Committee members will recall that we decided to appoint Dorothy-Grace Elder as a reporter and Dr John Curno as our adviser on petition PE327. We requested them to report back to the committee on whether the health aspects of the petition were being dealt with properly. To assist her in that process, Dorothy-Grace has arranged this morning's evidence-taking session.First to give evidence will be Mr Duncan Hope, who is the chair of the Blairingone and Saline Action Group and the chief petitioner for petition PE327. Mr Hope won the oyster award for environmental campaigning in relation to his work on the petition. I understand that he has been working on the issue for about five years, despite the fact that he suffered a stroke during that time. Thank you for attending this morning. I understand that you would like to make an opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Organic Waste Disposal (PE327)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind 74
- Mr Roxburgh 49
- Dr Roworth 46
- Tricia Henton Former Chief Executive, Scottish Environment Protection Agency 43
- George Reid SNP 37
- Phil Gallie Con 27
- John McAllion Lab 22
- Duncan Hope Blairingone and Saline Action Group 18
- Helen Eadie Lab 15
- Willie Halcrow Scottish Environment Protection Agency 12
- John Farquhar Munro LD 9
- Mr Halcrow 2
- Dr Mike Roworth Tayside NHS Board 1
- Mr Brian Roxburgh Scottish Environment Protection Agency 1
- Dr Malcolm McWhirter Forth Valley NHS Board 1
- Dr Charles Saunders Fife NHS Board 1
- Dr Saunders 1
The record
361 contributions · showing 1–200Good morning. Since I last gave evidence to the committee, the Blairingone and Saline Action Group's petition PE327 has made remarkable progress through the Scottish Parliament's committee system. That progress is well documented and has resulted in visits to both Blairingone and Argaty by Andy Kerr MSP, plus a report from the Transport and the Environment Committee that was published on 7 March 2002. A full debate on the matter was held in the chamber last October and a health investigation is being undertaken in our community. The willingness of the Parliament to come to Blairingone to listen to the concerns of the local residents and to consult them in their own homes has been much appreciated by the community. As I have said previously, that has brought the people much closer to the Parliament than they had ever been to it before.During the petition's passage through the various stages of the committee process, the action group received full co-operation, help and courtesy from everyone connected with the Parliament, including conveners, MSPs, clerks, receptionists, attendants and other staff. The Parliament has been accessible, open, informative and transparent. Everything has been recorded, documented and made available to the public either through the Parliament's website or through the Official Report. That is in stark contrast to the secretive and questionable methods that we encountered from the quangos and unelected bodies that were assigned to the previous health investigation, which was conducted by the environmental hazard investigation team—the EHIT.We first learned of the EHIT's existence through Dr Roworth's letter of 4 April 2002, which informed us that two meetings had been held at the Scottish Environment Protection Agency's Stirling office in October 2001 and February 2002. The letter stated that, as the team had concluded that the criteria for fulfilling stage 1 of the investigation had not been met, it was inappropriate to proceed further with the investigation. Nobody informed us that the EHIT had been set up; nobody contacted us; and nobody came to Blairingone as Andy Kerr, Bruce Crawford, George Reid and Dorothy-Grace Elder had done.I find it extremely difficult to understand how an investigation into the specific concerns of the residents of a community could have been carried out when no one visited or contacted the residents to find out what their concerns were. I was informed in a letter from SEPA that the EHIT had indicated that it wanted to meet me—the convener of the action group—in Stirling. That took place some seven weeks after Dr Roworth's letter was made public and only after I had written to SEPA for confirmation that the EHIT was to reconvene and to request a copy of its terms of reference, which I received seven months after the EHIT first met. I refused to go to Stirling and the issue was referred back to the Parliament on 26 June.The people of Blairingone believed that they were getting a whitewash from the EHIT. Such quangos and unelected bodies sit in their little ivory towers making decisions that affect other people's lives and no one has the power to question their decisions. Well, Blairingone questioned the EHIT's decision. These people are not our masters; they are public servants. A friend who has a military background told me that my refusal to go to Stirling was akin to tossing a grenade into their little bunkers and that they were now squirming and scrambling about to save their own necks, skins and highly-paid jobs, blaming everyone but themselves before it exploded.During the debate in the Parliament on 10 October, George Reid said that he believed:"the Parliament was set up to cast light on the dark corners of Scottish life, to give voice to the people and to ensure that the elites of old corporate Scotland do not determine what we should think."—Official Report; 10 October 2002; c 14605.I, too, believe in the Parliament. It is our Parliament and it is the voice of the people, as I am demonstrating today. I sincerely hope that the Public Petitions Committee, on our behalf, will send out a strong, loud, clear message to other quangos and unelected bodies that their days are numbered and that such practices are totally unacceptable and will no longer be tolerated by the people of Scotland.
Thank you. I open up the debate to questions and remind members that they will get the chance to ask questions of the EHIT later this morning.
Mr Hope, you stated your case very clearly. However, for the sake of absolute clarity, perhaps you could confirm the timing of events. You said that the Blairingone and Saline Action Group was told nothing of the setting up of the EHIT until a letter arrived on 4 April 2002, telling you that the matter was over and that the investigation team had decided not to proceed with its investigation. It was only some weeks afterwards that you received an invitation to visit SEPA in Stirling to discuss the matter. That invitation came only after the perceived finale, when the letter arrived saying that it was all over.
The invitation came seven weeks after the letter arrived and only after I had written to SEPA, asking for confirmation that the EHIT was to reconvene. We found out only through the media that the EHIT was to reconvene.
Had your MSPs been informed, given that several of them were involved?
I forwarded a copy of Dr Roworth's letter to George Reid.
But that was after the event.
Yes. We did not know that the EHIT existed. When Andy Kerr's report was published on 7 March, the action group expected the EHIT to be set up. We waited to learn the names of the people who would sit on the committee and to be passed a copy of the terms of reference. We expected to be contacted by the EHIT to be asked to provide a list of names of the people who were to be interviewed. No one contacted us, and we never knew that the EHIT had been established.
Were you given any details of the remit of the working group that undertook the investigation?
Only in Dr Roworth's letter of 4 April and in a copy of the terms of reference, which, again, I had to request. Those two documents arrived at the end of May 2002; seven months after the EHIT had first met in October 2001.
Have you any idea who appointed the EHIT?
We knew that the idea of the EHIT was part of SEPA's submission of 5 September 2001 in response to the petition, but we did not know that it had been set up. We were under the impression that, because it was recommended in Andy Kerr's report, the EHIT would be part of a parliamentary investigation, which is why we did not expect anything until after 7 March when Andy Kerr's report was published.
Have you no idea who was ultimately responsible for setting up the committee? Was it SEPA, the minister or someone else?
We never even knew that the EHIT existed until we received Dr Roworth's letter dated 4 April.
When the petition came to the Parliament and your community knew that there was to be an investigation, which stakeholders did the people of the community think would be involved in the inquiry?
Several people with alleged illnesses—well, the illnesses are not alleged; they exist—expected the team to do what Andy Kerr and his team from the Transport and the Environment Committee did when they carried out their inquiry, which was to come out to visit people in their own homes in the community. We are talking about cases of illness that should be treated as confidential, not discussed in public meetings. The community expected the team to visit, and we were going to provide a list of names for the team to aid its visit, but it never came.
You mentioned that you were invited to a meeting in Stirling with officials of SEPA. What sort of protest were you making when you decided not to attend?
We thought that we would not get a proper investigation. How could there be an investigation into, in the words of the report,"the specific concerns of the residents of Blairingone"when no one had visited that community to discuss with the residents their concerns? I have no authority to go to Stirling to talk on other people's behalf about their illnesses. I have no access to medical records or GPs, and that is where the information required for such an investigation must come from.
Do you think that SEPA's view might be that if you had attended the meeting and discussed the matter, it might have managed to keep you quiet?
SEPA must tell you whether that is the case. I did not go to the meeting; I refused to go.
You referred to a list of names of people in Blairingone who alleged that they had illnesses that could be environmentally related. Approximately how many were on that list?
We knew of about 30.
Given that people's problems in the village are related to particular effects on them, how were local authority environmental health people involved prior to your raising concerns about the setting up of the EHIT? Was the health board involved? Had it expressed concern?
We did not have much co-operation from environmental health officers. They came out occasionally, primarily at the beginning of the campaign, to ascertain whether there was an odour. However, neither the environmental health department nor SEPA could make up their minds about who was responsible for the odour. We had no contact with public health.
I understand that Saline is in Fife, but Blairingone must be just about on the border with Perth and Kinross.
We are in a wee corner of no-man's-land. We are in Kinross-shire, but our postal address is Dollar, Clackmannanshire. We are in the wee bit of no-man's-land between Fife, Perth and Kinross and Clackmannan, about eight miles north of the Kincardine bridge on the A977.
Which local authority showed the interest to which you referred?
Do you mean medical interest?
Yes—I am asking about the environmental health department.
It was Perth and Kinross Council.
You have obviously been campaigning on the matter since 1997, when it first arose as an issue in your local area. However, you would argue that the issue is not just a local one but that it has national implications.
Yes.
In the minutes of the two meetings that the EHIT held, reference is made on several occasions to cost and to the length of time it would take for a full inquiry into the health implications. What is your attitude to that?
I do not think that that should be a consideration at all. We are talking about people's health and their concerns about that. Why should cost come into it? We are talking about people's lives. They are real people and the illnesses are real. We want to get to the bottom of the situation.
I want to make just one point for clarification. You were eventually given the offer of a meeting in Stirling, but it is my understanding that the purpose of that meeting was not to have a discussion—as the convener said—but for you to be told why a decision had been reached.
That is correct. I was not even invited. The wording of the letter was that the EHIT had indicated that it would like to meet with me, as convener of the action group, at SEPA's Stirling office.
Thank you for your evidence this morning, which has been helpful to the committee.We move on to the second witness, Tricia Henton, who is the former chief executive of SEPA. I understand that she does not want to make an opening statement, so we can go straight into questions. Good morning, Miss Henton. Is it okay with you if we go straight to questions, or do you want to make an opening statement?
I have a brief comment, which is not a statement as such. Obviously, I am happy to help in any way that I can, but I ask the committee to remember that four months have passed since I left SEPA and I no longer have any connection with the organisation. The issues raised in the petition took place in the past, so it is probable that many of the questions that you will ask me would be better answered by people who are still actively involved.
We appreciate your trouble in coming today, although, as you stated, you have left SEPA, where you were chief executive. After Dr Mike Roworth, the public health consultant at Tayside, wrote in April 2002 that the EHIT was not going to proceed with its inquiry, did you publicly reject the way the investigation had been conducted and, if so, why?
I know that we had had a lot of discussion internally, but in terms of what you call public rejection, I would need to be reminded of the sequence of events. I know that I commented on the matter—a short television interview took place at some stage last year, but I cannot remember exactly when that happened. I have a feeling that it was either late in the summer or early in the autumn.
Would it be fair to say—despite various cuttings and so on—that you were concerned about the fact that the public and the action group in Saline and Blairingone had not been involved, that people had not been visited and that you wanted something to be done about the situation? Would that be a fair summation?
Yes, that would be a fair comment.
It was rather unusual, I think, for you—or SEPA—to make a criticism after the EHIT had concluded. Would you agree?
I am not sure whether my comments would necessarily be considered as a criticism. When there is public concern about a health issue, it is important that people feel that they have had a fair chance to put their case. I recall that that was what concerned us. No matter what the details, the people involved must feel that they have had a fair opportunity to put their case.
Indeed, SEPA helped to compose guidelines on how EHITs should be used. The guidelines have a rather cumbersome title, which Ms Henton will know only too well: "Dealing with assertions of human health risks or effects from environmental exposures—a systematic approach". Do you feel that the EHIT followed the guidelines on public consultation, the necessity for which is mentioned throughout that document?
We were concerned because we did not feel that everything had been done to give the public confidence that they had been listened to properly.
The EHIT had only two meetings, which were attended by a SEPA representative, Mr Brian Roxburgh. The minutes of the meetings show that the conclusion not to proceed was unanimous—there is no sign of any dissent from Mr Roxburgh or others about that. Will you comment on that? SEPA was involved in the team through a senior representative. Why was there no dissent from SEPA at that point?
Mr Roxburgh is better able than I am to answer that question.
Did you know that the EHIT had been set up?
To be honest, I cannot recall whether I knew. You will appreciate that a great number of things go on in SEPA and, as chief executive, I would not necessarily have known about the team at that time.
Did you know of other EHITs operating in your time at SEPA?
I was not aware of any, but that does not mean to say that there were not any. Again, SEPA staff might be better able to answer that question.
Have SEPA and others learned something for the future about the way in which an EHIT's work should be conducted? Is there room for improvement?
Public bodies should always be able to learn lessons from committees that are set up to look into problems that the bodies have. I am certain that SEPA and the other organisations involved will consider the matter and ensure that future committees learn from it.
I assume that you understand that there is a wider national public concern.
Yes.
People will be inclined to wonder whether other controversial matters have been given a completely clean bill of health after only a perfunctory examination and without public involvement. The issue is not only about Blairingone; it is a national issue.
The handling of any such issue is a public matter. The issue stretched across areas of public life such as health, environment and food.
When the Blairingone and Saline Action Group began to hit the headlines and the Parliament became involved, I would have expected a case conference to be established by the professionals who had a stake in the issue. Is that a fair comment? Did such a conference take place and, if so, which stakeholders were involved? Someone, somewhere must have taken the initiative to set up the EHIT, but it is not clear who did so.
I am sorry to seem evasive again, but I am not familiar with the details of how the process was conducted in SEPA or any other organisations. I am sure that my former colleagues could help you on that. I was involved in discussions that took place at various stages, but I do not remember where they fit into the sequence of events.
Will you comment on the general principle? As Dorothy-Grace Elder said, we are considering a national issue. Who would you, as a professional, expect to be involved in the conduct of such an investigation? I am mindful of a discussion that I had with SEPA's chair, who complained that a hazard impact assessment is not made before planning permission approval is given. Such points arise when we discuss more national issues. Who would you expect to be involved in preparing a hazard impact assessment?
Two separate issues are involved. The issue back at the land use planning stage is separate from the question of how a case is dealt with. The document with the horrendously unwieldy title that you mentioned is useful in dealing with cases. It sets out well the process that can be used to deal with an issue once it has arisen. How that situation is avoided by action way back in the planning process and in the granting of authorisations is a different matter. I know that concern is felt that the present land use planning system might not take adequate account of environmental issues.
I bring you back to the fundamental question. Who would you expect to be the stakeholders who are involved? For example, there was no sign that residents were involved. Perhaps other people should have been involved, such as MSPs and local council representatives. A group seems to have been parachuted in from we do not know where.
The document sets out the agencies that should be involved, such as consultants in public health medicine, environmental health agencies and SEPA, because the issue is environmental. On page 3, the document says that the importance of having a meaningful dialogue with the community and its representatives cannot be overstated. That sentence is extremely important.
Has not a weakness just been pointed to? Being meaningfully consulted is different from being involved as an equal partner round the table.
Once the procedure is in progress, local community representatives are obviously key stakeholders. The public bodies do their job on behalf of those people.
Might MSPs and councillors have been meaningfully involved in sitting round the table with the professionals?
I will speak in generalities, because I do not want to go into the detail of the specific case under discussion, as I lack back-up and papers. In some cases, councillors, MSPs, MPs or others will be, or should have been, involved; they are public representatives, so they should obviously have a role.
Should they have been involved round the table when the discussions took place with people such as Mike Roworth and others?
In this case?
Yes.
I see no reason why they should not have been involved. I know that George Reid and other elected members were involved. That is right and proper.
You referred to a document that laid down certain guidelines. Who published that document and what is its name?
It has the wonderful title of "Dealing with assertions of human health risks or effects from environmental exposures—a systematic approach". It is a guidance document for Scotland that was published in June 2000.
Who published it?
It was published by the National Society for Clean Air (Scotland), the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, the Scottish Centre for Infection and Environmental Health and two other organisations.
Was NHS Scotland involved?
Putting organisations' logos on a document is problematic when one cannot remember which organisations they represent.
It is hard for you to say which of those organisations would have been the lead body in putting together that document.
A group of people, the membership of which is listed inside the document, was involved in putting it together. Members of the group came from a range of organisations. As I recall, the document was produced under a research contract.
Who set up that research contract?
I think that the Scotland and Northern Ireland Forum for Environmental Research funded it. I am sorry—I was wrong: SEPA and the Scottish Centre for Infection and Environmental Health funded it.
When Mr Hope described his understanding of the situation, he seemed to think that SEPA was the lead organisation in setting up the EHIT. Are you saying that SEPA was not the lead organisation?
If you do not mind, the relevant people within SEPA would be better placed to answer that question.
I accept that, although you were the chief executive of SEPA—the lead person within that organisation. One could say that the basis of the Blairingone complaints was of national importance. I would have thought that the senior figure in SEPA would have known who set up the EHIT and what its remit was. Surely you had an important input.
As an organisation, SEPA had an important input. Later on, I was aware of what was happening and was involved in internal discussions about the conduct of the investigation. However, within SEPA, staff have a specific delegated role in dealing with dozens of issues on a daily basis. That means that the director of operations and his staff have primary responsibility for dealing with such issues day in and day out.Many things were happening within SEPA and although I might have known that a certain issue in a certain place needed to be dealt with, I would not necessarily have known about the details. I would have found out about them only if I had a particular reason to ask for more information or if staff to whom responsibility had been delegated felt that it was necessary for me to become involved or at least to be fully briefed.
I can understand that situation. Many issues must be dealt with at a local level, using SEPA's local structures. Are you saying that SEPA was dealing with the issue in question at a local level, at least in the first instance?
I think that that would be fair, yes. It was a local issue initially.
Thank you.
The issue has caused some controversy in this Parliament. It led to a Transport and the Environment Committee report, and a ministerial response in the form of a consultation paper. One of the key recommendations of that committee's report was to set up the investigation team. I understand from your answers this morning that there was no ministerial involvement in the setting up of the team, otherwise that would have gone through the chief executive. Is that the case?
There was no ministerial involvement.
So this was purely a response somewhere in the SEPA organisation to the recommendations of the Transport and the Environment Committee report. There was no political involvement in setting up the EHIT.
No.
Ministers did not know that the team was being set up. They did not know its remit and they did not know who was appointed to it.
I am not aware of that. My former colleagues might be able to assist more, but I am not aware that there was ministerial involvement in setting up the team.
It would be hugely unusual for ministers to appoint an investigation team without informing the chief executive of SEPA, especially when SEPA was represented on the investigation team.
Sorry, are we talking about the Blairingone EHIT?
Yes. If it had been a ministerial initiative, as chief executive you would be expected to know about it.
If it had been a ministerial initiative, yes, I would have known.
And the fact that you did not know suggests that ministers were not involved.
Yes.
You said in your evidence earlier this morning that you could not necessarily recall the details of the EHIT being set up, and that you would not have known specifically what was going on. Do you remember receiving three letters from me on the subject and there being three telephone calls between us?
Yes, indeed.
Can you recall the content? Would I be right in saying that my main concern was not to prove a causal connection between spreading and ill health, but to ensure that the process was open and transparent, and involved the villagers of Blairingone?
Yes, I remember that.
Did you pass that information to your colleagues in the EHIT?
Not specifically within the EHIT, because I recall that at that stage we had agreed that we had to handle the situation carefully and properly, but I discussed it, I think, with my director of operations, who was handling the matter.
Do you recall a most confidential list of 30 cases of ill health being sent to you personally?
I received various correspondence. Yes, there was a list.
Was that passed to the EHIT or to your colleague on the EHIT?
I am not certain. There was a list with names on it, and there was a list of complaints, as I recall. Each name had alongside it a specific complaint. I would have discussed that with my director of operations.
Was the list passed to the SEPA representative on the EHIT, and was it passed to the other members of the EHIT?
I do not know.
Looking back, are you concerned about funding for SEPA and other organisations that perform such investigations? Is there a funding shortage? Is there a shortage of people and expertise?
As a general principle, any organisation like SEPA that has a wide public role—and SEPA has a very wide remit to protect the public and environment—could always do with more funding. However, I am certain that we had a generous settlement over the past couple of years, and it was incumbent upon us to ensure that we used the funds most effectively across all the areas that the organisation was responsible for looking after.
There is no special budget allocation for investigations of this sort, following public concern. I know that you investigate things that happen as one-offs here and there, but there is no funding for EHITs per se, is there?
I am not aware that anything is ever set aside specifically. The money would come from the organisation's day-to-day operational budget.
Does SEPA receive quite a number of requests for wider investigations rather than investigations of one-off incidents that you can cope with on the spot? Are requests made for investigations of health issues that are connected with the environment, because there is so much concern about them? Do you get a lot of requests to deal with specific national issues?
I was not aware of what one would call a lot of requests. We got perhaps one or two such requests over the course of each year—we might not have had even as many as that.
What is the relationship between the chief executive and the chairman of SEPA? Is it a close relationship, or would the chairman come in only for board meetings and therefore not be aware of the issues that we are discussing?
It is the responsibility of the chief executive to keep the chairman informed of issues that are arising within SEPA. The chairman was certainly aware of the issue.
At what stage was he made aware?
I am afraid that I cannot remember. I would have to go back to notes to answer that.
Thank you, Miss Henton. You have been very helpful to the committee this morning and we thank you for your attendance.A number of members of the environmental hazard investigation team are here this morning. They are: Dr Malcolm McWhirter, who is the director of public health at Forth Valley NHS Board; Professor George Morris, who is from the Scottish Centre for Infection and Environmental Health; Dr Mike Roworth, who is a consultant in public health medicine in Tayside NHS Board; Dr Charles Saunders, who is a consultant in public health medicine in Fife NHS Board; and Mr Brian Roxburgh, from SEPA, who was on the team. In support of Mr Roxburgh, we also have Mr Willie Halcrow, who is the director of operations at SEPA and Mr Colin Bayes, who is the environmental regulation manager at SEPA. I invite Dr Roworth to make his opening statement and we can then go to questions.
I am pleased to make an opening statement to the committee on behalf of my colleagues. First and foremost, there appears to be a misunderstanding about why the EHIT was set up in the first place. I will give the committee the background. The setting up of the EHIT was first mentioned by John Milne, who is the director of environment services at Perth and Kinross Council, in February 2001—at least, that was the first that I heard of it. That was a few months after the publication in 2000 of the document that was referred to earlier. To my knowledge, this is the first time that the document has been used in the investigation of a hazard or an issue of this nature.I agreed with John Milne that we should proceed to set up a committee, and I suggested that we involve colleagues from neighbouring health boards—Forth Valley NHS Board and Fife NHS Board. It is my understanding that SEPA took the lead in setting up the meetings, the first of which took place in October 2001. I was not part of the committee at the time, because I was on secondment to another organisation, but a colleague from Tayside NHS Board attended the meeting. The second meeting took place in February 2002. The committee followed the guidance, and considered the allegations of ill health that the residents had made at various times. The purpose of the meeting was to consider the allegations; it was not to consider whether land spreading or soil injection was a good idea, because that was beyond the group's remit.The EHIT was set up in much the same way that a group would be set up to investigate an outbreak of infectious disease. To our knowledge, it was independent of any parliamentary committee and it was not set up in response to any request from any parliamentary committee. The first time that I was aware that there was committee involvement in this matter was the summer of last year. The EHIT followed the document and produced its findings. A number of technical criteria have to be satisfied. After carefully considering the information, we decided that there was no prima facie case for proceeding any further with the investigation. That would include doing survey work or further detailed health studies. That information was communicated to Mr Duncan Hope and to Mr Malcolm Snowie. They received exactly the same letter in exactly the same way.That letter must have been sent some time in February or March. I then received a letter from Ms Henton at SEPA who suggested that we make an effort to consult further with people from the Blairingone and Saline Action Group—BASAG. I said that I thought that that was a sensible idea, given the strength of feeling. I suggested that we set up a meeting with BASAG. The purpose of that was twofold: first, to explain why we had met, how we had carried out the investigation and why we had reached our conclusions; and secondly, to consider any further information that BASAG had. No real further information was received. We have heard from Mr Hope, for the reasons that he gave to the committee, that he did not wish to meet the EHIT. That meeting did not therefore take place.I hope that that background information is helpful to the committee.
The implication so far is that the EHIT was SEPA's. The Scottish Environment Protection Agency took the initiative to set up the EHIT based on a letter from the environmental health section in Perth and Kinross Council, as Dr Roworth said. Representatives from there were also on the EHIT, as were Dr Roworth's colleagues in Fife and Clackmannanshire.The Scottish Environment Protection Agency's interest in the EHIT can be summarised in one basic question. Our legislation requires us to take account when human health is endangered. We needed to know whether the types of waste that were being spread or the activities at Blairingone endangered human health. If the answer was no—which, based on medical opinion, it was—SEPA's involvement would be at an end. We could take no legal action based on our legislation.If the answer had been yes, we could have taken action. We would then have been in a position to prevent the activity. Spreading is an exempt activity—it requires neither the permission of SEPA nor a licence; it simply requires that the activity be registered.The EHIT was useful to SEPA in determining that one question. It is clear in the guidance document that a consultant in public health is the appropriate person to chair such a team and to make any decisions that are based on medical evidence.As Dr Roworth said, this is certainly one of my first involvements with the EHIT, and it provides us with a good mechanism for looking at such things in the future.
Thank you both for attending today.At any stage during the EHIT meetings, did Mr Roxburgh suggest that the public might be involved?
That was suggested. A number of suggestions were made, for example meeting the public and Snowie Ltd, and having a site visit.
Who made those suggestions? Are you talking about within the EHIT?
Yes. I made those suggestions.
At some stage during and not after those two meetings you suggested that the public should be brought to the EHIT?
Not necessarily brought to the EHIT, but consulted in some way about the recommendations.
What happened to your suggestion? Was it rejected?
It was not rejected out of hand. The evidence that we had—evidence that was sent to Perth and Kinross Council of medical complaints from some of the local people—was considered. However, the medical opinion concluded that there was no biological plausibility.
You will understand that we are dealing with the democratic process. Let us run back just a moment. Before the EHIT convened for the first time, in October 2001, or during the two meetings that you had, did you express a wish that the public should be represented—that a representative from the Blairingone and Saline Action Group or an MSP should be present?
Yes. That was considered.
Who, then, said no to that?
There was agreement between the medical experts who were present that that would be for a second stage. Once the evidence was considered, however, there was no plausible reason for the investigation to move to a second stage.
Yes. That would be for a second stage. However, the guideline document says that an investigation cannot be a success unless the public are involved. The guideline document—which was written partially by SEPA—infers strongly that the public should be involved right from the start.
This is a learning process, and the second edition of the guidance document, which came out in November, stresses further the need for public involvement.
It is not minuted that you asked for the public to be involved, is it?
No.
But you did.
Yes, among other suggestions. The first meeting was an exploratory meeting to summarise—
But why did the others not want someone representing the public to be there? Did they give a reason?
It was not that they did not want the public to be represented. Perhaps you had better ask Dr Roworth.
But they said no.
It was not a flat no. After listening to the evidence that we had, and after examining the biological plausibility, they concluded that that was not necessary.
How many allegations about ill health were you dealing with?
As I say, SEPA is not a health expert. The evidence went to Perth and Kinross Council.
The minutes indicate that you were considering five cases. Is that correct?
I believe that that was the initial evidence.
Were there any subsequent cases?
No. No cases were identified to me, personally, although there may have been others.
The minutes refer to trying to pin addresses on a map to see wind direction, or whatever, and the figure five is mentioned. However, the Blairingone and Saline Action Group representatives have stated that they submitted a list of around 30 cases. Did you ever see that list?
No. Not at any time.
Were you concerned to any extent that there was no involvement of the people who had originally complained?
Not at the end of the second meeting. It would perhaps have been ideal to have had such involvement, but the medical opinion was firmly that that was not required.
Was the contractor, Snowie Ltd, contacted?
Not during the EHIT process.
Not by you or by anyone.
No. We are in regular contact with Snowie over other matters, so we are aware of the types of waste and the quantity that is being spread.
But the contractor was not visited or called during the EHIT process.
No.
Why not?
That was the decision of the EHIT as a whole.
Did you find the contractor not open about what was happening?
No. The contractor is generally very open.
I am not trying to infer otherwise. We have been to see the company and we found it to be open about what it is doing. Did any member of the team visit Blairingone? Or did the team visit Blairingone?
Not that I am aware of. The team certainly did not, although some members may have done.
Did anyone suggest that a questionnaire should be circulated to the villagers?
Not to my recollection.
What would you say is the population of Blairingone, roughly?
Two or three hundred, perhaps.
So it would have been quite easy to circulate a questionnaire.
Yes.
There would be no more than about 100 houses. Did you think that you were rather short-funded to conduct such an investigation?
The funding was adequate for the initial study that was held. There was no question about that. To go into a second stage would have required considerable funding.
Did you agree with your then chief executive, Ms Henton, who stated afterwards that things should be looked at again because of the lack of public involvement?
Afterwards—yes.
You agree that Mr Duncan Hope was not invited to attend while the EHIT was functioning, nor was any representative of the Blairingone and Saline Action Group.
That is correct. They were not invited to attend during the EHIT's considerations. Afterwards, several attempts were made to invite along members of BASAG. The door was left open.
I know, but the EHIT had virtually finished by saying that it was not moving to the next stage.
Yes, but it was made clear that the door was still open.
Was that because of the public outcry? Was that basically a public relations exercise, following the controversy?
It was not to do with a public outcry. It was to do with the fact that it would have been desirable for people to meet members of the EHIT directly.
Afterwards?
Afterwards, to find out—
But just to be told why you had decided to virtually close down the study.
That is not the case. There was the chance for any new evidence to be considered.
Would Dr Roworth like to respond? Were only five cases considered? Why did you not think that there was justification for pursuing the matter? Mr Roxburgh said that a medical decision was taken, not a SEPA decision.
At the end of the EHIT's first meeting, organisations were asked to forward any statistical information or allegations of ill health to Tayside NHS Board, which had assumed the lead in taking forward the issue; that was correct, because Blairingone is in the Tayside area.The only information on health matters that I received related to letters of complaint concerning allegations from four or five households in the Blairingone area. The letters contained a number of allegations concerning a range of diseases. Some of the allegations concerned skin diseases; some concerned viral infections; some related to miscellaneous health problems. That is all the information that I received. I also received, from Clackmannanshire Council, information that related wholly to issues of nuisance and which did not contain any health-related matters.I am not aware of any list with 30 names on it; I have never seen it. Today is the first time that I have heard of the existence of that list; it certainly was not forwarded to me. That is all the information that we had. We would of course have considered any further information. We wanted to ensure that we received everything.It would have been difficult to carry out a survey, on a scientific basis, based on the information that we had. We knew from the information that we had gathered and considered that the conditions that had been cited as links to what was happening in Blairingone were, in all probability, not related, and that the conditions described could not plausibly be linked to what was happening. On that basis, we felt that it would not be appropriate to do a survey.
My questions are for Mr Roxburgh. If I have understand you correctly, SEPA did not consider there to be evidence that the operations posed a health risk.
SEPA is not qualified to assess health risks. That is why we were keen for an EHIT to be formed to consider the medical evidence.
As I understood it, you said that the aim was to determine whether there was a health risk. I think that you went on to say that there was not one.
That is certainly the message that we received from the medical experts.
How was that situation arrived at and what determined that there was no health risk? Did you consult the medical profession or the local general practitioners?
That is a question for Dr Roworth and the medical experts. We simply wanted a yes or no answer from the EHIT.
The information that you are giving us this morning is based on the response of the EHIT, is it?
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Feb 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 11 February 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 361
- New Petitions Petitions · 65
- New Petitions Petitions · 46
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 23
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Inadmissible Petition Petitions · 1
- Convener's Report Procedure · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.