Good morning and welcome to the Procedures Committee's sixth meeting in 2003. We have received no apologies, so I do not doubt that the two committee members who are not here will arrive shortly.Members will be aware that Susan Deacon has submitted comments on the text that we approved at our previous meeting. We do not have the papers in front of us to deal with that, so I suggest that, if the committee is happy, Susan Deacon, John Patterson and I consider the suggestions, which appear largely to be textual points of nuance and in keeping with what was agreed. We would not agree to anything that was substantively different. I think that that is the only way in which we can handle those comments at this stage.
Official Report · Committee
Consultative Steering Group Inquiry
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Murray Tosh Con 190
- Ken Macintosh Lab 71
- Susan Deacon Lab 52
- Fiona Hyslop SNP 51
- Donald Gorrie LD 39
- Paul Martin Lab 22
- Gil Paterson SNP 15
- John Patterson Clerk 3
The record
457 contributions · showing 1–200I am happy to take the convener's guidance, but I was unaware of the additional comments. If I could have a copy of the document, I would be happy to look at it.
The comments were e-mailed yesterday afternoon.
I was in the office until 8 o'clock last night.
You are more than welcome to be part of the discussion, if you want. However, we do not have time for another formal committee meeting. I do not want to sweep the points aside, because much work has been done on them. I would like to find a way of agreeing to the proposals, as far as possible, but that can be done only under a delegated authority to negotiate.
I apologise for the late submission of the points, which was my fault. They were the result of reading the report in the round. I felt the urge to suggest some textual points of nuance, as the convener said. I hope that I have not raised substantive issues about what the committee agreed to. If I had such a point, I would not press to include it at this stage.
Do we agree to the course of action that I proposed?
Members indicated agreement.
I will begin where we left off—at paragraph 496 of the consultative steering group report. We will round that off, although we must go back a step afterwards. In our previous discussion, we gave considerable scope to the debate on two options for paragraph 496 that would allow for alternative means of choosing motions for members' business. One option was to have a panel of back benchers and the other was to have a system of balloting.Ultimately, we agreed that we wanted a system of balloting, without agreeing how that would be done. Today's papers suggest new text for paragraph 496 and a new recommendation in paragraph 497, which attempt to bring together all the strands. The paragraphs reject the back-bench panel and flag up ideas about the form of ballot, without being over-rigid about it. Are we happy with that?
I am happy with the consensus in paragraph 496. However, as I have said to the convener, I would like us to add a reference to providing scope for urgent constituency matters to be raised to the paragraph's penultimate sentence, which concerns reserving time to commemorate anniversaries or significant events. If a ballot system were adopted, that might mean that a member would have to wait for ever to have a members' business debate on an urgent constituency issue. We need to provide a way to push that up the agenda.
That is a reasonable note to enter. Ultimately, the Parliamentary Bureau has the power to fix appropriate business, but it would be better to recognise that need, if the committee felt that the point was appropriate. I do not see anybody objecting, so I assume that, subject to that addition, we are happy to agree to paragraphs 496 and 497.
Members indicated agreement.
I say good morning to the members who have just arrived. Can we go back to—Interruption. There is nothing that can be said about that mobile phone ringtone. Enter Kenneth Macintosh, sprinkling stardust. Walt Disney could not have done it better.
I like to make an entrance.
While you get yourselves geared up and switch off your various pieces of equipment, I draw members' attention to paragraphs 466 to 469. They were in the previous meeting's papers, but for some unaccountable reason—probably because of being brain-dead at the end of six months of all this stuff—I skipped a page and did not highlight those paragraphs. They have not been discussed or agreed, so I have brought them back.Paragraphs 466 to 469 relate to the letter that we received from the Presiding Officer about fine tuning standing orders to make the guidance that covers questions equally applicable to answers. The text is self-explanatory. The issue requires a considerable amount of judgment, as many aspects of chairing do. The text responds to the Presiding Officer's request and I open it for discussion.
To be fair to ministers—which I always seek to be—and to create a level playing field, perhaps the last sentence in paragraph 469 could mention members whose supplementary questions dribble on. I do not know whether we need to alter standing orders to cover them, but if the Presiding Officer is to be tough with ministers, he should be tough with members, too.
I think that the authority to do that exists, but if it does not and if the standing orders are in any way ambiguous, I would agree with that suggestion. It is extremely irritating when people ramble on and on with questions. I do not know what it is about the word "question" that some members do not understand. It means a sentence with a question mark at the end that makes a point and seeks information. We have some verbose questions. We will double check the position and, if we need to include a reference to it, I am happy to do so to strengthen that paragraph because that is part of sharpening up business.
I thought we had discussed the issue, although that might not have been as part of the CSG inquiry. I am concerned that we are asking the Presiding Officer to take a rather contentious role. We do not want to encourage the Presiding Officer to pull ministers up any more than is necessary.Although there are a lot of concerns about parliamentary questions, I am surprised that we are making such recommendations at the moment. I thought that we were going to address all the issues in our inquiry into parliamentary questions and that this was a key area of that work.There is definitely a concern about how to balance questions and answers. However, given that we are going to conduct a long and detailed inquiry into parliamentary questions, it seems odd to pluck out an issue and make a recommendation without taking much evidence.
I thought that it was a pretty simple issue to deal with, because it has nothing to do with how information is made available. It is a matter of managing parliamentary business and is therefore a short, sharp and reasonably discrete exercise that we are capable of addressing.The Presiding Officer might be asked to make rulings on such questions but, at the moment, people get up and make spurious complaints. The paragraph would clarify the level of expectation. The speaker at Westminster appears to have a similar power because he has recently issued guidance instructing ministers to give short answers and members to ask short questions. I do not believe that there is anything particularly sensational about the recommendation.
I fall in line with Donald Gorrie's comments. I would be surprised to find out that members are already required to buck up and get on with their questions but, if they are, it is only fair and reasonable that ministers should work under the same constraints. As the convener implied, we do not have to be rocket scientists to bring about the change, which seems fair and reasonable.I take Kenny Macintosh's point about the deeper inquiry but we have tried to use other parts of the report to fix things now if they are not too complicated. We have to recognise that, throughout the parliamentary session, people have been questioning the way in which some ministers answer questions. It is up to the Presiding Officer to be the judge and jury and the recommendation is for a straightforward change that I support.
I was agreeing with Gil Patterson up until his last point about the Presiding Officer being the judge and jury. That is what concerns me.We are making a specific recommendation and we have not really discussed it or taken evidence from either side about the balance in question time between politically motivated questions and politically inspired answers. We are trying to get the Parliament back to being more about accountability and scrutiny.
That is the judgment that the Presiding Officer would make. If the question is disputatious and point scoring, we would expect the answer to fall within the same parameters. I do not think that it is a major problem; at least, it has not been a major problem since Susan Deacon stopped answering questions.
Oh!
We are simply trying to clarify the rules. It is not an issue that needs an awful lot of evidence. It strikes me as a point of common sense, to which evidence would not add anything.
I ask only because I want to know who is pushing for the change. Where does the concern come from?
The Presiding Officer.
We have not asked ministers what they think about the issue. I am not totally against the recommendation because, on the face of it, it is a matter of common sense. At the same time, the recommendation is for a specific change. The Presiding Officer can be in a tricky position and can be asked to rule on a point that contains nothing whatsoever and which someone has raised as an excuse to raise a political point. I do not want to encourage that practice.We ought to be trying to reduce the confrontational nature of question time and to make it focus more on the answers. The recommendation mentions "relevant and concise answers", which is not bad. Relevance is an important point. I am simply concerned about the Presiding Officer's role and how he would rule on such points. Could we amend the recommendation to say something like, "The issue will be reviewed in the inquiry into parliamentary questions"?
The only other possibility is that we would have to admit irrelevant and overly long answers. We cannot go there. If we are going to say anything explicit, it has to be along the lines of what has already been suggested.
The general principle of the recommendation is fine because we are trying to create a level playing field between questions and answers. I am happy for there to be some symmetry of approach.If I have a concern, it is that we have to be careful that we do not suggest that brevity is the most important thing in the world.
No, it depends on the context.
I agree. There is a difference between froth or obfuscation and a lengthy and informative answer about an important issue of the day. I am slightly concerned about the way that the recommendation is constructed and the use of "concise". I know that being concise and being brief are not the same, but there is something about the nuances behind "concise" that I do not like.
How about inserting "appropriate"?
The word "relevant" is appropriate.
If we were to say "relevant and appropriate", that would mean that the answer could take as much time as was needed.I feel that if a minister were answering the point and giving information, that would justify the time taken. We get a bit impatient if an answer is simply knockabout and goes on too long.
Or if it is just waffle.
It might be waffle, but that might happen with a response to a question that was asked in a similar vein.
Kenny Macintosh has a point about how we go on from here. I do not have an alternative phraseology to hand, which is why I give the convener papers containing my delayed reactions ages after our meetings. We have not jumped on other issues and recommended that standing orders should be changed to do something, so I wonder if the convener could change the recommendation to say something like "We therefore recommend that the standing orders are revised to allow the Presiding Officer to make appropriate changes." You see what I mean—I cannot think of something off the top of my head. However, the last line of the recommendation could be phrased slightly differently to address Kenny Macintosh's concerns.
We could say, "We therefore recommend that the Parliamentary Bureau should initiate discussion to revise standing orders." That would make it a matter for the bureau, and it would have to be negotiated by the business managers anyway. It would also allow the Executive and the Opposition parties to have their say. We are not promoting a specific change to standing orders and the issue will inevitably come back for further discussion. We would not make the change without that.
I guess that the Executive might come back with the point that there is sometimes a lack of detail in questions. We have discussed that before. A member might ask a question but be leading on to something else. Thereafter, the Executive's response might not be helpful to the member because the answer did not address the point that the question was leading to.
We are talking about oral questions rather than written ones.
My comment is related to oral questions. A member might ask when the minister last visited Kenny Macintosh's constituency of Eastwood—I do not want to mention Springburn again—but the question might lead on to something else. That is probably not the best example but we have to get back to the real world, and sometimes a question lacks detail.We have all asked questions to which a civil servant's response has been given. There is an issue about civil servants effectively advising ministers on their responses and about their understanding of exactly what members are trying to extract from the minister. Although ministers are not trying to be unhelpful, it sometimes appears that a minister has been unhelpful in the light of their response.
Sometimes, ambush questions are asked. Someone might ask when a minister last visited Eastwood, with a supplementary question that the minister simply could not have predicted from the lead question. The minister frequently replies to such questions by saying that they will write to the member on the subject concerned. I think that we should accept that that is what ministers do, so that members have no incentive to ask such questions. I know that the leaders of the Scottish National Party and the Conservatives ask questions in that way at First Minister's question time, but they do so as a bridge to get to the issue of the day. The First Minister—virtually always—has anticipated those issues well, which is fair. It is really quite outrageous if one thinks of the range of supplementary questions that a member could ask on the back of such questions as, "When did the minister last meet Fife Council?" Although such questions are not inadmissible, ministers and members should not be trying to play that game.
I do not want to water down the emphasis on the need for answers to be relevant. I assume that the point of recommendation 56 is to ensure that ministers do not use the opportunity of answering a question to go off on a spurious attack on the Opposition on unrelated matters.
You are right.
We could underscore our feeling that ministers should keep their answers relevant. It is a question of whether we actually recommend a change to standing orders. The suggested wording on asking the bureau to consider the matter was good.
I am not happy with this. People have been asking ministers to keep their answers concise and to answer the question. That is what we are talking about.
We are not losing that in our recommendation.
I know that, but I am referring to what Ken Macintosh said. I think that a change to standing orders is required; that is better than not calling for one. If our proposal is to be meaningful, it requires a change to be made, although I am not concerned whether such a change would come about through the Parliamentary Bureau, the Procedures Committee or another mechanism. A problem has been recognised and we need to tackle it. Members might get a good minister to answer their question—in fact, there are some good, concise ministers out there.
You sound surprised.
No, I am not surprised—it is just the way things are. Every party is the same in that regard. We should bring the bad ministers into line, and the only way to do so is through a change to standing orders.
The point is to kick the subject onto the agenda for creating standing orders, which have to be discussed and broadly agreed before they get through the Parliament. The wording could be something like, "We therefore recommend that the Parliamentary authorities consult on, and bring forward, proposed standing orders to allow the Presiding Officer to require ministers to offer relevant and appropriate answers to oral questions."
That is fine. I would go for that.
Peace is brokered.
Send him to Iraq.
There are limits—I am not willing to be a human shield. My next change is to paragraph 503. It is by way of being a piece of narrative, which explains what we have done. I have so many bits of paper in front of me that I am struggling to find the right one. I do not think that anything in paragraph 503 caused a problem, however. My next change applies to page 82. Interruption. I apologise—I am working from last week's papers. The relevant paragraph is paragraph 525.
Before that, I would like to make a point about paragraph 506. It struck me that we might want to expand it. We have stated:"We recommend that our successors in the next Parliament should consider taking forward such proposals for changes to the Parliamentary week as appear to command significant support from Members."Sorry—are you working on a different draft from mine, convener?
Yes. That is paragraph 505 on my copy. That is because I put in an extra paragraph 497.
It struck me that recommendation 64, which is contained in paragraph 505, or 506, depending on which copy we are referring to, is written in a slightly obscure way. People will not necessarily see the recommendation in context. Did we mean to link that recommendation to our survey, which showed that if we had to expand parliamentary time, Wednesday evenings were the favoured option?
Yes. The reworded paragraph 503 refers to "further work on proposals".
I am obviously working from the wrong copy of the report.
No, that was paragraph 503 in last week's papers, which should now appear as paragraph 504. The underlining has disappeared.
Can I check what papers we are meant to have here?
We have two versions of the draft report.
I am confusing everyone.
I threw one out, because—
I am confusing everybody. I will use the updated report. I had written things on last week's copy, but it is better if I do the same as other members, as we will be one paragraph out otherwise.Paragraph 504 contains new text, which should be underlined. It is not underlined because we circulated stuff.
Yes—we circulated what was paragraph 503, and the underlining is now different.
Paragraph 504, as it is now, refers to "further work on proposals for changing the shape of the Parliamentary week".In the papers that you have now, the paragraphs that are underlined are those that we did not ask you to clear by e-mail. Last week, we put out an e-mail asking you to clear a whole load of minor textual stuff. We said that we would take a non-response as an indication of assent. Paragraph 503 was cleared, and the underlining has gone. Paragraph 503—now paragraph 504—refers to "further work on proposals", and the reference to "such proposals" in paragraph 506 refers back to paragraph 504.
I have some comments to make on the substance of underlined paragraph 503 as was, or paragraph 504 as is. I am quite happy with the way in which that paragraph is written, but I suspect that I am not alone in having issues to probe and questions to ask before some other points in this section of the report are signed off. Although I appreciate the mechanism that was used for circulating the text and asking for assent, with silence being assent, I suspect that there are still some burning issues that need to be raised. Despite the fact that I do not have an issue with paragraph 504, I had noted something from previous drafts of the report, and I wanted to raise this at the committee and take a sounding from colleagues. It relates to the construction of paragraph 505, which refers to "‘family friendly' hours". I wanted to share a few thoughts on this.As members might imagine, I support the concept and practice of family-friendly hours and practices in the Parliament. I could certainly benefit from them, not only because I have young children, but because I live close enough to the Parliament to benefit from going home at night. I have a real concern about the way in which we have described and dealt with the family-friendly issue for two reasons. First, we have started to imply that having nine-to-five hours is somehow the same as having a family-friendly Parliament, which is just nonsense. Secondly, we have created a rod to beat ourselves with, in that we have been talking up the nine-to-five hours that the Parliament works. That has led to a misunderstanding of the nature and role of our work. It has also led to a wee bit of a backlash on some of the thinking around family-friendly practices. Some of the thinking around the Parliament having nine-to-five-type meetings is not about family-friendly practice; rather, it is just about having a modern Parliament, and not maintaining some of the anachronistic practices that exist at Westminster, such as starting business at 2 pm so that business owners or farmers can do their business in the morning and then come and sit through until the middle of the night. In raising that, I do not intend to open up what is obviously a huge, broader issue. I float those thoughts to get them off my chest and because I wonder whether we could modify the report so that, when we talk about business hours, we do not do so only in terms of their being family friendly. Having said that, we should keep in our report the substantive point about family-friendly practices in the broader sense. My apologies for opening up what is quite a wide range of issues, but I have noted the point in relation to much of the draft, although I was waiting for that paragraph so that I could make those points. Thank you for letting me do so.
Subject to that, do we agree the section on time in the chamber?
Could we not just replace "hours" with "practices" in paragraph 505? If I understood Susan Deacon correctly, that would make her point.
I am happy to do that if that is what the committee wants.
Members indicated agreement.
Are there any queries on the next section, which is on the civil service and runs from paragraph 507 to paragraph 513?
I have a note on paragraph 513. The first sentence of that paragraph says:"Nevertheless, civil servants do interact directly with the Parliament."At our meeting in Ullapool, the point was made to us that civil servants also interact with the public and are often regarded as the public face of the Government. I suggest that we add to the end of the first sentence in paragraph 513: "and the public and are often perceived as the public face of Government for those who deal with them".
I am happy to add that. It is a matter of fact.
We would want to add cross-references to the Ullapool meeting, as that statement came out of it.
Is everybody happy with that?
Members indicated agreement.
If there are no issues with the section on evidence, which is paragraphs 514 to 518, we will move on to the section headed "Discussion". Donald Gorrie has a point to make about paragraph 519.
The quotation from Sir Edward Bridges is perfectly correct and well known, but there is an implication that we agree with him, which an examination of paragraphs 528 and 529 shows that we clearly do not. I suggest that we add a note after the quotation, which is in heavy type, to say, "This definition should be compared with paragraphs 528 and 529." The point may be pedantic. I personally think that Bridges is talking rubbish. We need not say that. We could say it more politely.
The quotation is in paragraph 519 to state an opinion. I have noted the committee's discomfort with opinions with which it does not agree. I am happy to add a piece of text after the quotation to refer to the current practice, which is discussed in paragraphs 528, 529 and 530. We can sort out the paragraphs later.
I, too, have concerns about the Bridges quotation and would challenge it. A bigger discussion about the nature of power needs to be had. We are not in a position to have that discussion. If we accept, as I do, that knowledge is power, there are all sorts of issues about the way in which knowledge and information are shared and used.I would also like to insert a point in paragraph 523 or 524—that is where I jotted it down, but I am open minded on that—to note the significant responsibilities that civil servants have for the implementation of policy and a wide range of operational matters. We have discussed the matter, so I do not want to revisit the discussion, but we understate civil servants' role and powers throughout the section. Given the emphasis of many of the devolved policy areas—for example, the operation of public services—the civil service's skills, practices and culture all impact directly on policy delivery.I have noted that down. If I have another burst of enthusiasm, the convener might get another paragraph or two on the issue winging its way across the ether. My general points are that I agree with Donald Gorrie and that I would like to build in a broader and more accurate expression of the civil service's role.
If we say something about the civil service's responsibility for interpreting and implementing policy, would that cover your concerns?
Yes, I think so.
We will include something round about paragraph 523 or 524.Are there any other comments on the section, which runs up to paragraph 542?
I have a point on paragraph 540 about the departmental committee liaison officers. I regard them as two-way gateways, if that is the right expression, so, after saying that the system is"an explicit ‘gateway' for committees to obtain briefing and guidance from the policy sections of the Departments of the Scottish Administration",we should add, "and for departments to be kept in touch with committee inquiries and other activities."
I think that the reason that that is not included is that it is the practice. However, for that reason, it might be appropriate to include it. The DCLOs' job is to monitor what committees do, but it would not do any harm to add that process.
I may be ignorant, but I have never met a DCLO. They exist, do they? They are not mythical.
Our DCLO has attended committee meetings, has spoken to the committee and is regularly in touch with the clerk. You would probably know him if you saw him, but we are not allowed to name civil servants in the committee. Although we would be doing so in an uncritical and non-aggressive way, I am sure that he would be grateful not to have his identity revealed.
So they do exist, but I do not relate the person to the title. Mea culpa in that case.
It is not tua culpa—that is the point.
Use a code name.
M would probably do.
Donald Gorrie makes an important point. It proves the point that we are trying to get across.
I did not know who the DCLO was for the Transport and the Environment Committee when I was a member of that committee, but I know who this committee's DCLO is because I asked the clerk. Now that I know who the DCLO is, I am in the loop and I know the carefully guarded secret. That is absurd, as the DCLO ought to be known to us all. We ought to be able to have a proper, open relationship with whoever that person is. Apparently, there is a squad of such people throughout the civil service. They do a useful job, no doubt, but it tends to be a one-way street. Paragraph 540 tries to make it work in both directions. I am sure that the DCLOs will find that professionally enhancing.
I have a number of points on paragraphs 536 to 539. I ask colleagues to give me an early indication if they do not agree with me, in case I am on my own. I am not necessarily one to stick up for civil servants but, although I agree with a great deal of paragraphs 536 to 539, I have question marks over some of their content. They are perhaps a wee bit prescriptive and jump the gun a bit. In paragraph 542, we recommend that a steering group work out how the relationships can work and how we can ensure a better relationship in future. I am not sure whether prescribing that relationship in paragraphs 536 to 539 is the best way forward, but I am happy to keep that in if colleagues think that it is important to flesh out the relationship.
Paragraphs 536 to 539 were added because members wanted a lot of the points in those paragraphs to be added. Paragraph 539 was an explicit response to the request that civil servants should help members to draft amendments. The idea of putting the DCLOs in the report came from a specific request that we identify a contact point for committees.
That is fine. I have problems only with paragraphs 536 to 539. Paragraphs 540 to 542 are fine and the bulk of the content of paragraphs 536 to 539 is fine, but I wondered whether we were being a bit premature.
Paragraph 537 does not prescribe anything; it is observational. Paragraph 536 is pretty general and is the basis on which paragraphs 539 and 540, which are about more collaborative work, are written. Paragraph 538 is more specific. If members do not want to include paragraph 538, I am relaxed about that.
At the risk of sounding as though I am facing all ways at once, I will make a comment. The specifics that are proposed in paragraphs 536 to 539 are fine—I do not balk at any specific suggestion. However, the approach that we have adopted elsewhere in the report has been to be clear that a job needs to be done and to make some specific suggestions that we think ought to be implemented but to leave space for those who get round the table to think about the best way of doing it.If I have a concern about the way that the section is worded at the moment, it is that it could let senior managers off the hook. It might just mean generating a whole load of additional work for lots of middle-ranking people in the civil service—who are already under inordinate pressure, given the volume of work that has flowed from devolution—without requiring the people at the top of the civil service and the Parliament to consider how systems, practice and culture need to be developed to ensure that constructive relations are in place, as well as the support and the systems to facilitate communications. I would like to move towards what Fiona Hyslop said about suggesting some of these things rather than being prescriptive about them. I would like to strengthen paragraph 542. I want to make it explicit that we expect any steering group to comprise senior representatives of the Executive, the civil service and the Parliament.
Do you want to add senior parliamentary officials to that paragraph?
And senior Executive people.
I am being quite explicit about this: let us be absolutely honest about it. We are in the process of appointing a new permanent secretary for the civil service of Scotland. I am not sure when that person will be coming into post, but it will probably be at a key stage in the second session of the Parliament. It is important that the new permanent secretary takes direct responsibility for crafting and shaping precisely the kind of relationships we are discussing. We should not regard the suggestions as concerning wee day-to-day operational changes.
I am happy with being explicit and I do not want to be difficult here, but in previous discussions, we have already asked for the things that Susan Deacon mentioned. We asked for a standard to be set at the very least.During exchanges with civil servants, they have asked for my internal telephone number because they do not believe that MSPs have constituency offices. They do not understand that process. Senior managers of public limited companies exchange working practices to understand what their business is about and I do not know why civil servants should be any different. They should understand the role of MSPs and of public organisations. If I asked civil servants about the work of community councils, tenants associations or charitable organisations in our constituencies, I think that most of them would have a parochial civil service view—they have not come out of their parish, so to speak. We must find a way of getting the senior management to understand the role of MSPs and the purpose of the Parliament. Civil servants talk about tackling social exclusion, but I wonder how many of them have visited some of the projects that tackle social exclusion. That is why I welcome the suggestion in paragraph 538 about "exchanges, work-shadowing and the development in general of personal, and face-to-face, contacts".People have been critical of local government. The locality of local government makes contact much easier. There is more face-to-face contact with local government than there will ever be at national level if we do not change that. We asked for those changes. I recall that we wanted to set a standard. I appreciate Susan Deacon's point about the need to develop the situation, but we need to say to civil servants, "Get out there. Don't just talk a good game, but get out there and walk the walk as well." It is not just up to MSPs to be out there—civil servants must understand that role. We must ensure that we help them to do that. The way to help them is to set out the principles of what we seek—that they get out there and do not locate themselves permanently at St Andrew's House, or wherever.
Having raised the issue, I am conscious that we must press on or we will not be able to complete our consideration of the inquiry. I am happy to keep everything in the paper, bearing in mind the comments that have been made. Susan Deacon's points help me because they indicate that we are not closing down and restricting what we are looking at. We want it be broader and deeper.
Okay, do we agree on Susan Deacon's addition?
Sorry, convener, I have been trying to comment on the matter too, although my point is slightly different. I am comfortable with the direction of the suggestions and the specific wording. I am slightly concerned that we come across as naive, although perhaps that is the wrong word. As much as I want a better relationship between the civil service and the Parliament, there is a tension between the Executive—including the civil service as an arm of the Executive—and the Parliament. Paragraph 541 begins with the words, "We see no reason". Paragraph 539 talks about "considerable scope" and I totally agree with what other members have said. I do not want to make this the wording necessarily, but I think we should add something like, "We recognise the difficulty of making progress in establishing this new relationship in the face of either oppositional or confrontational politics."In other words, as much as we try to encourage a consensual way of working, the reality of the current situation is that we often have confrontational or oppositional politics. Therefore, civil servants need to establish a relationship of trust with the Parliament. Paragraph 541 says:"We see no reason why the establishment of such a practical relationship between the civil service and the Parliament should disturb the constitutional position".I imagine that civil servants would not see it like that. When we first came to Parliament, the civil servants told us about their fears about how much they can open themselves up. They are answerable to ministers and therefore have to consider how they open themselves up to working with the Parliament in a more consensual manner. I wanted to add something that echoes those feelings and not just leave it as if there were no hurdles to overcome.Paragraph 534 talks about the civil service as being "disappointingly static". I thought that there had been movement. We should not be too condemnatory. Paragraph 513 is a good example of where civil servants are making contact with committees. Through their own will and through contact with the Parliament, civil servants are beginning to open up. The relationship is largely not as it is in Westminster. I do not agree with that point in paragraph 534, although there is a lot of work to do.
The fact that six of you do not know who our DCLO is—and most of you will not know who the DCLO is in your other committees, such as the Standards Committee—is disappointingly static.
It is disappointing, but there is also movement. I am just making my point.
I do not agree with that last point, but I agree with your first point, which was that we should include some wording to reflect the civil service concern about being sucked into political or partisan issues, as opposed to providing information, guidance and expertise. That is a perfectly fair point to include.
I will try to meet some of the points made by various people. Would it create a constitutional disaster to say in paragraph 542 that the steering group should be made up of MSPs, ministers, senior civil servants and parliamentary officials?
That is what we agreed.
There is a considerable difference between that and the current suggestion that the civil servants should take a supportive role in the group. I believe that the civil servants should be there to fight their corner rather than going away in a cabal afterwards.To satisfy the point that the inquiry should be far reaching and should not just deal with some of the suggestions, as Susan Deacon said, instead of saying "along these lines" at the end of paragraph 542, we could say "including consideration of the points made above." In other words, the recommendation could be more fundamental.
I think that we should take out "along these lines" and include simply "a new relationship between the civil service and Parliament." That gives the group complete scope.We move on to arm's-length bodies, which are covered in paragraphs 543 to 551. Does anybody have points to make?
Paragraph 551 says that there will be a proper consultation, but we should add that, in the meantime, we recommend that committees should scrutinise non-departmental public bodies annually.
Do you mean that every committee must do an investigation of the cognate NDPBs every year or simply that they should consider the annual report? The NDPBs will lodge an annual report with the Parliament and committees will have the opportunity to read and take evidence on them. We could bog committees down substantially if we required them to scrutinise everything that comes within their purview every year.
The committees could quiz the NDPBs on their reports annually and if they did not like what they heard they could undertake more serious investigation.
I have an example from the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee of what I hope is good practice on major NDPBs. Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise dominate the scene in the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee, but there are many other organisations, such as VisitScotland, that that committee must consider. The Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee took the view that it could not review everybody's annual report, and decided this year, as part of the budget process, to focus on Scottish Enterprise.
Paragraph 551 asks our successors to come up with a framework for scrutiny. The point that has been raised is something for the successor committee to consider in determining the framework. I think that Donald Gorrie is jumping to the end of the process and trying to prescribe a conclusion that might be inappropriate given the work load of some committees and the number of bodies with which they are involved.We come to paragraphs 552 to 661 on modernisation of government.
I am afraid that I continue to have concerns about this section. I apologise that I have not consigned alternative text to writing, but I am willing to do that at the 11th hour. I do not disagree with anything in the section, but I think that it is mealy-mouthed. It is not the remit of the inquiry to get into a comprehensive exercise on the modernisation of government.If members are broadly sympathetic to the point that I am making, I would like us to sharpen up the wording of key paragraphs, notably 561. We could say that there needs to be an acceleration of the process of modernising government and of creating greater openness in its operation. I note that the phrases "modernisation" and "opening up" are used almost synonymously. I do not think that that is accurate, but that is a separate point. I would certainly like us to strengthen an exhortation for the process of modernising government, developing an effective, 21st century, post-devolution government operation. We should indicate that the Parliament has a role in driving forward that process, both in contributing to shaping it and in scrutinising its development.
Paragraph 556 struck me as rather odd. I am not quite sure why it is in the report.
I am not quite sure why the section is in the report, but never mind.
We say on one hand that we welcome the Executive's work on modernising government and we talk about the consultation process. We then say:"We wondered where the strategy was for involving the Parliament and the people directly".The Executive told us where the strategy was and talked about it.
Consultation is not the same as developing. Do you want paragraph 556 to be taken out?
Yes.
We could take it out and start with paragraph 557. If Susan Deacon wants to propose ways of fine tuning the section, we could agree to try to negotiate a form of wording separately later. You have obviously done some thinking about that, but I do not think that you are clear about precisely what you want to do.
I am clear about what I want to do, but I readily confess that I have not given you a specific wording. In response to your throwaway line about why the section is in the report, I think that it is relevant to have a section on modernising government.
I am just upset about the time.
That is fair enough, but we have spent a year and a half on this, so it is worth trying to get some of those points right.
I think that everyone is happy for us to go over that section subsequently. There are no problems with paragraphs 562 to 566, on parliamentary consideration of constitutional and governance matters, or with paragraphs 567 to 577, on power sharing. We come to parliamentary committees' operations, in paragraphs 578 to 582. There are no points on that, so we move on to the section on concerns expressed, in paragraphs 583 to 584—a nice short section.
I picked up on a point of substance in paragraph 579. We have not discussed—nor should we have because it is not part of our remit—the hybrid nature of parliamentary committees, which is a fundamental aspect of the way in which the Parliament operates. At the absolute least, there ought to be a stock taking on that point over time. I fear that worked into the report is the implicit endorsement that we think that that is a jolly good thing and that it is all working well. The last thing that I am suggesting is that we open up discussion of the report in that regard just now. However, I do not think that we should allow a view to creep in almost by accident on something as substantive as that.
I take that point entirely. Let us agree that we will put in a new paragraph that notes that committees' dual role has not been part of the investigation, but the Parliament should audit it and consider it at a future date. Our successor committee might want to work on that in conjunction with the Conveners Group.There are no points on paragraphs 583 and 584, headed "Concerns expressed". The next section is headed, "Third Parties on Committees of the Parliament". We have drawn the teeth from that.Paragraphs 590 to 602 are on meeting in private, which again we have discussed extensively.
I am sorry. I go back to paragraph 589, on co-option. My understanding is that we are certainly not making a recommendation for co-option, albeit that we are pointing out the view that was expressed. Are we making that clear enough in the report? The paragraph reads:"We did conclude that co-option itself was only part of the substantive issue".That kind of sounds like—
We have said that the key question is entirely different. We have not recommended that there should be co-option.
If other members think that that is good enough, I do not want to labour the point.
At our previous meeting, Ken Macintosh asked us to leave out the phrase about that being an example of the procedural changes that might be possible if control of procedures were fully repatriated. We put in the phrase about the Deputy Presiding Officer instead. We are struggling a wee bit to think of a third point.There was a clear view that co-option should not happen, although there was support for it in the committee. We did not want to get bogged down in the issue, and the record shows that explicitly. We come to paragraphs 590 to 602.
I have a brief point on paragraph 596. I feel that a view has crept in to which we have not agreed. Please correct me if that happened at a meeting that I missed. Paragraph 596 reads:"We do not consider that there should be public discussion of such appointments, which require consideration of candidates' personal details, and of the relative suitability of candidates for particular posts."The comment relates to the appointment of committee advisers. Was there an explicit decision on that? I am of the view that that is one area where greater transparency should apply. Questions have been asked about committee advisers' interests, which have not necessarily been made open at the time of their appointment.
We discussed whether there should be guidance and whether it should be public, and we agreed that we did not think that there should be public discussion of the individuals.
I do not want to revisit a committee decision; I was just not aware of actively agreeing to one.
Our agreement was implicit in our discussions and in the evidence that we heard. I am not sure whether Susan has been involved in appointing committee advisers on subject committees, but I find the idea of going through the personal details and candidates' merits or demerits in a public session difficult.
Perhaps we could comment on the transparency of the process, which seems to be Susan's concern.
I do not want to press the matter if there is no consensus.
We will move on to the next section, beginning at paragraph 603, on draft reports on committee inquiries. I have suggested text for paragraphs 616 and 617, which I draw to members' attention. Does anyone have anything to say about the paragraphs prior to paragraph 616?
No.
Paragraphs 616 and 617 cover the vexed issues of whipping and freedom to vote. I have disaggregated what was originally included by leaving in some detail about committee business, and including details on the role of back-bench and non-ministerial MSPs in a new paragraph. We do not need a huge discussion on whipping, but it cropped up in the course of discussing committee reports. The purpose of paragraphs 616 and 617 is to say that the committee does not see whipping as particularly significant, and that political pressures should not be important.
I am happy with the wording. My point is separate, and is about discussing proposals in public.The section does not refer to the role of the media. We hope that draft reports will be formulated in a way that recounts evidence. We all have many experiences of working on committees, and know that, if the first time the text of a draft report is seen is during an open session of a committee, the media will report what is new. Each new development in the report's formulation will be reported, but not the committee's conclusions. Obviously, the way in which the report is reported reduces the impact of its conclusions and concentrates on the process of negotiation. I have particular concerns about first drafts, because they often include comments at which members throw their hands up in horror. However, by the time the process of developing the report is finished, we are happy with what we have achieved. If the whole committee has been taken in public, the media will not have reported the final conclusions, just the stages in between.That reality is not reflected in this section. Somewhere in the report we state that we understand that there is not general support for an immediate, overnight move to full public meetings to consider draft reports. I think that I have suggested one of the reasons why that might be the case. Is there space in the section to add my comment?
Is your comment that the media can distort and misreport the process by concentrating on interim positions rather than final conclusions?
The media will not misreport, but will report what was discussed. They will say, "A draft report of Parliament suggested so and so," but the fact that it was a draft report will be missed. The general public receive most information through the media, and they will not see the word "draft".
The media usually say what they are commenting on. There was some coverage of this committee in The Herald and The Scotsman, and both made it clear that our report was a draft.
With respect, convener, our report is probably not the most controversial or politically sensitive.
Indeed.
Ken has a point. Perhaps we could include a sentence that says that a more open system would place a greater obligation on committee conveners to ensure that the public relations aspect of making everything clear is dealt with.
There is scope to include such a comment, perhaps after paragraph 622, which refers to the public coming to understand the process. As Donald says, including Ken's comment would put the responsibility on conveners, on our public relations people and on the press to report drafts as drafts.
I have difficulties with this section for several reasons. We are talking about the consideration of first reports. Let us face it: despite the magnificent efforts of clerks, serious clerical errors can occur in what is included in the draft report. That puts additional pressure on staff in preparation of the report. A draft report is then introduced to the public domain. The media have to make a living, and if the report includes something that can set a couple of hares running—for example, during the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill, the committee considered recommendations for a ban on smacking—errors could make the situation worse.
Yes. Errors could be heavily publicised.
This section should relate to the concerns that have been raised by all committees about the relationship between committees and the media prior to publication of a draft report. The Justice 1 Committee has referred public leaks of draft reports to the Standards Committee.We might think that draft reports would not be leaked if they were made public, but people would look for what was in the draft report before it came before the committee. The media will always look for an exclusive, and I understand that—we must deal with it. Making the draft report public will not prevent someone from trying to leak the document before it is published, or from speculating about what it might include. We must face the fact that there will always be speculation, and that hares will be set running. I think that committees are entitled to private time to consider draft reports, and I do not see anything wrong with that.
We have had this discussion—this is the third time that we have had it. What do you want to do?
I shall move against it. I think that I reflect the opinion of most members when I say that draft reports should be considered in private.
What specifically are you moving against?
Paragraph 622 states that we considered the argument for confusion if draft reports were released, but "concluded that the public would be likely to come to understand this process very quickly."I cannot see how the public will come to understand the process, and I do not think that people will be queueing up to view the committee proceedings.
I am not asking you to redebate the issue, but I want to be clear that you are moving to delete paragraph 622.
There are several elements of the section—
If you want to move something, you need to say what it is.
I would like to clarify something about the process. As I understand it—I think that Donald Gorrie understands it in the same way—if we want to change the report, we must submit suggestions formally in writing.
Yes, but we are going through the report and deciding whether to approve it. I do not think that Paul is suggesting alternative text; he disagrees fundamentally with something and wants to remove it. The committee is entitled to do that.
It sounds as if Paul is referring to the whole section.
That is what I am trying to establish.
Before we go to the vote—
We have not got anything to vote on yet.
Well, this is a point of clarification then. Recommendation 70 does not preclude committees meeting in private.
Of course it does not.
It suggests—and I happen to agree—that too many committees automatically meet in private. I would be the last person to suggest that reports should automatically be taken in public, because sometimes sensitive issues are involved that might not reach the final report. It is horses for courses. There must be flexibility, but the committee received a great deal of evidence from many parties that suggested that we do our committee work in seclusion automatically. Too many parts of our committee work are taken in private automatically. I do not think that there is a need to exclude any of the proposed text.
Nor do I. We are debating the issue yet again—this is our third substantive debate on the issue. We need to come to a decision. Paul Martin has indicated that he wants to take out some text. While he thinks about which text he wants to take out, Ken Macintosh will make a constructive suggestion.
I would like to add what I said earlier about the role of the media, which the convener accepted could be included in paragraph 622. Most members have a genuine fear that their actions will be misinterpreted, that draft reports will be misinterpreted and that the process will become the focus of attention, rather than members' conclusions. We should include a reference to that genuine fear. It is not just a fear; it is a problem that will have to be overcome.In the final sentence of paragraph 622, I also suggest that we change "concluded" to "hoped". I do not think that we can conclude that the public will understand the process quickly, although I hope that they will. We should move to a more open system. Rather than having an automatic presumption that we should meet in private, we should assume that we will meet in public, where possible.We should boost the emphasis on those two aspects. We should state that members have a genuine fear that the Parliament's work will not be interpreted fairly and that we hope to overcome that difficulty. I am fairly comfortable with recommendations 70 and 71, although the use of the phrase "normal practice" in recommendation 71 could perhaps be modified.We should weight the process heavily towards meeting in public. In our report, we are strongly in favour of that—indeed, the drafting goes further than I would have been willing to go. However, I am willing to agree with what is proposed, because the point is important. If we can reflect the fact that there are genuine concerns, we might just get there.
I am perfectly happy with your suggestion for additional material for a new paragraph after paragraph 622. We could express fears of misinterpretation and anxiety about the process looming larger than the outcomes in reporting. Those are pertinent points to make.
I take that on board. In the light of the helpful contributions of Ken Macintosh and Gil Paterson, I withdraw my proposal for paragraph 622.Paragraph 634 states:"It is hard to see how meeting in private to discuss lines of questioning could be compatible with some of the ideas we have considered for less formal ways in which to gather evidence."I do not think that meeting in private in such cases causes any difficulties. For example, as a member of the Audit Committee, I found it very helpful to discuss in private with the Auditor General for Scotland how I proposed to question Sir Muir Russell on issues relating to the new Scottish Parliament building project, as Sir Muir Russell was not aware of the questions that I would ask him. We are talking about the real world. It is helpful to meet in private to discuss how we will question witnesses.
Paragraph 636 deliberately provides for that. It recognises that, with many witnesses, we engage in a more interrogative process. Some witnesses are hostile. I am not suggesting that civil servants would fall into that category. Paragraph 636 acknowledges that there are cases in which a committee might decide that it wanted to take such an approach. There is no reason why it should not do so.
Paragraph 634 states:"It may appear threatening to many potential committee witnesses for committees to discuss their lines of questioning in private."Discussing lines of questioning in private is not threatening in any way and I have no difficulties with it. Committees are entitled to private time to discuss questioning.I am sure that witnesses meet in private before they come to committee meetings. Sometimes they meet the civil servants privately before they meet us. I do not find that threatening. Witnesses are entitled to spend their time being briefed on how they propose to answer any questions that we might put to them. Sometimes committees are helpful in providing witnesses with information on the questions that they might be asked. I feel strongly that committees should have an opportunity to meet in private to discuss lines of questioning.
Paragraph 636 covers Paul Martin's concerns.
So does paragraph 637.
There is a range of witnesses. There is a difference between Muir Russell and some of the witnesses from community organisations that the Social Justice Committee has questioned. It is horses for courses. The relevant paragraphs cover the issue adequately. Paragraph 636 takes account of Paul Martin's concerns. Committees will still be able to meet in private to discuss the questioning of witnesses. There is no problem.
Broadly speaking, I am content with this section of the report, but I have a specific point to raise. I had to nip out of the room, so I apologise if the committee has already dealt with it. Do we say at some point that there should be a framework within which committees should operate? For example, on a previous occasion, I mentioned local government practice. John Patterson circulated a helpful note on that. Local government has established practices for prior publication of what will be considered in public and what will be in private. Paragraph 600 gives a general exhortation to publish such proposals in advance, but I wonder whether there is a paragraph that says specifically that a more formal guideline ought to be produced.
In paragraph 634, there might be room to emphasise the fact that we want to establish the principle that the Parliament's business is conducted openly, so that everyone can follow it. We do not want to put obstacles in the way of good practice or the efficient working of members. We could recommend further work, as Susan Deacon suggested. Such work could be along the lines of practice in other areas of government or it could build on the work that committees already do.
The directorate of clerking and reporting produces guidance for committee conveners. That guidance is being considered and the comments that have been made would fit into that process. In effect, the Conveners Group is being challenged to review the guidance under which it operates. The crux of the report is directed at the Conveners Group, the Parliamentary Bureau and the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. Where appropriate, we want those bodies to respond to the issues that we have raised.
I suggest that we do not get too bogged down in the issue. The Conveners Group is reviewing how well things have gone in the past. That will be a legacy for future committees, after the elections. I would not want to be too prescriptive. We have flagged up our concerns about meeting in private. Although we encourage committees to meet more in public, we reserve their right to meet in private. That addresses Paul Martin's concerns. The Conveners Group is working on the area that has been mentioned. The convener is right—we should bounce back our thoughts to the Conveners Group, so that something will be included in the guidance that goes to the new committees after 1 May.
If there are grey areas, we could find that committees start to spend time on whether matters should have been discussed in private. That happens already. There will be debates on whether lines of questioning should have been considered in private or in public. Such debates will take up committee time. Although I appreciate that we expect members to act maturely and to enter into discussions in the right spirit, some members will raise concerns. They will say that the CSG report said that almost every item should be considered in public. There might be grey areas. It will be difficult to be prescriptive.
I am sure that it will. However, we should be pleased if our recommendation causes committees to reflect on their decisions to go into private session automatically, which tends to be what happens, even if, after consideration, they decide that the circumstances merit taking an item in private. At least the question whether to take the item in private will have been considered. That is the principal point.
That is right. Explaining the rationale means that the public will have a better understanding. Too often, even members do not know why a recommendation to deal with an item in private has been made. It is reasonable to operate in such a way that an explanation is given in advance and a decision is taken.
May I clarify the point that I asked about earlier? What will result from all of this? I have lost sight of the end point of the process. Are we saying that the Conveners Group will produce a specific set of proposals for the committees to work to?
We cannot tell the Conveners Group what to do, but in the last paragraph of the report I suggest that"We address the report to the Executive, the Parliamentary Bureau, the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, the Conveners' Group, and all MSPs."The points that are within their areas of responsibility are addressed to them. We are inviting the Conveners Group to reflect on anything in the report that is germane to its function.
Does anybody have an objection to us tagging on to the end of that a statement such as "with a view to developing guidelines to which committees will operate in future"? That is still quite a minimalist position compared with the statutory framework to which local authorities have to work.
We can add an extra paragraph that states that the issues that are raised in this and other sections of the committee part of the report should be referred to the Conveners Group, and that it should be asked to reflect on the report and review its guidance.
This is an incredibly important area. We have received so much evidence on the matter that it is vital that we produce something with some hard edges.
The paragraph will not necessarily belong in this section, but it will be in this general span of the report. We will consider where such a paragraph might best be located.Do members have points on the section on draft committee reports on bills at stage 1?
No.
Members have no points on paragraphs 652 to 657, on Executive majorities on committees, and on paragraphs 658 to 667, on committee meetings outside Edinburgh. We will move on to paragraphs 668 to 687, which deal with changes to committee membership. Paragraph 682 has been substantially rewritten. I have left it in for members to consider. We have discussed the matter before. I think that the agreement was that we should reflect the range of opinions and the concern that existed, although we could not see a way to resolve the difficulty. I hope that members are happy with the way that that is expressed.
Members indicated agreement.
Paragraphs 688 to 707 are on non-Executive bills. I have no points to raise on those paragraphs and neither do other members.The next section, paragraphs 708 to 735, is on other committee operational matters.
I have a tiny point, which might be covered in the first half of the report. We had a discussion about the importance of non-confrontational meetings to get the best out of some witnesses. That is not covered in those paragraphs.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Feb 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Procedures Committee Tuesday 25 February 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Consultative Steering Group Inquiry Committee business · 457
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.