Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Abandoned Properties (PE602)

Tuesday 25 February 2003 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 43 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

43 contributions
John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The next petition is PE602, from David Cleghorn, on behalf of Dedridge community council. The petition calls on the Parliament to take the necessary steps to decentralise to local authorities the previously centralised power held by the Scotland Office, under planning regulations, to recover abandoned private sector properties. Four people have come to speak to the petition: David Cleghorn, Rosalie Walton, Councillor Danny Logue and Douglas Marr. I ask Mr Cleghorn to introduce his colleagues and to make a presentation, after which the committee will ask questions.

David Cleghorn Dedridge Community Council
link

Thank you for allowing us to address the committee on our petition. This is the first time that two of us have been to the Parliament, and it has been interesting to watch the proceedings this morning. On my right is Councillor Danny Logue, the councillor for Dedridge. I am the secretary of Dedridge community council. On my left is Rosalie Walton, who lives in Dedridge in close proximity to an abandoned house. On my far left is Douglas Marr, who works in the housing department of West Lothian Council.Dedridge, where we come from, is a densely populated, mixed-tenure housing estate on the south side of Livingston. The population of Dedridge is more than 7,500 people in an area that is one mile by half a mile. Most of our houses are terraced houses, and any house that becomes vacant—for whatever reason—is immediately noticeable. Any house that lies vacant for a long time can attract all kinds of problems, including vandalism, upset to neighbours, rodents and environmental problems.Over a number of years, the community council has heard of several instances of private properties—former council houses that were purchased by individuals and sold on—being abandoned and lying empty for several years. Folk have, rightly, asked us why that has happened and we have reported those cases to the council. However, the council has told us that it does not have the power to do anything about those properties; ergo, we have unhappy people and an unhappy community. That is why we have come here today.Our petition is simple and sets out our understanding of the situation. Our colleagues from the council will keep us right on why they want the procedures and the application of the law to be changed. It seems that the council does not have the power to purchase the abandoned properties compulsorily under the rules that currently apply. The purpose of our petition is to get that power transferred from the Scotland Office to the Scottish Executive and for the Executive then to devolve the power to local authorities so that they will be able to exercise it when they have exhausted every other avenue in respect of the empty properties.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I am very interested in the petition. What are the reasons for people abandoning their properties? I understand that that happens quite often and that private owners are involved.

David Cleghorn Dedridge Community Council
link

Danny Logue will answer that question. He is the chair of the council's housing appeals special sub-committee.

Councillor Danny Logue West Lothian Council
link

I have received many complaints from members of my community regarding abandoned properties. One such property was repossessed four years ago after it had caught fire. It was the third house that the owner had set on fire for the insurance money. It was repossessed by the building society and sold to a property developer, which hoped to send someone round with a couple of tins of paint to paint the building up and re-let it. It is a five-bedroomed property with a staircase that goes up to the loft, so it potentially has seven bedrooms. It also has a dining room, a large kitchen and three bathrooms. Such houses sell for about £92,000—they are not on what might be called a run-down council estate. Many of our houses are going through one of the largest-ever refurbishment programmes. They are being fitted with new kitchens, high-quality bathrooms, double glazing, new roofs and so on. It is not as if our estates are run down. We are one of Scotland's leading councils for housing.The property is now noticeable, in that part of the roof has now disappeared and it has been boarded up because it is continually vandalised. The grass is about four feet high. There is still food in the building after many years. However, we are not allowed access to the property. Our correspondence on the matter has gone on for months, if not years; my initial correspondence, in which I asked that something be done, started in February 2000. It took nearly a year to locate the present owner but by that time, the house had deteriorated to a terrible condition. It must be remembered that the house is between two tenants' houses.The property was in such a terrible condition that building control had a look at it, but a notice could not be served because the building was assessed as borderline. Commitments have been given by the owners that work would be carried out within about three months, but the legal department for the present owners has continually used stalling tactics to try to prevent the building from being done up. I do not know why.One of the neighbours was under such stress that he took a severe heart attack. He had to be moved out because of smoke inhalation and the damage that was done to his property. He is now so ill that he no longer comes to see me but must send his daughter instead because he was told not to overstress himself. This man used to work six days a week but he now goes round in a wheelchair. All of that is directly related to the problems with the neighbouring house.The house was last vandalised yesterday. The police were called out because a group of youths were running riot in the house. They smashed any remaining windows, ripped out most of the plumbing and put holes through the walls. Such incidents are a constant problem.We have asked the owner's legal department for the building to be refurbished but still nothing has happened. We therefore ask that the Executive give the local authority the powers that are currently held by the Scotland Office so that we can compulsorily purchase such properties within a limited time frame. Our legal department has been negotiating with the Scotland Office to try to get it to use the legislation, but because the lawyers for the property's owners issue correspondence claiming that something will be done, the problem has gone on for four years. That just is not on, but there is nothing that we can do about it.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

That gives me a nice lead-in for my question. What has been your experience of trying to get the Scotland Office to act by using its existing power? Does the problem go wider than Councillor Logue's community? Do other local authorities have similar difficulties when trying to progress such matters through the current system?

Councillor Logue
link

We had a couple of houses of a similar nature—one in the same street and a couple in other communities in West Lothian. I know from having downloaded information from the internet that other authorities have had similar problems. I know that many areas have similar outstanding problems.When their house is repossessed, many owner-occupiers tend to abandon the property. In a few circumstances, the house had actually been paid off and the people who owned the house passed it on to their family. However, the family just left the house as they did not have enough money at the time to do it up and did not want to sell it at a discounted rate. It must be remembered that the council approached the owner of the property in question and said, "We'll buy it off you." We were told, "£92,000 would be nice, thank you." The house needs a new roof and a new heating system and all the walls need to be stripped out. It would probably cost us £30,000 to £40,000 to refurbish it.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

The point that I am trying to make is that you currently have the capacity to refer such matters to the Scottish ministers to make a compulsory order. Have you ever tried to get them to make such an order?

Councillor Logue
link

We must follow certain legal guidelines first. We have never been able to reach the starting blocks. We must follow the legislation and consider the owner. We must first attempt to buy the property from him or get him to do something with it. The lawyers of the person in question continually use stalling tactics, so we are at a loss. There is nothing that we can do.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

So you never reach the point at which you have everything in place to—

Councillor Logue
link

We cannot pass go.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The housing legislation that governs the matter and the guidelines that must be followed before a compulsory purchase order can be requested must predate devolution. Which act applies?

Douglas Marr
link

It is the consolidated housing legislation and the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001; the previous legislation was probably the Housing (Scotland) Act 1966. Our problem is the hoops that we must jump through and the hurdles that we must go over. Certain things must be proved. The state of disrepair of a property has been mentioned. Defining what serious disrepair means is a problem. One must also prove that a property has been empty over a protracted period. It must be proved that one has taken reasonable steps. There is a lot of red tape and bureaucracy in the process and a lot of public money is involved. Is there good value for money in the example that Councillor Logue mentioned? The local authority takes part in the empty homes initiative, which has been ideal for recovering property if the owners are willing to sell, but there is a problem if owners are identified and are not willing to sell or will not accept the market value of the property.On perceptions, it can look like the council is doing nothing and that properties are lying empty in estates. The first assumption is that the house is a council house and that the council has left it empty and is doing nothing about it. We must counter such assumptions, but when we do so, we have problems. The existing legislation makes things difficult and does not work for us. We are here today because we do not have the end ownership of the process.I reiterate what has been said about communities' interests. As soon as a house or property appears to be empty, it becomes an attraction. The legislation needs to be streamlined and the local authority needs ownership.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Before Phil Gallie says something, I would like to clarify a matter. Have Scottish Executive ministers given any indication that they want to retain the power in question? Is there resistance to passing power down to local authorities?

Douglas Marr
link

I think that this is our first journey through the process.

Councillor Logue
link

The legal opinion that we have received from the Scottish Executive is that the matter that we are discussing still comes under the old legislation, but there will be a review at some point in the future.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

The problem exists not just in areas where there are council houses; it also exists with business premises and old private properties in particular. Has West Lothian Council or the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities made any representations on the issue? Have housing officials recognised and highlighted the problem in the past?

Douglas Marr
link

On the shortage of accommodation, there is a great housing need—

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I am not thinking about accommodation shortages. You have identified a real problem. Have West Lothian Council or COSLA discussed the matter? Have they made any representations to the Executive?

Douglas Marr
link

I am not aware of any representations.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Would that be a good starting point? I am surprised that representations have not been made before.

Councillor Logue
link

When we investigated the legislation, we were surprised by how hard it is to purchase a property compulsorily—in fact, doing so is almost impossible. We came to the Scottish Parliament with the petition because we thought that it would be the best organisation to put pressure on the Scotland Office to have the power in question transferred down to the local authority.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

You mentioned the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001. We parliamentarians had a chance recently to consider housing issues, but the issue that we are discussing seems to have escaped our notice. That is why I am asking about previous COSLA involvement and whether people have raised the issue before.

Councillor Logue
link

It was presumed that the empty homes initiative would address the problem, but it has not.

David Cleghorn Dedridge Community Council
link

I would like to make one point on behalf of the community. We elected you people. This issue is causing major problems where we live. The community, which is nice, is densely populated. Eighty per cent of folk have bought their houses and the other 20 per cent rent. Tenure is not an issue; it is about how the streets look and how folk feel. We expect you as a Parliament to do something about it. We are not interested in passing the buck from organisation to organisation. We are not here to play those kinds of games. Members of the Parliament may want to, but we do not. We want the politicians to sort the matter out.

Rosalie Walton Dedridge Community Council
link

I would like to add something on behalf of those who live in the conditions described. I am an environmentalist by profession, and people's environment is not just about butterflies and birds; it is about the boarded-up house next door that people see when they draw the curtains in the morning. That type of environment causes many health problems and depression, which are bound to creep in.I moved to Dedridge 25 years ago when the council was known as Livingston Development Corporation. Every house was owned by the public sector, and maintenance was just part of the story. Every house was maintained and cleaned, and if they were not, something was done about it. Over the past 25 years, I have seen small pockets of depression and undermaintenance gradually creep in. Rhoda Grant's question was interesting: why should people own property and do nothing about it? We must consider the economic climate. Property, including former public sector housing, is a good investment. Sometimes people invest in houses and sit on them in the hope that they will always be a good investment, unlike personal equity plans and individual savings accounts. That depressing occurrence does not happen just in Dedridge, and its frequency is bound to increase unless we have legislation to halt it.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

About eight or nine years ago, a scheme was instituted in London to recover abandoned private property. A helpline was set up so that the public could shop abandoned properties. Through the scheme, several thousand houses that were wasting away were recovered. With all the mix-max and terrible confusion, sometimes it turned out that one of the local boroughs owned the houses. Nevertheless, the scheme helped to revitalise parts of London. Some of the properties were posh, and others were poor. It might be worth contacting the London mayor's office to see whether the scheme is still thriving—I last checked a number of years ago.

Councillor Logue
link

We understand that, but we find that when we locate the owners they do not want to do anything about their houses. They point-blank refuse. They say that they will get to it when they have the time and the finances.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

London put some teeth behind the scheme. I cannot remember exactly how it was done, but the people working on it did not just want to have a list of abandoned properties; they acted on the list through local boroughs and so on. I cannot recall whether the mayor's office ran the scheme, but I am sure that Ken Livingstone could give us guidance.

Councillor Logue
link

Dedridge community council could tell people that they have six months, for example, to do certain things to a property or we will compulsorily purchase it. That should force an owner into doing something. If we bought a property compulsorily, we would have it valued at what it is worth, not at what the proprietor assumes it is worth.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I would like you to refresh my memory. I know that at one point local authority finance committees had the discretion to give relief on council tax, but in recent years that has changed. What is the current council tax position in respect of empty homes? At one time council tax was paid on such homes at only half the normal rate. Is that still the case?

Douglas Marr
link

There are various circumstances in which council tax is not payable. An earlier petition related to residential establishments for the elderly. If someone who has a property goes into hospital for a time, council tax will not be payable on the property for that period. A discount is also applied to empty properties, if whoever owns the property contacts the council.

Councillor Logue
link

We have a list of bills that the owner-occupier owes us for works to board up his property to make it safe, because it was being set on fire and vandalised. We are still waiting for him to pay those bills. We are constantly in contact with his lawyer but we have not received much money.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will now consider the action that has been suggested on the petition. We take the point that so far this issue has escaped the notice of the Parliament. The Housing (Scotland) Act 2001, which was passed in the first session of the Parliament, dealt with the social rented sector. As we have heard this morning, the empty homes initiative does not address the problem that the petitioners highlight. I know that the Executive has long promised legislation dealing with the private sector, which might provide the opportunity for us to do something about houses of the sort that we are discussing.It is suggested that we seek a response from the Executive by asking it to comment on the issues that the petition raises. In particular, we should ask it for details of its policy position on this matter and to indicate whether it has plans to devolve responsibility for authorising compulsory acquisition of abandoned properties to local authorities. We should also ask the Executive to indicate how often Scottish ministers have authorised such compulsory acquisitions and request details of the circumstances and time scales of those cases. Finally, we should ask the Executive to comment on the petitioners' suggestion that abandoned private properties could be acquired and used as a means of boosting dwindling local authority housing stocks.From questions that were asked earlier, I suspect that we will want to ask COSLA to set out its position on PE602.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We should ask Ken Livingstone or whoever is responsible to outline the system for recovering abandoned properties in London.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I am not sure whether that is done through the mayor's office or through the boroughs, but there is a system and the authorities in London should be able to provide us with information about it.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Can we ask the Minister for Finance and Public Services about the council tax situation?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will ask the Executive about that.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I might be able to help on that issue. I recall a bill in the mid-1990s that gave local authorities discretion to decide how much council tax they would take from empty residences. I know of one chap whose business went bust and who was dying to get rid of his properties. He would have loved a compulsory purchase order to be served on them, simply to get rid of them. However, at the time the council's funds were limited.I am not trying to pass the buck on this issue from parliamentarians to COSLA or any other organisation. As the convener said, no thought was given to the issue during consideration of the Housing (Scotland) Bill, although the problem has existed for quite a long time. If possible, local authorities should get COSLA's backing to add to the pressure that parliamentarians are putting on the Executive.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will ask the Executive to confirm the position on council tax.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Local authorities should not have discretion to be generous to owners who leave their property empty. On the contrary, punitive levels of council tax should be imposed, unless the owner can provide justification—because the occupant is in a home, or elderly, or in hospital, for example. The current policy should be stood on its head.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Okay. We can consider that once we get a reply from the Executive.I thank the petitioners again for their evidence this morning and for bringing the matter to our attention. We will keep you informed of progress as the bodies send their replies.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 25 February 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 2
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 20
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 70
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 54
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 43
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 20
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  17. Convener's Report Procedure · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.