Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports (Responses)

“Managing the use of medicines in hospitals—A follow-up review”

Wednesday 17 June 2009 Public Audit Committee Committee business 17 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Item 5 is a section 23 report. We have received a response from the accountable officer on the Auditor General's report "Managing the use of medicines in hospitals—A follow-up review". Do members have any questions or comments on the response?

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I am a wee bit concerned about the answer to our second question. If I remember our discussion on the matter correctly, everybody thought that the system that is used in NHS Ayrshire and Arran is a good one that should be rolled out if it is proven to be able to do the job. However, the responses to our first two questions say that, even if work is done to prove that that model could work throughout the NHS in Scotland, it will still be up to each health board to decide whether it wants a stand-alone system. I am all for local democracy and people taking decisions at a local level, but those decisions must take cost effectiveness into account. If we have put in a lot of work, nationally, to find out whether that is a good system, I do not see the clinical or cost benefits of telling boards that they have the choice to go with the system that we recommend or to pick up a system of their own. Am I right in my understanding of that response? Is that what it is saying, and is that the best use of resources to date and in the future?

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

The response talks about health boards following that example if they feel that the business case is proven. It states:"we intend to carry out an assessment of the experience in Ayrshire and Arran to help inform such Board level business cases."When we discussed the issue, did we consider writing to the health boards individually?

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I do not think that we did. One of our problems is that, although in considering the report and following it up we are commenting on the use of resources, we are starting to talk about clinical and policy issues. We might need to refer the matter to the Health and Sport Committee for its consideration, because it would not be appropriate for us to go into detail on whether, from a practice perspective, the proposed approach is the right way to proceed. We have made some comments on effectiveness and efficiency. We must tread a fine line.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I understand what the convener says. In fact, that is one of my constant frustrations with the Public Audit Committee's remit.I find the response extremely strange. We discussed the report on a Wednesday and I met Lothian NHS Board on the Friday. I raised two issues: the hospital electronic prescribing and medicines administration system, and generic prescribing. The board told me that it was developing its own system of electronic prescribing and gave me the percentage of generic medicines that it uses, which is extremely high, as it has been working on the issue.However, the response says:"Outwith NHS Ayrshire and Arran there are no systems in place".Do these guys in the civil service in Edinburgh really know what is going on? I think that they just sit there and send letters out; I do not think that they ever get out and about to find out what is happening in the health boards. The Auditor General does. Are other members happy about that?Anne McLaughlin made a very good point. Why do we not write to the health boards directly, rather than ask the civil service to do it, because it does not seem to be doing anything? To pick up what Nicol Stephen said about the Danish system, instead of relying on the civil service, at some point we ought to visit one of the health boards to follow up an important issue and find out what is happening.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I do not know whether anyone from Audit Scotland can throw any light on the matter but, again, we need to be careful not to go beyond our remit, which we will do if we start to examine clinical practice policy.

Mr Black
link

The team has just passed me a copy of the supplement to the follow-up report, which contains a paragraph that might be helpful. It might be that the issue is to do with the nature of the information that is communicated. The HEPMA system is a general system for hospital prescribing, but a paragraph in the supplement to the follow-up report talks about"Specialty-specific electronic prescribing and medicines administration systems".It says:"Seven NHS boards have at least one electronic prescribing and medicines administration system for an individual specialty".NHS Lothian is one of half a dozen boards that have"the oncology system called Chemocare"and one of two boards that have a renal system.What comes out from that report is that, as ever, it is a moving picture. It is clear that NHS Lothian was certainly active in the field of electronic prescribing but that it did not have a total system at the time that we produced our report.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

A number of options are open to us. We could go back to the accountable officer and ask for further information, should we need it. We must also decide whether there is an issue for the Health and Sport Committee to consider. Is there any information that members would like Kevin Woods to provide?

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

When we discussed the report, it emerged that a huge amount of money was spent on medicines in hospitals. I worked out what percentage it was of the total block grant, but I forget the figure. There is a great potential for saving, given what is said in the excellent report that we received from the Auditor General. However, all that we have done is send a letter to the accountable officer, who has given us—I do not know why Andrew Welsh, who usually says these things, refuses to comment—just a lot of verbiage that does not deal with all the points that we raised.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I am inclined to agree with what the convener said. It is clear from the report that a patient management system is being rolled out, given that the contract for it will be awarded in the autumn. From my reading of the report, there is scope for boards to choose whatever is appropriate to their situation. That is a matter for clinical judgment, of which we need to be respectful. Progress seems to be being made in gathering information and on prescribing mechanisms, but the clear message from the response is that the decisions should be based on clinical judgment, which can be applied more appropriately by boards. I am quite happy with that.

Andrew Welsh SNP Angus
link

I agree with that. The great danger is that we end up in a position of telling boards what their policy should be. Cathie Craigie mentioned the need for cost effectiveness, which is what we hope systems will achieve. The response states:"It remains open to Boards to procure a stand-alone system if they believe there is a good business case. Indeed, we intend to carry out an assessment of the experience in Ayrshire and Arran to help inform such Board level business cases."Ultimately, such matters are for board policy. We should seek to ensure that boards are better informed, but we have been told that that is what will happen. To start deciding what the policy would be in individual health boards would be a dangerous road for the committee to go down. We can encourage boards to be involved in best practice.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Do we require additional specific information from the accountable officer? If not, I suggest that we note the response and refer it to the Health and Sport Committee for its interest. If we need further information, let us ask for it. I am in the hands of committee members.

Andrew Welsh SNP Angus
link

Will George Foulkes explain that? It is news to me.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

He can explain it outside the committee.

Andrew Welsh SNP Angus
link

I can assure the committee that I have not been got at by anyone.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Let us leave all that aside. Do we require specific further information from Kevin Woods?As the answer is no, we will note the response, thank Audit Scotland for its report and refer the matter to the Health and Sport Committee for its interest.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Audit Committee Wednesday 17 June 2009 Committee business · 1
  2. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Audit Scotland (Annual Report) Committee business · 25
  4. National Health Service (Information Issues) Committee business · 22
  5. Scottish Government (Progress Report) Committee business · 18
  6. Section 23 Reports (Responses) Committee business · 17
  7. Section 23 Reports (Responses) Committee business · 8
  8. Section 23 Reports (Responses) Committee business · 9
  9. Section 22 Reports (Response) Committee business · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.