can that point be made in the conclusions as well as in paragraph 35? The point is made halfway down paragraph 35, which says that the medical adviser"explained that meningitis of the type which could be linked with the environment had not been involved".It is suggested that that be added to the recommendations because it is quite important.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

That is also linked with the stress that was caused by the powers that be denying information for five years.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is not suggested that we remove the information about meningitis, but we should repeat it.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are we agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are the sections entitled "A village let down" and "New problems ahead" relevant? Could they be summarised? The report is meant to be about the health implications for the community. Although the sections are pertinent, they do not relate directly to health implications.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It looks as if the coal industry has not been very nice to the village and that it made promises that it did not keep. The land was then passed on to Snowie Ltd.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I am concerned about these paragraphs. The petition is about the specific issue of sewage sludge, but the report expands and covers a range of other issues such as British Coal and opencast mining. I know that there are strong feelings about such issues throughout Scotland, but I take exception to their inclusion in this report. It is one thing to investigate opencast coal mining, but it is not appropriate to do that in the context of this report. We should miss out that reference.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am not sure that I go along with that. The clerks are concerned about the length of the report and want to make it as succinct as possible. Such issues can be referred to because they contribute to the villagers' feelings of being let down and to the effects on their well-being and health. It is just a question of summarising the information rather than going into great detail. I am sure that Dorothy-Grace Elder could agree a form of words with the clerks.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The medical adviser was very strong on the issue that Helen Eadie mentioned. He went by the World Health Organisation definition of health, which is not necessarily just the absence of disease. He felt that the village had been under severe stress for many years. Paragraph 40 says:"If ever a village has been raided and pillaged repeatedly, it is Blairingone … Industry has hauled benefits out of it, put nothing back. The Reporter and Medical Adviser found that a boiling sense of injustice is one factor militating a sense of healthy well being among many."Later, when the waste firm came in after all that other activity, it did so against a background of bad feeling. We think that we have produced proof that the locals have had every reason to be highly dissatisfied, stressed and anxious for the past 20 years about the way in which they have been treated by officialdom.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Now that Dorothy-Grace Elder has explained, I see where she is coming from. There is a similar scenario in my community of Westfield, where remediation and repair have never taken place. I understand the point.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Okay, but is it agreed that the information should be summarised to make it more succinct?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Paragraphs 50 to 58 give a personal history of the petitioner and his family background.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I accept that it is horrendous, but should it be in the report?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Perhaps Mr Hope should come before us with his own petition.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is a very sad tale indeed. However, the report is supposed to be about the health implications. Do members think that the personal information should be in the report?

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

It would be a shame to lose it, but I do not know whether it is really hitting the button as far as the remit of the report is concerned. I would hate it to be lost, so is there some way that it could be included as an appendix?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Do members agree to take that information out of the body of the report and add it as an appendix to give background?

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

It is an individual case that shows how, over the generations, a family has been let down. It was very touching to find "Duncan Hope: gunner, died France, age 17"on the war memorial. Today's Duncan Hope has not been treated well by the country that his relatives served.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are we agreed to take that information out of the main body of the report and include it as an appendix?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Paragraphs 64 and 65 refer to Snowie Ltd making"millions out of carcass destruction during the UK foot and mouth outbreak, gaining government contracts"and making contributions to certain individuals in the Labour party. Are those facts or rumours and should they be in the report? Are they relevant?

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

They are facts. I put them to the directors of Snowie Ltd and they answered openly. There were rumours flying around the village of very great numbers. The directors confirmed that there was only one donation of £5,000. They were rather angered at the question and said that they were not really political people but had made the donation because one Labour MP had taken an interest in them.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The company has not given £5,000 to George Reid.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The money was certainly not given to me.However, you have written "one local rumour". We need to be clear about whether it is a fact or a rumour.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

It was being rumoured that Snowie Ltd had made huge donations to the Labour party, so I thought that it was best to put that in the report. It was another point that caused stress in the village and it made people believe that there was something seriously wrong.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

So the rumour was that huge donations were made, but the facts are laid out in paragraph 65.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The facts were pinned down with the directors. They did not expect that question, but they answered it. I admit that it was like the moment in "Pygmalion" where the old dustman asks Professor Higgins for one guinea and Higgins says that he hopes that Doolittle is not implying that there is anything improper between him and his daughter and the dustman says that he would have asked for five guineas if he thought that. I think it would take a bit more than £5,000 to influence a political party.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I suppose that there is a difference between the rumour referred to in paragraph 64 and the reality referred to in paragraph 65. Can you say that paragraph 65 is accurate?

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Yes, and the company can confirm that. The question was asked openly and I felt that it was answered honestly.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Okay. I have just been advised that we should be careful to retain the focus on the effect on health of the spreading of sewage sludge. We are drifting away from that issue. Are members happy for those paragraphs to be left in, or should they be taken out?

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I am unhappy about paragraph 64. Paragraph 65 is okay, as it is factual, but it is not necessary to include paragraph 64, as it is based on rumour, innuendo and hearsay. We operate a justice system that is based on evidence. Unless we can produce evidence to back up paragraph 64, we ought to set it aside. If the directors say that one individual declared that he had made a contribution of £5,000, I am sure that that would have been registered in the appropriate way. The Electoral Commission has laid down that contributions of more than £50 must be declared in every election expense. That is the law of the land. A businessman or a businesswoman can no longer get away with not declaring financial contributions openly.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The directors made it clear that the contribution was not made under another name. Paragraph 64 can be taken out, if members wish. I thought that I should raise the issue of the rumour and get truth on the table. I think that I was being told the truth.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It has been suggested that Dorothy-Grace Elder could co-operate with Steve Farrell on redrafting paragraphs 64 and 65.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

As I understand it, only one £5,000 donation was made. According to paragraph 65, "there had been one" donation of £5,000, but the way that that reads leads one to ask how many more donations there were.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

That should be clarified, to make it quite clear that there was one donation and no more.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Dorothy-Grace Elder can sort out the drafting with Steve Farrell. There are no other points on that page or on the page containing paragraphs 67 to 73.The section entitled "Composting—how safe is the air?" begins with paragraph 81 at the foot of the next page and continues for nearly two pages. It has been suggested that, as the section on composting is lengthy and is not directly relevant to the health impact of the spreading of sewage sludge, it is not necessary to include it. What do members think?

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Composting was mentioned in the original petition. Mr Hope is in the public gallery and I think that he is nodding his head. PE327 referred to the health aspects of composting. Composting now forms the major part of Snowie's business at Blairingone.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am told that PE327 did not look at the health impact of composting but at that of sewage sludge spreading. Are you talking about the remit from the Health and Community Care Committee?

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Although I do not have the original petition in front of me, it has been my understanding all along that PE327 deals with that issue.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

If there is concern that the section on composting waters down the report, why do not we include it as an appendix, as we agreed to do with the section on Mr Hope? The section on composting might be interesting, but it might be better to include it as an appendix, given that the report is on the health implications.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is suggested that we could summarise the section in the main report and include the whole section as an appendix.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I have just received a note from the Blairingone and Saline Action Group that makes a suggestion about another matter, but we are not at that stage yet. I am not sure about your suggestion. If we were to refer to the original petition, we would find that composting was mentioned. I ask that we double check PE327 to find out whether it refers to composting. If it does, I ask that the section on composting remain in the body of the report.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will do that. Dorothy-Grace Elder can liaise with Steve Farrell.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The issue is the distance from habitation. That is where the question mark is.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Dorothy-Grace Elder should liaise with Steve Farrell to double check on the remit. The section on composting will appear in the report in one form or another. I am sure that we can get agreement on that.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Composting is the suspect for the smell. Duncan Hope gave us evidence on that on 11 February, in addition to the original evidence that we received way back.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

There are no points on the pages that begin with paragraphs 74 and 82. On the page that begins with paragraph 88, it has been suggested that, as the discussion of rumours in paragraphs 92(b) and 92(c) is not especially related to sludge spreading, those paragraphs could be taken out. Paragraph 92(b) refers to"Mr Hope allegedly ‘campaigning' against new housing in the village"and paragraph 92(c) refers to Sir Robert Stewart, former Lord Lieutenant of Clackmannanshire. Given that individuals are named under the heading "Rumours", we wonder whether those paragraphs should be kept in the report.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

We might want to include those paragraphs as an appendix, as they contain research that the reporter has carried out. If they appeared in the main body of the report, they might take away from its main thrust, but it would be useful to include them as an appendix.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Paragraph 93 makes an important comment. It says:"The EHIT turned out to be a model of secrecy. The tone was of a number of experts and professionals simply doing things ‘the old way' and handing down a verdict".That might be why all the rumours grew.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

There is no problem with paragraph 93; it is being kept in. It is suggested that paragraphs 92(b) and 92(c) be taken out, because they refer to rumours that were circulating.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

There are strong allegations that the entire campaign centred on a mere handful of people. Most campaigns are run by a handful of people who do all the work. On an icy night—it was one of the worst nights of winter—up to 70 people, or most of the adult ambulant population, attended the meeting that I arranged, even though it was difficult to walk up the path to the church, despite the efforts of local activists to clear it. Some time before that meeting, there was a meeting of about 300 people in Saline. More than just a handful of people are deeply concerned about their health.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Paragraph 92(a) is staying. It is suggested that paragraphs 92(b) and 92(c) could be included in the appendices.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Paragraph 93 mentions the secrecy and the tone of the EHIT. Perhaps we could insert a sentence that said that that led to rumours abounding in the community. We could put in something along those lines, because that is the point that Dorothy-Grace Elder is trying to make.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The EHIT did its investigation on five cases behind closed doors. One paragraph—I do not know which one—indicates that the EHIT did not know of any more cases. It was suggested that people should have written to the secret investigators. How could anyone else have written, when no one but the people who were involved in those five cases knew that an investigation was taking place?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

That was a ridiculous situation. The second meeting of the EHIT did not happen—the EHIT was a scandal from beginning to end.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Do we intend to put all the EHIT bits together?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is suggested that paragraphs 93 to 96 should be included in a section with all the EHIT bits, so that they form a coherent whole.Should the information about Saline—I am sorry that I keep getting the pronunciation wrong—be in the report at all? Although it is interesting, it is not strictly relevant to the report.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

People keep telling me that there used to be packed dances in the hall in my village.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It has been suggested that paragraph 97 could be included, but not paragraphs 98 to 101. Although the information is interesting, it is not directly relevant to the report.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Purely from the health point of view, it is important that, although Saline is only about four miles away, there does not seem to be a problem there.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That is why paragraph 97 should stay.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

It seems that there is no health situation in Saline, as far as Dorothy-Grace Elder is aware.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The village of Saline was included in the name of the Blairingone and Saline Action Group because there had been some complaints from Saline and also because the smaller village of Blairingone wanted to include the much larger village of Saline and its community council in the campaign. People from Saline have been emotionally supportive of the cause, but they have not had the same degree of problems. There have been complaints about smells in Saline, but the same level of nuisance has not been perceived.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

If we develop paragraph 97 to make the point about the contrast between the two communities, we could leave out the detailed points about going to dances and so on.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Blairingone has lost every facility except its lovely church and school. Saline is thriving, however, and I think that it is good that the bigger village is protective of the smaller one and that we do not see the usual jealousy that can exist between villages.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are we all agreed to tidy up that section in the way that has been suggested?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We have some comments on the section headed "Comments and Recommendations".Recommendation 1 reads:"That the Scottish Parliament continues the system of questioning in public any group which has made a contentious public decision in private without any form of public consultation."It is recommended that we accept that recommendation, with a slight change to the wording. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 2 reads:"Never again must any body investigating health meet in private without first intimating they are being set up, publishing their remit, proposed names of membership and ensuring proper and regular consultation with the public and their representatives."Again, it is recommended that we accept that, with the addition of some clear reference to the EHIT process and the existing SEPA guidance and an indication of the need to place more emphasis on the importance of public consultation and to monitor what is done in each case. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 3 reads:"That there is another public meeting in Blairingone where the work of the Medical Adviser and reporter can be discussed and ideas taken forward for the future."Again, it is recommended that we accept that. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 4 reads:"That a form of ‘Blairingone Revitalisation Group' be set up swiftly, composed of all players—local councils, health and social work services, the churches, community councils, Blairingone and Saline Action Group, Local MSPs, local councillors and companies to achieve: A Village Hall, protection of the future of precious remaining assets such as the school and the church, a by pass, a shop, post office, pub or cafe etc. (A new village hall could combine several functions). The Reporter is compiling a list of some bodies which might be helpful on finance."It is recommended that, as that recommendation is not directly related to health impacts, it could be suggested that local authorities act to co-ordinate the proposal, separate from the report.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Locally elected members have a duty in that regard. It is up to them.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

We should also take out the specific recommendations about what is to be done in the village. Decisions about that should be taken by the local group, once it has been set up, rather than by us. The situation could change over time.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Local authorities could consider the report and think about its implications. The Public Petitions Committee has always tried to encourage local authorities rather than tell them what to do.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Do we agree to ask the local authorities to co-ordinate the activity?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 5 reads:"That there should be a reasonable amount of new housing in Blairingone, preferably including some social housing for young families who cannot afford to buy. There is obviously a pressing need to increase population in Blairingone is a village ‘on the cusp'."Again, it is recommended that, as that recommendation is not directly related to health impacts, it should not be included.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

The recommendation should be sent to the revitalisation group as it concerns a matter that it should deal with.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

There is a repeated reference to the need for new housing throughout the report. As a result of our research, the medical adviser and I both came to the conclusion that that was an important issue. When we visited a medical practice, the nurses and health visitors pointed out that the geography of the situation was problematic. The village is on the border of three local authorities and there are always problems with finding out, for example, which social worker was responsible for which part of the area. Blairingone is falling down between various stools. Everybody thought that revitalisation would be helped by the construction of a limited number of new houses and somewhere to meet. It is stressful for a community not to have anywhere to meet—nowhere for the brownies or for young mothers to meet, or for people to get together and have a pint to find out what is happening in their community.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I suggest that that concern would not form part of the core recommendations of the report on the health impact. However, we could suggest that the local authorities co-ordinate a revitalisation group to consider such important issues.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Dorothy-Grace Elder's point is important. The report should highlight the fact that Blairingone is on the boundary of three local authorities as that will have had some impact on the amount of control over the situation that the community has had.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are we agreed to follow the recommended action in regard to this recommendation and to suggest that the revitalisation group consider that important issue?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 6 reads:"That there should be no more open cast mining in the area."It is recommended that that should not be included as it is not relevant to the health impacts and it is for local authorities to consider all such applications on their merits.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I agree. The guidelines have been strengthened enormously in the past few years. I speak as someone who represents an area in which a lot of coal used to be mined. The issue is contentious in my constituency, but I believe that the controls that are in place across Scotland are strict and that we should deliberate this matter at another time.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Dr Curnow also recommends that there be no more opencast mining in the area. He said that the village has had enough of it and that he does not want the villagers to have to put up with the problems of extra dust and the associated stress.In the documents that are before members, they can read that Scottish Coal said that there would be a risk of no more than "cosmetic cracks" appearing on local buildings, although it would be necessary to demolish Mr Hope's farm house. The man has already lost his livelihood.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I think that the recommendation would involve changing the national planning policy guideline 16, which would be a matter for the Scottish Executive.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The committee is divided on this matter. I have a great deal of sympathy with the point that Dorothy-Grace Elder makes about the impact that opencast mining is having on local people. However, the petition is about the health impact of sewage sludge being spread on fields and the recommendation opens up a completely new area. The matter could be referred to the revitalisation group, but that would have to be pursued separately from the report on the petition.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

If we want to include the recommendation in the report to ensure that the message gets across that it is felt that the problems caused by opencast mining far exceed the benefit to the area, we could put it in as an annexe. That way, if someone were to make a planning application in relation to an opencast mine, objectors to such a scheme could use the report in their objection.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That would be reasonable, but the recommendation cannot stand as a core recommendation.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Dr Curnow wanted to be here today, but was unable to make it. He is extremely concerned about the future of the village because of opencast mining. I thank Phil Gallie for his suggestion.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Do we agree to follow the suggested action?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 7 reads:"No reassurance on any health matter should be issued without the full extent of the work on the issue being published in detail."It is suggested that the recommendation ought instead to refer to "reassurance in relation to any publicly expressed concerns about sewage sludge spreading or similar practice." Do we agree to use those words instead?

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I meant that recommendation to be wider. We do not know if the same thing has happened before or if it will happen again. Should the public be reassured without knowing that precious little work has gone into that reassurance? People will not simply accept the word of the great and the good nowadays—at least they should not accept it unless they know how much work has been put in.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I accept those points, but the context of our report is an inquiry into a particular problem and how that impacts on health. We have not considered "any health matter"; we have considered a specific health matter relating to a specific practice. All we are doing is rewording the report with that in mind. The point stays in, but we must reword the text so that it refers to what we are looking into rather than a general recommendation.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

We could include, "for example, sewage sludge spreading", rather than confine the wording to that issue alone.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The objection is to the phrase "any health matter", because we have not taken evidence on "any health matter". Therefore, we cannot use the phrase. We must restrict the wording to what we are dealing with. Is the proposal agreed to?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 8 reads:"That the Scottish Parliament and local councillors continue a watching brief over Blairingone."Should any monitoring role be conducted by local authorities and responsible public bodies, rather than by the Parliament?

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I am sorry, but I would like to go back to recommendation 7. We should consider an issue that was raised with me by the chairman of SEPA: when a planning application is considered, no health impact assessment is considered by the relevant planning committee prior to the application being approved. That matter should be picked up. In many of the planning applications that I come across, I find potential health concerns that have been raised by local people. The chairman of SEPA told me that SEPA has to run with the issues following the approval of the planning application, which presents a problem. We should perhaps make some recommendation that addresses that issue and that states that health impact assessments need to be considered prior to planning applications being approved.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Sometimes SEPA does not even do an environmental impact assessment. I have been through the card with SEPA on the matter of the incinerator at Carntyne. SEPA is looking at things again after the Carntyne case. Would Helen Eadie accept that SEPA should have a clear public health remit, at least to liaise with other bodies on public health? Time and again SEPA will say that it cannot consider health issues. Surely to goodness health should be part of its remit. Its remit should be reviewed.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

In recommendation 7, we could say that the experience of Blairingone would suggest that public health impact assessments should be an essential part of the consideration of planning applications. Members indicated agreement.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Could we address the fact that odour seems to be excluded from SEPA's considerations?

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

That should be borne in mind, as should what Susan Deacon said in relation to PE517 at last week's Transport and the Environment Committee meeting.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Which recommendation would that come under?

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Odour would be embraced under the context of the wider health issues. Odour can cause people mental health problems and all kinds of other problems, and it can affect community well-being. The issue came up when I spoke to public health consultants in Fife, who said that we all need to be concerned about community health when dealing with planning applications.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I suggest that we make an additional recommendation on odour, pointing out that the issue is being pursued in relation to other petitions and that, although it has been a problem in the case of Blairingone, it will have to be addressed on a national basis. I am sure that we could find a form of words.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

SEPA has washed its hands of odour. That is one of the things that—

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That is what I mean. It is important to include that point.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

SEPA claims to investigate odour, but I have been through the matter with it in relation to dumping.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The point is that we can probably find a form of words that refers to odour and to the fact that the matter is being pursued in relation to other petitions.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

We could stress the importance of tackling odour for the well-being of a community. Could we also have a clear statement that SEPA should have a health consideration—"consideration" is perhaps the best word to use—remit? It has dodged health matters in every single case of pollution that I have been involved with. SEPA keeps saying that health is nothing to do with it. What, then, is to do with SEPA?

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Would Dorothy-Grace Elder agree to the inclusion of a requirement for health impact assessments prior to any approvals being granted at the planning stage?

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Yes. That would be a good move. However, if possible, I would like to include something on the consideration of a health remit for SEPA. The public is wandering around from quango to quango. Indeed, Blairingone has been thoroughly quangoed; the community is suffering from quango-related stress. The public keep on being fobbed off and told that this, that or the next department deals with the matter. Responsibility for environmental matters is absolutely fragmented.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We have already agreed to refer to the need to conduct a public health impact assessment. We will also say that such assessments are being pursued in relation to other petitions that we have received. The petition that Susan Deacon has been dealing with, PE517, is being dealt with in a similar way. We will try to work in some references to odour so that that issue may be taken on board, too.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We return to recommendation 8:"That the Scottish Parliament and local councillors continue a watching brief over Blairingone."It is suggested that local authorities and organisations such as SEPA, rather than the Parliament as such, should have that watching brief.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We could still mention "local MSPs"; it is a local matter, rather than—

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Would a reference to local MSPs do?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We should refer to "local elected representatives".

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Shall we put "locally elected representatives"?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That would include MSPs and councillors.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

As long as there is some reporting back to the Parliament. The thing about the secretive EHIT, which took place behind closed doors, is that the local MSPs were not told about it, let alone the local councillor.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

There might be a concern over Blairingone getting the Parliament to look after it, whereas nobody else in Scotland gets such treatment. That is why we should refer to local elected representatives.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

We could perhaps add a sentence restating that, if problems arise and if things do not turn out properly, there is the possibility of lodging a new petition with the Parliament. That would give some strength to people who are involved in local activities.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Would it be possible for us still to refer to the Parliament as well as to councillors? Lots of people might be able to wriggle off hooks otherwise. Look at what has happened so far: we were not even informed that an EHIT was being conducted.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We could say, "That a watching brief over Blairingone be continued by local MSPs and councillors, who have the right to refer any concerns to the Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee."

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Is that okay?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 9 reads:"That it is accepted by the Scottish parliament that he spreading of untreated or semi treated sewage on farmland is a revolting concept to the public and to some farmers and parts of the food industry and that Parliament should work towards banning this practice completely by ensuring safe scientific methods of disposal. An expert group should be set up urgently involving the Scottish Parliament, Westminster, the European Commission, the Waste Industry, all relevant public health bodies, the agricultural industry and food industry to assess safety of current practices, conduct field tests in various parts of Britain, review current technology and decide on safer methods."The suggestion on that recommendation is that it could refer to the Executive's consultation on sewage sludge spreading. It is likely that regulations will be tightened, which is to be welcomed. We could suggest that it is imperative that the Executive take a robust approach, and we could work that suggestion into the same paragraph.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

This is a continuing problem. If there is no right to put any of that stuff into the sea, more and more spreading on land will have to be done—it is a growing problem.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The Transport and the Environment Committee has already made recommendations along the lines that are suggested; we should not interfere with that. We could take into account the fact that that committee has recommended steps that should be taken, so we could endorse the Transport and the Environment Committee's ideas.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The Transport and the Environment Committee is not, however, saying that we should one day end spreading of partly treated and raw sewage on fields. On the matter of the safe sludge matrix becoming part of legislation and so on, it would be useful if we took a tougher stance. The practice at Blairingone ended four years ago, but we have been dumping sludge on land only because Britain was not prepared for when the sludge boats stopped. When the sludge boats stopped, matter that was not safe enough for the sea was suddenly being dumped on farm land.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am informed that the minister has said that the practice will not continue.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Was he referring only to raw sewage? Does that also cover partly treated human excrement?There are all sorts of ways to dispose of the waste, such as pelleting and other far less disgusting or potentially threatening ways in which to deal with it using the proper technology. So far, we have not bothered to find the finances for that, although Europe gave us 13 years' warning.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It has been suggested that we recommend that the Transport and the Environment Committee monitor the Executive's consultation on the issue, in order to ensure that those items are properly dealt with. We do not want to get involved in the remit of that committee or to produce recommendations to rival the recommendations of the Transport and the Environment Committee, which has conducted an in-depth study into the issue.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Yes, we could recommend that, in monitoring the Executive's consultation on the subject, the Transport and the Environment Committee should consider those issues and ensure that the Executive honours its commitment to end the practice.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I am not sure that the Executive is fully committed to ending sewage spreading. Partially treated sewage is not nice stuff, either.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We can ask the Transport and the Environment Committee to monitor specifically whether the sewage is partially treated. It is that committee's role to do that, not ours.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We can ask the Transport and the Environment Committee to monitor whether the sewage is untreated or semi-treated.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Would members be happy if we framed the recommendation to say that the Transport and the Environment Committee should ensure that the practice is outlawed by monitoring the Scottish Executive's consultation?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 10 reads:"That the euphemism ‘organic wastes' be avoided by responsible Parliamentarians when referring to the element which means human excrement or abattoir waste. Public relations spin should not be indulged in - the public must know clearly what is being dumped near habitation. A rose by any other name will smell the same - but this is no rose."The suggestion is that we accept that recommendation, but that we amend the wording to include only the first sentence.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We do not need the poetry about the rose—roses do not spring to mind in this context.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is suggested that the second and third sentences be dropped, although the image in them is colourful. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 11 reads:"That a liaison group be set up between Snowie and the villagers for exchange of information on the company's activities. Snowie has agreed to this and it is now up to the villagers. As a first step, Snowie could let the villagers and Parliament know about the idea of a catch screen at their composting site, etc."It is suggested that we accept that recommendation. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 12 reads:"That air monitoring by the responsible public bodies be conducted at Blairingone, and reported to Parliament."It is suggested that the recommendation could be a more general call for appropriate monitoring to be carried out at other sites where concerns are raised about public health. We could broaden the recommendation a bit.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Yes. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Recommendation 13 reads:"That an expert group be set up to study health in relation to composting in Scotland."It is suggested that that is outwith our remit and that it is not necessarily something that we should sign up to.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We are looking into the issue of composting. What did we agree to do on it?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We can check our position on that.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The company is now pursuing composting at Blairingone. It is no longer spreading sewage there; it has not done so for four years and does not intend to do so again.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will check our remit and clarify our position on that.Finally, let us turn to the medical advisor's report, which contains lots of good material. The report is appendix E of the main report and was written by Dr John Curnow. Paragraphs 2.1 to 2.6 give the background to the problem and paragraphs 4.1 and 4.2 detail the purpose of the health inquiry. Paragraph 5.1 provides a working definition of health, paragraphs 6.1 to 6.3 talk about the health of the village and paragraphs 7.1 to 7.3 are an analysis of the questionnaires that Dorothy-Grace Elder circulated. Paragraphs 8.1 to 8.7 contain a discussion on the health implications and the report ends with some conclusions. It is suggested that Dr Curnow's report could be merged with the main body of the report to make the final report, which could be redrafted and brought back to the committee, probably on 25 March.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Paragraph 11.10 brings us back to the danger of the compost fibres blowing in the air. That is what is happening now.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 11 March 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 4
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 2
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 83
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 64
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 219
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  20. Convener's Report Procedure · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.