Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Scottish Law (Protection of Minors) (PE565)

Tuesday 3 December 2002 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 66 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

66 contributions
Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

For PE565, I invite Jacqueline, Mark and Karen Shields to come to the desk. I welcome you to the committee this morning. We are always pleased to welcome young visitors in particular.Your petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to take the necessary steps to provide a protective mechanism to ensure that the welfare concerns of minors are paramount in Scottish law. I invite Miss Jacqueline Shields to present her petition.You have three minutes. After that, the committee will ask you questions. The members will then deliberate on how they would like to proceed with the petition.

Jacqueline Shields
link

My name is Jacqueline Shields. I am 12 years of age. I am here today with my brother and sister, who are helping me to present the petition.I have been fighting for years to stay with my dad. While that has been happening, I have felt that wrong decisions have been made on my behalf. They have been made when I have had no counsel acting for me.Jill Carrick, my mother's lawyer, has used the threat of sheriff officers and police to remove me from my father's against my free will on a number of occasions. She has wrongly advised my mother that that is the correct action to take, even though it has been extremely frightening, depressing and stressful for me. It has been a mentally abusive time for me.I ran away numerous times in the past year because I felt unsafe while with my mother. Police officers have physically threatened to take me back. On one occasion, two male police officers took me away in a police car at night, which was extremely frightening for me. They gave me no time to get representation.As I add all this up, it all points to the actions of Jill Carrick, my mother's lawyer. She advised my mother to call police and social workers and to have sheriff officers take me back to a place where I feel unsafe. Jill Carrick has stood up in court knowing that I wish to stay with my dad and made up all sorts of lies about why I should remain with my mother. Because of that lawyer's actions, I have had to stand up in court and give hurtful and upsetting reasons why I wish to stay with my dad. Even then, it was still granted that I should return to my mother's.Jill Carrick has spoken in court as a witness to the horrible and distressing times that my mother and I have had. She has ruined the relationship between my mother and me forever. Those arguments—not just wee silly ones, but emotionally disturbing ones—have occurred behind closed doors, where only my mother and I were present.I have had my mother threatening on many occasions that she will speak to Jill and stop me seeing my dad, my brother and sister for good. That has been extremely frightening.Jill Carrick has corruptly distorted facts to put me under extreme mental pressure, with the help of other professionals, who have provided false accounts of my family's circumstances.I ask the Scottish Parliament to investigate why my views and wishes have been totally ignored, and why I have been separated for long periods of time from my father, my brother and my sister because of lies, deceit and corruption.Tens of thousands of pounds in legal aid have been used to fund the emotional harm that has been done to me over the past seven years. I enclose a list of legal firms, which includes the Scottish Child Law Centre, which have refused to act for me. That has allowed the continued abuse of my rights by this lawyer's actions.

Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

Thank you. It is a bit unfortunate that a professional has been named in the committee. Wherever possible, we try to avoid that. I ask both members and witnesses not to name the individual professionals who have been involved, but to keep to the general issues. The committee has the responsibility of sticking to the general issues.With that, I thank Jacqueline Shields. Members may now ask questions.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Have you heard of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995?

Jacqueline Shields
link

Could you repeat that?

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Have you heard about the Children (Scotland) Act 1995? Let us just call it the children's act of the mid-1990s.

Jacqueline Shields
link

Yes.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I might be wrong, but that act states that the courts must take into account the opinions of children of eight years and over. When you have been involved in the legal process, what kind of contact have you had with the sheriffs who have been making the judgment? Have they taken you aside or into a separate room and found out what was on your mind?

Jacqueline Shields
link

No. When my mum and dad were there, I have said in court why I would like to stay with my dad, but I have not actually been taken into another room.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

The sheriffs have tried to find out what was on your mind and they have still gone against your wishes.

Jacqueline Shields
link

Yes.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I am trying to make the point that the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 was meant to address the fact that youngsters' opinions should be registered and accepted by the courts. If this case is typical then it gives me some concern about the workings of the act.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Jacqueline, thank you for a well-put presentation. I know that it is not easy. I would like to clarify one or two points. There are three members of your family here. Are all of you living with your mother or your father? How is it working?

Mark Shields
link

At the moment, I am a student at the University of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology. The situation is now worse, because my mum has custody of my sister. My dad is only supposed to have access from 11 until 7 on Saturdays.

Mark Shields
link

Yes. I only get home at certain times of the year, when I am on holiday.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Your mother has custody of your younger sister. Did she have custody of you two until you reached adulthood?

Mark Shields
link

No, and that is why the situation is so bad. I was of a similar age to my sister when my parents first separated. At that point I was allowed to express an opinion, so I said that I wanted to stay with my father. That is why I have to question why, when Jacqueline is now 12 years of age, she is not being allowed to express her opinion.

Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

I interrupt to ask you whether you are here to talk about the wider issue or just about your specific circumstances?

Mark Shields
link

I am just explaining the situation.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I asked the question in order to see if their situation is related to a wider problem.How old is your other sister?

Karen Shields
link

I am 23.

Karen Shields
link

I was 16 and I have lived on my own.

Karen Shields
link

I lived with my father.

Karen Shields
link

He was living in the family home, so it seemed natural that we would choose to stay there.

Karen Shields
link

Jacqueline lived with her father at first and my mother got custody and took Jacqueline to live in a women's aid refuge rather than letting her stay at home with her family.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Did any legal or other so-called professional consult you and Mark about Jacqueline's situation?

Karen Shields
link

Not at that time.

Mark Shields
link

That happened later on after custody was awarded. It has been like a game of tennis—backwards and forwards. She used to be allowed a two-night stay over; then it was a one-night stay over.When I was about 15, a social work report was done and I complained about it because I felt that it had misreported me. It said that I had failed to elucidate and elaborate on certain situations, when I had explained. If they felt that they needed any more information they should have asked me.

Mark Shields
link

Yes.

Mark Shields
link

Basically they were asking me about the situation at home to try and find out who was more suitable to take responsibility for Jacqueline. Their report missed out a lot of events that I told them about. When I complained to the social work department, I was told that because there were two social workers, my interpretation of the situation was wrong. The worst thing about it was that they said that because I was a child—I was a teenager at the time—my interpretation was wrong. If they responded like that when they were questioning me at age 15, what are the chances of their properly reporting my sister, who is much younger?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Are you trying to raise the issue that a child of over 12 years of age should have the right to their own lawyer? Is that one of the things that you are saying?

Jacqueline Shields
link

Yes. I have tried lawyers—I have a list here—but none would act for me or get back to me about the matter. I have waited for a month or so without receiving a reply. I phoned a couple of lawyers, but they said that they could not become involved.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Currently, you do not legally have the right to your own lawyer. Are you asking for the law to be changed to give you that right?

Mark Shields
link

Basically, she wants the right to choose where to live. She can achieve that only by legal means, as any question that arises about where she can live goes back to the court. I do not see how she can attack the problem in any way other than by legal means through a lawyer.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The courts have a duty in respect of a child's welfare and well-being. That is the law, so the law has not been disobeyed. The problem is that Jacqueline is one of many people in custody who is not happy with that custody. Currently, the law allows the court to make a judgment.The petition refers to the Scottish Child Law Centre. Have you been there, Jacqueline?

Jacqueline Shields
link

I contacted it for advice.

Jacqueline Shields
link

Yes. It gave me telephone numbers, which I phoned. However, the lawyers whom I phoned either told me that they could not act for me or did not get back to me.

Jacqueline Shields
link

Yes.

Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

We are considering the more general issue of access rights. To pick up on what Dr Ewing said, legal representation exists in specific circumstances only, in respect of children's hearings. Would you like that representation to be extended? Is that the more general issue that should be addressed?

Jacqueline Shields
link

I would like to have representation that I could trust and would like to know that my representation would go to court and say where I want to stay.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I have been taking notes. Am I right to assume that you blame the legal process that you have gone through and the actions of lawyers for worsening your relationship with your mother, for instance, and that that relationship might even be better if you had not been subjected to things that you say the legal side did? Is that assumption fair or unfair?

Jacqueline Shields
link

I think that my mother's lawyer, Jill, has affected matters. Even when I said that I wanted to stay with my dad and ran away, my mum received advice from her about what to do.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

If you and your mother only talked about things without intervention, do you think that things might be better?

Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

We do not want to put the petitioner in a difficult position. I sense that she feels uncomfortable, so we will leave that question, although she can answer it if she wants to.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I want to return to what I said about the 1995 act. I was wrong to say that a child's opinion should be registered from the age of eight—it appears that it should be taken into consideration from the age of 12. Jacqueline, you are now 12, so perhaps things will improve from now on. However, problems arose for you from the age of seven or eight. Do you think that, when you were eight, you were in a position to make it clear—to whoever asked—what you wanted to do?

Jacqueline Shields
link

No, I do not think so.

Mark Shields
link

At the time of the separation, one problem that arose was that Jacqueline wanted to see both parents—as I did—but people did not look at the whole picture and take into account the opinions of the family about our mum's mental state and how fit she is to be a parent.They said, "Okay, Jacqueline wants to see both parents, so we'll give custody to her mother", even though, under the circumstances, both parents should have had equal access. Parental responsibility for Jacqueline's welfare should have been with my father. That is the main problem. None of the family has direct contact with my mum; even if I come up and visit from university, my sister and I cannot see each other whenever we want. My mum is using her control to prevent Jacqueline from having fair access to all the family, which is something that she deserves.

Karen Shields
link

My mother is using the legal process to do that. When families split up, there is a lot of emotional tug-of-war between parents. The court mediates that situation in the child's best interests, but only for a short term. What usually happens is that couples that have split up will eventually agree their own arrangements as the emotional tension eases. However, the situation with my mother has worsened and, instead of her lawyer advising her to address Jacqueline's feelings, she has continued to allow my mum to stand in court—

Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

I am sorry to interrupt you, but I must point out that we want to examine the more general issues that are contained in the petition. We do not want to get involved in cases on which courts have already ruled. We are asking you for evidence on wider issues. Your useful evidence has focused attention on some of the more important general issues, and I think that members might have gathered enough information to consider those. Unless you have anything more to say on the general issues, I thank you for your evidence.I remind members that the Parliament is unable to investigate the particular circumstances around the petitioner's case. However, should the petitioner's evidence appear to suggest that the current system contains general inadequacies, the committee might wish to agree to write to the Scottish Executive, seeking its views in relation to the issues raised in the petition, with a particular request for clarification of the existing rights of children to legal representation under the European convention on human rights and the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 in the types of cases highlighted by the petitioner. We might also ask for an indication whether the recent Court of Session ruling on article 6 of the ECHR in certain cases before children's panels has any implications for the rights of children in parental responsibility cases. We might also ask for confirmation of how the views of children up to and beyond the age of 12 are currently taken into account when major decisions about parental responsibility are taken, together with an indication as to what constitutes a "major decision". Finally, we might ask for details of the Executive's position on the adequacy of the current measures aimed at protecting the welfare rights of children in parental responsibility cases, together with an indication whether any improvements in the current system are planned.The committee might also wish to seek comments about the adequacy of the current system from the Scottish Child Law Centre, the Scottish Alliance for Children's Rights and the cross-party group on children.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I agree with all those actions. Indeed, I was going to suggest the last point myself.The third course of action suggests that we ask the Executive to confirm how the views of children up to and beyond the age of 12 are currently taken into account. However, it seems to me that the petition is asking that children have a right of review at their request when they turn 12. Can we make that clearer in our letter?

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I agree with the suggested courses of action. Indeed, Dr Ewing's point is well made.My only question was perhaps undercut by a comment from Jacqueline Shields. During the passage of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995, I wondered whether it was correct to set the age limit at 12, and whether children should be able to make up their minds a bit earlier than that. However, one has to acknowledge the emotional upset of such a time. Perhaps we should ask the Executive whether it would be reasonable to lower the age limit just a little bit.

Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

That is fair enough. We can accept that.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

It is alarming that we have heard two similar complaints today about professional misconduct, whether that is about the Law Society of Scotland or some other organisation. That seems to be a regular presentation, and we should take it more seriously and ask questions, rather than just dismissing it.

Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

The Justice 1 Committee has conducted an inquiry into misconduct and the legal profession, and it is in the process of producing a report on that. We could point you to that.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

We have heard today about problems that go wider than the legal profession.

Helen Eadie Lab The Deputy Convener · Dunfermline East
link

I thank the petitioners. It is always a harrowing experience for anyone to come before the Public Petitions Committee, but particularly for younger people. You have done very well, Jacqueline, and I thank you and your brother and sister for appearing today. We will report back to you so that you will know exactly what is happening.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 3 December 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 2
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 74
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 65
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 70
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 66
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 23
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 18
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  13. Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 1
  15. Convener's Report Procedure · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.