Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Elderly People (Residential and Respite Care) (PE551)

Tuesday 28 January 2003 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 23 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

23 contributions
John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Our next petition is PE551, from Pat Brown, on care of the elderly. It relates to South Ayrshire Council's decision to close St Meddan's Court in Troon which, when the petition was first received, housed 16 residents. It says that the council used the home's inability to meet standards that are required by the Regulation of Care (Scotland) Act 2001 as a reason for the closure. We have written to the Scottish Executive, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the Scottish Commission for the Regulation of Care. They have all responded, as detailed in the papers before members. Before I turn to the suggested action and response to the letters from the three bodies, a number of members want to speak.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

As far as the committee was concerned, the key issue from the first hearing was whether the Regulation of Care (Scotland) Act 2001 was having unintended consequences by putting councils in a position whereby they could not afford to bring residential homes up to the new standards. It appears that in the case of St Meddan's Court in Troon, the council's version of events is not accurate. The care commission carried out a formal inspection of the home in November and, consequently, the home has been reissued with its registration under the new act. It was registered under the new act last April, so it would appear that the unintended consequences of the act have not come to pass. The council's reasons for closing the home are not related to the new act—that is the substance of the matter. It is clear that local politicians have been taking up the matter and challenging the council about its decision and the reasons for it.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

I welcome the Public Petitions Committee's investigation of the matter. I am concerned that the Regulation of Care (Scotland) Act 2001 appears to be creating such situations not just at St Meddan's Court but elsewhere. I am also concerned that the council appears to have jumped the gun, because planning permission was given by the council's planning committee before the committee heard the petition.However, I believe that the council has probably acted properly in terms of the law and the regulations that will need to be adhered to by 2007, but I am naturally dismayed that nine old people might have to be removed forcibly from their homes on 1 April. I do not understand why there has been such a rush to do a deal, especially after the matter was raised at the committee and after the planning application was called in.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We are in a very fluid situation, which has changed even since the papers were issued to members. For example, the response from the care commission, which is detailed in the papers that have been given to us, did not make the point that the home has now been reregistered, so we did not appreciate that fact before the meeting. The position indicated is that the council was prepared to see the residents remain together as a group in Troon.An update from the council has been given to the clerk. I shall say what it contains, because it is not in the papers that members have. The council intends to go ahead with the proposal to close the home and move the residents. An alternative facility will be provided at Crosby Towers. Residents will move as a group, they will remain in Troon and they will have the same staff; those are the three requests that the residents made. The Executive has called in the planning application for the Hanover Housing Association development, which is standard practice, given the council's involvement in it. The care commission carried out its regulation inspection of St Meddan's Court in November. The council received that last week and is considering its response, but the document is not yet in the public domain. The registration process has already begun in relation to the new accommodation.The constant drip of information into the committee makes it difficult for us to arrive at a clear position. The petition touches on other petitions that we currently have before us, for example PE576, the recently submitted PE599—which is not yet on the agenda, but will be on a future agenda—and another petition that the committee received recently. It is suggested that we link PE551 to those other petitions, on some of which we await responses from the Executive. We should deal with all the petitions when we can see the picture that is emerging around Scotland. The clerk has reminded me that it must be stressed that we cannot act as a court of appeal against decisions that are taken by South Ayrshire Council. It is for the council, as the elected authority in the area, to take those decisions; we cannot countervail those decisions. We must consider the legislative framework and see whether there are lessons to be learned.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I accept that we cannot make a judgment on the matter and that it is the council's responsibility. However, I feel that South Ayrshire Council has acted in a most inappropriate way in coming to a settlement on the funding and on the planning process while the committee is still in the process of deciding on the matter as it was waiting for information to come back from the Scottish Executive. It seems to me that the information from the Scottish Executive conflicts with the information that was originally provided for councillors. On that basis, the committee should write back in the strongest terms to say to South Ayrshire Council that we feel that we have been railroaded and that the council has not given the committee its due recognition.I make the point that within the council both the planning application and the funding for the sale of the land were queried by councillors; a vote was taken and it went ahead. There was a challenge. The council was made aware of the Public Petitions Committee's involvement, so it seems to me to be a bit off that it has gone ahead with its decision.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am reminded that we made it clear when we received the petition that it is not our job to question decisions that are arrived at by the local elected authority. We certainly did not ask the council not to go ahead with the process. It would therefore be wrong for the committee to write back now to complain that the council has done so, because we did not ask it not to. We have on previous occasions asked health boards or whoever to suspend any action on their proposals until we have had the chance to consult, but we did not ask South Ayrshire Council to do that. It would be wrong to write back to it now on that basis.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I am not sure that I agree with that. South Ayrshire Council was made aware that the committee found it surprising that the care regulations were leading to such a conclusion's being drawn by the council. I used the word courtesy—I did not say that the council had breached any agreements or ignored any comment. It seems to me that as a matter of courtesy to the Parliament and to the committee the council should perhaps have held off until the Scottish Executive had responded; it might have given the council for backing for its actions. The Scottish Executive has not responded.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is perfectly reasonable for us to write to South Ayrshire Council to draw Phil Gallie's remarks to its attention and to say that although we did not ask it not to proceed, perhaps as a matter of courtesy—as Phil Gallie suggested—it might not have done so.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

If you write to the council, I want to make clear that I do not agree with Phil Gallie's comments. The Parliament, the Public Petitions Committee and any legislative changes that the Parliament makes would have no impact on the decision on St Meddan's Court in Troon. The council has taken its decision. We have always said as a committee that we have no locus in changing decisions that are made at local level. We have always made it clear that we would have a serious concern if there were a lack of consultation, but that has not been suggested in the petition.I have had experience with the care commission. We must remember what its remit is. We have a high regard for the care commission in that we want it to succeed and we want to ensure that it delivers quality provision throughout Scotland for our elderly people. One thing that I have found in my work in my area—we have seen it on television and in the newspapers—is that there are terrible examples of the ways in which old people have been treated in some homes. We have also seen examples of the staff being treated abysmally and trade union rights being thrown out of the window. We must bear it in mind that the care commission has a job to do and that we need to support it in that job. However, we ought not to ask local authorities—whether in Troon, Fife or Strathclyde—to reverse their decisions. If, as a consequence of the impact of changes, we decide that we do not like what is happening, we can go back and change the legislation. Nothing is written on tablets of stone. However, the committee has always said that it will not tell councils to change their decisions.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We have always been absolutely clear that the committee has no power to ask another elected body to reverse a decision that it has taken. It is for the elected authority to take its decisions. Phil Gallie wants his remarks drawn to South Ayrshire Council's attention. It is reasonable to draw its attention to his remarks and to yours.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

No, not as the committee's remarks. I am not taking that kind of decision.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

If other committee members feel as I do about the way that the committee is being ignored, I must make the point that, never at any time did the committee ask the council to reverse its decision. The committee questioned the information that was passed to councillors at the time that the council reached that decision. We also asked for clarification from the Scottish Executive.We have received something less than clarification. It seems to me that it is quite reasonable for the council to make its own decisions without our challenging them, but it should have cleared with its councillors the reasons for and the legitimacy of the actions that it was taking. On that basis, I appeal to other committee members to add to my feelings on the matter.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The Official Report of this part of the meeting will be sent to the council. If anyone wants to add their views at this point, they can do so, but the committee cannot decide to reprimand or call into question the action of a council as an elected body. Our job is to consider the bigger picture. The substance of the recommendation from the clerks is that we link the petition to the other petitions on the same matter and thereby continue our consideration of the petition. We will decide what we should do in response to all the petitions on the matter, not just PE551.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I accept that we should continue, but I am surprised that no other committee member feels that the job that we were doing on the petition was worth pursuing to the end. I register my disappointment that no other committee member—

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I back Phil Gallie on that. We have heard many other examples of old persons homes closing down. Another one was mentioned earlier this morning.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will send an Official Report to show that members have indicated their support or lack of it.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

Would a point of information be in order?

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

Helen Eadie mentioned that there may or may not have been a problem with consultation. I emphasise that there was a problem with lack of consultation. Essentially, the council informed the home's residents that the home had to close. The reason that was given was that the council could not afford to bring the home up to the new national standards that are required under the Regulation of Care (Scotland) Act 2001. There was no consultation of residents.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

That was why the committee agreed to proceed with the petition. I accept John McAllion's point about the big picture—that is about consultation, but it is also about ensuring that we have quality provision. There is no point in lots of homes being opened throughout the country if their quality and standards do not match those that the Parliament has set down.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

As it happens, in this case, the care commission has—

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We know. We will have to write to the petitioners to tell them the latest position. We will draw to their attention the fact that they have access to the Scottish public services ombudsman if they believe that the council has acted improperly in the way that Adam Ingram has described. However, it is for the petitioners to access the ombudsman. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 28 January 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 2
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 64
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 27
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 45
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 30
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 42
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 119
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 23
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  13. Inadmissible Petition Petitions · 4
  14. Convener's Report Procedure · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.