The next two petitions are from Mr Tony Southall, on behalf of the Scottish Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament. The first deals with the review of emergency planning measures for nuclear submarine accidents and the second is about the adverse consequences of the location and operation in Scotland of nuclear weapons systems.Members will remember that we wrote at various stages to the Scottish Executive, to the local authorities concerned and to Nuclear Free Local Authorities (Scotland). Ultimately, we decided to ask the Transport and the Environment Committee and the Justice 2 Committee whether they were interested in taking up the two petitions. The Transport and the Environment Committee decided that the subject of the petitions was not a matter for it but for the Justice 2 Committee. It was therefore left to the Justice 2 Committee to take the petitions further if it wanted to. That committee's members were advised to contact the committee's clerks by 10 September if they wished the committee to carry out an investigation into the issues that are raised in either petition, but no members of the Justice 2 Committee took the opportunity to do so.The Public Petitions Committee's clerks were advised of the position only in March this year. We have been waiting for some time to establish whether the Justice 2 Committee is minded to consider further the issues raised in the petitions. We have now been informed that it is not. It is therefore suggested that the committee should formally agree that no further action should be taken in relation to either of the petitions and that accordingly we should inform the petitioners of the situation.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Nuclear Disarmament (PE334 and PE364)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McAllion Lab 14
- Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP 13
- Dr Winnie Ewing SNP 8
- Phil Gallie Con 1
- Helen Eadie Lab 1
The record
37 contributionsI wonder whether the Health and Community Care Committee would not have been a more appropriate committee to consult on reviewing the emergency planning measures for nuclear submarine accidents, rather than the Justice 2 Committee. Health and the devastation of human beings are the number 1 issue in the matter, apart from the environment. Should the petitions be forwarded to the Health and Community Care Committee? There are regular exercises and mock-ups of the evacuation of Helensburgh, and I think that the Health and Community Care Committee has seen papers on that in the past. It is a huge issue. The base at Faslane could take out the whole of Scotland and get Europe on the way back.
There is no doubt that it is a major issue, but no one questions the fact that it is the remit of the justice committees to address such petitions. The Health and Community Care Committee has been involved as an interested party, but the Justice 2 Committee has indicated that it is not prepared to take up the issue. That is unfortunate, but we do not have the powers to take up the matter.
The petitioners are calling for the Scottish Parliament to ask the Executive to initiate a review of emergency planning measures.
Any petition would go initially to the committee whose remit covers that area. When the petition first arrived, that was the Justice and Home Affairs Committee. Now, there are two justice committees.
I still do not twig at all why the Justice 2 Committee is involved in the operational facets of the matter.
I am informed that the Scottish Executive justice department co-ordinates such activities and the justice committees shadow the justice department. That is why the matter comes under that committee's remit.
Having had Dounreay in my constituency for a long time, I was intrigued to know what would happen if there was a meltdown. There has not been one, although it is a possibility. I was interested in the detail of what would happen. The information was to some extent guarded, but I think that the locals are entitled to know what would happen if there were a meltdown. Apparently, the local authority would be responsible for dealing with people who were endangered, but could not take them to local hospitals, because that would make the hospitals out of bounds, so they proposed to take them to school buildings. That involves transport and health. With Faslane on the doorstep of the industrial population of Scotland, it seems extraordinary that we are just told, "That's the end of it." We have not tried the Health and Community Care Committee yet, have we?
No.
Health would be a primary concern. I agree with Winnie Ewing. I have heard of previous plans for the Helensburgh area, under which schools were to be commandeered to accept the wounded who remained after a nuclear accident.
Would it be possible for us to write to the Health and Community Care Committee to ask whether it wishes to take up the health implications of the petition? We could mention the fact that the Justice 2 Committee is not interested in doing so. We should write such a letter in order to keep the Health and Community Care Committee fully in the picture.We always come up against this: as a petitions committee, we cannot go any further once a policy committee decides that it does not want to do anything. That is one of the weaknesses of the system.It would be the first of the petitions—PE334—that we would pass on to the Health and Community Care Committee. I do not think that the second petition—PE364—has a direct bearing on health. It deals only with the question whether Trident weapons should be on the Clyde.
No—PE364 covers health. It says:"Recognising … the health and environmental dangers".
I do not think that the Justice 2 Committee is doing the public much good. Would not it add to panic if the public had absolutely no idea in advance about what the score would be, and about what they would have to do? It cannot all be left to the emergency services.
Winifred Ewing was right to cite Dounreay, where a local emergency action committee would involve all the main emergency services, including the health service. I suggest that, to broaden the committee's knowledge, it would be fair to ask what facilities exist at Faslane. We would then be able to make an informed decision.
Why not? That is a good idea.
We could write directly to Faslane, in other words.
Remember that our record in dealing with the petitions in question goes back to February 2001. We have already had extensive replies from the local authorities involved and from the Scottish Executive about the existing emergency arrangements. There is an argument about whether those arrangements are adequate.
Are they updated?
Yes, they are continually reviewed and updated. If members wish to continue with the petition, the only way forward that I can see would be to ask the Health and Community Care Committee whether it would be interested in considering the health implications of the emergency arrangements that exist to look after the nuclear weapons system that is located in Scotland. That committee would not have an interest other than in the health implications.
I agree that health should definitely be a consideration. However, in any other situation, the public is informed about what to do, whether that relates to the simple evacuation of a cinema or school. I am not implicating the committee in saying this but, once again, information is being fudged because the word "nuclear" is involved.
Information is always fudged.
People must know what to do if the worst happens.
Nobody knows what to do.
There is a 144-nuclear-warhead potential in each submarine.
As far as I know, the emergency arrangements are public documents and are available.
Do we hold regular press conferences to bring that to the attention of the public? No, we do not.
In the context of Rosyth, where I used to be an elected member, a document called ROSPUBSAFE—or "Rosyth public safety"—was published. That was a publicly available document, which was regularly updated.As an elected member for that area I, like others, was invited to be a part of the process. That process embraced all kinds of guidance, including what the emergency services and the local authority's emergency planning team would be expected to do in such a situation. My understanding from serving as an elected member in the Rosyth area was that the same kind of scenario applied to other nuclear establishments in Scotland: they are required to give such information and policy guidance to their local communities.
The Public Petitions Committee has referred the petition to the appropriate committee, which has not shown an interest in taking the matter up. That is the unfortunate situation in which we find ourselves. We could write to the Health and Community Care Committee to ask whether it is prepared to consider whether the health arrangements in the event of a nuclear accident are satisfactory.
I was not on the Public Petitions Committee when the Faslane safety plan was apparently made available. I wonder whether the clerks could provide me with a copy for my own satisfaction.
Sure. Extensive material came in from all the bodies that we wrote to.
I am sorry to be a bother, but I will read it.
Can we write to the Admiralty as well?
We should first establish whether the Health and Community Care Committee is interested in the petition.
As the convener and I are members of the Health and Community Care Committee, we know that the committee would be interested in the petition. However, that committee does not have time to consider everything.
We can write to the Admiralty, but we will get the same reply that we received from the Scottish Executive.
The problem is time—it is not that committees are not interested in petitions.
Do we agree to ask the Health and Community Care Committee whether it is interested in pursuing the issues that are raised in petition PE334? The Health and Community Care Committee does not have a direct interest in petition PE364, so we must conclude consideration of that petition.Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Apr 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 23 April 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 69
- New Petitions Petitions · 79
- New Petitions Petitions · 56
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 17
- New Petitions Petitions · 10
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 37
- Current Petitions Petitions · 26
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 7
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.