Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Audiology Services (Modernisation) (PE502)

Thursday 6 June 2002 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 83 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

83 contributions
John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I welcome everyone to the 10th meeting this year of the Public Petitions Committee. We have received apologies from John Farquhar Munro and Rhoda Grant, both of whom are attending a meeting of the Rural Development Committee. Mike Rumbles MSP has joined us this afternoon to support our first group of petitioners. Without further ado, I move straight to the first petition, which is PE502 from Fiona Stewart on behalf of the Royal National Institute for Deaf People. Ms Stewart is accompanied by Stuart Smith, who is the chief executive of the RNID, and Andrew Dewey, a sign language interpreter. I invite Fiona Stewart to make an opening statement.

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

Thank you for allowing us to attend today's meeting, as it presents a good opportunity for the RNID to make the committee aware of its concerns about audiology services and digital hearing aids. The committee will be aware of such hearing aids from various parliamentary questions and will have received campaign reports and other material on the issue.We know that the Scottish Executive is awaiting the completion of a review of audiology services. However, my chief executive and I have received countless calls and letters from the general public on the issue. Many members and non-members of the RNID want vast improvements in audiology services and the use of digital hearing aids. Many people say that they feel isolated from friends and families and wonder when people will start to listen to their needs.The situation is dire. We are very behind England and Wales in this area. The audiology service in Wales is being modernised and the service in England is being reviewed. By 2003, a third of the people in England who need digital hearing aids will be able to receive them, whereas only 1.6 per cent of people in Scotland who need them will be able to.Evidence from England suggests that hearing aid users who are given digital hearing aids experience a 40 per cent improvement in hearing quality. There are 730,000 adults in Scotland who are deaf or hard of hearing, which is one in five of the adult population. In England, 20 hospitals already provide digital hearing aids and £10 million has been provided to allow 45 more hospitals to incorporate digital technology in their audiology services. Moreover, in England the price of digital hearing aids has been reduced to £150.Now is the time for the Scottish Executive to make a firm commitment to review audiology services and examine the provision of digital hearing aids. Why should we have to continue to wait for audiology reports and reviews? Why must we wait for the report from England? Why should we continue to wait for people to listen to us? Why cannot commitments just be made? Often, we are asked, "When will people listen to the needs of those who are deaf or hard of hearing?" We were asked to be proactive and we have taken action. I ask that the petition be referred to the Health and Community Care Committee so that action can be taken now.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I invite Mike Rumbles to speak in support of the petitioner.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Thank you for inviting me to do so, convener. I support the petition. As Fiona Stewart said, thousands of members of the RNID will benefit from action on this matter. Social inclusion is important for us all in the Parliament. For relatively little cost, people's lives can be revolutionised by accessing digital hearing aid technology.I will read the committee a couple of sentences from a letter that I received more than two years ago from Susan Deacon, the then Minister for Health and Community Care. It was sent on 28 April 2000, when I first raised the issue with ministers. In the letter, she states:"Digital hearing aids are already available on the NHS in Scotland and we have just widened the choice available to patients by introducing further types of aid as from 1 April this year"—that is, April 2000."I hope this reassures"your constituent"that we are taking a very pro-active approach to the provision of this kind of equipment for patients in Scotland and that I have allayed his fears over potential costs related to using digital hearing aids."It is evident that the Scottish Executive felt that digital hearing aids were being provided in Scotland, but it is apparent that health boards were not providing them. In Grampian, after much pressure, the training of audiologists began only in January. There is now a commitment to assess the first patients at the beginning of the autumn, but there is still no commitment to issuing people with digital hearing aids.Not everyone can benefit from those aids, but the vast majority of people can. The technology will revolutionise social inclusion for many people at relatively little cost. I hope that members will listen to what has been said and will refer the petition to the Health and Community Care Committee for action. It would be wrong to hold up the issue any further, because we have been going at it for more than two years.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Before I open up the meeting to questions, I remind members that there will be a delay between their asking a question and the sign language interpreter conveying the question to the petitioner. I ask members to speak slowly and clearly. I know that I am the last person who should be telling committee members to speak slowly and clearly, because I am not good at that myself.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Fiona Stewart suggested that the cost was around £100 per digital hearing aid south of the border. However, when I followed the issue up with my local health trust, I was told that the capital cost of the equipment is not the sole charge—costs for training, technical back-up and other aspects go with it. Could you compare the overall costs of the digital hearing aids with those of the analogue hearing aids that are currently in use?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

You are correct that digital hearing aids incur investment costs in training staff and in some of the equipment, but many hospitals already have the equipment and the software packages are supplied by the manufacturers. There are additional costs, but they would be incurred in any case, because the modernisation of audiology will bring a need to increase the effectiveness of audiologists.That process has started. The Scottish Executive allocated £750,000, which was ring fenced, to all health boards; one factor that was built into that was the better use of staff. For example, less-qualified staff can undertake administrative tasks and leave audiologists and senior audiologists more time to deal with patients.That is part of a process. I will not hazard a guess at the exact figure, but that process has started in England and, as Fiona Stewart mentioned, a third of all patients in England will receive digital hearing aids by late 2003. In Wales, the percentage will be even higher, because all people who require digital hearing aids will receive them this year. That is part of a modernisation process that has been successfully completed in England and Wales.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

You did not mention the cost of analogue systems. Will you do that, so that we can have a comparison?

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

The cost of a top-range analogue hearing aid would be comparable to that of a digital hearing aid.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

What quality of analogue hearing aid does the national health service issue?

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

Detailed research was conducted on analogue hearing aids about five years ago. There has not been any subsequent detail on them.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

What percentage of NHS patients would find digital hearing aids useful?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

Cathie Craigie has made comments—based on the findings of audiologists—suggesting that 85 per cent of people would benefit from digital hearing aids. If you will bear with me, I can give you the reference to her comments.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

If Cathie Craigie said it, it must be true.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I am not so sure about that, but never mind.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

A fundamental question is what degree of deafness benefits from the digital hearing aid. Would a person who had been stone deaf from birth benefit or would only those who are hard of hearing benefit? Is it a question of degree? You said that 85 per cent of people would benefit. I would like to understand that fully.

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

Cathie Craigie said:"according to two of Scotland's leading audiologists, in 85 per cent of cases, digital aids are superior to current practices."—Official Report, 29 November 2001; c 4457.People who are profoundly deaf, especially people who are born profoundly deaf, will not benefit from a digital hearing aid. They might not benefit from any type of aid. However, in 85 per cent of cases—that would principally cover hard-of-hearing people—benefit would be felt, because of the directional facilities of the digital hearing aid, which allows sound to be tailored more precisely to the individual. It is correct to say that digital hearing aids will not necessarily be an improvement for people who are profoundly deaf, but analogue aids are also unlikely to be suitable in those cases.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

This morning, I, like Mike Rumbles, signed letters on behalf of constituents who have made representations about hearing aids. I have received responses that are similar to those that he has received. Reviews by various health boards are taking place throughout Scotland.I notice that the minister has made available £0.75 million to aid that work. I also notice from the papers that have been distributed that the RNID has been successful in managing a UK Government programme to modernise audiology services in 20 NHS hospitals in England—Fiona Stewart mentioned that. Does the RNID think that that could be a better way of tackling the problems in Scotland, bearing in mind the number of health boards in Scotland? Would there be streamlining of administration and would duplication of administration be avoided? Most important, would that approach deliver hearing aids urgently to my constituents and Mike Rumbles's constituents, who desperately need them?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

Yes. In England, the RNID co-manages the project with the NHS. In Wales, the RNID is on the project team, although it does not co-manage it. There is no doubt that a lot of information, facilities and expertise are available of which the NHS in Scotland could avail itself. Indeed, I serve on a number of audiology committees, such as the audit committee needs assessment group, with other voluntary organisations. We could certainly take advantage of the RNID's experience in Wales and England. I am sure that we would be prepared to consider that. I hope that doing so would lead to faster implementation.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Do you think that the RNID would have the capacity to deliver the programme exclusively? Would that route be better? Should there be partnership with existing NHS audiologists throughout Scotland? Is there some other way that might facilitate quick action? This case is not the first that I have had to deal with today. The worst case was at Christmas. I had to say no to a constituent who was going to suffer from broken equipment over the Christmas holiday. The person was old and was going to be excluded during that period. That did not make me feel good.

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

The way forward is through partnership working. We have worked in partnership and on project management teams in England and Wales and we believe that a similar model should be followed here. Certainly, we have experience, skills and staff who can give a lot of input and support, but a partnership approach is the best way forward.

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

I totally agree with Fiona Stewart. Partnership has been a key success story in England. One must work with the health boards, the health trusts and audiology staff. By doing so, parties can gain from one another's experiences.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

You say that the £150 cost to the NHS in England is "a small price to pay to revolutionise someone's life."Could that money affect employment, too? Do you have an approximate idea of the true level of unemployment among hard-of-hearing people? I know that the level is high.

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

The percentage is high. Many deaf and hard-of-hearing people have difficulty finding employment. People have approached me asking for digital hearing aids to assist them in their employment; they believe that such aids would help them in their employment. Many people who would like the assistance that digital hearing aids bring are suffering in silence.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Do you have an estimate of the extent of the problem in the community? I was once at an event at which I heard that an estimated 60 per cent of people in Strathclyde had difficulties with hearing and that the problem was on the increase. Perhaps it is just that the diagnostic tests are better, but 60 per cent seemed a very high figure. What would your estimate be?

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

We suggest that one in five adults in Scotland suffer from some hearing loss, which is about 730,000 people. At least one in five of the people in this room will have some degree of hearing loss.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Is not there a Government scheme, called access to work, which allows people to draw on digital facilities if they have the need?

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

Yes, but the access to work scheme does not cover private use. Digital aids are purchased privately through the access to work scheme, costing between £1,000 and £2,000, but why not give us digital hearing aids regardless, instead of giving out analogue hearing aids? Why must I and other people who pay taxes have to apply for eligibility for digital hearing aids? Why should we not be given the opportunity to get digital hearing aids, which can radically change people's lives, in the first place? Access to work will not help people who have retired and who require digital hearing aids. Because those people are not eligible for them, they will suffer and will be worse off.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I totally accept that, but I was really referring to Dorothy-Grace Elder's comment about employment. Is it in the hands of individual health boards to supply digital hearing aids if they feel that to be appropriate? Is the problem not so much about the provision of the equipment as about staff expertise and the expertise of those who deal with digital facilities?

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

We are aware of the shortage of staff, which is why the RNID has commissioned research. We are not criticising health boards. The subject needs more research. We have approached the Scottish Executive and the Parliament to commit more to improving audiology services—we are not focusing solely on digital hearing aids. We need to consider audiology services overall and digital hearing aids form part of that service. Unless there are improvements in the next year or two, we will fall further behind England and Wales, which are making strides forward.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I have spent the past two years sending many letters to and getting many letters from ministers and I know that Susan Deacon was, and that Malcolm Chisholm and Mary Mulligan are, very sympathetic to the idea of modernising audiology services. What is your perception of the problem? I know from the members' business debate on the matter last November, from all the responses to parliamentary questions and from informal contact that ministers seem to be very positive on the matter. However, the health boards do not seem to be sufficiently organised to deliver an effective service and are pleading that they do not have the necessary resources. What, effectively, is the problem? Do you think that you need to ask the Health and Community Care Committee to investigate the problem? Everybody seems to be in favour of resolving it, yet that is not happening. Should the matter go to that committee so that it can determine why it is not happening?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

I definitely think that the issue should go to the Health and Community Care Committee. The problem is money in the first instance, but it is not just a question of money and budgets. Before the recent allocation of £750,000 to audiology services, money was not ring fenced. It is said that audiology is the cinderella service of the health service.A deaf person said to me, "You don't die from being deaf." Perhaps that is the source of the problem. There is a general perception that audiology services have been underfunded for many years, but that is coming to light only as a result of England and Wales taking the initiative. We need a cash injection into audiology and we need the money to be ring fenced.Training is dreadful—people have to go to Middlesbrough to obtain an audiology degree, as there are no facilities in Scotland. Staff morale is dreadful. I know that because I visit many of the audiology services. The staff are more than willing to help and they put in many hours, but they are under-resourced, they lack the training in some cases, they do not have the information technology infrastructure, they are without proper equipment and in many instances the sound-proof rooms are not up to standard. Some 18 months ago, best practice standards in audiology were issued. Many hospitals simply cannot afford to attain those standards. The situation is serious. Fiona Stewart mentioned our desire for better provision of digital hearing aids, but we need more than just that. We require a modernisation of the whole audiology service.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I will pursue the issue of ring fencing. The briefing paper says that the £750,000 was "for NHS boards across Scotland to speed up treatment for patients with hearing problems".Are you suggesting that that money will not be ring fenced for hearing problems and that it might be spent on other areas?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

No, I said that the allocation of £750,000 was the Scottish Executive's first ever allocation of money specifically for audiology. Such an allocation has never taken place before. The press release that accompanied the announcement of the £750,000 stated that the sum was non-recurring—it was for one year only.The total health budget for last year was of the order of £5.4 billion. The amount of direct spending on audiology was £7.2 million. That sum does not take account of all the overheads. The percentage of expenditure on audiology services is 0.14 per cent, which is not even a quarter of 1 per cent. That is a tiny proportion. The fact that one in five adults are deaf or hard of hearing shows the extent of the imbalance. We want to emphasise that point and we feel that it is vital that the matter be referred to the Health and Community Care Committee.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

So the deaf are the Cinderellas of the whole situation.

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

Absolutely.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I escorted a blind man who won me as a prize—the prize was to spend a day with me going around Edinburgh. He had a marvellous time. Everyone was wonderful to him and his dog. Even though it was a busy July, everyone made way for him when we went into a pub. He said to me that everyone is kind to the blind. No one is kind to the deaf, however, because people are not aware of deafness.On the subject of the shortage of interpreters for the deaf, I was told that we have 35 sign interpreters, whereas Finland has 350 sign interpreters. In Finland, deaf children who go to an ordinary school are accompanied by a person to help them through their schooling and deaf university students are accompanied by an interpreter for the deaf. What a contrast that makes to the situation in our country. The poor interpreters here are developing diseases of the fingers. They are becoming exhausted because they are so kind and cannot say no. Many of them tell me that they are sorry that they ever became signers. I will ask a separate question. Fiona, could you qualify as a teacher of sign language?

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

You are right—there are great challenges. People like me need an interpreter to access all kinds of things. A deaf person needs access and an interpreter enables such access. It is essential to have communication—and therefore to have an interpreter present—in many situations. The shortage makes that difficult. One often goes to places and is not given information until afterwards—one is kept waiting to receive information. If someone comes from a family that has different generations of deaf family members, it is possible to see that there has been very little improvement for deaf people, as things are the same now as they were for previous generations. There is still discrimination and improvement has not been forthcoming. Deaf people continue to feel second class, despite paying taxes and so forth.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. I was sorry to digress a little, but I could not resist the opportunity to ask the question.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

This morning I wrote to my constituents to say that Fife NHS Board was undertaking a review and that that review was feeding into a national Scottish Executive-level review. The letter also set out that the review process would come to a culmination in September. Are you involved in the review? Is there any way that we can push the RNID to head up a task force that would be charged with delivery?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

I am involved in three sub-groups of the review group: the audit, needs assessment and needs assessment of adults sub-groups. The report will be ready by September or October. I have offered members of the review group and the Scottish Executive the opportunity to visit the modernisation programme in Wales in which the RNID is involved. I am pleased to say that, in two weeks' time, members of the Scottish Executive and the review group are coming with me to visit Wales.The visit will give us an excellent opportunity to review the running of the project. The health service in Wales has been very kind, as it has offered to give us a copy of the facilities that it uses for the project implementation plan. Cost has not been mentioned—we might get it for nothing. That is a genuine step forward. In answer to the question, the RNID is keen to be involved in such a project.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I have a final question about the comparison of Scotland, Wales and England. The audiology services in 65 hospitals are to be completely modernised. Do you know the cost of that?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

I do. If the convener will give me a minute, I will dig through my papers and give the committee a breakdown of the costs.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am interested in the £750,000 that has been made available by the Scottish Executive. How does that figure compare to the amount that the NHS in England is making available?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

If the convener gives me a second, I will go through my papers. The funds are additional funds that have been invested in England and Wales. A figure of £30.6 million has been invested in England, of which £10.6 million went in the first wave to 20 hospitals. That figure was followed up with a £20 million allocation. In Wales, the figures are broken down over a three-year period with £2.25 million in 2001-02 and £3.5 million spread over the following two years. The moneys were ring fenced specifically for audiology and were to be spent on modernisation and digital hearing aids.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

If we were to set an equivalent figure for Scotland, would it be somewhere between those two?

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

An equivalent is difficult to set. That is because England and Wales were ahead of us even before they started and because of the introduction of what is called the universal neonatal hearing screening, which will add additional costs to the audiology services. However, if a comparison were made between the figures, a rough estimate of the starting position, on which I would not wish to be quoted, would be of a figure between £10 million to £12 million.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Can I add some information to that? Of the £750,000 that has been allocated in Scotland, £60,000 has come to Grampian NHS Board. That sum has to be used simply to purchase software that will enable the database to be established. No money is coming to Grampian NHS Board to assist patients once they are assessed. Patients can have an assessment, but no commitment can be made to give digital hearing aids to patients.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

In order for us to be clear on the subject, will the £750,000 make a difference to the number of Scots who will be given access to digital hearing aids?

Fiona Stewart Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

No.

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

This is not a question, but I would like to raise the issue of waiting lists. In Edinburgh, for example, after a person has appeared before his general practitioner, it takes 73 weeks for him to be fitted with a hearing aid.

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

Seventy-three weeks.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I can give a personal viewpoint on that, as I have a little bit of a problem with my hearing. I am sure that I was not treated with any privilege, but only eight or nine weeks elapsed between the time when I saw my GP and the time when I should have been fitted with a hearing aid, which was yesterday. That was in Ayrshire. Does that suggest that there is a great disparity between the various health boards?

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

No, I am quite sure that it was not. I am aware that other people have been treated similarly quickly.

Stuart Smith Royal National Institute for Deaf People
link

I do not have the figures for every health board area, but the waiting time in Edinburgh was quoted to me as 73 weeks. The situation in Kirkcaldy is also fairly bad, although not as bad as that. I do not have figures for other health board areas but, from what Phil Gallie is saying, it appears that there is a disparity between treatments in different health board areas.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Thank you very much. That was valuable information. I hope that the committee has acknowledged it. You are welcome to listen to the committee's discussion of what it wants to do with the petition.The suggested action is not what the petitioners have asked for, which is that we refer it directly to the Health and Community Care Committee. That committee will hold only a couple of meetings between now and the recess. If we refer the petition to the Health and Community Care Committee now, nothing will happen until after the recess. However, if we write to the Executive now and get a response, that will be available to the Health and Community Care Committee when we refer the petition to it after the recess. That will get some of the work done and will get us further down the road than we will be if we just pass it on directly now.The suggested action is that we write to the Executive, asking it for confirmation of the position regarding the provision of digital hearing aids by NHS Scotland and for comment on the seemingly different approach that is being taken in England. We should also ask the Executive for an update on the review of audiology services provision in Scotland and whether it expects the additional funding that is being provided to the health boards to improve the treatment of those who have hearing difficulties and benefit individuals who require digital hearing aids specifically. We can get that information and pass it on to the Health and Community Care Committee. We can also pass a copy of the petition to the Cross-party Group in the Scottish Parliament on Deafness and to the clerk of the Health and Community Care Committee, for their information.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We should include in our comments to the Executive some of the points that have come out of today's debate. The waiting time that has been quoted is horrendous, although Phil Gallie gave a better account.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We can ask for confirmation of all the waiting times.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We are also told that"the Executive is currently assessing the measures that individual NHS Boards take in following the Good Practice Guidance."The good practice guidance recommends that all people who need a hearing aid should be able to get one. Can we ask whether the assessment will obey the good practice guidance or ignore it? That is a relevant question. What is the status of the good practice guidance? Who issued it? Was it the Scottish Executive or somebody else? I do not know.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will ask the Executive for clarification of the status of the guidance and whether following it is mandatory.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

It might have been issued by SIGN—the Scottish intercollegiate guidelines network.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

In addition, we should point out that it has been exposed to us that the ring-fenced £750,000 is not likely to put a single hearing aid in a single ear. In case the Executive gets the idea that that is a large sum of money and that the Executive is doing a good job, we should point out the fact that has arisen out of today's debate, which is that that money is not going to do the job. We should also point out that there is a big need for money and make the contrast with expenditure in Wales and England.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It has been suggested that we could send the Executive a copy of the Official Report of this part of today's meeting and ask it to respond to the points that the petitioners have made.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I do not know where the good practice guidance comes from. I do not know who issued it.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will ask the Executive for the statistics.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

In the members' business debate that took place in November, the Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care, Mary Mulligan, said that the good practice guidance had been issued about 18 months previously. That is why the confusion has arisen. I referred earlier to the letter that I received from Susan Deacon two years ago, in which she was quite adamant that digital hearing aids were available and that the Executive assumed that they were being issued. At the end of the members' business debate in November, Mary Mulligan said that the chief executive of the NHS in Scotland had written to the chief executives of all 15 health boards in Scotland to ask them to adhere to the good practice guidance.My point is that things are not happening on the ground, although Scottish Executive ministers are saying, "This is what we are putting into practice. Those are the good practice guidelines that we have given out to the health boards. We assume that everything is okay and that things are happening". When the convener writes to the Executive, I ask him to refer to the letter that Susan Deacon sent me two years ago. I will also give a copy of the letter to the official report.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I suggest that we should also ask the Executive to report back to the Public Petitions Committee on its initiative in writing to the 15 health boards and to tell us what response it received from them.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Could you also make a strong recommendation in that letter, convener? I do not know whether we have the right to make recommendations and I do not know whether members would agree with me, but I have a strong view that we should set up a task group to bring people together as a matter of urgency. We should not wait for a review in September, October, November or December. Let us get started and sort out the problem now. Let us bring together all the audiology services in Scotland under the directorship of some capable person—possibly the RNID—and pool resources. In my experience, there is nothing better than getting people who have mutual interests and the drive and determination to succeed to make collective endeavours.I would like to think that we could send that strong message to the Scottish Executive on the back of today's meeting. I feel a sense of sheer frustration, because I have had to make similar representations to the minister. If I were called upon to do so, I could produce the letters that I had to write, although they provided no comfort to my constituents, as the responses spoke only of reviews. We do not want reviews; we want action.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I remind members that our ultimate decision will be to refer the petition formally to the Health and Community Care Committee. That committee will make recommendations, although we can ask the Scottish Executive to respond to the proposal to set up a task group, so that progress can be made, as part of a partnership between the RNID and the audiology service.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

In the light of the letter that Mike Rumbles mentioned, could we not declare our dissatisfaction with the situation?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We could do that, but it will be for the Health and Community Care Committee, rather than the Public Petitions Committee, to make firm recommendations about the way forward. We are simply trying to shortcut the system. The Health and Community Care Committee would have to write to the Executive anyway and it would be better for us to do that first.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

As members of the Health and Community Care Committee, the convener and I know better than anyone that the big problem is having a reporter available to do a report on the petition. I should explain that the Health and Community Care Committee appoints reporters from among the members of the committee. The stronger our letter to the Executive is the better. As I glance at the figures, I notice that England gets £30 million for English services for the deaf. It is clear that, with £750,000, the Scottish deaf are being short-changed. The £30.6 million is ring fenced, as Fiona Stewart pointed out. That information is incredibly valuable and should be included on your publicity leaflets.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is perfectly in order for the Public Petitions Committee to make clear our strong views that we expect the Executive to treat the petition as an urgent matter and our disappointment and anger that Scotland should be lagging so far behind the other parts of the UK in the provision that is made for deaf people.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

My attention goes back to the letter that Mike Rumbles received. I am quite sure that other members who wrote to the Executive got exactly the same response. We were reassured by the Executive, but it seems that, two years on, no progress has been made. That is particularly the case in respect of the digital apparatus that was the initial target of the petition. I want to back up Mike Rumbles's comment about getting the Executive to concentrate on that point. Given that the letter was sent out two years ago, why are the health boards not delivering on this?We cannot use what we have heard about the money that is spent in Wales and England as a real criticism, because devolution means that we are different. However, given the cost of what the health boards are delivering south of the border, what does the Scottish Executive think that it will get from its £750,000?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The letter is starting to turn into "War and Peace"—it has everything in it—and we have to be careful. The clerks have taken down most of the points that we have made and they will be put to the Executive. I was interested to hear that Phil Gallie thinks that devolution means that we spend less on public services.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Devolution does not mean that. The Executive makes that choice and perhaps it has made the wrong choice in this case.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Is it agreed that all those points will be incorporated in the letter that we will send? When we get the responses in, we can formally refer the petition to the Health and Community Care Committee. I hope that that committee will get down to taking action on it immediately after the recess.Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Yes, we give a sincere thanks to the signer, without whom this discussion could not have happened. The lack of signers in the Parliament is another example of how it is not living up to claims of openness, transparency and accessibility. The Parliament is not accessible for deaf people and we have seen that vividly this afternoon.

Andrew Dewey
link

I hope that you will see more of us in the future.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

At its next meeting the committee will deal with a petition on education for deaf people. Such issues are on the Parliament's agenda. Thank you.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Thursday 6 June 2002 (Afternoon) Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 83
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 64
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 76
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 14
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 9
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 24
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  15. Electronic Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. Convener's Report Procedure · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.