Gil Paterson is present to discuss petition PE512, so we will bring that forward. I am sorry that we are jumping about a bit on the agenda, but a large number of MSPs are in attendance this morning.Petition PE512 is from Mr George Reid and is on the saltire flag. It calls on the Parliament to endorse the 1989 guidance that the Ministry of Defence published, which defines the blue of the saltire as azure, and urges the Executive to publish guidance on the matter.The committee will remember that, initially, we received the wrong information that the matter was reserved. The Lord Lyon King of Arms said that the matter was devolved to the Scottish Parliament and we wrote back to the Executive for its views. The Deputy First Minister and Minister for Justice provided a detailed response and we also have a response from the Heraldry Society of Scotland, which backs up the Deputy First Minister. They both say that the issuing of guidance or the introduction of regulations would be unnecessary and would create more difficulties than it might solve. They believe that no evidence suggests that abuse of the design or colour of the saltire is widespread, so the Executive will not issue the proposed guidance.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Saltire (PE512)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McAllion Lab 11
- Gil Paterson SNP 9
- Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind 3
- Dr Winnie Ewing SNP 2
- Phil Gallie Con 1
The record
26 contributionsThe matter seems a wee bit trivial. I have sat through all the committee's deliberations this morning and the committee has considered some heavy matters, not least the petition on pensions. I wanted to be involved in that discussion, but I knew that I could not be.I have never claimed to be an expert on anything, but I can claim to be an expert on colour. That is my profession. I have been involved in the business of colour for 30 years. The business that I own—but no longer operate—can come up with a colour for anyone who phones from anywhere in the world. We have about 2 million formulations on record. If someone picks up the phone and calls one of my businesses, we will deliver a specific colour over the phone. That happens all day every day in my business.
No advertising is allowed here.
My business and every other business in colour operate with numbers. The system goes back to its invention by the Chinese. People do not talk greys, blues or whites, but numbers. In the UK, we talk about British standard numbers. There are German RAL colours, which are standard colours. All over the world, people work to standards. Standards exist for clothing—for the wool and the cloth that people wear—for the paint on the walls, for the cars that we drive and for print materials. We need some form of identification to work from.I am holding up the Scottish Parliament logo, which has a colour. I could call that colour one name and I am sure that everyone else would call it something different, but the person who ordered the headed paper for us would have been asked, "How much paper do you want?" and "What colour do you want the logo in?" That person would have quoted a reference number for the colour of the heading.The situation is extraordinarily strange. We in the Parliament are the only people with the authority to put a number on the colour of the Scottish flag. The petitioner is not asking for a decision for down the line, once a flag has weathered, which has been talked about. A pigment can be produced that can be put on a flag or anything and will never weather—it stays the same colour. If someone damaged their 50-year-old car today and wanted it repaired, they would want it and expect it to be repaired in the same colour. That is just how it is. The determining factor is the colour that is produced at the start—not the colour after five or 10 years of weathering—which should be of the same value.The petitioner is looking for the Parliament to take the simple responsibility for designating a colour. Every other country that I know of, including England, designates the colour of its flag.Let us suppose that Jack McConnell decides to go to America sometime next year or the year after, and someone says to him, "Glad to see you're coming, First Minister. We're going to manufacture 1,000 flags to put up on the flagpoles. What colour do you want them?" He might say, "Just make them blue." "What shade of blue?" he might then be asked. "Och, anything you like," he might reply. That would be so ridiculous. We want the answer to be, "Here's the reference number for the colour of those flags." For the Executive to put out such a stupid message to professionals all over the world, that we do not know the colour of our flag and cannot designate a reference, is highly insulting. I hate to have to go on about this—flags do not clothe us, feed us or make us rich. In fact, they do not do anything for us other than identify us. The matter may seem trivial compared with other, weighty subjects, but it is certainly petty and trivial for the Executive to supply a response such as the one that it has issued. The Executive wants its backside kicked, and its response should be sent back. It should give us a reference. It is its responsibility.
Right—that was some passion delivered there. I do not know anything about the designation of numbers to colours. You are calling for the flag colour to be designated by number. Does that mean that all flags that are produced or manufactured would have to be specified according to that number? There would then be problems of monitoring, to ensure that people abide by the specification. Any number of people in Scotland sell flags.
It is a straightforward technicality. When someone makes an order, they are asked what colour they want and they give a number.
What I am trying to get at is the fact that it would not be mandatory. The Parliament can designate a certain number of blue—
Exactly. That is the point.
But people would be free to use other numbers of blue if they wished.
You know the story of "Jack and the Beanstalk". We do not want "Jack and the Flagpole", with Jack climbing up to check the colour of all the flags.
That could not be done.
Of course not. This is not about regulation, or whether all flags are of the same colour: it is about who is responsible for designating the colour so that when flag manufacturers all over the world—a lot of flags are made in China now—make the flags, they all start off the same colour. The responsibility is not to have all the flags the same colour today, but to ensure that they are all the same colour when they are manufactured.
It happens that the saltire has been chosen, but why not solve the whole problem by switching to the lion rampant, which is much cheerier?
We would still need a colour.
We would still need a yellow—with the Queen's permission.
I call Phil Gallie.
What has the Queen got to do with it?
And we would need to consult the Lord Lyon.
I must admit that, until Gil Paterson spoke, I would have been happy to go along with Jim Wallace's comments. I then started to think about colour references. I think that Gil's approach is right. We are not talking about a mandatory colour; we are not trying to bring in regulation. All we are saying is that there should be a base colour, or standard colour—a particular number of blue—which everybody should aim for. There is an element of sense in what Gil Paterson said, which I appreciate. He has changed my opinion. That is a good thing.
And Phil Gallie is the expert on blue.
Let me suggest that, in the light of Gil Paterson's contribution, we write back to the Executive, asking it whether it would be prepared simply to designate the colour for the national flag, using numbers. That requires no monitoring or mandatory guidance. It would be a matter of designating an official colour for the Scottish flag. That is all we are asking the Executive to do.
I would be happy to give the Executive 30 years of my experience. It is there to be picked up.
I hope that you are not looking for contracts.
No.
Is that course of action agreed?Members indicated agreement.
Thank you. Let us get back to the agenda. Interruption. I am sorry, but we will have to jump around again. Another member has joined us—we are very popular this morning. We will deal with petition PE517 next.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Oct 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 8 October 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 34
- New Petitions Petitions · 79
- New Petitions Petitions · 58
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- New Petitions Petitions · 27
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 14
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 17
- Current Petitions Petitions · 26
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 1
- Convener's Report Procedure · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.