We turn to the section 23 report. We have invited Dr Malcolm Reed, the chief executive of Transport Scotland, to our meeting for this item. The line of questioning will be to you, Dr Reed. Obviously, you should feel free to consult your staff, should that be required. Would you like to say anything by way of introduction?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Report
“The First ScotRail passenger rail franchise”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Malcolm Reed Transport Scotland 151
- Sir John Elvidge Scottish Government Permanent Secretary 119
- Hugh Henry Lab 113
- Nicol Stephen LD 69
- George Foulkes Lab 55
- Andrew Welsh SNP 23
- Cathie Craigie Lab 16
- Murdo Fraser Con 13
- Stuart McMillan SNP 11
- Steven McMahon Transport Scotland 8
- Bill Reeve Transport Scotland 5
- Willie Coffey SNP 4
- Gary Bogan Transport Scotland 3
The record
593 contributions · showing 1–200I will make a brief introductory statement. First, I thank you for your earlier introductions. Gary Bogan is standing in for David Binnie who is, I am afraid, down with the flu that is doing the rounds. I am grateful to you for accepting that late change in our representation.We are grateful, too, for the opportunity to provide input to the committee's consideration of Audit Scotland's report, "The First ScotRail passenger rail franchise". I emphasise immediately that we welcome many of Audit Scotland's findings, in particular the conclusions that First ScotRail is performing well, that Transport Scotland is generally managing the franchise effectively, that the franchise extension was robustly appraised and that it has secured £73.1 million of guaranteed benefits to rail passengers and taxpayers in Scotland. We welcome, too, the report's clear articulation of some of the contractual and commercial issues around the decision to extend the franchise.I acknowledge that the report also contains a number of criticisms, or suggestions for improvement. We would not seek to question the Auditor General's role in seeking the best possible outcomes for the Scottish public and, in common with the rest of the Scottish Government, we in Transport Scotland constantly look to improve our performance. There are therefore a number of learning points in the Audit Scotland report that we are happy to take on board and which, indeed, we have already begun to implement.As is usual, Audit Scotland offered us the opportunity to comment on a draft of the report. In this case there were, in the draft, about 70 matters of fact or interpretation that we questioned. In about three quarters of those instances, Audit Scotland either accepted our corrections or agreed to an adjusted form of words in which we had found common ground.Normally, we would regard that as a good score, but I have to say that in this case we were, just before the report was due to go for printing, presented with significant further revisions that had not been discussed with us. We therefore did not have the opportunity to engage as fully as we would have wished with the Auditor General's staff on those additional elements in his findings. If we had, I am confident that we would have been able to resolve many of the issues in the report that appear to have caused the committee some concern and which were discussed at length when Mr Black and his colleagues gave evidence before Christmas. Therefore, I hope that we will be able, in responding to your questions, to set the record straight on some of the issues that were raised in your previous meeting.
Thank you for that. We want to come back later to the appointment of Mr Houston—I think Nicol Stephen will follow up on that—but can you clarify when Mr Houston was appointed to Transport Scotland?
From memory, he was appointed in May 2006, but I can confirm that later.
When did the discussions on extension of the franchise start?
I ask Mr Bogan to clarify that.
We first examined the options for revisiting the franchise during the summer of 2006. At that point, we were taking a broad-based look at the performance of the franchise and other issues.
So, Dr Reed, you were privately starting to think about the franchise, whether it should be extended and what might happen with it. There were discussions among your staff before you started any of that work in summer 2006, and Mr Houston was appointed in May 2006. We will leave that sticking for now.I will ask you about the meetings at which the franchise extension was discussed. You knew that Mr Houston had worked with FirstGroup. Did you know at that time that he held shares and share options in FirstGroup?
Yes—he declared them in the normal course of events during his first year of appointment.
So you knew, presumably, that he had a material interest in the outcome of any discussions.
We need to choose our words carefully. I question whether the word "material" is appropriate. You might want to explore this further as the questioning develops, but the civil service code is very strict on what officials can do if they receive in the course of their employment information that affects their private interests. There is nothing that makes me think that the civil service code was broken in that respect.
I did not ask that, nor was I suggesting it. I was asking about material interest. You said that you did not believe that Mr Houston had a material interest. Did he stand to gain if FirstGroup's share price increased?
He stood to gain to the same extent as any FirstGroup shareholder would benefit.
So, someone who had sufficient shares to declare would have gained if the share price went up. Do you not think that that is a material interest?
Perhaps I am splitting hairs. I do not regard his shareholding—in view of its size—as a "material interest", but the underlying point that you make is correct.
So, you were not concerned that he was a shareholder and that he held not only shares but share options, which—as you probably know—offer the opportunity to make further gains, depending on what happens with the share price. Had you no worries about his participation in your discussions when you were considering the extension of the ScotRail franchise?
It is important to clarify that. Mr Houston was a participant only at a very late stage in the process. He attended two meetings after the deal had been struck, one of which was simply to discuss the handling of the deal. The second meeting was held after ministers had taken the decision to proceed with the extension. He was, therefore, not a participant in the process and played no part in shaping or negotiating the deal.
None whatsoever?
None whatsoever.
And you had no worries about his participation at that "late stage", as you describe it?
No, because the meetings that he attended did not affect the outcome and were not material to the recommendations that we put to ministers.
link
I will follow on from the convener's questions. Who provided the financial advice to Transport Scotland on the question of the franchise extension?
That advice came from two sources. We received advice from our strategy investment directorate—a member of that team is here today—but we also received external advice from Ernst & Young throughout the process.
link
Did the strategy investment team report to the director of finance and corporate services?
No—it is a separate directorate.
link
I just want to get this clear. You were aware that there was an issue with Mr Houston, given his shareholding in FirstGroup. Was that why he was not involved in earlier discussions about the franchise extension?
No. When the process started, it was not part of his corporate responsibilities. We had a separate rail finance team in Bill Reeve's directorate and all the details of the franchise were kept within that directorate. It is ironic that, as a result of a recommendation by Audit Scotland, we changed that at the beginning of 2008 and that, at that stage, the responsibility passed to Guy Houston. We had in place very clear management arrangements that ensured that there was no conflict and that Guy Houston was not involved in decision making that could affect his personal shareholding. That is recorded in our annual reports.
link
Okay. When Transport Scotland advised the minister on the franchise extension, did you advise him of the issue with Mr Houston's interests?
It was not an issue. The interest was a matter of public record and ministers were aware of it; I did not advise ministers of it specifically. Mr Houston was not party to those meetings.
link
Thank you. With hindsight, do you accept that things should have been done differently?
With hindsight, I accept that we could have arranged things differently, but I do not think that what happened materially affected the outcome, or that it affected it at all.
You said that ministers were aware of the interest. How do you know that?
Our annual report is cleared by ministers before it is presented to Parliament.
Okay.
If everything is as you have just described, why is Mr Houston no longer working with you?
I am afraid that I am not in a position to comment on a personal decision that Mr Houston took.
Why do you think Mr Houston is no longer working with you?
If this were a court of law, an answer to that question would be hearsay. I am afraid that I do not want to be drawn in that direction.
Can you see why people might have drawn inferences from his resigning at that particular time?
Yes—I can certainly see that.
You do not think that there might be any connection between a perceived interest and his no longer working for Transport Scotland.
Employment matters are confidential between the employee and the civil service. I do not want to comment.
You do not think it proper that you should give Parliament an answer to that question.
I am advised that it would not be proper, but you can take up the matter elsewhere if you wish.
Who has advised you not to answer the question?
I have had advice from the senior staff team within the Scottish Government.
Was the advice from Sir John Elvidge?
It was from the team that works for Sir John.
They said that you should not answer the question about why Guy Houston is no longer working with you. You were advised of that by a team working for Sir John Elvidge.
I am advised that such things are confidential staffing matters, which it is not appropriate to disclose, and that such a disclosure would, in fact, be in breach of the Data Protection Act 1998.
For the record, will you clarify who in the senior staff team advised you?
Paul Gray.
Okay.
You said what the director of finance did not do; you said that he was not involved in decision making. What did he do? Did he provide any information, advice or material based on which decisions were taken?
Absolutely not.
So what did he do?
He was involved in two respects. First, he was involved in discussions on the handling because he had, as well as his financial responsibilities, responsibility for our corporate affairs. Secondly, given that he was responsible for the whole financial management of the organisation, it was important that he was aware of the impact on other budget arrangements of the deal that was being done. That is where he was brought in, after the deal had been concluded.
I want to follow up some of the earlier questioning. In relation to the day-to-day management of the organisation, it must be quite a blow to Transport Scotland to lose such a senior director. When the director of finance and corporate services tendered his resignation, did you try to persuade him not to resign?
No, I did not. That was a personal decision for him.
What were the financial terms of his departure?
Again, I cannot comment on that.
Are you unable to tell a committee of the Parliament how much Transport Scotland—a public authority—paid to an employee who left?
I am not sighted on how much he was paid.
Who is so sighted?
The senior staff team in the Scottish Government is.
You are not aware of the financial terms under which he left.
No.
I want to clarify a general point. You said that the issue was decided by senior staff in the Scottish Government. Do those people decide all salary-related issues for your senior staff? Do you have no input whatever into the matter?
That is correct. I have no delegated powers or responsibilities for senior civil service staff in our organisation.
You are saying that the decision about the package to allow a senior member of staff—whoever it might be—to leave is made by senior civil servants.
Yes.
And signed off within the senior civil service.
That is correct.
Did you have direct involvement in recruiting Mr Houston?
Yes. I was a member of the panel that recruited Mr Houston.
You said that he declared his interest during the first year of his appointment. Did he do so prior to his appointment?
In my recollection, the issue did not come up during the panel interview.
Therefore, when you appointed Mr Houston you were unaware of his interest in FirstGroup.
We were not directly aware. He had worked as a senior manager for FirstGroup.
Were you unaware of his shareholdings? That is an important point.
I was unaware of them.
I think that there are strict rules about such matters in the civil service code. You are saying that when Mr Houston was recruited you were unable to discuss with him how his shareholdings and material interest in FirstGroup should be handled.
Yes—that is the case.
Is it normally the case that someone who applies for such a civil service post should declare a material interest in a company such as FirstGroup?
I am afraid that I cannot speak from broad experience. I do not know what the normal practice is in such situations.
Is the question asked as part of the recruitment process?
The question was not asked as part of the recruitment process that we are discussing and it was not asked of me when I was recruited.
Are you aware that under the civil service code material interests should be disclosed?
Yes.
Was the civil service code incorporated into Mr Houston's contract?
Again, I have not had sight of Mr Houston's contract.
Therefore, we should ask such questions of other civil servants.
That is correct.
When did you first become aware of Mr Houston's interest?
I cannot give a precise date, but it was certainly during the first year of his employment.
What action did you take to implement the terms of the civil service code?
We did two things. First, we ensured that his interest was properly recorded—during the course of the year we are all asked to record our interests. Secondly, as I said, we put in place management arrangements to ensure that Mr Houston was not involved in decision making that could be construed as affecting his interest in FirstGroup.
Was his presence during discussions, at a late but no doubt still important stage of the process, in keeping with those arrangements?
With hindsight, I acknowledge that it would have been more appropriate if he had not been part of those discussions.
I wish to clarify something. You are the chief executive of Transport Scotland, but you have no say over the salaries of senior staff; you have no knowledge of the final remuneration package that is offered to any of your senior staff who leave; and you had no knowledge whatever of Mr Houston's contract.
Yes—that is the position.
Do the senior civil servants not discuss any of those issues? Before Mr Houston was appointed, did they not discuss with you what was going to be offered to him?
The range of salary was certainly discussed, but it is a matter for personal negotiation between the individual and the Scottish Government.
So irrespective of what you, as chief executive—the person running the organisation—might think about a person's worth, someone else, who is not directly involved in your organisation, will make the decision about the individual's salary.
That is correct. We work within very strict rules, which, ultimately, are set by the Cabinet Office in London.
And the people who conduct those negotiations do not advise you about what is in the contract that is offered.
Certainly they do not advise me about detailed terms, although they would consult me about the salary levels. As I said, it is down to individual negotiation between the person who is being recruited and the civil service team.
So when someone is appointed you have no knowledge of the salary and no knowledge of the conditions of service. The hours to be worked are not discussed with you, nor are holiday arrangements or the length of notice that would be required. None of that is discussed with you—the chief executive.
Perhaps we misunderstand each other. All those items are standard. We work to a standard set of conditions, including holiday entitlement, and we are all appraised on the same basis. The only negotiated element is the starting salary.
Everyone works to a standard contract, and there will never be any variations in contract.
As far as I am aware, we all have standard terms of employment.
I remain puzzled. The director of finance should be involved in giving financial advice, but you have said that he was not involved in the decision making. If the director of finance was not involved in the decision making and became involved only after the deal had been concluded, who provided the financial advice on which the franchise extension was based? Somebody had to provide financial advice. That is normally the work of the financial director. Are you saying that he was not involved at all?
No, he was not involved, for the very good reason that rail finance is a complex area and we already had corporate arrangements in place for rail franchise financial matters to be handled within the rail franchise team. As I have also said in evidence previously, the internal advice that we received was validated and scrutinised by external financial advisers Ernst & Young.
Which post was held by the person who actually gave the financial advice?
At the time, that would have been Bill Reeve.
Yes. At that point, a rail finance manager was working for me. As the Auditor General has pointed out, we had a rigorous appraisal capability within Transport Scotland's strategy investment directorate. Its staff were able to subject the financial numbers in the franchise contract and in the various forecasts that were available to that rigorous appraisal. To ensure that we had done the analysis appropriately, it was validated by external financial advisers Ernst & Young.
I am not aware of what Mr Reeve's job title is, convener.
I am the director of rail delivery.
I want to clarify something before bringing in Cathie Craigie. When you were undertaking that process, how did you communicate with people in the organisation? Did you use hard copy, e-mail or both?
We kept the circulation very tight within the organisation, but we used both hard copy and e-mail.
In terms of the circulation, was Mr Houston able to access any of that? Was he included or specifically excluded?
There were instances when Mr Houston received copies of papers for information. Generally speaking, he was not part of the team and was not on the routine circulation list for documents that were connected with the franchise extension.
But Mr Houston would have been aware that Transport Scotland was looking at an extension. He would have been aware of the general developments that were taking place and whether the discussions were productive. He would also have been aware of some of the broad financial issues that were involved in the discussion. As a FirstGroup shareholder, he had—as we have established—a material interest in the matter. He would have been aware of much of what was being said.
He would have been aware of some of what was being said. Again, I would avoid using the word "material".
And you know what he was able to access and what he was not able to access.
In broad terms, yes. However, if Mr Houston had wanted to access more of the information, I have no doubt that he could have done so. I know of nothing that makes me believe that he did.
Okay. I will bring in Cathie Craigie and Nicol Stephen, after which we move on to address the business case.
Mr Bogan told the committee this morning that the option to revisit the franchise was first considered in the summer of 2006. Dr Reed said that Mr Houston was appointed in May 2006. I can only imagine that the interview panel chose the best person for the job. Did Mr Houston's employment history with First ScotRail have a bearing on the appointment? Did it give him the edge at interview?
Not at all. In fact, he was not in the employment of FirstGroup when he applied for the job, although it was on his curriculum vitae that he had worked for the company. The fact that it was that company had no bearing at all on his appointment.
You can probably understand my reason for putting this question. People think that Transport Scotland appointed this person because of his expertise and knowledge of the rail industry, yet the appointment was made at what could be called the late spring of 2006 and this major piece of work was being undertaken that summer.
I will answer the question in two parts. First, the appointment was not made with any view to the franchise extension process. Indeed, as Mr Bogan confirmed, extending the franchise was not under active contemplation when the appointment was made. Secondly, the member is correct in saying that, when we went to the market for a financial director, one thing that we specified and stated as being desirable was experience in the transport industry. By and large, that is what our business is about. We were looking for a senior finance figure who had knowledge of the way in which the industry works. If one is recruiting in that field, it is inevitable, or it is almost certainly the case, that a recruit will at some stage in their employment have worked for one or other of the major transport companies in Britain.
I am looking at the civil service management code, which makes it clear that "Civil servants must … declare to their department or agency any business interests (including directorships) or holdings of shares or other securities which they or members of their immediate family … hold, to the extent which they are aware of them, which they would be able to further as a result of their official position".I think you would agree that Mr Houston's share holding and share options fall into that category.
Indeed.
Who in the civil service is responsible for ensuring disclosure?
I am responsible for the management of the agency. Mr Houston disclosed it to me.
But you explained that that did not occur at the time of appointment. I presume that he was in post for a period of weeks or months, during which time he would have been in breach of the condition. I repeat the question: who was responsible for ensuring disclosure?
Compliance with the civil service code is a matter of individual responsibility.
Are you suggesting that Mr Houston was responsible for disclosure?
Yes.
Okay. Who is responsible if there is a breach of the civil service code by an individual civil servant?
That depends on the materiality of the breach. I would automatically refer any significant breach to the senior staff team within the Scottish Government.
When Mr Houston did disclose, you would have been aware that there had been a breach.
No, I do not accept that. He disclosed, and in doing so he was complying with the civil service code.
When did he disclose, and what were the circumstances of the disclosure?
I am sorry, but I cannot give you an exact answer—not because I am trying to evade the question, but because that is not something of which I have current knowledge.
I presume that the interest would have been registered.
Yes. I would need to check the register of interests to find out when he registered it.
So you could provide us with a date.
I will do my best, yes.
Who is responsible for implementing arrangements? As you know, the civil service code goes on to say that arrangements should be discussed for handling interests and that civil servants"must comply with any subsequent instructions from their department or agency regarding the retention, disposal or management of such interests."It is clear that you had decided to manage the interest. Is the responsibility for that yours alone?
That is my responsibility.
When you became aware of the shareholding, did you get advice on the management of the arrangements from the senior civil service?
No. The management arrangements that we agreed seemed to me to meet the requirements of both the civil service code and the staff handbook.
So you did not clear any arrangements with senior management.
No.
Were they aware of the arrangements that you had put in place?
It was a matter of record, as I have said, that we had arrangements in place. No one asked me what the details were and I did not find it necessary to discuss them.
But you could provide us with the date of registration of the interest and a copy of the detailed arrangements.
I am not sure that I could provide you with the detailed arrangements. Again, they are a personal matter because they would disclose the number of shares and share options that Mr Houston held.
Is that not a matter of public record?
I will need to take advice on that.
If it were a matter of public record because share registers are public, would you be able to provide us with the written agreement that was set down?
Yes, indeed.
That would be helpful. Thank you.
Will you remind us of the total costs involved in funding the franchise extension?
There were no costs involved in funding the franchise extension. It was done within the existing financial settlement for the franchise. However, Bill Reeve can comment in more detail on the headline numbers.
Malcolm Reed is right. The franchise extension did not alter the envisaged costs of the franchise as extended to 2014 because the franchise contract that we inherited from the SRA included those provisions. It allowed us to secure an additional £73.1 million-worth of benefit without any increase in subsidy. The cost to the Scottish taxpayer remained as expected, but the benefits were increased substantially.
I had better rephrase the question. I was looking for an overall view. What finance total was involved in the financial appraisal?
Well, there were £73.1 million-worth of benefits in the appraisal.
That is a substantial amount.Transport Scotland did not provide the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change with a fully documented business case, instead taking the view that it was more appropriate to provide presentations based on the option appraisal work. However, if I picked you up correctly, you said earlier that financial advice was provided by Transport Scotland's own staff. Why was the minister not provided with a fully documented business case before he decided to approve the franchise extension, leaving him to rely instead on a presentation?
I will clarify what happened. In March 2008, we went to ministers having reached a deal that we felt that we could recommend to them. What is referred to as a presentation was actually a detailed walk-through of all the key issues in the deal. We went to ministers to ask them whether they wished us to conclude that deal, and they self-evidently felt that we had given them sufficient information to take that decision because they gave us that instruction. The presentation included a table—which we gave to ministers in hard copy—of all the headline numbers and how they were affected by the options that we recommended.
Surely you would accept that a business case is all about financial viability, practicality and detailed scrutiny of the proposals, whereas a presentation is more a general introduction. Presentations, especially presentations on such a complex and major project, are not fully documented business cases. Surely any minister would want to rely on a robust business case, of which expert advice would be an important part, rather than only a presentation.
That is a question that you would want to address to the minister. I am satisfied—and, I believe, ministers were satisfied—that the information that we gave was more than adequate for ministers to take a decision on the franchise extension. We did not press them for an early decision and made it clear that further information was available if they wished it. We presented to them the outcome of what you have described: a very robust, independently validated appraisal with very clear numbers that made the case themselves.
Did you not consider the need for a business case to be available for scrutiny after the franchise extension was announced?
A business case is available.
When was it available to the minister?
It was available whenever he wanted it.
You had a business case but you did not give it to the minister. Will you clarify that?
We made it clear to the minister that a business case had been completed and was available. We gave him the headline numbers in that business case.
So there is a business case.
There has always been one and I am surprised that the evidence that you heard before Christmas suggested that there was not. There is a very robust business case for the extension and I am happy to talk you through it.
Are you saying that the minister did not ask to see the business case?
He did not ask to see it at that stage, but he was subsequently given it.
Had he seen the business case to which you just referred before he made the decision?
The minister saw a sufficient summary of what, in his view—
No, no—did he see the business case to which you have just referred before he made the decision?
If you are asking me whether he saw the document, the answer is that he did not, but he saw the output from it.
Why did you not offer the document to him?
We did not withhold it from him.
I did not say that you withheld it. Why did you not offer it to him?
Because, when we went to him, we went to report on where we had got to and to seek his advice on how we should take the process forward. At that meeting, he was sufficiently convinced of the strength of the case for extending the franchise that, in effect, he instructed us to conclude the deal immediately.
link
I would like to get clarity on this matter, because it is an important point in the Auditor General's findings. The evidence that we took from him told us that it was good practice for people who were making such a decision to review the business case. The minister did not do that in the situation that we are discussing. We need to be absolutely clear about whether you offered him the full business case. Did you do that?
Within the presentation that we gave to him, there was a table that summarised the business case. We did not actively offer him the detail behind that summary but, equally, it was open to him to request it if he so wished.
link
Do you accept that that was a failure to follow good practice?
No, I do not. First, as you will know, advice to ministers is confidential. Secondly, it is for the minister to reach his own view on what information he requires in order to make a decision.
You had a business case and material information about any decision that was to be taken. I therefore presume that a decision was taken on what I would think was insufficient information. How normal a practice is what you described? In any business, for such an important decision, we would ask for the business case that backed it up. Surely, if you were advising the minister as to what the situation was, you should have pointed out that there was a business case.
We did point out that there was a business case. We go to the minister with many significant investment decisions. It is very rare that we are asked to provide the business case in extenso. Ministers look to advice from the civil service, and we provided that advice on the basis that I, as accountable officer, was satisfied with the business case that lay behind our recommendations.
Is that normal practice?
It is the practice that I have worked to. I have never sought to withhold information from ministers. I have provided ministers with the information that they have wished.
Can I clarify that, when Audit Scotland was conducting its investigations, you advised it that there was a business case and offered it the opportunity to examine that business case?
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Audit Committee Wednesday 14 January 2009 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- Section 23 Report Committee business · 593
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.