PE512, which is from Mr George Reid, calls on the Parliament to endorse the Ministry of Defence's 1989 guidance that defines the blue of the saltire as azure, and urges the Executive to publish guidance on the matter.We have received a response from the Deputy First Minister on behalf of the Executive, a further letter from the petitioner and a letter from the Heraldry Society of Scotland. Members can see from the responses that the minister restated the Executive's view that it is not convinced that guidance is necessary or would be helpful. The Executive feels that the current position, which allows flexibility, is appropriate and satisfactory. The petitioner has provided a copy of a draft code that was produced by the St Andrew Society and the Saltire Society, which defines the saltire's colour and dimensions. We have several alternatives to consider. The first is to accept the minister's response as reasonable and take no further action on the petition. The second is to establish whether a subject committee would be willing to consider the petition further. Members will remember that the Education, Culture and Sport Committee declined to consider a similar petition but, at that time, it believed that the matter was reserved to Westminster. The Lord Lyon has made it clear that the matter is devolved to the Scottish Parliament, so we could pass the petition to that committee, which might be prepared to reconsider the issue.The third option is to suggest to the petitioner that the most realistic way to make progress is for organisations such as the St Andrew Society, the Saltire Society and the Heraldry Society of Scotland to agree and promote a voluntary code along the lines of those that have been submitted to the committee. That is open for discussion. I see our good friend at the back. Would Gil Paterson like to speak?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Saltire (PE512)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McAllion Lab 5
- Gil Paterson SNP 4
- Phil Gallie Con 3
The record
12 contributionsI would not mind. I could help the committee somewhat by providing graphic illustrations of the problem with the Scottish flag's colour. From my business, I have gathered a small number of colours that are called azure. Mr Wallace suggests that the recommendation should remain that Scottish flag manufacturers should use azure. I will illustrate the problem of doing that if the colour is not given a reference number.With the convener's indulgence, I will pass him a small number of colour references—I could have filled the place with them—which he can pass round. Members should take one colour reference—I have marked each azure with a small sticker—and put another colour reference on top of it, then see the difference. I have retained three reference guides to illustrate the problem. The first, light colour is called azure, as are the second and third colours. One colour is almost black, one is not quite white, but is very light, and one is right in the middle. We cannot ask a manufacturer to pick a colour by referring to azure.
The Saltire Society, the St Andrew Society and the Heraldry Society have suggested Pantone 300 unglazed as azure.
I was about to come to that. The important aspect of colour is not the name that it is given. The colour can be called whatever we like—Scottish flag blue, azure blue, sky blue, egg blue or duck blue. What is important is attaching a number to the colour. I recommend that the committee should go along the lines of the draft code, which suggests Pantone 300. That is an internationally recognised standard. If you phone up a manufacturer in Brazil, India or any other country and say, "I want you to manufacture something in Pantone 300," they know exactly what you mean. We can attach a new name to it—we can call it Scottish flag blue or azure blue—but that is irrelevant. The important thing that the Executive must do is to attach a number. It is the Executive's responsibility. No one else has that responsibility.I do not suggest that we take down and tear up flags because they do not match Pantone 300. I suggest that if anyone approaches the Scottish Executive and says, "We want to manufacture flags using the Scottish colours. What do we use?" the Executive should say, "Pantone 300." Whether it is called azure blue or sky blue is irrelevant. If we attach a number, we all win.
We all take the point that Gil Paterson makes. It is very well made, understandable and clear. It is also clear that the Executive is aware of the matter and still does not believe that it has the responsibility to do anything about it. We must decide whether to pass the petition to the Education, Culture and Sport Committee for its consideration or to suggest that the different organisations come together to set up a voluntary code and seek to get it recognised. In my opinion, we should pass the petition to the Education, Culture and Sport Committee. It should be given the opportunity to take the matter up. We would have to consult that committee. It previously declined the petition simply because it thought that the matter was reserved to Westminster. It clearly is not; it is a matter for the Scottish Parliament. The Education, Culture and Sport Committee is the appropriate committee for the petition.
We are always talking about passing on issues to other committees and the difficulties that they have in coping with our petitions. Far be it from me to support Labour and Liberal Democrat ministers, but I honestly think that we are as well leaving the matter alone. I accept Gil Paterson's point and the technical argument to a degree. However, the matter is too complicated. We are talking about 400 years of history. Why should we suddenly put a number on the colour now? We seem to have got along fine without one. I remind members—Gil Paterson will not like this point so much—that we would have to ensure that our blue matched the union flag. I do not know what the number is for the union flag.
The colour of the union flag is a matter for the union Parliament, not this one. I suppose that we have no real views on that.
Perhaps I could help Phil Gallie. The colour of the saltire is irrelevant to the union flag. The union flag also has a standard. It has numbers attached to it. The union flag, the English flag, the American flag and every flag that I know have number references. We do not see different colours of American, English or union flags.
Does the union flag blue have a number?
Yes.
I suggest that we just take the union flag blue.
It is for the Education, Culture and Sport Committee to make the ultimate decision, as it deals with such matters. I suggest that we ask that committee if it is interested in taking the petition. If it is not, we can come to some kind of decision.Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Jan 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 14 January 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 2
- Convener's Report Procedure · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 58
- New Petitions Petitions · 62
- New Petitions Petitions · 53
- New Petitions Petitions · 29
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 1
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.