Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Domestic Abuse (Support) (PE560)

Tuesday 19 November 2002 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 112 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

112 contributions
John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

On the rejigged agenda, the next petition is from Claire Houghton on behalf of Scottish Women's Aid. The petition calls on the Parliament to take the necessary steps to provide and ensure adequate long-term funding for support workers who deal with children and young people who experience domestic abuse. Claire Houghton cannot be here this morning because of illness, but Margaret Donovan, Frances Tait, Mary Jones and Heather Coady are here in support of the petition.

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

Margaret Donovan will make an introductory statement, which might not last for three minutes, but Frances Tait will take over from her.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That is fine—there is no rush.

Margaret Donovan
link

Good morning. I think that there should be more children's workers in Scotland, because I have heard that Women's Aid has to turn families away if there is not enough room in a refuge. Such families might well go back to situations in which there is domestic abuse. The advert on television about domestic abuse includes children. However, if children phone up for help they might not get it because there are only three outreach workers and six follow-on workers in Scotland. Children who have suffered from domestic abuse should have a follow-on worker. I have one and she really helps me. She gives me confidence and helps me with problems. She is somebody other than my mum, brother and sister to talk to.No extra money is being given for work with children. I enjoy the group that I go to, which also helps me and gives me confidence. It would be nice if other children could be given that chance. Children are all lumped together in the children's refuge. There is a pre-fives group, a five to 11s group and a young person's group in one playroom. They should be in separate rooms and it would be better if there was a separate worker for different age groups. I know about ChildLine, but there should be a phoneline so that workers who understand what young people are going through can give them support. There should be a drop-in centre for young people to discuss problems, display their work and carry out activities in their own space. Someone should always be there and there should be lots of space. Young people should be able to drop in or phone at any time. They should have 24-hour support.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Thank you very much. That was excellent—first class.

Frances Tait North Ayrshire Women's Aid
link

I have worked with children and young people in Women's Aid for more than 14 years. Developments in children's work have been slow. There are many opportunities to expand, as our children's and young people's services are still fragmented. Eight groups in Scotland do not have a children's worker to provide basic support for children who witness or suffer domestic violence; children in a refuge need that support. We still do not have an adequate number of children's and young people's follow-on and outreach workers. Children in the transition period of moving from a refuge to their own homes need support to move on. Sometimes children start to open up about the abuse that they have suffered only when they leave the refuge. Children need support at that point, but we have only six follow-on workers and three outreach workers in Scotland.Children and young people who are in a refuge face considerable pressure at school. Some children cope well, but others do not. Some have to move to different schools and different refuges three, four, five or six times to escape the violence. We have started to include work on domestic abuse in the school curriculum, but even when it is in the curriculum and children hear about it in school, there are no workers in the classroom to support children who are living with abuse.Many children's workers are part time and funding can be short term. A lot of children's workers work in a refuge for only 10 hours. There could be 15 children in the refuge, so there is not much time for each child. If there is only short-term funding from various sources, there is no continuity for these vulnerable children. The quality and effectiveness of our service are important for many children and young people. We need to address all the gaps in our service for the sake of the children. If we are to work effectively for children, we need commitment and resources. Action must be taken on their behalf. Although there are many children's workers in Women's Aid, it is obvious that there are not enough. Each child who comes to our service has the expectation that they are going to get help and support, but sometimes we cannot give it. It is hard to turn children away. I support eight young people in a support group, but the group has a long waiting list. It is hard to tell children who experience domestic abuse that I will be able to give them support only in a few months.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Thank you. We hear from many petitioners in the committee, but Margaret Donovan is as good a petitioner as we have seen.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Most of your evidence related to the aftermath of discovering that domestic abuse is taking place. Margaret Donovan mentioned a helpline—does that not exist in most parts of Scotland? The initial problem is enabling a child who has been abused to get in touch with someone. Does some of that contact come through teachers' referrals? How difficult is it for children to get in touch with someone? Where I live there is a good neighbourhood watch scheme, which falls within the jurisdiction of the chief constable. Is there a way of joining the services that already exist with neighbourhood watch schemes, which have telephone lines and volunteers?

Frances Tait North Ayrshire Women's Aid
link

As members may know, domestic abuse is a sensitive issue that needs to be tackled in its own right. We have a domestic abuse helpline for adults and some children and teenagers also use it. However, those who answer the calls are not experienced children's workers who can answer the callers' questions. Some children phone ChildLine, but often they do not get through. Some children want an answer there and then—they do not want to have to wait for an answer.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

From the evidence that the witnesses have given, it appears that the big gaps exist before someone enters a refuge—there are children's workers at refuges, although not enough of them—and after they leave. Young people want to deal continuously with the same person. How can we provide that continuity, given that folk move to different refuges if they are tracked down? How can we build trust between a children's worker and a young person?

Frances Tait North Ayrshire Women's Aid
link

It is hard to provide such continuity. I work part time in a refuge for only 15 hours and it is hard to deal on a continuous basis with the children who are there. We are now trying to do follow-up work with children when they leave the refuge. I work with children for six or eight weeks after they have left the refuge. Unfortunately, because of the limited time that children's workers have to work with children, they cannot provide continuity of support. It would be wonderful to have two full-time children's workers in the refuge. Eight of our refuges do not have even one children's worker. It is hard to provide continuity of support when the basics are not in place.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

What kind of training and skills does a children's worker need? How long does it take to train someone to be a children's worker?

Frances Tait North Ayrshire Women's Aid
link

Training varies throughout Scotland. Scottish Women's Aid training takes a number of weeks. The national office also provides continuing specialised training for children's workers. Some children's workers have a background in child care, but others do not. Training is provided to enable them to work with children. The associated child protection issues are also addressed.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

So training is not the issue. Funding is needed to make posts permanent and to provide more of them.

Frances Tait North Ayrshire Women's Aid
link

Yes.

Margaret Donovan
link

I am 14.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

You spoke about feeling more confident once you got to know your child support worker. How did you feel before your support worker came into your life?

Margaret Donovan
link

I did not know what to do. I had no one to talk to. All my feelings just crammed up inside me, and sometimes they got the better of me. I do not know what I would do if I did not have a support worker.

Margaret Donovan
link

Yes.

Margaret Donovan
link

No.

Margaret Donovan
link

I would not say terribly.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

But your child support worker was an adult in your life different from those whom you knew already.

Margaret Donovan
link

Yes.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

You did not feel that you could tell the adults whom you knew everything about things. Do you feel that you can tell your support worker everything?

Margaret Donovan
link

Kind of, yes.

Margaret Donovan
link

No.

Margaret Donovan
link

Yes.

Margaret Donovan
link

Every week.

Margaret Donovan
link

Two hours.

Margaret Donovan
link

Yes.

Margaret Donovan
link

Yes.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I will pick up on Rhoda Grant's comments on continuity. You mentioned in the presentation that some people work as support workers for as little as 10 hours. Is that through choice, or because that is all that is on offer from the organisations that employ you?

Frances Tait North Ayrshire Women's Aid
link

The reason is funding restraints. The funding is not available for more hours. Some groups do not have funding for any more than 10 hours. Some groups may be fortunate, and be able to provide 30 or 35 hours, but quite a number of groups have a small number of hours. Some groups have no hours at all.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

If, all of a sudden, the money became available, would there be enough support workers with expertise to fill the additional posts that you seek?

Frances Tait North Ayrshire Women's Aid
link

I am sure that there would be. Of course, we give training as people come to our organisation, and we have follow-on training. There would be people who were willing to do the work. Even people who only do 10 hours would love to increase the work that they do with children.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Finally, I seek clarification, because I am not sure if I have got the picture right. We are talking about children who have witnessed domestic abuse, rather than suffered abuse themselves. No doubt some will have witnessed and suffered domestic abuse but, in the main, they have witnessed domestic abuse within households.

Frances Tait North Ayrshire Women's Aid
link

Yes. Both situations may apply but, in the main, they have witnessed abuse. They may have been in the same room or in the room next door, but the children themselves may have been abused as well. Also, children who have never been in a refuge or never used our service sometimes need support. We have workers who go into schools and talk about domestic violence. In a class there may be several children who are living with abuse at home, and they may want someone to phone or to talk to, but we do not have the resources to cover that.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Good morning. I would like to ask about resource funding. I do not know who will answer the question. I see from the background papers provided by the committee clerk that separate amounts of money—£10 million and £4.5 million—have been made available to develop support services. That is what has happened at this end, but how has that translated into reality at your end? We see that money going out, but it would appear from what we are hearing this morning that it is not really hitting the ground and allowing you to run fast enough to keep up with demand.

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

Quite a lot of money has been made available. The problem for Scottish Women's Aid is that it has gone into refuge development so, although there are more refuge places, there is no guaranteed money for support work with children, or even for support work with women. The funding is focused on buildings rather than on wages costs.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Who in Scotland is co-ordinating support work with children and ensuring that best practice is translated between local authorities?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

That is a difficult question to answer, because each of the 39 groups in Scotland is autonomous. I am one of the national children's rights officers, and the national office is working very hard to get some kind of co-ordination. It is difficult to co-ordinate a service that is patchily funded. There is no comprehensive, cohesive service at all, but that is what we are aiming for. It is difficult to have minimum standards where either no hours, or only five or 20 hours, are being spent doing children's work. The network is aware of those problems and is pushing all the time to increase funding, but it is difficult when it is not secure. What we need is secure funding. If funding runs out after a year or three years and funding for a whole new project must be applied for, that takes up a lot of energy and time. Does that answer your question?

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I suppose that, to some extent, it does. The background papers for today's meeting contain information about standards. Do you feel that those standards, if implemented, would match your expectations of how things ought to go? The Scottish Executive has clearly tried to set standards, but the issue is how those are enforced in local authority areas.

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

That is a problem. It is difficult because a lot of the groups do have some council funding, but it is minimal. There does not seem to be any mechanism to say that councils have to provide funding for those groups, so provision is mixed across the country. That is part of what we are asking. If we can have secure funding and improve the service, that could change. At the moment, it is difficult because we cannot make local authorities fund that work.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Are you saying that the service standards are probably adequate, but that the problem lies with the money that is coming from the Executive and with implementation at the grass roots? Is it just a matter of everything not coming together as it should?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

Applications to the domestic abuse service development fund require matched funding, so a bid has to go to the Scottish Executive, with councils and other groups doing the work. That is not always easy.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Could you explain matched funding?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

It means that the local council or the local domestic abuse forum can apply to the Scottish Executive for funding from that fund, but the local authority must say that it will match the funding that it gets from the Scottish Executive. The Executive is quite flexible about matched funding—it can be funding in kind—but it is still difficult for groups to get access to money. If the domestic abuse forum does not apply for the money, it does not happen.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Are there examples of what you would call best practice in Scotland that you would like to highlight?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

Yes. North Ayrshire is a good example, as there are a number of children's workers there. It is one of the lucky areas where there is a quite a cohesive service. As Frances Tait and Margaret Donovan have said, that service is still limited, but it is one of our better examples. Follow-on work is being done there and there is also work in refuges and a small amount of outreach and prevention work in schools. There are areas where there is good practice and there are councils that are committed to funding those posts, but that is not the case across the board.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

You are working at national level to oversee all of that. Who are the link people in the Scottish Executive responsible for monitoring that activity?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

Our biggest link is with the Scottish Executive crime prevention unit, which gives us most of the funding for our national office. The unit also runs the domestic abuse development fund.We are concerned that when children are involved in cases of domestic abuse, their problems can fall between departments. If domestic abuse is involved, the crime prevention unit should become involved. If the case involves children, it should go to the children and young people's group. Children's problems can disappear in between those departments, which is a problem.Given that domestic abuse impacts on children's health and education and that it can result in homelessness, social exclusion and extreme poverty, a number of departments should be taking responsibility for the issue. We would like that. We are asking the Scottish Parliament to examine the issue and find a way of identifying an appropriate funding stream.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

You spoke about the matrix of people who ought to be involved in the issue. You have helped us to highlight the need for a team approach by services and departments. The Scottish Executive needs to take a more proactive interest in the subject to ensure that the development of services reaches the parts that we want it to reach. Thank you for helping us to get to that point.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We have two small final points from Phil Gallie and Dorothy-Grace Elder.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

You mentioned 39 different groups. Are all of them related to various local authorities?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

Yes. I should have said that there are 39 affiliated groups. There are also a number of unaffiliated groups in Scotland—I think that the number is five. Each local authority area has one or more group.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Why is the subject not the responsibility of local authority social work departments? Children are all important and social work departments have a duty to look after their interests. Why do those departments not pick up their responsibilities?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

That is a hard question.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

You are not the one to answer that question—local authority social work departments should do so.

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

We work with social work departments and, depending on the area, we work closely with them.

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

If social work departments picked up the work?

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

If they picked up the responsibility and provided the service.

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

The service that we provide has been built up over many years. We have expertise and I think that we are best placed to provide the service. What we need are the resources to provide it well.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The area is specialist, Phil. Social work is overloaded with everything else.You said earlier that children and their mothers sometimes have to move three, four or five times to escape a violent man. The children therefore go to different schools. When people try to get a place in a refuge nowadays, are they shifted anywhere in Scotland? A couple of years ago, phone calls would have to be made up to Aberdeen or down to Galloway to get a Glasgow woman and her children a bed for the night in a refuge. That was because Glasgow was so overcrowded. Is that still happening?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

Yes, I think that that is still the case. Our statistics will be published in a couple of week's time. I am focusing on children, but our statistics show that thousands of the children that go with their mothers to get a refuge place are still turned away. That means that they either have to go to departments that deal with the homeless or to a different area. We do not fulfil the need that is out there.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

A couple of years ago, 9,000 women and children were turned away from your refuges in Scotland. Is the level the same today?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

Yes, although I would have to check the figure, as there are some changes to the statistics. Housing shortages mean that women and their children are staying in refuges for longer periods of time. That can have the effect of the statistics looking as if they are coming down, but it simply means that people are not getting rehoused for a year or so.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Some extra money was made available, but I seem to recall that the actual number of additional beds or rooms that were available was very small.

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

With the domestic abuse service development fund, there will be an increase, but the concern is that there will not be an increase in the money being made available to do the work.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The children are traumatised not only by the fact that they have had to move around so many times with their mothers to escape violence, but by seeing whether they can even get a place in a refuge. Are children still being sent from Glasgow to Aberdeen or to the Borders for instance?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

I shall let the local group members answer that.

Mary Jones Dunfermline Women's Aid
link

We have four women's refuges in our area and we often have to turn women and children away. We then have to use the network to find space for them and quite often that space is as far away as Inverness or Glasgow.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Do any of them get nothing at all and just go out into the night or back to the abuser?

Mary Jones Dunfermline Women's Aid
link

When people contact Women's Aid we do our very best to accommodate them where they want refuge space. If we cannot do that, we phone the network of Women's Aid groups and find them a space. Failing that, we would get in touch with the local authority provider of accommodation for the homeless.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Do you agree with your colleague that the figure of around 9,000 women and children being turned away from refuges every year in Scotland is probably going to be near the mark again when the new statistics come out?

Mary Jones Dunfermline Women's Aid
link

Yes.

Mary Jones Dunfermline Women's Aid
link

We have had to accommodate larger families for anything up to a year, because of the lack of housing stock. There are not enough houses that are big enough to accommodate a woman with, for example, six children, so those families stay in refuges longer, which means that the space is not available for families who phone up to ask for it.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

So children such as Margaret are living in limbo with the anchor of one support worker.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

In your petition, you also talk about national minimum standards of service. You gave us figures this morning, such as that there are only three outreach workers for the whole of Scotland and six follow-up workers, when it is estimated that 100,000 children suffer from domestic abuse. Are no figures, standards or criteria available? What are the correct figures and how many workers should there be?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

The Convention of Scottish Local Authorities recommended a number of refuge spaces for each area of the country. However, there are no national standards for children's support work.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

There are no national standards?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

No.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

And no one has ever drawn them together?

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

No.

Heather Coady Scottish Women’s Aid
link

When the Parliament was inaugurated in 1999 we ran a campaign in which we asked MSPs to listen to what the children had to say about their circumstances. There was consensus and broad-based support. This year we ran a "Listen Louder" campaign. We have moved on a number of years, but there has not been a significant change in the situation. There has been a little increase in the number of workers in the whole of Scotland. We urge the Scottish Parliament to put its money where its mouth is.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

We should compliment the young lady who has come before the committee this morning. It takes quite a bit of courage to come and make a presentation such as the one that you gave this morning and you did it very well, so we are very proud of you. Given the excellence of your presentation and your support team, I am sure that the committee will give your petition every bit of support that it possibly can.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

John Farquhar Munro speaks for us all in those comments. Very well done, Margaret, and everyone else. That was a very good presentation. You are free to listen to the committee's discussion about the suggested action on the petition.I draw to members' attention the suggested action. The first stage would be to approach the Executive to ask for its comments on the petition and particularly to raise the points that are set out. First we should ask about the details of the funding streams that are currently available to local groups to provide support services to children who are experiencing domestic abuse. We should also ask whether local organisations might not be in a position to apply for funding from the domestic abuse support fund because of the requirement for matched funding.Secondly, we should ask the Executive whether there are any plans to provide long-term sustainable sources, rather than project funding, to address the shortage of support workers, which the petitioners argue is likely to worsen with the expansion of refuge accommodation. Finally, we should ask for details of the measures that the Executive is taking to ensure that local authorities adopt the service standards for women and children who experience domestic abuse that are outlined in the national strategy. We could draw Helen Eadie's point about the obvious lack of co-ordination and departmental responsibility in that area to the Executive's attention and ask what it intends to do about that.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

With your permission, convener, we might state that we are very disturbed by some of the evidence that we have heard today. It does not look as if there is a profound difference in the situation from three years ago, although we welcome the small amount of funds that has been given. We have been presented with the most terribly disturbing situation.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It would be fair to say that we recognise that there have been improvements in terms of the support for additional refuge places in Scotland, but as yet there has been no funding.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

There has been support for a small number of additional refuge places, but the general scene has not changed in three and a half years.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We are trying to encourage the Executive to do something, so we should try to be nice. We should acknowledge that the Executive has allocated funds for additional refuge places, but say that we are disturbed to see that, as yet, there has been no progress in allocating funds for support workers for children who are in those refuge places.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Can we mention the terrible statistic of 9,000 women and children that Dorothy told us about?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

There is no reason why we cannot do that.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

It is expected that that statistic will be roughly the same when the new report comes out. Those figures are two years old.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will certainly draw that to the Executive's attention.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Can we highlight the outreach workers? If work is going on in schools to support children who are living with domestic abuse, and such children are being identified, we need to get the support in there. There should be outreach workers providing support before and after children go into refuges. The refuge places might attract support workers, but more work needs to be done with people before they go into refuges.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will draw the Executive's attention to the very low level of outreach workers and follow-up workers who are available to work with such children, and the absolute absence of any national standards in that respect. It is important that the Executive addresses those issues and identifies sources of revenue funding to tackle the problem.As there are no other points, I thank the witnesses for attending and for their excellent exposition of the arguments.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 19 November 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 2
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 51
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 112
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 56
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 22
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 41
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 28
  14. Convener's Report Procedure · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.