Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Tolls (Trunk Roads) (PE445)

Tuesday 21 May 2002 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 70 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

70 contributions
John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The next current petition relates to Skye bridge. Members will recall that the petition calls on the Parliament to examine the discrepancies between the terms of a toll order and those of the assignation statement that relates to the scheme for the Skye road bridge. The petitioners argue that the Government of the day did not follow the proper procedures before the Skye bridge opened in 1995. We considered the petition and agreed to seek the views of the Executive and the Lord Advocate, whose responses we have now received. Those responses are far too lengthy for me to go through them in detail. We will deal first with the question of the validity of the documents.The Executive argues that the empowering statute that was used to validate those did not require either the road scheme or the toll order to be laid before Parliament or published, and indicates that that did not happen in either case. However, the Executive claims that the orders were made available for public inspection, as required by statute. Strictly speaking, in terms of the law, nothing wrong has been done but, in terms of politics, there was a complete lack of transparency, openness and accountability in the way in which the order was pushed through the parliamentary process. Shall we deal with that issue first?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

My recollection, based on my two sojourns in the House of Commons, is that statutory instruments had to be laid, however unsatisfactory the method of laying them was. They might be laid on a Friday when no one was there or laid in terms that were meaningless—for example, when 5,000 miles of Scotland's fishing waters were stolen, no one who read the instrument would have known that that is what it was going to do. I doubt that the requirement for them to be laid has changed.The statutory instruments also had to be published in a printed form. Perhaps, for once, the House of Commons is showing us a better way of doing things.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That issue is key, as this matter is hugely complicated. The Statutory Instruments Reference Committee ruled that the instruments did not need to be laid before Parliament or printed and published as they were correctly classified as local instruments. The Government of the day was required only to make them available for public inspection. I would like to know how many people asked to see the orders.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Hardly anybody. Is the Statutory Instruments Reference Committee above the law?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It classifies instruments and decides which have to go before Parliament and which do not. The reason that the instrument did not go before the Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments is because the Statutory Instruments Reference Committee said that it was a local statutory instrument.The situation is that, although the process by which the orders were dealt with was strictly legal, it was completely lacking in transparency, openness and accountability. The courts have decided that the process was legal, but whether it is politically acceptable is a different matter.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Well, it was certainly untransparent.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Each of the arguments that has been presented on this issue has fallen on stony ground. However, it is interesting to note that subsequent orders for similar schemes in the country were printed and published before the schemes were approved. If the legislation applies to certain contracts, why does it not apply to the Skye bridge contract?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That is the question that needs to be asked. Why was a different legal method used in relation to the Skye bridge?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Could John Farquhar Munro give us an example of a similar contract?

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

You will recall that, recently, tolls on the Erskine bridge were suspended because the documentation had not been signed.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

So the Executive has learned from the mistake in relation to the Skye bridge.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are we agreed to seek further information from the Executive as to why the Skye bridge instrument was handled differently from all other orders and was not printed, published and laid before Parliament?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We do not know that all other orders have been printed, published and laid before Parliament.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will ask whether its treatment was unique. It was certainly dealt with differently to other similar orders. We can also ask the Executive to explain in detail why, given the controversial nature of the project, the instrument was not printed, published and laid before Parliament.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Could we ask whether any subsequent instruments have been dealt with in the way that the Skye bridge instrument was?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Yes. I should point out that Robbie the Pict has made available further briefing material on this question. It came in far too late—the clerks have not even had a chance to read it—but it will be circulated to members for information.Are we agreed to write to the Executive to ask the questions that we have raised?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The next issue that the Executive responded to relates to the argument about whether the assignation statement was invalid because it was not signed or dated. That matter has been ruled on by the courts and the Executive is of the view that"the Assignation Statement is valid although it is not a probative or self-evidencing document".I do not know what that means—a lawyer might. Winnie?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Before you leave the previous issue, I want to raise a point about the quote that is at the foot of the second page—there are no page numbers—of the Scottish Executive's response. The response quotes Lord Sutherland as saying:"I find it difficult to see how the printing of these instruments … would have brought anything more to the attention of interested parties than had already been achieved by the massive publicity".In other words, he allowed the press interest to substitute legal transparent agreements. In other words, if there is massive press publicity you can forget any obligation to tell the good old public officially. We should question that because it is surely an extraordinary statement—if it was made by Lord Sutherland.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We can challenge that by asking for the basis of his argument.To return to the assignation statement, I do not know what the Executive means by saying that"the Assignation Statement is valid although it is not a probative or self-evidencing document."We can perhaps simply accept what the Executive has said, but I do not know what it means. We could ask the Executive to explain that further.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It means that the judge has made up a new law.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It is not the law. In our law, a probative document is needed for any serious matter. The judge has simply ruled that a probative document is no longer necessary in the case of the Skye bridge. It is quite incredible. For the simplest of ordinary dealings in trade and commerce, the documents must be probative for any serious matter.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

In our letter to the Executive, shall we ask it to clarify whether its reference to the assignation statement being "valid although it is not a probative or self-evidencing document"simply means that the judge was making new law in that respect?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We shall ask the Executive to confirm that.Let us move on to the Executive's response to the point about the contracts being issued prior to the public inquiry. Members will see that the Executive's response states that that was normal practice.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

That is quite incredible. I have the correspondence dating back to that time, when I was involved because, as MEP for the Highlands and Islands, I had wanted the bridge to be financed in a different way in the first place—possibly with European help. I have the file, which shows that the project had already been awarded to Miller while the public inquiry was being conducted in Kyle of Lochalsh.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Yes. The project had already started. Now, the Executive has given an interesting legal argument that I have never heard put before. The Executive does not dispute—it cannot because I have the file—that the project had already been started prior to the public inquiry. That fact has been admitted by the Executive.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

No, but it would have been if I had not kept the file.The Executive response continues:"Following a competitive tendering process, the joint venture company Miller-Dywidag was selected as the preferred bidder … Thereafter"—as John Farquhar Munro has mentioned—"work proceeded on the design phases … The main contract documents were agreed".The Executive goes on to say that, if the public inquiry had objected, the secretary of state would have had to pay up and compensate Miller for cancelling the contract. That is quite an extraordinary attitude. It makes you wonder what public inquiries are for.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The response refers to the fact that if the public inquiry had opposed the project, the contract would not have been completed. The element of conditionality in the contract would have meant that the project would have stopped and that the Government would have paid full compensation.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

However, it is not clear from the reply what is meant by full compensation.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Exactly. It is a most amazing puzzle. It means that public inquiries about any such matter are valueless because the Government can go ahead on the basis that if the public inquiry dares to oppose the scheme, the company will be paid by the taxpayers' money.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is worth our while asking the Executive for an explanation of what was meant by full compensation in those circumstances. Would the company have been compensated with the actual cost of physically building the bridge or with the profits that they might reasonably have garnered over the 14 to 18 years if the bridge had gone ahead? We need that to be clarified.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Full compensation might simply have been the refunding of expenditure that the company had incurred in preparing plans.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

As you know, such expenditure could be dolled up to any amount.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Not if a contract is properly specified—and we can see the consequences of that in the disaster down the road from here.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We could ask the Executive to clarify what is meant by full compensation. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Let us move to the other points, starting with the financial arrangements. There is a question whether excessive profits were made from the contract by the Bank of America. Members will note that a formula in the concession agreement determines the length of the concession period for the company. That formula was based on the fact that the company was able to recover the costs of building the bridge, which are put at £23.64 million, based on 1990 prices. The concession period was estimated at 14 to 18 years, which allowed an agreed margin of profit to be made.The Executive dismisses as "entirely speculative" the sum that has been mentioned by the petitioners—which I think is £170 million—and does not give any information as to what an agreed margin of profit is under the circumstances.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Towards the end of the letter from Mark Rae, there is a reference to the toll revenues. They are not given, but they are in the public domain and we can apparently find them out from Companies House. The letter says:"details of toll revenues to date … are set out … and are available from Companies House."Do the petitioners have that information or have they tried to get it? Perhaps we should try to get it.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

If it is publicly available, it can easily be had.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

But the amount of that revenue is relevant to the argument.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Absolutely. We should still ask the Executive what the agreed margin of profit over the 14-to-18-year period of the contract will be. Although we can find out from Companies House what revenue the company has taken so far, we do not know what it is due to get in future.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

You will find it very difficult to get any response from the Executive. I have asked the question, and the figure has not been made available. The ironic thing is that the cost of the bridge was originally about £23.6 million. I understand that almost £10 million was allocated to the contract by the then Scottish Office, which made the fiscal cost of the bridge something in the region of £15 million—which we might call the shore-to-shore cost.If we consider the various figures that have been presented, which have been well researched by many people in Skye and Lochalsh and by the protesters, we find that substantial sums of money are being extorted from the travelling public. Some estimates suggest that the final sum, if the tolls extend for the duration of the contract—which I think is about 27 years—would amount to something like £170 million, for a £15 million span. The most conservative estimate that I have seen is for about £125 million. That is a huge amount of money. I do not know how much profit the Bank of America is making, but, based on those figures, it must be pretty substantial.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I still think that it is worth the committee asking for that information. I realise that you have done that as an individual, John, but there is no reason why the committee cannot ask for it.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

I find the tone of the long and detailed letter from Mark Rae objectionable in parts. It obscures facts that could easily have been released, especially the situation with the Bank of America. It says, for example, that"these figures are entirely speculative and it would not be appropriate for the Executive to comment on these in detail."We are dealing with taxpayers' money. It is highly appropriate that the Executive comments on the matter.Furthermore, there is more than a lack of transparency when it is pointed out "that details of toll revenues to date, and other financial details are set out in the Annual Accounts of Concessionaire, Skye Bridge Ltd, and are available from Companies House."Mark Rae could have provided that information to us. It would have been helpful and transparent for us to have had that before us today. The Executive has chosen not to provide it; it has chosen to give us the bare minimum. The letter is filled with fudge.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We are agreeing that we will seek all that information now. So is it agreed—

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

But time is going by while people are giving us these fudgy answers. We are all sick of them, convener.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

John Farquhar Munro mentioned a period of 27 years. I thought that the concession period was between 14 and 18 years.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I understand that the concession period is 14 to 18 years. The Executive referred to that period of time.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Do members want clarification on that point?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We move on to consider the response from the Lord Advocate. Members will note the Lord Advocate's ruling that the decisions of judges are not for him to question; he uses the phrase:"the Opinion is set out comprehensively and is binding".The Lord Advocate deals with the question of Robbie the Pict being denied the opportunity to petition the nobile officium. His response is that the Lord Justice General gave full reasons as to why there was no proper basis for such an application. I understand that Robbie the Pict is currently challenging the Lord Advocate's refusal of a hearing on the grounds that it is a violation of human rights. I understand that the matter is therefore sub judice. We should be careful what we say about the case.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

One thing strikes me about the point that the Lord Advocate makes. If we look at the end of the Executive's letter, which Dorothy-Grace Elder called a fudge, the section that deals with the court's scrutiny of the assignation statement states that:"these are correctly matters to be addressed in detail by the Lord Advocate".When we turn to the Lord Advocate's response, we find that he states that the matters are not for him, but for the judges. Which is it? Is Mr Mark Rae wrong to suggest that we look to the Lord Advocate for guidance? The Lord Advocate has not given us guidance; he has said that the judges are independent people.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am advised that the Lord Advocate's ruling is the one that matters. The Executive was wrong, as the decision is for the Lord Advocate and not for the Executive.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The Executive was wrong to state that the Lord Advocate would address the matters.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I have been told that the matters have been addressed, in the sense that the Lord Advocate has said that he will not address them.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It is civil service speak—by the Lord Advocate not addressing something, it has been addressed.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The letter is insulting. It insults the intelligence of the committee and everybody.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Okay. We have gone through PE445 in detail. We have sought responses from the Executive and the Lord Advocate. I sense that the committee is not of the opinion that all avenues have been exhausted and that no further action could be taken. That is the action that was suggested to us. I sense that the committee wants to write to the Executive again to put the detailed questions that have been raised this morning. We want to seek further clarification on all those questions.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

When does the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Bill come into effect?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We do not know. We will have to check that.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Perhaps there is a need for such an act after all.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Phil Gallie is changing his mind.Are we agreed that we should respond in the ways that we have detailed?Members indicated agreement.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I have another point to make in respect of PE445. I suspect that the argument with the Executive will go on for a long time. However, it is clear that the Scottish Executive could do something about the matter tomorrow, if it so desired, although the solution would be expensive. The issue is political. Perhaps all the parties who will fight the next election in 2003 should consider the matter; that would ensure that the matter would be in—or out of—their manifestos. People will be asked to vote on such issues. We should remind the petitioners of that fact.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

You can remind the petitioners of that. Although the matter is not one for the Public Petitions Committee to rule on, the point is well worth making.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 21 May 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 74
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 71
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 84
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  6. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 70
  8. Community Volunteers (PE447) Committee business · 17
  9. Community Volunteers (PE447) Committee business · 31
  10. Community Volunteers (PE447) Committee business · 6
  11. Community Volunteers (PE447) Committee business · 5
  12. Community Volunteers (PE447) Committee business · 16
  13. Convener's Report Procedure · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.