Bristow Muldoon has arrived to talk to PE428, on Binny House, so we will deal with that next. An additional paper came in this morning from Sue Ryder Care, which has been circulated to committee members. I appreciate that members will not have had a chance to read it. It is a response to the letter that we sent to the chief executive of Sue Ryder Care, Iain Henderson. Members will also be aware of the recent tragic reports about a resident at Binny House who has asked to have her treatment discontinued in protest at the closure of the home.Sue Ryder Care's response expresses the view that a national health service is in operation, that tax-raising powers are in place to provide revenue for that service and that that should be the Parliament's starting point when investigating regulation. It also makes the point that Sue Ryder Care has provided a substantial building at Binny House, together with continuing maintenance and provision of equipment to enable the care of high-dependency residents. Mr Henderson contends that the health authority and Government agencies have a statutory duty to provide such facilities and that they should have been providing them.Mr Henderson also asserts that it is for the health authority and Government agencies to provide all health care services and facilities, and that the Government is occasionally fortunate in having assistance in meeting its obligations to the electorate from the voluntary and not-for-profit sector. He states that, for many years, Sue Ryder Care has helped the health service in Lothian to meet its obligations to patients by providing treatment that is worth many millions of pounds.He also says that Sue Ryder Care is making a multimillion pound investment in building a new care centre in Aberdeen, with realistic revenue funding from Grampian NHS Board and Government agencies. However, he states that dealings with Lothian NHS Board and associated agencies have not been harmonious and that the publicity and reporting of the proposed closure of Binny House have been consistently unbalanced. For example, he says that it was widely reported that the only remaining obstacle to a solution for Binny House was a revenue gap of £18,000, whereas the true figure was in excess of £250,000, year on year.Mr Henderson also expresses the view that the reporting of Sue Ryder Care's negotiations with the health board has been distorted. He says that Lothian NHS Board was unable to offer sufficient funding to allow the charity to keep Binny House open, having made a final offer of £680 per week per patient, with no further room for manoeuvre. He therefore does not consider that Sue Ryder Care has walked away from negotiations, and states that he has written on two occasions to the chief executive of the health board about the provision of increased funding, which he believes constitutes participation in discussions. Mr Henderson concludes that he has always remained ready to listen to proposals about the Binny House situation, were any proposals to be tabled.That is a brief summary of the response from Sue Ryder Care. We also have a response from the Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care, Hugh Henry, who reiterates his view that it is a matter for local negotiation between the principal commissioners and Sue Ryder Care and that it is not appropriate for him to intervene. However, he provides details of steps that have been taken by local authorities and the health board to prevent the closure of the facility. He refers to the fact that the Minister for Health and Community Care, Malcolm Chisholm, wrote to the chief executive of Sue Ryder Care in November, urging the resumption of discussions with the commissioners of care to safeguard Binny House's future. Hugh Henry also restates the Executive's desire that a solution to the situation should be found through such discussions. Finally, Hugh Henry indicates that a full response that will cover the more general points in the petition will be provided in due course.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Charitable Organisations (Regulation) (PE428)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McAllion Lab 7
- Bristow Muldoon Lab 6
- Dr Winnie Ewing SNP 2
- Rhoda Grant Lab 1
- Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP 1
- John Farquhar Munro LD 1
The record
18 contributionsI am grateful to the committee for including the issue on its agenda and accommodating me in this way. I would like to respond briefly to some of the issues that are raised in the response from Sue Ryder Care, before I address what the petition asks for.One of the points in the Sue Ryder Care letter with which I will not disagree with is the fact that Sue Ryder Care has provided an excellent level of care for many years at Binny House and other facilities. However, that is not the issue. In fact, part of the reason why people are fighting so hard to maintain the service is that they hold the service in such high regard. The problem is the way in which Sue Ryder Care is going about trying to close the service. It is trying to do it within a short time scale and has not been completely open and transparent about its financial dealings. Mr Henderson's letter points out the fact that there is a dispute about the level of the funding gap. He refers to reports of a revenue gap of £18,000, which I mentioned at a previous meeting. Part of the problem that I and others have had in dealing with the issue is that there has been a lack of transparency from Sue Ryder Care about its true financial position. The figure of £18,000 was quoted to me by Lothian NHS Board.I have put some questions to Sue Ryder Care to try to get to the bottom of its financial position. For example, its most recent published financial statement showed an increase in costs at Binny House of about 10 per cent. I am absolutely sure that the staff did not receive a wage increase of more than 10 per cent, nor am I aware of there being any substantial difference in the range of people who were being provided for in Binny House during that year. I have tried to get to the bottom of that increase.At the previous meeting, I highlighted the fact that there have been increases in management costs and publicity costs for the organisation. I am concerned that some of the cost increases might not, in fact, be cost increases that are associated with the care of people at Binny House.The letter mentions Lothian NHS Board's offer of £680 per week per patient. That is exactly the same as the offer that was made to Marchmont House, which is being kept open. We have not received an explanation for why that is a suitable figure for a broadly comparable range of patients who are being maintained in a location that is only 30 or 40 miles down the road from the home that is to be closed.I do not want to comment on the position of the lady who has been mentioned in recent television coverage, because I have not spoken directly to her or to her family. However, I have encouraged Sue Ryder Care to negotiate. Last week, I spoke to the chief executives of Sue Ryder Care and Lothian NHS Board and I still hope that Sue Ryder Care will come back to the table to negotiate. Negotiating by letter from 400 miles away is not appropriate. It is better to get people around a table to find out where divisions lie between organisations and to try to close those divisions.PE428 calls for a framework that would not allow organisations to close in such a short time scale. The proposal is to put in place a framework in which there would be a minimum period of consultation and in which notice would be required before a closure could take place. That would be appropriate. Many people who are in such residential care accommodation are highly dependent and many have become settled. It cannot be said that there will never be change in such care homes, but if there is to be change, there should be the opportunity to deal with potential funding problems. If, in the end, people are required to move to another location, they should be given a satisfactory period in which a suitable place can be found. The petition calls for that. The committee might agree that it is appropriate for the Health and Community Care Committee to consider whether we need a stronger statutory framework.
I ask members to separate the two issues. Bristow Muldoon referred to the need for a regulatory framework for charitable organisations that provide health care. The committee will take that suggestion seriously, but we are still awaiting the final response from the minister on that issue.There is the immediate problem of Binny House's impending closure. There is not a great deal that the Public Petitions Committee can do about that, other than to appeal to Sue Ryder Care and to Lothian NHS Board to come together for further negotiations around the table, as Bristow Muldoon said. Using the committee as a medium to negotiate with Lothian NHS Board is not the way forward—that would be slow, cumbersome and would not achieve anything. Does any member want to ask Bristow Muldoon questions on Binny House's impending closure?
Is something wrong with the structure of the building? Is there any excuse for Sue Ryder Care to treat it differently from its other homes?
I am not aware of any excuse. In his letter, Mr Henderson mentioned the Care Standards Act 2000, but that is a bit of a red herring. I understand that that is UK legislation that applies to England and Wales and that Lothian NHS Board has advised Sue Ryder Care that the legislation does not apply to Binny House.I am not aware of any substantial problem with Binny House. Over the years, there may need to be a change in how service is delivered there. It is an old building, but it is maintained to quite a high level. The standard of accommodation is high and I am not aware of a substantial structural problem that has driven the decision.
Regulation on a minimum period of consultation is an excellent idea. A big adjustment is involved in a person's going from their own home to a residential home. People settle down and to ask them to move again is absolutely cruel. That has happened in Nairn. Seeing those old people is heartbreaking.
We also need to consider not so much the time span for consultation, but the time between a decision's being taken and its implementation. That is important because people might not consider alternative provision until a decision is made. It can take a long time to find suitable alternative provision.
We will discuss that in the light of the Executive's response on the issue.The difference between the yearly revenue gap figures—the Lothian NHS Board figure of £18,000 and Sue Ryder Care's figure of £250,000—is enormous. What is the basis for the £250,000-a-year claim by Sue Ryder Care?
There is disagreement between Sue Ryder Care and Lothian NHS Board over the true cost. There is also disagreement about the underlying costs of the organisation and some additional costs that have been incurred, which might be managed out. In particular, the degree to which agency nursing has been used recently is an issue, and the question is whether some costs could be managed out by employing staff directly instead of using agency staff. There are other costs that Sue Ryder Care regards as base costs, but which Lothian NHS Board believes can be managed out of the system without the quality of care being affected.In addition to the base-cost offer that Lothian NHS Board made, it offered to underwrite 50 per cent of any cost overrun during the period when some of the costs were being managed out of the system. An offer was made to contribute towards some of the additional costs on an interim basis.
However, Sue Ryder Care claims that it has been running on a deficit of £250,000 a year.
The deficit that it cited previously was £500,000 a year.
At Binny House?
Yes—at Binny House, prior to the opening of the negotiations. However, Lothian NHS Board advises that it was first made aware of the deficit at Binny House in August 2001.
Excuse me, convener. I have an urgent advocacy case to attend, to which I referred earlier. I am sorry. Will the committee still be quorate if I leave?
Yes. We need only three members.There are two issues. The only thing that we can do in respect of the immediate problem is to write back to Sue Ryder Care and Lothian NHS Board, asking them to reopen negotiations because of the urgency of the situation at Binny House. There is not much else that the committee can do. We must then wait for the Executive's response on the further question of the regulatory framework for charitable organisations. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
I ask for clarification. The figure that is cited in the submission is £680 per patient per week. Surely, that figure is much higher than that which one would normally associate with such establishments. Is that figure the offer from Lothian NHS Board or is that a sum that was demanded by Sue Ryder Care?
That figure is the sum that has been offered by Lothian NHS Board and the local authorities concerned. Some patients have especially high levels of need and would be funded to a greater amount than that. However, the majority of patients would be funded to the tune of £680 a week. It is a high figure partly because of the high levels of dependency of the people in the home and partly because Lothian NHS Board feels that it is paying a high premium towards the service and has gone further than it normally would to try to maintain it.
Thanks, Bristow.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Jan 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 15 January 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 68
- New Petitions Petitions · 51
- New Petitions Petitions · 80
- New Petitions Petitions · 60
- New Petitions Petitions · 21
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 41
- Current Petitions Petitions · 18
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.