Agenda item 3 is our continuing inquiry into the extension of the First ScotRail passenger rail franchise. Mr Guy Houston is with us. I thank him for agreeing to give evidence to the committee. I am sure that what he says will be very helpful to us in our considerations.I understand that you do not wish to make any opening comments, Mr Houston. Is that correct?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Report
“The First ScotRail passenger rail franchise”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Guy Houston Former Director of Finance and Corporate Services, Transport Scotland 184
- Hugh Henry Lab 126
- Nicol Stephen LD 115
- Sir John Elvidge Scottish Government Permanent Secretary 63
- Paul Gray Scottish Government Change and Corporate Services Directorate 27
- James Kelly Lab 18
- Cathie Craigie Lab 14
- Andrew Welsh SNP 12
- Murdo Fraser Con 11
- Willie Coffey SNP 8
- Anne McLaughlin SNP 6
- Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland 3
- Angela Cullen Audit Scotland 3
- Mr Black 2
- Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland 1
The record
595 contributions · showing 1–200Yes. This is just my opportunity to set the record straight.
Thank you. Before we take questions from the committee, perhaps you could help us to clarify a couple of points of fact. In paragraphs 2a, 2b and 2c of your letter of 14 March 2007 to Malcolm Reed, you refer to increases in your shareholding. At 2a, you say that you had 16,722 shares that you were able to buy at £2.751 of an option price. What was the share price at that date, roughly?
The date that I exercised them?
Yes.
I do not know. It was about £5 or £6. The figure in the letter should read "£2.75", not "£2,751".
Okay. We can get the exact figure later on.At paragraphs 2b and 2c, you say that you had exercised 6,309 shares and 3,432 shares respectively "at £Nil option price." Does that mean that you were able to buy them at zero cost? The committee is not familiar with the phrase.
Yes. On all those share options, you pay tax on whatever the value of the shares is on the date that you exercise them. If, when you exercise them, the value of the shares is £5, you pay 40 per cent tax on £5. In the case of the shares that are set out in paragraph 2a, you pay on the difference between £5 and the option price. So, I pay £2.75 for the shares that are set out in paragraphs 2a, 2b and 2c. The "£Nil option" relates to bonus payments; instead of receiving cash bonuses, you receive share bonuses. That was way back in 2003-04.
Was that income tax?
Yes.
So, it relates to your income for the year in which the share option is exercised.
Yes.
So, if you earned sufficient to trigger the 40 per cent band—which you did—you would pay that rate.
Yes.
I should clarify that you have not yet exercised the third option under paragraph 2c. Is that correct?
Correct.
In the second paragraph on page 3 of your letter to the committee, you say:"As part of the process, Audit Scotland was shown a copy of the letter you see attached. Therefore, the statement from the Auditor General in earlier evidence that ‘we certainly had no knowledge of the Director of Finance's particular private interest in this issue' seems difficult for me to reconcile."I have raised the matter with Audit Scotland, but it has no recollection of seeing the letter. Did you show it to Audit Scotland or did someone else in Transport Scotland show it to Audit Scotland?
I do not know. I was involved in the discussions with Audit Scotland that took place round about June 2007. I do not remember the exact details, but Audit Scotland was shown that there was a letter that was dated March 2007. There was a letter. I remember it being shown to Audit Scotland—the team that was involved in the annual report at the time.
Right. For the purpose of clarification, and if we have an opportunity later, we might clarify that with Audit Scotland.
I should point out that the discussions that took place in June 2007 relating to the annual report for January 2007 were held specifically to talk about the paragraph on my shareholding that was to go into the annual report. It was quite clear to Audit Scotland that I had the shareholding and that I therefore had private interests. That is the bit that I find difficult to reconcile.
Okay. Thank you for that. We can clarify the matter with Audit Scotland.When did you tell your senior managers at Transport Scotland that you had a share interest? We note that you wrote to them in March 2007, but that was a considerable time after you started to work for Transport Scotland. In your letter to the committee, you say that you notified your senior managers. When did you do that? Who did you notify?
I notified my line manager within weeks of starting—I do not know the exact date. As soon as I took up employment and read the civil service code, I recognised that I had an interest that should be disclosed and I did so in the one-to-one meetings that I had with my line manager. I ensured that the other directors were well aware of my interest as well.The first sentence in my letter of 14 March begins, "As previously discussed". We had discussed the matter at length for quite some time.The other point that I would like to make is that the ScotRail franchise, as it was at that time, was a seven-year contract that was signed many years before I was with Transport Scotland. As you know, the contract is a 300-page document. One cannot take any decision on the franchise once that document has been signed; every part of the decision making is done through that contract. If we wanted an extra train, fewer trains or changes to the train services, we would go through a process that was, basically, like a flowchart. It was not possible for any one individual to make any difference to that process. Therefore, whether I wanted to or not, I could have had no involvement in decision making on the franchise at that stage. It was just not an issue.
Leaving aside the fact that you could not make decisions about individual aspects, you were aware during that period that discussions were taking place about extending the franchise that would be of benefit to FirstGroup. Is that correct?
I understood that a confidential project was taking place, and that we were looking into the possibility of an extension. However, that was happening along with a number of other improvements. Some of the directors, including me, had no idea of the content of the discussions.
Yes, but you were aware that discussions about extending the contract were taking place, and that they would be of benefit to FirstGroup.
Not necessarily.
You were not aware?
No, the discussions would not necessarily be of benefit to FirstGroup. As Audit Scotland pointed out, in and around June 2007, the discussions were about three options. One option was to extend and another was to not extend; I cannot remember the third option, but my point is that three options were on the table at that stage. Therefore, the discussions were not necessarily of advantage to FirstGroup.
So you were not aware that the discussions that were taking place were about an extension. We can clarify this with others, but am I right in understanding that you are saying that, during that period, the discussions included the option of not renewing or extending the contract?
I knew very little about it. All I knew was that there was a confidential project, called project golden key—very few projects in Transport Scotland had specific project names or were kept confidential. I was not aware of what the project was about in detail at that point.
You say that you notified your line manager at an early stage. Who was that?
Dr Malcolm Reed.
Why did you write to him in March 2007 after telling him about your interest at an early stage?
The first opportunity to publicly disclose my interest was in the annual accounts for the year to 31 January 2007. We decided to place the matter in writing for the purposes of Audit Scotland, among others. In the letter, I stated that I would continue to have no part in the franchise negotiations.
Did Dr Reed suggest that to you, or did you think that it would be a good idea at that time?
I do not know. Both of us knew that we would have to put it in writing. We were well aware of the consequences of not doing so. We both agreed that there had to be an audit trail.
Given that you knew of the discussions that were going on, and that you knew that at least one of the three options that were under discussion would not benefit FirstGroup, why did you decide to exercise your share options?
There is a specific window of opportunity, as I said in my letter to the committee. In my letter of March 2007 I had made clear what I had and the exercise dates, and my final comment in the letter, which was that I would not increase my shareholding beyond what was in the list, was given approval. I had approval for taking up those share options, and given that share options work only within a window of opportunity I had to take them up at that time. However, in relation to the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 I knew that that was well away from any decision on anything—I was nine months away from any timescale on the issue, so I knew that I was not going to break any rules by exercising those options. I already had approval from my line manager, in line with the guidance. That is the simple reason why I took up the opportunity.
Malcolm Reed knew that you had those share options and that you intended to exercise them.
Yes. He approved the letter.
Although different options were being considered, you thought that it would be advantageous to exercise the options at the time.
I had no alternative but to exercise them. If I did not exercise them, I would lose them.
That was an alternative; you could have lost them. There was an element of choice. You decided to exercise the options rather than lose them.
Yes.
link
You will appreciate that the committee is concerned about a potential conflict of interest. The civil service management code says:"Civil servants may freely invest in shareholdings and other securities unless the nature of their work is such as to require constraints on this. They must not be involved in taking any decision which could affect the value of their private investments … or use information acquired in the course of their work to advance their private financial interests".You had a substantial shareholding in First ScotRail—
Excuse me, but I had a substantial shareholding in FirstGroup. First ScotRail is a subsidiary of FirstGroup. FirstGroup is a £6 billion business and the likelihood of an individual being able to manipulate in some way the FirstGroup share price for a contract that was worth £250 million a year—
link
You will appreciate that that is precisely the point that the committee is trying to understand. You were a shareholder in FirstGroup. You were present at meetings at which the extension to the First ScotRail franchise was discussed. Did it occur to you that there might be a conflict of interest? What steps, if any, did you take to draw the potential conflict of interest to the attention of the management in Transport Scotland?
To which meetings are you referring?
link
For example, we understand that you were present at meetings on 19 and 28 March 2008.
I am referring to my notes. The meeting on 19 March was about what the handling strategy would be if there was to be an announcement. As well as being director of finance, I was director of corporate services; media handling and communication were a main area of corporate services that I looked after.As Audit Scotland pointed out, we did not minute the fact that I disclosed in the meeting on 19 March that I had a shareholding. However, I disclosed that verbally at the beginning of the meeting on 19 March—as we all sat down I said, "Guys, remember my shareholding." In the discussion that took place, as happened with many FirstGroup-related matters, it was considered that the meeting was not about financial decision making and therefore there was no conflict of interest.
link
Were you not present at any meetings prior to the meeting on 19 March at which the issue was discussed?
I was at lots of meetings at which the First ScotRail franchise was discussed in relation to performance, human resources, communications and all sorts of issues that related to First ScotRail. I was not involved in financial decision-making meetings.
link
However, you were present at meetings at which the possible extension of the franchise was discussed.
Yes, I was involved. The key thing to remember is that the onus was then on me, in knowing that there might be an extension, to do nothing with my shares and not to trade during that period. I certainly did not trade during that period; I have not dealt with my shares since July 2007, when the option was exercised.
link
With respect, the point that you did not trade in the shares is not the only relevant point. If you were involved and could influence decisions that might have affected the share price, the fact that you were a shareholder could have meant that you had a conflict of interest.
As far as I am aware, the only discussion that took place in which I received any detail on the franchise extension was the meeting on 19 March. By that time, Dr Reed—as he has said in evidence—had already agreed it with FirstGroup, around 5 March. The meeting was about handling if there was to be an extension. I could not influence the decision at that stage, because the decision had already been made to take the matter to ministers.
link
I understand your point. However, you said to me a moment ago that you had been involved in a series of previous meetings in which discussions had taken place on a wide range of subjects, including the possible extension of the franchise.
Yes—but on the "possible" extension. I am generalising—I am not denying that I was involved in a lot of First ScotRail meetings, but they were all on a range of areas. I could not influence any decision because I was not involved in decision-making meetings that related to the franchise. I may have been given progress updates, but there is a crucial difference between receiving information on progress, and receiving knowledge and using it.It is clear from third-party evidence—the FirstGroup share register—that I did not use that knowledge for personal gain. That is a crucial point: I may have been knowledgeable, but I did not use that information for personal gain—I still have the shares.
link
I am not entirely convinced that your analysis of the situation is correct. As a shareholder, you do not have to deal in the shares to make a gain. If the share price had gone up as a result of decisions that were taken—for example, to extend the franchise—that would have been to your benefit. That is why I am concerned about a conflict of interest.You have made it clear that you were not involved in the decision-making process. I understand that, but I have one more question. The minutes of the meeting of the directors of Transport Scotland on 21 November 2008 record that you informed the board at that point that you no longer held shares in FirstGroup, and the board agreed that you could remain for the discussion as there was no conflict of interest. Can you explain the background to that particular entry in the minutes?
The meeting on 21 November took place around the time that I resigned. I have never seen the minutes of that meeting, other than when I was given a copy by the committee last week. I was not party to the minutes: I did not write them, I did not have a say in them and I never approved them. There is half a sentence missing from them, which is "transferred to wife". I was not party to the minutes after they were written.The meeting took place within days of my resignation. I cannot comment on the accuracy of the minutes, and I certainly did not approve them—I was not there to do so. To be honest, I did not remember what the meeting on 21 November was about until I saw the minutes. It was a six-monthly update to the board of Transport Scotland on the performance of the First ScotRail franchise. If you read the minutes, you will see that it was a progress update.The meeting did not involve financial decisions and therefore, as the minutes state, there was no conflict of interest—not because I did not own the shares any more, but because it was not a financial decision-making meeting. That is a simple fact. It was an update to the board on the progress of the First ScotRail franchise.
link
I understand that, and I appreciate that you did not approve the minutes and may not have seen them before last week. However, I find it curious that the minutes of that board meeting specifically state that because you no longer held shares, the board agreed that you no longer had a conflict of interest. That suggests that, at the time when you did hold shares, there was a conflict of interest.
As I said, I cannot comment. I do not believe that those minutes are accurate; it is as simple as that. I did not approve the minutes. I was not there to approve them, so they cannot stand as a record of what I said on the day. It would be difficult for anyone at Transport Scotland to sign them off and say, "Yes, that's a true and accurate record, because that's what Guy Houston said and he confirms it." I do not believe that the minutes are accurate.
link
Okay. Thank you.
We can get further clarification on that. I will invite Nicol Stephen to ask a question in a minute, but I would like to stay on this issue for a moment. You said that there was no conflict of interest on 21 November because you had disposed of the shares. Sorry—they were trans—
No. That is not what I said.
I am sorry. The shares were transferred to your wife.
Yes.
Under the civil service code of conduct, shares owned by a spouse are a material issue. There was therefore still a potential conflict of interest because your wife held the shares. Is that correct?
Yes, but this is the point that I just made to Mr Fraser. The sentence in the minute is not whole. The reason that a conflict of interest did not arise was that the meeting was not a financial decision-making meeting; the reason was not that I had the shares or that my wife had the shares. The sentence is too short.
Okay. We can sort that out later.I have one further question on the dates that you mentioned for meetings that you attended. We now have a record that, on 23 January 2008, you attended a franchise extension meeting. That date is earlier than the dates that you had suggested.
Yes, and I believe that the permanent secretary has already commented specifically on that meeting. It was something to do with progress, and was a pre-meet with FirstGroup, or something like that. I cannot remember the full details but I saw the details and I said that, again, it was not a financial decision-making meeting. However, I must admit that I do not recall that specific meeting.
But you attended that meeting, which was called to discuss the franchise extension.
You say, straightforwardly, that the minute of the meeting on 21 November 2008 is inaccurate. You would contest the minute because it should have said that you had transferred your shares to your wife. Can you explain when and why you did that?
I will explain, but it was for personal reasons. The committee is going into a lot of detail about my personal affairs. I transferred—
I am not asking you about personal reasons. If the reasons are personal—
They are to do with tax efficiency.
I do not need to press you on that, but I need to understand why you chose to inform the board at that meeting that you had transferred the shares.
That was the first opportunity.
So the transfer had happened—
In November.
Yes, in November 2008. However, the decision was not related in any way to your knowledge of the issues that were about to arise in the context of the First ScotRail franchise.
The tax reasons are related to dividend payments. I do not really want to give this away, but—
No.
I just want to be clear.
If there are issues that relate to your personal tax situation, you are not obliged to disclose them to us.
Okay, but I just want to be clear that the transfer was for personal tax reasons.
The fact that all this happened within days of the First ScotRail franchise report, which raised this issue and which triggered your resignation, is coincidence. That is what you are telling us.
My transferring the shares to my wife was before the report came out.
Yes, but the report was coming out at the time. Was the meeting on 21 November before the report came out, or before you had knowledge of the report?
It was before the report came out.
So when was the phone call that you refer to in your letter to us?
It would have been five or six days before the print deadline, which I cannot remember—Audit Scotland might have the answer. It was a few days before 28 November.
You resigned on 28 November.
I did.
Five or six days before that is about 22 or 23 November. Is that right?
That is when I disclosed. It was the first opportunity to do so. I transferred the shares to my wife some time in the middle of November.
So it was earlier in November.
I have already explained that that was for personal tax reasons.
It was the week before, or two weeks before, everything that we are discussing occurred and, as you explained, coincidence. You went to the meeting on 21 November and explained about the transfer of shares to your wife. For some unexplained reason, the minute states:"Guy Houston informed the Board that he no longer held shares in First Group and the Board agreed that he could remain for the discussion as there was no conflict of interest".
I believe that it says at the end of that comment that there was no conflict of interest because it was not a financial decision-making meeting.
That sentence in the minute came as a complete surprise to you; you were unaware of it.
Yes. I was not present when the minute was agreed; I was not in the employment of Transport Scotland.
Okay.You also attended a meeting that related to the ScotRail franchise extension in November 2008. Malcolm Reed and the permanent secretary told us that your attendance at any meetings to do with the franchise came late in the process and that you attended two such meetings, both of which were in March 2008, as I recall. Are you telling us that that is incorrect?
I was involved in those two meetings.
But you attended more meetings than that. You attended additional meetings on the ScotRail franchise extension. Is that correct?
I am saying that I was involved in a lot of meetings to do with First ScotRail.
This is very important. Did you attend meetings to do with the project with the code name golden key prior to March 2008?
If I did, none was decision making or about influencing the decision.
That is not the question I am asking. The question is: did you attend meetings about project golden key prior to March 2008?
There was a rail policy board, which met monthly, had a group of directors and discussed the policy on rail. One of the topics in those discussions would have been ScotRail's performance, which may or may not have included an update on project golden key. I do not have paperwork with me, but I would not be surprised if there was an update to the meeting in 2008.
If project golden key was mentioned at any of the policy board meetings that you attended—such as April, May, June, August, September, November and December 2007 or meetings in 2008—did you remind those attending that you had a shareholding, or did you leave the meeting?
They were certainly reminded on a number of occasions, although I cannot confirm whether it was at every meeting. It was common knowledge, had been in our annual report for two years and was in the register of interests. We had received confirmation that the arrangements that we had put in place were suitable because they had gone into the annual report, which Audit Scotland had signed off.As far as I was concerned, the letter from March 2007 confirmed what shares I had, what I was going to do with them and the arrangements that we were going to put in place. We worked to that letter and the discussions beforehand. If any financial decision making was to be done, I would ensure that I was not involved. The directors of Transport Scotland were so aware of the situation that they knew that they could not involve me in financial decision making on franchise extension.There is a difference between receiving knowledge in a progress report and using that knowledge for personal gain. It is clear that I did not use it for personal gain.
We have a note of at least two meetings at which project golden key was discussed prior to March 2008. One was on 23 January 2008, which was the franchise extension meeting that has been referred to, and the other was back in August 2007. I assume that that is accurate and that you do not dispute those minutes.
I do not dispute anything. As the permanent secretary said, on 28 August, I had disappeared before that agenda item came up. I think that the January 2008 meeting was the meeting about which he said that I was on a train at half past 5. Therefore, the topic might have been on the agenda, but I was not there.
That must have been a different meeting. We were told that you had not been involved in any discussions or meetings on the franchise extension prior to March 2008 and that you were involved with only two meetings, neither of which involved financial negotiations. I am trying to establish that there were prior meetings that involved project golden key, but which you state did not involve financial negotiations. Over several months, there was a series of meetings. Is it fair to say that you were comfortable attending those meetings even though project golden key was being discussed, unless there were financial issues?
Yes—unless there was a financial decision to be made on the negotiations on the franchise. The letter of March 2007 said that I was not to be involved in financial decision making. The agreement and the procedures that were put in place did not set out that I was to have no knowledge of the issue. From an administrative point of view, that would have been virtually impossible.
So the financial negotiations in relation to project golden key were being conducted elsewhere and you, as the finance director of Transport Scotland, had no involvement in them.
Three senior directors—the chief executive, the head of the rail directorate and the director of strategy and investment—were closely involved. We should remember that they had support on financial issues from Ernst & Young and the Scottish Government. They had lots of financial help from people other than me. We were comfortable with that.
As you might know, I have pressed Transport Scotland fairly hard on confidentiality and market sensitivity. The main reason that Transport Scotland gave to the committee as to why it kept project golden key—the franchise extension project—confidential and did not at any point consult or involve external stakeholders was the market sensitivity of the project. Malcolm Reed told us:"There is market sensitivity because as soon as negotiations start both parties to the deal have inside knowledge. All the individuals involved are in a position to take financial advantage of that knowledge, if they choose to do so. In that regard, my situation was no different from that of Mr Houston. If I had been minded to breach the civil service code, I could have traded in FirstGroup shares. Of course, I did not do so." He went on to say, on the record, to the committee:"I am firmly of the view that the nature of the deal and negotiations, and the market sensitivity around them, made it entirely appropriate for the negotiations to be conducted in private."—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 14 January 2009; c 838, 843.You seem to have a slightly different view. From what you have just said to us on the record, you seem to feel that the contract extension was not particularly market sensitive for an organisation such as FirstGroup. Will you explain your perspective on that?
No—I was talking about one individual being able to make a difference to the FirstGroup share price and being able to guarantee that. That is subtly different from the statement that you have just made.
So you agree that, even in the context of a £6 billion business, the scale of the contract extension project was significant and was market sensitive.
Yes—I am sure that it was. Does anyone actually know the facts about what happened to the share price on the day that the franchise extension was announced?
That is really what I am asking you.
From what I understand, the share price went down on that day.
With respect, you cannot have it both ways: you cannot say that you personally feel that the issue was sufficiently important—
I am just saying that, in the context of a business that is worth £6 billion, one decision on its own does not necessarily make a huge difference to the share price. A number of issues could make a difference to the share price; this is just one of them.
I think that you tried to make that point in your letter when you said that the decision was not that substantial or significant within the context of FirstGroup. However, were you aware of how sensitive the project was regarded as being by people in the organisation and of the reasons for the strict confidentiality that surrounded it?
I was aware of that, yes. As I said earlier, the project was called project golden key, and the fact that it had such a name demonstrated the fact that it concerned confidential matters.
If you had been aware of another individual in Transport Scotland who was a substantial shareholder in FirstGroup and was involved in discussions around that project, what would you have felt?
As long as we had an audit trail that said what people could or could not do and we were all agreed on that, I would have had no issue with that. The onus is on that individual not to trade in sensitive areas, because they will be caught by the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. The matter is not only to do with Parliament; it is to do with a load of other legal issues.
You have talked a lot about the issue of public disclosure and the fact that your interest was publicly disclosed in Transport Scotland's accounts. However, the onus on you, in terms of your contract of employment, had nothing to do with public disclosure, did it?
Sorry, what do you mean?
I mean that your contract of employment states that you should disclose such issues to your employer and that the matter does not have to go on the public record or be disclosed in the annual accounts of the organisation that you work for. It is a contractual matter between you and your employer.
Yes, and that is why I informed my employer.
And when you informed your employer—which you said you did verbally within the first few weeks of joining the organisation—you did not believe at that stage that there was any need to set down in any way the nature of your shareholding interest.
I knew that I had to put it in writing to my line manager.
Why was that not done for a period of 10 months?
There are no timescale requirements with regard to disclosure. In previous evidence-taking sessions, you have said that there was "late disclosure". That is not correct. The disclosure was within the guidelines and the rules. The fact is that Malcolm Reed and I had discussions about what action to take and how to put the matter in writing. At that time, I had no involvement in the franchise extension, so the matter was never an issue. The fact that I told everyone verbally—
So disclosure can take place at any time. It does not matter whether it takes place after 10 months, one year, two years or whatever. Is that right?
Disclosure should take place when it is appropriate. A set of annual reports was due, and my view was that the matter should be put on the public record at that time.
It is unusual for a civil servant to be subject to a set of annual accounts in which a disclosure of that nature needs to be made. Most civil servants do not work for an organisation that produces a set of annual accounts of that sort. Assuming that the issue should be handled in a manner that is appropriate for all civil servants, I would have thought that it would have been far better if you had sent a private letter to Malcolm Reed at a far earlier stage. That would have been the appropriate point for disclosure.
We discussed the matter on numerous occasions beforehand, and we formalised the matter in March 2007. It is as simple as that.
So, in your opinion, the arrangements that were followed in March 2007 reflected your previous discussions with Malcolm Reed. Your letter starts with the words, "As previously discussed".
Yes, and the letter also says:"I would continue to be at arms length in relation to any negotiations with First ScotRail on the franchise costs."I was simply formalising, at the end of the financial year, the way in which we had already been working.
But the only reason for formalising that in a letter was that the public accounts for Transport Scotland were being prepared.
I would not say that it was the only reason—
That was the reason for the timing of the letter, in March 2007. Is that correct?
The timing was related to when we would make the public disclosure. Malcolm Reed and I had decided that it would be best to publicly disclose the matter.
You have said a number of times that you did not trade in any shares during that period. However, did you obtain additional shares in that period?
What period are you referring to?
The period between your starting with Transport Scotland and your leaving Transport Scotland. Did you obtain additional shares in that time?
I exercised the share options up until a point in July 2007, which was many months before the franchise extension was crystallised in any way, shape or form. Audit Scotland has already stated that, around that time, there was a number of options, and any educated individual could work out what those options were.
During that period, you obtained additional shares.
Yes, and that was approved in the letter of March 2007. As far as I was concerned, I was allowed to do that.
I would like to clarify a point that you made in answer to one of the convener's questions. You joined Transport Scotland in May 2006 and you acknowledge that, at that time, you were aware of a confidential project called project golden key, which was considering three options relating to the ScotRail franchise extension, one of which was to extend that franchise. Do you acknowledge that, if the option to extend the franchise was pursued, that would be of benefit to FirstGroup?
Of course it would.
With regard to the contract extension—Interruption.
I think that Mr Houston needs to be given every opportunity to give evidence in ideal circumstances. However, the noise from outside the committee room does not make these circumstances ideal. I apologise for the interruption, but I suggest that we suspend the meeting until we can get the noise stopped.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
We have asked whether the work can be halted, but it might be happening beyond the Parliament's curtilage, so the matter might not be entirely within our control. I apologise, but we might just have to suffer through it.I ask James Kelly to start again.
Apologies for the interruption, Mr Houston.Obviously, consideration of the extension of the ScotRail franchise had financial implications for Transport Scotland. What role did the organisation's finance department play in those considerations?
At the time, the rail finance team was under the rail directorate. I do not want to appear flippant, but I was not involved so I do not know what its involvement was. As a result, I cannot actually answer your question. I know that a rail franchise team—a rail finance team—sat under the rail directorate, and I assume that they would have provided the directorate with information. I do not know.
Are you saying that the role of the finance department was to provide clarification and support to the rail franchise team, which sat under a different directorate from your own?
Yes. That team sat under the rail directorate.
Who in the finance department provided and directed that support?
The team was under the director of rail at the time.
Yes, you have already made it clear that the rail franchise team is under a separate directorate. However, from what you have said, it required some support from the finance department, so who—
The rail finance department was under the rail directorate.
Just to be clear, what role did the finance department that you were finance director of have?
I do not believe that it played any part.
So the finance department—
I cannot confirm either way. If information was asked for that I was not knowledgeable about or if key decisions were to be made, my team would not be involved. We did not have the expertise; rather, the rail finance team had the expertise.
So you cannot state whether the finance department had a role in considering the financial implications of the ScotRail franchise.
I do not believe that my central team had a role. We would simply consolidate information that we had been given. We would get information from rail, concessionary fares and roads teams that we would consolidate. We would then send information up the line.
Can you be clear about whether the department that you were director of had a role?
Only to consolidate numbers and send them up the line.
Right. So staff in your department had a role in providing analysis and passing that on to the rail franchise team.
No; things were the other way around. The rail finance team would provide forecasts for a number of years. We would consolidate those into a future forecast.
Just to be clear, staff in the department that you were finance director of had a role in liaising and helping to provide information to the rail franchise team.
Yes, but that was not to do with the franchise extension.
Okay. So who was responsible for that in the department?
I am sorry, but you are being too general. Templates and spreadsheets and so on to fill out would go from my team to the rail finance team, which was under the instructions of the rail directorate at the time.
I think that we are all clear that the rail franchise team was under a directorate that was separate from the department that you were finance director of. I am trying to establish and be clear about the involvement that the department that you were director of had in analysing the financial implications of the ScotRail franchise extension.
It had none.
Okay. That is clear.In answering a question that Murdo Fraser asked, you said that you had been involved in many meetings to do with the ScotRail franchise extension.
No. I said that I had been involved in many meetings to do with the ScotRail franchise.
Okay. You said that HR and communications were discussed in those meetings, but none of them was on financial decision making.
Correct.
I assume that there were meetings on financial decision making. Who deputised for you in them?
There would not necessarily be a deputy. There was a set of governing rules that said that people up to certain levels could make certain decisions. The rail directorate was entitled to make decisions with the approval of the chief executive. Financial decisions did not have to be taken through me.
So you are telling us that in your role as director of corporate services, you had, as your department had, input on HR and communications in discussions on the ScotRail franchise, but your department had no finance input in any discussions or meetings on the ScotRail franchise.
We had no input on its extension.
Good morning. I would like clarity on two matters, one of which James Kelly has just covered a wee bit. Murdo Fraser talked about the meeting on 19 March and asked whether you had attended meetings in which the franchise extension, or project golden key, if we must call it that, was discussed. We have talked about that matter subsequently, and you said that you had. Like James Kelly, I want clarity. Did you ever attend a meeting at which you said, "Shall we or shan't we award the franchise extension contract?"
No. It was not about that; it was about saying, "Here's the progress: we are working with First Group; we still have the options on the table; and this is where we have got to."
Okay. On the meeting on 19 March, you said that your role was multifaceted and that you covered lots of different areas. On that occasion, the purpose of the meeting was to discuss any communications issues, should the franchise be extended. It would be helpful to the committee if you could give examples. Initially, it sounded like you were saying, "Yes, we were discussing the franchise extension." However, I now understand that what you meant was that you were discussing not whether to extend the franchise, but the implications of a franchise extension—something that one has to do in a normal business.You said that you had an HR input. Perhaps you could give us an example of the type of thing that you might have discussed around the franchise extension. That would help the committee to be clear about what you mean when you said, "We discussed the franchise extension." What were the types of thing that you were discussing?
Those were very much rail policy meetings, and if the franchise extension was brought up, it was by way of a progress update. Other than listening, my input would be minimal. On 19 March, on media handling in particular, we discussed who to tell, when we should tell them and how we should tell them. Basically, we put together a communications strategy around an announcement on the extension. Is that the sort of thing that you were looking for?
Yes.
The whole discussion was around which MSPs to phone, and when and how to inform the Department for Transport, Network Rail and all the major stakeholders. It was all on the specific announcement of an extension.
And you would not be able to do your job without discussing the franchise extension—I mean not whether to have an extension, but the franchise extension itself. The example was a good one.James Kelly questioned you on the exercise of the share options that you had been given between 2003 and 2005. When he asked whether you had obtained additional shares, you said yes. Did you mean that, in obtaining those additional shares, you exercised the existing share options, or did you say to yourself, "I have got these share options, and I am going to go out and buy lots more shares"?
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Mar 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Audit Committee Wednesday 25 March 2009 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- Accounts Commission Committee business · 52
- Section 23 Report Committee business · 595
- Public Audit Committee Report: Response Committee business · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.