This morning, we will take evidence on the reform of the enterprise networks and the related transfer of functions, which the committee considered closely at the time of the budget and the Government's statement on the enterprise networks last September. We have four separate panels of witnesses, beginning with representatives from Scottish Enterprise. I am pleased to welcome Jack Perry, the chief executive of Scottish Enterprise; Hugh Hall, its chief financial officer; and Stuart Patrick, its senior commercial director. I thank them all for coming today.Mr Perry, by way of introduction, it might helpful to the committee if you could set out the differences between how your organisation was and how it is now in respect of its budget, its operating staff—on which there has been some comment—and the responsibilities that it used to have and those that it still has.
Official Report · Committee
Enterprise Network Reform
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tavish Scott LD 65
- Jack Perry Scottish Enterprise 61
- David Whitton Lab 42
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 41
- Councillor Hay 38
- Sandy Cumming Highlands and Islands Enterprise 34
- Hugh Hall Scottish Enterprise 29
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 22
- Dave Thompson SNP 19
- David Valentine Society of Local Authority Chief Executives and Senior Managers and Scottish Local Authorities Economic Development Group 14
- Gavin Brown Con 13
- Donald Henderson Skills Development Scotland 11
- Barbara Lindsay Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 10
- Brian Adam SNP 7
- Sandy Brady Highlands and Islands Enterprise 6
- James Fowlie Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 6
- Stuart Patrick Scottish Enterprise 5
- Christopher Harvie SNP 3
- Councillor Alison Hay Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 1
The record
431 contributions · showing 1–200Thank you, convener. I would be delighted to do that. I will first make a few opening remarks, if you do not mind.The last time that we came to see the committee was a little bit unsatisfying for us all. We appeared only two weeks after the Government had issued its budget and we did not, at that stage, understand its implications for us. As a consequence, we had not prepared our budget or developed our business plan. Both of those have now been issued and sent to members individually, so I hope that we will have an opportunity today to answer any questions that members might have on them.Since our last appearance before the committee, we have undertaken a dramatic root-and-branch restructuring of all our operations, following the Government's review of the enterprise networks. We used to be responsible for all the national skills programmes and the business gateway; we also operated through a network of 13 statutory limited companies throughout the country. We have changed all that quite dramatically.The impact on our staffing is as follows. We used to have approximately 2,500 people in the organisation. Approximately 1,200 of them have transferred, principally to Skills Development Scotland, although some have gone to local authorities and some to the Scottish Government. In addition, a voluntary severance programme has reduced our head count by a further 260, which brings it down to roughly 1,050. Some people have been retained for another couple of months so, at 1 April, not all those who selected voluntary severance had left the organisation, but we should have 1,050 staff within the next month or two.We have simplified all our governance structures and streamlined our operations to generate new efficiencies, which we think will provide significantly better value for money for taxpayers. Although the local enterprise companies have been disbanded as statutory limited companies, we have retained all our local offices and are basing more of our staff near our customers so that we can be more responsive to their needs. We will do more of that over the coming year.Operating as a single organisation gives us the flexibility to allocate resources and people where they can have the biggest impact. For example, specialist teams that focus on innovation, internationalisation and infrastructure now operate across an entire region—or, indeed, across Scotland—providing our account-managed customers with the specialist support that they need.We have published our business plan for 2008 to 2011, which sets out our new focus on supporting higher-value business growth and helping to build an internationally competitive business environment. It also highlights the measures of what we will deliver in the coming year. We have set ourselves some ambitious targets for the year that aim to demonstrate our impact in terms of the turnover that we will help our customers to grow, the research and development investment that we will help to stimulate and the private sector investment that we hope to leverage on top of our own spending.We now have clarity of focus, which we have sought for some time, on economic development driven by the demands of our industries and providing support for growing businesses and the business infrastructure that will make Scotland a better place in which to invest.I am happy to take the committee's questions.
You are clear about the staff numbers; could you also be clear about the numbers in relation to the budget for the coming year?
We had a baseline budget of about £550 million after all transfers and the settlement in the spending review. Our operating budget for the coming year will be about £327 million on a resource basis, or about £297 million on a cash basis.
Thank you. We have two types of question this morning. First, colleagues have some questions on detailed matters; we will then consider the wider picture. Please do not think that we are asking only about details—we will also raise some broader themes.
I will start by asking about local economic regeneration. In his statement of 26 September 2007, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth referred to the amount of activity that had transferred from Scottish Enterprise to local authorities. Has there been any change in activity at a local level since 1 April? In other words, how much activity has been transferred to local authorities? What was the spend on local economic development before, and what is it likely to be over the next three years?
I will perhaps bring in Hugh Hall at this point.
It is a very important issue for me.
Of course it is. Local economic development is an area for which Scottish Enterprise has been responsible. In fairness, however, its importance within Scottish Enterprise has been reducing over a number of years. Local authorities have always had a significant role. The work that we did was almost always in partnership with local authorities. Hugh Hall might be able to expand on that.
Since the cabinet secretary's announcement, we have been in discussion with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the Scottish Government about the transfer of our business gateway function and our local regeneration functions. Those discussions have now come to a conclusion. We are tidying up the fine detail of the new arrangements.To summarise what is happening on the regeneration front, we will transfer £12.5 million cash from our budget to local authorities for local regeneration activities. In addition, £12.5 million will be ring fenced within our budget. In the first instance, that will be used to fund projects involving urban regeneration companies. Any available funding beyond that may be used following discussion with local authorities and community planning partnerships. The total sum transferring over is about £25 million.
My information indicates that there was a £50 million budget for local economic development before 1 April. If it has gone down to two tranches of £12.5 million, that would seem to be a reduction.
We provided information to COSLA suggesting that our spend on local regeneration last year was something like £7 million and was in fact reducing. Our board had signed off a strategic investment plan in which, increasingly, any resource that we had to spend on business infrastructure was being dedicated to high-value transformational projects. We were gradually moving away from local regeneration activity in any event.We had an open-book exercise with COSLA and the Scottish Government. We went through each of the projects in our pipeline in very great detail to determine what is a local regeneration project and what is legitimately a business infrastructure project of scale that supports our business plan.There are some grey areas in between. We have been investing quite heavily in infrastructure works in St Andrews, for example, which could be seen as work in the public realm. Looking at that through one lens, one could see that as local regeneration. Through another lens, one could see it as business infrastructure investment and destination management. We had some interesting discussions with COSLA colleagues around that point.
From £50 million to £7 million—that is a big grey area.
I am not sure where the £50 million figure comes from, although it could come straight out of our business plan. Last year we spent £49 million on our local and national infrastructure activities. However, I do not recognise the £50 million figure. Certainly, we could never ascribe that figure to local regeneration—the figure for local regeneration is nothing like that.
Is the £12.5 million over three years?
No—£12.5 million per annum has been transferred to local government for regeneration projects, which we think is a fair and reasonable settlement.
Does COSLA agree?
You can ask its representatives later.
COSLA agreed the figure.
In his statement on 26 September, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth said:"Local regeneration activity in the Scottish Enterprise area will also become the responsibility of local authorities. Currently, Scottish Enterprise is engaged in a range of regeneration and economic development-related activities, including land and property interventions. Some of that regeneration activity is very local in nature".—Official Report, 26 September 2007; c 2074.In light of those comments, will you set out your plans for transferring to Scotland's local authorities the land and property assets that are held for local economic regeneration? It is not just about the revenue costs; what are you going to do about the land and the assets?
We have an asset base that is valued at about £180 million. That has been a major topic of discussion between us and COSLA. We made it clear from the outset that we have to transfer our assets at value—that is a requirement in the Scottish public finance manual. We have also given COSLA and local authorities our list of assets and the evaluation of those assets. We agreed with them that if we were to transfer or sell any of those assets, we would discuss it first with local authorities and give them first shot, if you like. That arrangement is in place. We cannot transfer assets at zero cost, but we are happy to transfer them at value.Now that we have concluded the negotiations and agreed the transfer values, we need to sit down with local government and talk about how we can work together to develop projects. The fact that one cannot put a dividing line between local regeneration and business infrastructure came out of the negotiations. We need to look at how we maximise the total resource available, particularly in tourism, in relation to which both we and local authorities have expertise that we can bring to the table. The same goes for assets—how can we maximise their value?
You said that you have valued all those assets.
We have.
We do it every year.
Can you share that value with the committee?
The total asset value is around £180 million.
Is the expectation that the assets will transfer to local authorities?
No, we will retain the assets in Scottish Enterprise accounts.
So what will happen if there is a piece of land that might be valuable to a community for a local regeneration project?
We have given a list of the assets to all the local authorities and asked them to identify any that they wish to be transferred.
So such an asset would not stay with you—
We would transfer the asset at market value.
That is fine. I also asked whether there has been a reduction in activity at the local level since 1 April. If so, can you quantify it?My last point is important: the cabinet secretary said in answer to questions from the committee that where there were successful partnerships, they would continue, and that Scottish Enterprise would continue to lead and support local economic partnerships in the future. We are down to 10 to 12 account managers in Scottish Enterprise Fife in my constituency. How will you be able to support those successful local partnerships, which are very important to people outwith the cities in particular?
I am happy to answer the final point. It is important to recognise that the account managers are there to serve individual businesses. Our business plan looks to increase the number of account managers. Although we have had a dramatic reduction in our total staffing, during the coming year we will increase by about 10 per cent the number of account managers who serve business customers.We also now have a network of industry specialists in the life sciences, digital media and energy, for example, and in business processes in areas such as manufacturing. That network is available as a national resource to any customer in the country. I do not have the precise number of people who work in our Glenrothes office, but there has been no diminution in the number of account managers serving customers in Fife or anywhere else.
I am comfortable with that—I know that account managers have worked well in Fife. However, you are well aware of partnership projects and other projects that were run by Scottish Enterprise in Fife—you are aware of the three big projects. What role will Scottish Enterprise have in the successful projects that it has been involved in if there are only account managers in the local office? How will you serve and maintain local partnerships that deliver the projects? I am not concerned at all about the account managers.
Okay—good. I am sorry; I thought that there was some confusion.On the management of infrastructure projects, we have an infrastructure team within our regional structure that takes responsibility for the delivery of our projects. Recently, I visited Fife energy park. That project is continuing; we are continuing to work with private and public sector partners to ensure that it is delivered. It fits in with our national programme. We have a very capable infrastructure team in the east of Scotland that will continue to work on such projects. That team will work out of whichever office is appropriate at the time, as all our people do. All our people can now work across and between regions to ensure that we use our expertise to the best of our ability. One of our frustrations with the old network was the rigidity that existed. It was not easy to transfer or second staff or simply have them working across boundaries because of how the budgeting was done and the way in which staff were accountable, but that has all gone. We can now use our most capable people where they can add most value to projects.
Members have a number of supplementary questions.
May I ask a question again that has not been answered? I think that I have asked it three times.
You will have to keep it tight.
Has there been any reduction in activity at a local level since 1 April?
I will be brief. I reassure you that there has been no diminution in activity. We have been an open book on the projects that were in the pipeline, we have shared information with local authorities, and we have a joint commitment to ensure that all those projects are delivered either by Scottish Enterprise or by transferring the cash to local authorities for them to deliver. There has been no reduction in planned activity.
Thank you for your refreshingly blunt answer.
I want to be absolutely clear about the numbers. Jack Perry mentioned a cash budget of £297 million for the year. Is that net of the transfer of £12.5 million, but including the ring-fenced £12.5 million?
Yes.
Hugh Hall cited assets—mainly property assets—of £180 million. Given the recent headlines about the condition of the property market, are you confident that those assets will retain their market value?
That was the asset valuation at the end of the financial year, which was a couple of months ago. Generally speaking, asset values have held up, although we have taken a bit of a hit in one or two areas—on our waterfront investment, for example. We were looking for a planned reduction in value of around 10 per cent, but we have taken a hit of around 20 per cent because of the nature of the market in the area. However, generally speaking, our property investments are holding up reasonably well in the marketplace. We will continue to keep them in view.
It is important to recognise that, to meet our budget, we rely on income from property in respect of both revenue and disposals.
I will go back to Mr Hall's figures for local regeneration, on which I think that he said Scottish Enterprise spent about £7 million last year. If so, why is Scottish Enterprise content to give that area up to £25 million a year?
We are not giving that away: there is £12.5 million for local regeneration, and another £12.5 million for URCs. Our starting position was that we were reducing the amount of investment in local regeneration: we had reckoned that the amount involved was about £7 million or £8 million last year, and it was moving towards £3 million or £4 million. I made the point earlier that it is a grey area: one man's regeneration project is another's business infrastructure project. We had a dialogue with COSLA, examined individual projects, discussed the matter and settled on the cash transfer of £12.5 million. I am not really content with that, as I would have preferred to hang on to more money for investment. COSLA is probably not really happy with it either, but we had to settle on a figure and £12.5 million seems a fair and reasonable settlement. Having settled, the important thing is that we now get on and deliver the programme.
I will move on to national and regional regeneration. I read the following statement in the operating plan: "we have a real challenge in delivering our growing pipeline of projects".However, when Mr Perry appeared before us in November, he said:"We will comfortably meet all the commitments that are currently in the pipeline".—Official Report, Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee, 28 November 2007; c 282.Can he explain the discrepancy between those two statements?
We have a pipeline of potential projects, some of which are at a further stage of development than others. At one end of the pipeline are projects to which we are legally committed, and we have given an indicative commitment to other projects. At the other end of the spectrum, there are projects that are just at the initiation stage. Our total pipeline includes about £80 million-worth of projects that we could do. I am comfortable that we will meet all our commitments; we are not overcommitted or overextended. We will probably not be able to do every project in our pipeline, so we might have to consider rephasing, how we can leverage in greater levels of private sector investment on top and some reprioritising, based on the demands of our key industries.We will manage our pipeline. We know what our cloth is, and we will just have to cut the programmes to fit.
You mentioned that you are planning to increase the number of account managers by 10 per cent. Is that a 10 per cent increase on the number before the restructuring or on what was left after it?
There is no significant difference in the number of account managers before restructuring and after. Certain categories of job were not eligible for voluntary severance, and account managers are at the core of what we do.
Will you give me a rundown of how the transfer of business gateway functions has gone?
I am happy to do that. I may bring in Hugh Hall, who led on most of our negotiations with COSLA.The business gateway negotiations were completed in time for the beginning of the new year. We successfully transferred the management of the business gateway contracts through COSLA to 12 lead local authorities. During that time, we maintained business as usual within the business gateway for our customers. That was done particularly well. In fact, last year, the business gateway served and supported a record number of business start-ups—about 10,400, which is an 11 per cent increase on the previous year. We were pleased that it was business as usual as far as customers were concerned. The contracts are now managed by lead local authorities, but the national inquiry centre, the website and national marketing have remained with us. However, a new joint board that involves us, COSLA, the Scottish Government and business organisations has been created to determine the future for the remaining national functions within the business gateway.In terms of service to business, the new contracts that were introduced last year have been launched successfully and the transfer of functions seems to be operating. The challenge will be to ensure that the working relationship between Scottish Enterprise and the local authorities is positive and constructive, because we need to get a pipeline of fast-growing companies to graduate into account management at Scottish Enterprise.
This is probably just for my benefit, but could you clarify the budget numbers that were transferred over?
The overall budget number that has been transferred over for this financial year is £11.7 million. The figure is very similar for future years: between £11.7 million and £12 million. There is an estimate in the business plan. When we were drawing up the business plan, we estimated a figure of around £11.6 million. Although it is slightly higher, it is pretty much in line with what we said would happen in the business plan.
That is just for the business gateway.
Yes.
You are quite happy that every area that had a business gateway, if I can put it that way, is being served well.
What was planned by way of changes to the service has been implemented. I know from previous discussions that there were concerns about the number of business gateway offices and so on. I do not have a breakdown by local office, but nationally there have been record numbers of inquiries and of new business starts that have been supported. In terms of the operating metrics for the past year, things seem to have gone okay.
Going by my experience in my own area, I am still not aware how many staff have transferred from Scottish Enterprise Dunbartonshire to East Dunbartonshire Council to look after the business gateway there, for example.
Very few staff in total actually transferred with the business gateway. It was about half a dozen overall—that was about the full-time equivalent number involved in the management of the contracts.
We have transferred the salary value to the lead local authorities. We have also agreed—
I am sorry—what does "the salary value" mean? Does that just mean giving local authorities the money to employ people?
The individuals are transferred over under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006, or the salary costs and an additional cost are transferred over to the lead local authorities so that they can employ the staff who are required to run the gateway. We have also agreed with local authorities to have a handover period, during which we will give additional resource and support to ensure a smooth transfer of activities.We will need to have a continuing dialogue around the transfer of knowledge and information between the respective organisations. We are particularly keen for the business gateway to continue to identify growth businesses, which will transfer over to our account management processes. We will rely on the national grouping that is chaired by the Scottish Government and includes Scottish Enterprise and local authorities to ensure that business continuity and liaison are firmly embedded.
Who is on that new national committee?
It is chaired by the Scottish Government, with representatives from Scottish Enterprise, Highlands and Islands Enterprise, COSLA, the Scottish Chambers of Commerce and the Federation of Small Businesses.
Will that body set the targets for business gateway?
No. It will be responsible for determining the future of the national functions that remain at present with Scottish Enterprise—marketing, the national inquiry centre and the national website.
Before I call Gavin Brown, I want to check for the record that six staff have transferred to—
About half a dozen staff actually transferred to individual lead local authorities.
Do those half dozen staff have responsibility for the £11.7 million contracts?
No.
All the business gateway activity is contracted out.
So what do those staff do?
The staff are there to do intelligent client management. They manage the contracts, oversee them and ensure their smooth delivery.
What do the staff who are retained within Scottish Enterprise continue to do? Do they continue to fulfil the national functions that you described earlier?
Yes, absolutely.
How many of them are there?
Gosh, I could not give you that figure. I am happy to provide you with the number who are employed at the national inquiry centre and involved in the website.
Thank you.
To be clear, throughout Scotland only six staff have transferred.
Yes.
Did they really oversee the delivery of more than 10,000 business start-ups?
No. Last year, we re-engineered the contracts and now all the business gateway services are provided by contractors, who operate the business gateway shops and provide the advisers. Scottish Enterprise staff are responsible for the management of the contract—they supervise the contractors. As Hugh Hall explained, six staff who were involved predominantly in doing that transferred. Often, the person in a local enterprise company with responsibility for managing the contract would have other responsibilities as well. It was not a full-time equivalent post, so we transferred a salary-equivalent budget to the local authorities to enable them either to hire someone to do that job or to redeploy someone else within the local authority to fulfil that function.
A transfer of around £600,000 is being made to cover the costs of the necessary staff, so it is not an insubstantial sum of money.
What structures are in place to ensure that high-potential companies are transferred from each of the 32 local authorities upwards to Scottish Enterprise? That seems to me to be pretty important.
Indeed. We will have prospecting managers—it is probably a horrible name—within our local offices to work with the gateway.
Prospecting managers?
Absolutely. They will go out prospecting among the companies served by the business gateway for companies that have the potential to grow to £1 million turnover within three years, and those companies will transfer to account management at Scottish Enterprise. In effect, that is what we did when we had the business gateway in-house, but we have now set up a mechanism to ensure that companies can graduate from the business gateway to account management now that the gateway is operated by local authorities.
Is that happening already?
It is.
With the greatest respect, how do we know that it is happening? If a local authority chose not to pass on the information, for whatever reason—not least of which might be that it wished to have the kudos of taking a company up to a higher level—how would Scottish Enterprise pick up such a company?
Well, to some extent, we have to rely on good will and collaborative behaviour, which are certainly reflected in the nature of the discussions that we have had. I have had very constructive meetings with Pat Watters and his colleagues at COSLA. If someone wants to behave as you describe, we will start to see company growth suffer in their region. Our information systems provide some see-through and our customer relationship management system will give us some information but, at the moment, I cannot think of any reason why the mechanism would not work.
Let us rehearse the situation briefly, taking the area of Scotland that I represent as an example. The business gateway service is provided by Enterprise North East Trust, which is the contractor; I think that it provides the service in Tayside as well as in Grampian. In each area, a lead local authority is now responsible for running the system. If I recall correctly, in the north-east, that is Aberdeenshire Council. Have the funding and staffing that you said are being transferred gone to Aberdeenshire Council for it to provide and manage? Is it correct to say that it is the holder of those resources on behalf of the other local authorities?
That is correct. The value of the contract was its value before the transfer. That is the amount that was transferred to the lead Local Authority, together with a cash sum to cover any additional staffing that the authority now needs to manage the contract.
When the local authorities took on that responsibility, was there a requirement to renegotiate any of the contracts, or did all the contracts go forward as they were?
We were keen for the contracts that had just been awarded and negotiated to remain in place. The whole philosophy was to have a uniform contract throughout Scotland. We knew from the previous regime, when we had 27 different contracts, that there was a huge disparity in performance from contractor to contractor. The whole thrust of renegotiating or developing a single, uniform, national contract, with uniform, national service standards and performance measures, was to allow every contractor to get up to the standard of best of breed from the previous regime. That principle remains intact. I know that there has been a little press speculation and that some local authorities have discussed how they might wish to change in future, but the contract was transferred as it was at the time.
There is a tension between rationalising the contracts to a single national standard, which you had already overseen, and then devolving the management to 12 different groups of local authorities? Does that tension cause you concern?
Potentially but, in our discussions, COSLA was keen to maintain that national standard.
We have had those negotiations over recent months and, as I think we mentioned in the business plan, we welcome the increased commitment of local authorities to local regeneration and local economic development. We have a joint commitment to ensure business continuity. We have to retain the confidence of the contractors who supply the services and ensure that the customers and potential customers of the business gateway are well served. I do not see that there is anything between us in that regard.How local authorities will want to deliver the business gateway in the future is a matter for them; we transferred the activity to them. However, we would like to think that any changes that take place—particularly substantive ones—will be subject to discussion with Scottish Enterprise in the joint forum of the Scottish Government, Scottish Enterprise and COSLA.
The three-year contracts are all new, so there is no reason that you are aware of why any of them should be subject to renegotiation in those three years.
There is no reason why they should be, but the nature of the contract is such that if someone wished to renegotiate it, they could.
If a local authority—not necessarily a lead authority—decided that it was no longer going to spend money on things that it was not obliged by statute to spend money on, would the services be protected?
I am not sure that I can answer that.
Perhaps that is a question for COSLA colleagues later, but my understanding is that the cash is transferred not ring fenced. A contractual commitment is in place that would have to be negotiated away somehow, but that question is more for COSLA than it is for Scottish Enterprise.
But I think that you are saying that the test of the success of the process will come when the contracts are up for renegotiation in three years' time.
Yes, but I am also saying that I cannot imagine that local authorities will want to damage the existing service provision. If anything, they will want to see whether there is any way that they can improve the contracts, with an eye on local provision. Marketing might be looked at, for example, and the extent to which investment should be in local or national marketing or a balance between the two. There is scope for further discussions, but they would be about refining and improving the contracts, rather than the withdrawal of a service.
It is interesting to find out what has happened as a result of the reorganisation, but it is still Scottish Enterprise's business to make Scotland's economy grow. The Government has identified that as few as 115 companies in Scotland have a turnover of £100 million. A lot of your money and effort is supposed to be directed at high growth. What confidence can you give us that you will help to grow the number of larger companies that will be dynamic enough to generate the jobs that we need for the future?
What you described is what we are now charged to do. I stress that our job is to make a measurable contribution to that goal. I also stress that we have less than 1 per cent of the Scottish Government's budget. That is why we support and are greatly encouraged by the Government's economic strategy, which sets out the alignment that all of Government has to have behind growth. You simply cannot give us less than 1 per cent of the budget and say, "Over to you—on you go." Unless everyone is committed to the agenda, it is not going to happen. We have talked a lot about the need for greater alignment of public investment towards growth, to provide the infrastructure for growth companies to flourish.Within our remit, we can do an awful lot. We can leverage a lot of private sector investment into transformational projects such as the Edinburgh BioQuarter. We invested about £23 million and attracted £250 million of private sector investment in that project, which is creating 1.4 million square feet of dedicated commercial space for the life sciences. That is a pretty good return on the investment.We can also drive more innovation in our growth companies. That is why we segmented 1,900 companies; there are 300,000 companies in Scotland and we account manage 1,900 of them. In our business plan, we mention deeper engagement with those companies, using innovative programmes such as the proof of concept programme, the intermediary technology institutes, Scottish Health Innovations Ltd and the translational medicine research institute, and making better connections between those projects and companies that can commercialise the intellectual property that they develop. We work with them on process improvement through the Scottish manufacturing advisory service.Companies in Scotland underinvest in research and development. Can we encourage and stimulate more of that? Our work is not just about development into products but about process improvement. We work with tourism businesses on service improvements and business models. Our work is about deeper engagement with companies, about driving more innovation into our companies, and about transformational projects in which we leverage in more investment.Our business plan contains a measure of the contribution to growth that we can add to our account-managed companies, and you can compare that with growth for a control group of other companies in Scotland. We believe that we make a genuine difference.That is what we are committed to in our business plan. Our high-growth start-up unit is another example. It is working with 20 to 30 new companies that can get up to £5 million of turnover relatively rapidly. In last year's Deloitte fast 50, the top three of the 50 fastest-growing companies in Scotland were products of our national high-growth start-up unit. Our work is about building companies of scale, which is not easy, but we are focused on doing that and we are up for it. It is all about business growth.Sorry. That was a long-winded answer to a simple question but, as you can tell, I feel strongly about the matter.
Before I bring in Christopher Harvie, will you elaborate on the ITIs, which you mentioned? The operating plan contains a figure that illustrates that their financial support is being reduced. Will you explain the reason for that?
You will see in the plan that the figure for last year was £53 million. That included £8 million for a one-off project, so the baseline was £45 million. The figure for this year is £38 million, so it has reduced. As a percentage of our total budget, however, it is larger than ever.I am afraid that you will see some reductions throughout our budget. Most of them are in overheads, which have taken the largest single hit. In some areas, we are growing. However, the figure was agreed with ITI Scotland and we believe that it will be able to manage a full programme. As with the pipeline of physical projects that I described, it might be able to do more, but it will manage its commitments. Many of its programmes last for a significant period of time. It will honour all its commitments and will be able to do new projects as well.
So you are comfortable that, in three or four years' time, the ITIs will still be an essential part of the infrastructure.
We remain committed to the ITI project. Will it continue to evolve as it has done? Yes. Ultimately, it is not a programme to commission research. If that is all that we achieve, we might as well be one of the research councils or the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council. It is a company growth programme—it is about high-technology growth companies. Now that it has been operating for three or four years, and many of its programmes are reaching maturity, the big challenges are how we can more rapidly commercialise the intellectual property that it has created; how we can drive it into the account-managed base; and how we can bring in new investment from outside Scotland to commercialise it. The model will almost certainly evolve.
That sounds like a logical, flowing consecutive programme but, in my discussions with Scottish businessmen in Germany, I was conscious that they believed that Scottish Enterprise was overly fixated across the Atlantic, and not sufficiently conscious of its European relations. Now that we have a situation in which the dollar is collapsing vis-à-vis the euro, is it not time to develop much closer relations with Germany? We now know that German companies have extensive shopping lists in terms of inward investment in this country. What steps are being taken along those lines?
We have beefed up our continental Europe team—we have an office in Düsseldorf, and we have beefed up the northern European team that is based in Paris. We are more engaged with Europe. The propositions are often quite different because Scotland is an integral part of the European Union and the investment needs and objectives of EU-resident investors are different from those of investors outside the EU.We are absolutely interested in having better connections, particularly for Scottish companies to invest in and exploit European markets. We have increased our staff numbers in those areas and we will continue to monitor the situation. You will see in the Scottish Enterprise business plan budget that, despite the fact that we have had to cut our cloth, our commitment to Scottish Development International is undiminished right through the three years of the plan. It has been completely protected and we will continue to view it as an essential part of what we do.
I had the opportunity at the oil energy conference in Aberdeen yesterday to talk to Duncan Botting, the new managing director of ITI Energy. He is ambitious, as are all the ITIs, to deliver on his objectives. You say that this is a priority area, but the budget is reducing, which clearly has consequences. One of the purposes behind ITI Scotland is to lever private investment. Do you work to an equation in terms of how much private investment you get for how much public investment? How is that relationship changing?
We do not have a prescriptive figure for ITI, although we do for our investment funds. The real challenge now is the relationship between ITI and Scottish Enterprise, because ITI has been involved in market foresighting and commissioning research, and it is now harvesting the intellectual property that is coming out from that. It has now registered more than 117 patents.The real challenge is the level of private sector investment that we can get, which will take a variety of forms. Some of the investment will involve straightforward licensing to either domestic or overseas companies, from which we can realise value. Some will involve overseas investment coming into Scotland and establishing operations. The form of investment that was originally intended and which we hope will be the largest single one is indigenous Scottish companies running with the intellectual property. ITI does not have the company formation or the relationship, systems and procedures that Scottish Enterprise has. ITI is a wholly owned subsidiary of Scottish Enterprise, so it is important that we effectively gear up those relationships and the deeper knowledge and understanding of our account managers of what is coming out of ITI now. That is a big challenge.A review is going on into how that will work and what ITI and Scottish Enterprise need to do differently in the future to maximise our ability to exploit that intellectual property.
I think that you are saying that that is about communicating internally as well as externally.
Absolutely.
I want to pick up on a point that you made about SDI. When will the new chief executive be appointed?
The appointment is imminent. I hope that there will be an announcement shortly.
When the new chief executive is appointed and given what you said in answer to Christopher Harvie, will SDI have a new focus on Europe rather than America, and will it operate slightly differently?
I certainly expect the new chief executive to have an open mind about how we operate. However, the new international framework is in place, and SDI has continually evolved. We have dramatically changed our overseas representation, and we continually review the operations of our overseas offices. There is a renewed emphasis, which I expect to continue, on the internationalisation of Scottish companies. I expect there to be a shift in the balance between inward and outward investment. North America remains very important to us. That does not mean that Europe is unimportant but, in terms of figures for foreign investment, North America is the largest investor by far. With regard to our priority industries, the United States is 83 per cent of the world life sciences market. Everything has consequences; we could spend loads more on this stuff. Again, though, it is a question of priorities.
You say that you could spend loads more. I assume that you have had a discussion about that with the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth, and that he said that you cannot have any more.
We go through all our priorities in developing our budget and business plan, and we reckoned that we got the right balance.
Is that what you reckoned was the right balance or what the cabinet secretary reckoned was the right balance?
It is what we reckon is the right balance within the funds that have been made available to us. One of the things that we are working on in the course of the year—
Mr Hall, you could become an MSP with an answer like that.
The acting chief executive of SDI, Lena Wilson, had a successful trip to India just in the past couple of weeks. When she came back to the office she said to me, "There are great opportunities here. We need to look at increasing the resource. Can you make some money available?" The challenge for people such as me and Stuart Patrick is to consider our business and ask, "Can we carve out some more money? Can we do less of certain things? Can we reduce the overheads?" We will seek to free up as much resource as we can to invest in particular activities.
But it comes back to what Mr Perry said about having less than 1 per cent of the Scottish budget. If your task is to grow Scotland's economy, and you are telling us that there are great opportunities to be had in India, China or elsewhere, but you are not being given the budget, you are fighting with one hand tied behind your back, are you not?
Let me put it this way: I suspect that you will not find that anyone who comes before you will say that they want less money. For example, I suspect that people from the areas of health or education would say the same as us. Do I have a great big wish list? Of course I do.
Right.
The budget is the budget. We have made our priorities and that is what we will deliver.
On the question of the imminent appointment of the chief executive, will that be this week, next week or next month? Have you gone through an interview process and whittled the choice down to one person, or will it be an in-house appointment?
I will just say at this stage that the appointment is imminent. I am happy to give the committee notice of when that will be.
We can come back to that, David.Gentlemen, one of your key industrial sectors is the creative industries. I am interested in the issue of creative Scotland, particularly the Creative Scotland Bill. The bill's policy memorandum states that creative Scotland will have a cultural and economic remit. Has there been any transfer between Scottish Enterprise and creative Scotland in respect of its economic remit, or is any transfer planned when that body is up and running?
To my knowledge, no transfer is planned for that remit. We support many sub-sectors of the creative industries substantially. On 19 March, evidence was provided to the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee that detailed the extent and nature of that investment. I am happy to provide a copy of that evidence, although I am sure that the committee has access to it.The creative industries remain an important sector for us to continue to support. Of the 13 sub-sectors of the creative industries that the National Endowment for Science, Technology and the Arts identified, we heavily support interactive leisure software, publishing, software and computer services, television and radio. We support designer fashion through our textile team and design businesses through our account management. We also support advertising and architecture. We are not big into art and antiques, crafts, music or the performing arts, which will belong—properly—to creative Scotland. However, we provide much for the important sub-sectors in our priority industry of digital media.
Is it fair to assume that, because ministers have signed off the operating plan—you gave a clear answer on the record about that—ministers absolutely endorse the allocation of responsibilities and budgets to Scottish Enterprise that you describe?
Ministers have signed off our business plan.
We talked about local economic regeneration, but we referred only in passing to national projects. Is Ravenscraig a national regeneration project?
Ravenscraig remains one of our commitments at the moment. It is a long-term project. How it evolves will be subject to further negotiation and discussion. We have a current commitment, on which I ask Hugh Hall to elaborate.
We have a current legal commitment of about £4 million, but the forward commitment is even greater. We are currently committed to that but, as with all our investments and projects, we will keep that under review. We will look to discuss the shape of our future role with local councils and the other partners.
Does a group of projects of which we should be aware lie in the grey area between clear forward commitments by you and clear local authority responsibilities?
Several projects have a regional dimension, so they lie in that middle space—the URCs are the obvious examples. We are involved in and continue to be committed to the URCs and we work with local authorities to ensure successful outcomes. We are and will continue to be in that regional space.
Jack Perry mentioned that Scottish Enterprise has retained all its local offices and that they have more staff than before. Has the increase in the number of staff in those offices been major?
We now have 1,050 staff. I cannot give exact numbers but, before all the transfers, we had about 600 staff in Atlantic Quay in Glasgow. We are considering a redeployment plan to reduce that number to about 150, so the remainder of those staff will be redeployed to local offices around the country. Does that mean that all 12 local offices will have more people than before? Not necessarily. However, overall, a much higher percentage of our total staff will be deployed in local offices.
We will not have a settled position until the end of this financial year, because a major component is the withdrawal of most of our staff from Atlantic Quay on a rolling programme over Christmas and into early next year.I make it absolutely clear that when we talk about retaining a local presence, that is not a firm commitment to keep all our local offices open in the future. One idea that we are considering is co-locating with local authority services and other non-departmental public bodies, such as VisitScotland. Retaining a local presence does not necessarily mean retaining a physical office.
What level of delegated authority do your local offices have? Have you increased it or do you plan to increase it?
We have a system of delivery agreements which, in effect, subdivide the budgets so that local offices can go ahead and deliver. Do you want to expand on that, Hugh?
I think that that covers it. We have a scheme of delegation. A sum of money is agreed at the start of the financial year. The account managers, local directors and so on can commit up to that level of expenditure. That is broadly in line with the scheme that we had before, although there are no longer local boards.
To what amount can your local managers commit? Is it 10 grand, 20 grand, 100 grand or another amount?
They can commit to anything up to the level of the budget that has been set.
So they could give somebody the whole budget.
They cannot do that. If something is in the delivery agreement, they can go ahead and do it—they do not need further authority—but they cannot spend above what is in the delivery agreement in their area. Local boards could approve projects up to £1 million. As Hugh Hall said, that level of authority does not exist now. That responsibility now rests with the executive board at Scottish Enterprise.
Do you have a specific figure for any local area office?
No. The offices themselves are not operating entities as such; they operate within the region. They are not separate business units. Within the office there will be people who are responsible to an industry team, people who are responsible to a regional team, and people who are specialists who are responsible to an infrastructure innovation team. That is the matrix that we have created. The budgets and so on will be defined within those specific areas. If something is in the delivery agreement for a specific area, the offices can go ahead and do it.
Dave Thompson asked earlier about the numbers in the organisation. If my arithmetic is right, 150 staff members are staying in Glasgow and, therefore, 450 will be moving around Scotland. Is that correct?
The number might be slightly less than that. I do not have the breakdown with me. We had about 650 staff members in Atlantic Quay before the transfers. I do not have the split of the number of transfers out prior to the redeployment.
If it is possible to furnish the committee with the detail of that, we would all be interested to see it.
We can certainly do that. What Hugh Hall said is correct: there is now a rolling programme. The remaining 150 or so staff members at Atlantic Quay will co-locate with the Scottish Government and Skills Development Scotland; the Scottish Government is moving out of Meridian Court and Europa house in Glasgow.
It is self-evident that you have a big human resources task in respect of people moving away from Glasgow who have families, mortgages and schools to consider.
We hope that many will redeploy to offices within a commutable distance. We are moving out our information technology support unit, which is a definable business unit. We have a number of staff who commute from long distances, so we hope that they will be able to work much closer to home. We expect that a number of people will move to Edinburgh and the east as well.
So, on decentralisation from Glasgow, there will not be decentralisation and most people are expecting to be able to commute to their place of work.
We certainly hope so. We do not want to spend huge sums on that.
I have a question on the budget, but I also want to follow up on what the convener asked. In Fife, there were about 25 to 30 staff and now there are 10 to 12. My concern is that we have lost local expertise. We have lost good people such as Joe Noble—you know the people whom we have lost. The situation will be the same across the country. In redeploying people, you lose expertise, which is a worry to the local authority and many key stakeholders in my area. I just wanted to put that on the record.I want to follow up Dave Thompson's point. You said that regional directors will have no flexibility outwith the agreed budget. Previously, if there was a new project coming up in Fife, it could go to the board with a budget set at, for example, £1 million, but there was flexibility in that. What you are saying is that regional directors now have no flexibility and that everything will come back to Atlantic Quay.
Under the old regime, boards could approve projects, but they could not go ahead if there was no budget. Projects were always subject to affordability and that continues to be the case. We are actively encouraging local teams and our industry teams to develop new projects and to fill the pipeline. We welcome competition for funding and we want to support the projects that will create greatest added value for Scotland.
Will those projects have to come back to Atlantic Quay for approval?
The fact that we are operating with a regional structure means that we have a managing director of regional operations. He—
Or she.
It happens to be a he, but you are right. He holds a high level of delegation, which he can decide how to apply with his regional directors in a management team. Although the regional directors will not have the same style of delegated authority that they had previously with LEC boards, they will operate as a management team to exert that delegated authority with the managing director of regional operations.
I would appreciate some written information on that because it is important.I come back to the budget. The Sunday Herald stated in March 2008 that £12 million was transferred from Scottish Enterprise to COSLA for the business gateway—I can understand that—and £25 million was transferred to COSLA for local economic development. You have explained the figure: £12.5 million for local economic development and £12.5 million for urban regeneration. However, COSLA's delegation stated in evidence to the committee in November that it understood that the budget for local regeneration"could be around £100 million"—Official Report, Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee, 28 November 2007; c 335. I had heard that the figure had dropped and that the negotiations would be around the figure of £50 million. I know that you will tell me to ask COSLA, but is there still a big difference between Scottish Enterprise and COSLA on the figure? I would appreciate a straight answer. It appears that you think that the figure should be £12.5 million, but COSLA thinks it should be more.
We have agreed the transfer of funding. We have struck what I think is a fair and reasonable deal and that is the resource that will be transferred.
We will ask COSLA in a few minutes.
I will pick up on the point that Lewis Macdonald raised about Ravenscraig—I want to understand the position. You say that the Ravenscraig development is a national priority and that you are fully committed to it. Phase 2 is the big-spend part in which a new railway station, railway sidings and factories will be built, as well as housing. We have been told in evidence that if the phase 2 commitment from Scottish Enterprise does not go ahead, the development will just become a massive housing estate. Are you totally committed to phase 2 of Ravenscraig—yes or no?
We are committed to working with our partners in Ravenscraig. We have continued involvement and a legal commitment of £4 million, which we will honour. As I said, the future commitments are substantial, so we will need to consider what our continuing involvement will be.
That does not sound like a 100 per cent commitment to me.
As with all our forward commitments, particularly when they are on such a scale, we keep it under review, but we continue to be involved and committed.
I was not aware of the position of Joe Noble at Scottish Enterprise Fife, although I am aware of the position of Jennifer Craw at Scottish Enterprise Grampian. How many of the 12 chief executives of local enterprise companies have now left the organisation?
Nine out of 12 have left.
That is a significant loss of local expertise.
The largest single element by far of our severance programme, which was part of our restructuring, was at director and senior manager level. We have taken out substantial layers of management. That is on top of a severance programme for 40 directors and senior managers a year ago. Our staffing model was very top heavy. You mentioned good people who are extremely capable and who did a very good job for us but who have chosen to go off and do other things based on the availability of a severance programme. We were limited to voluntary severances and had to make some tough choices about whom we would allow to go.
The loss of local expertise caused a lot of concern when the changes were announced last year. Might Scottish Enterprise come back to us again in a few months' time to tell us how that local expertise has been replaced?
I am absolutely confident that we have very capable people in all the new leadership positions in the organisation. It is a different structure from that which we operated previously, but I am absolutely confident that our regional directors are extremely talented and capable people. The people in our new infrastructure team, with the leadership that they show, are also extremely capable. Although we were sad to lose experienced people who did a very good job for us, the new team is highly capable.
Thank you for coming this morning. I am sure that we will return to the issues that we have discussed, not least during the budget process later in the year. We are grateful for your time and evidence. We will look out for the other information in due course, when your organisation has a chance to provide it to the committee.
I will be happy to provide it.
Let us move straight to the second panel of the morning on the enterprise network reform and transfer of functions. We will wait while the traffic jam of witnesses sorts itself out.Having dealt with Scottish Enterprise—that might sound a bit pejorative—we turn now to Highlands and Islands Enterprise. We are pleased to welcome this morning Sandy Cumming, the chief executive and Sandy Brady, the director of strategy. Mr Cumming, you are welcome to say a few words of introduction, but as I asked Jack Perry to do, it would be helpful if you would cover budget numbers and the organisation's new shape and responsibilities compared with the previous position.
Thank you and good morning to everyone. When we last appeared before the committee back in November, we affirmed our commitment to change and our enthusiasm to refocus our efforts to deliver sustainable economic growth across all parts of the Highlands and Islands. Today we are fully focused on three activities. First, we will support high-growth businesses in key sectors and, by so doing, raise regional and national growth. Secondly, we are very much involved in creating the infrastructure and conditions to improve regional competitiveness. Thirdly, and importantly, we will be strengthening communities, especially in the fragile parts of our area.Today I can report that HIE's reorganisation is largely complete. We have reshaped our structure, we have reduced our workforce through voluntary severance and we have successfully transferred our careers function and individual training and skills programmes to the new agency, Skills Development Scotland. We have also made changes at board level. The HIE board is now slimmer; we have eight members instead of 12. I will be happy to take questions on those changes.During 2008, we continue to work very closely with the local authorities, which are our key partners. I will highlight our work in the development of single outcome agreements in the Highlands and Islands. We believe that it has been very productive and we look forward to further involvement with single outcome agreements. We continue to be very involved in community planning and we are taking every opportunity to co-locate with our local government colleagues and other public sector bodies. We continue to develop the business gateway approach for the Highlands and Islands in partnership with COSLA and the local authorities.Our chair, Willy Roe, has taken opportunities to meet—in some cases—full councils, but he has certainly met senior members of local authorities throughout the Highlands and Islands to communicate the changes that are taking place in HIE. He will complete that task with the remaining local authorities over the next six weeks. Our organisation remains highly ambitious for the Highlands and Islands and we believe that we are in good shape to deal with the opportunities and challenges that lie ahead.As regards the specific changes that the convener asked about, among the biggest changes has been the change in staff numbers. Until the end of March we were an organisation of 550 full-time equivalent staff; today we are moving towards having 350 staff. That is a significant reduction. Our resource budget last year was close to £132 million and this year it will be £92 million, which in cash terms means a shift from £118 million to £78 million.With regard to specific changes that are outlined in the operating plan, we no longer have responsibility for careers advice, national training programmes and individual skills grants. This is also a transition year for business advice and information. Over the course of the year, we will lose that responsibility as we develop the business gateway model for the Highlands and Islands. However, it is important that we retain that responsibility until we can say—and until the local authorities are confident—that the new model is ready.Before I conclude, I will highlight three other significant changes for HIE. First, we are introducing the account management model that Scottish Enterprise explained earlier. Our previous approaches were not similar: this time we are very much going down the same route. Secondly, as the operating plan makes clear, we have refreshed our approach to strengthening communities. Finally, at the beginning of June, we will introduce our new policy of small business grants.
You made two references to continuing to develop the business gateway model and you said that this year—meaning, I presume, the current financial year—would be a transition year. My understanding was that the Government wanted to put business gateway out to competitive tender on a pan-Highlands and Islands basis, the practicalities of which, as you know, I had extreme concerns about from a constituency point of view. Yesterday, I received a letter from Jim Mather saying that, after three and a half months, the Government still did not know what it was going to do on this matter. Are you in a position to tell us more about how the business gateway will be delivered in the Highlands and Islands?
Discussions are on-going. We are here to take forward the final decision on how the model will be designed and delivered in the Highlands and Islands.Over the past six months, we have spent a lot of time getting to know the business gateway product and have, in the course of that work, established very good relationships with the local authorities, COSLA, the Scottish Government and Scottish Enterprise. We have created a business gateway liaison group and, after making a number of visits to find out how the gateway operates in the Scottish Enterprise area, we have a clearer understanding of the current system. However, you are absolutely right to say that the final decision on this matter has yet to be made.
Does HIE have a view on the competitive tendering proposal? Would you, for example, prefer the gateway to be tendered in areas where there are business interests? That might be possible in Moray and the wider Inverness area, but it simply will not work in some of the islands. How might the approach be developed to ensure that we achieve what we all want, which is effective operation of the business gateway across the whole area?
Our organisation fundamentally believes in the value of procurement. We think that it is healthy, provides value for money, is very transparent and is competitive. As I made clear when I previously discussed the issue with the committee, a private sector company already delivers throughout the Highlands and Islands, on our behalf, not what might be called business gateway but business advisory services that are broadly similar to what is delivered under the business gateway.
Good value in procurement does not need to take place on a pan-Highlands and Islands basis. Surely it can be developed more locally.
With procurement, there is the opportunity to have either a single contract or a more flexible contract that takes account of the various subeconomies in the Highlands and Islands. As I have said, discussions are on-going, and we await the final decision of the Scottish Government and COSLA.
What in the meantime is happening to provision of local practical business advice in, say, Inverness, Kinlochbervie and Baltasound?
I am pleased to say that it is business as usual. The approach that was enjoyed and valued by people until the end of March continues. We still have the contract with a company called Development Partners, which provides one-to-one business advice and information.
When do you hope to hear an announcement on the final shape of what will exist in the future?
The decision will be made fairly soon. However, given that this is a transition year, the new model might not be in place until towards the end of the current financial year. I realise that that is a long time, but the key decision that we await is on whether the model will be procured uniformly throughout the Highlands and Islands.
Given the letter that I have received from the Minister for Enterprise, Energy and Tourism, that decision will be made by ministers.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 May 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 21 May 2008 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- Enterprise Network Reform Evidence session · 431
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.