Good morning and welcome to the ninth meeting in session 3 of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. This morning, we begin our interrogation of the budget process 2008-09 and the spending review period in general. We will take evidence from a series of organisations on the significant areas of budget expenditure for which we have parliamentary responsibility.I am pleased to welcome Scottish Enterprise's chief executive, Jack Perry, its chief financial officer, Hugh Hall, and the finance director of group operations, Andrew Downie. Mr Perry might want to make a brief opening statement; if not, we will fire off with questions.
Official Report · Committee
Budget Process 2008-09
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tavish Scott LD 71
- Sandy Cumming Highlands and Islands Enterprise 51
- Jack Perry Scottish Enterprise 37
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 32
- Philip Riddle VisitScotland 27
- David Valentine Society of Local Authority Chief Executives and Senior Managers and Scottish Local Authorities Economic Development Group 22
- Peter Peacock Lab 21
- Hugh Hall Scottish Enterprise 14
- Christopher Harvie SNP 13
- Councillor Hay 13
- Brian Adam SNP 12
- Dave Thompson SNP 12
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 11
- Gavin Brown Con 11
- Andrew Downie Scottish Enterprise 8
- Forbes Duthie Highlands and Islands Enterprise 8
- Sandy Brady Highlands and Islands Enterprise 7
- George Foulkes Lab 7
- Riddell Graham VisitScotland 4
- James Fowlie Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 4
- Councillor Alison Hay Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 1
- Barbara Lindsay Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 1
The record
389 contributions · showing 1–200I will make a brief statement. We welcome the opportunity to discuss where we are with our plans.It is just two weeks since the Scottish Government made its spending review statement, so we are still working through the detail of what it means for Scottish Enterprise. We reiterate what we said in our written submission: we would welcome the opportunity to come back to the committee to discuss our budget in full, once it has been developed.As members will be aware, major changes are being made in how Scottish Enterprise will operate in future. Following the Government's recent review of the enterprise networks, from 1 April we will be repositioned as Scotland's enterprise, innovation and investment agency. Our strategy will be determined by the needs and demands of our key industries, and our customers will be businesses that have the potential to make a disproportionate impact on the Scottish economy. Our focus will be on delivering effective support to encourage those businesses to grow and on helping to improve the environment in which they operate. We are in the process of implementing major changes across the organisation to ensure that we deliver that service as efficiently and as effectively as we can.It is undoubtedly a challenging time for our employees, for whom a significant element of uncertainty has been created, which we are trying to clear up as quickly as we can. Our approach to managing change has been to engage with our staff as often as we have been able to and to get our own people to lead the implementation of the changes that we have embarked on making. More than 100 people from across our organisation are participating in work on subjects ranging from how to effect a smooth transfer of people and activities to the new skills body, to how to re-energise our relationship with local government and build on the best practices that have been adopted by our local enterprise companies. The outcome of those work streams will have an impact on our final budget position, particularly on those areas that are concerned with transferring activities into and out of Scottish Enterprise.Generally speaking, the financial settlement that we face over the next three years is extremely challenging, but that is hardly unique to us. It will require us to prioritise what we do, which might result in our taking some unpopular decisions, but we aim to squeeze as much value as we can from the resources that we have, through realising efficiencies of up to £10 million annually. That will entail a significant reduction in staff numbers but, in line with Government policy, we have given our workforce the guarantee that there will be no compulsory redundancies.We will use our resources to leverage in as much private sector investment as we can—in our submission we have given examples of the opportunities that exist—and we will work as collaboratively as we can with public sector partners to ensure that we do not duplicate our effort and that our investment is better aligned across the Scottish public sector. We seek better alignment with the investment of VisitScotland and Highlands and Islands Enterprise, in particular, but also with that of bodies such as Transport Scotland and Scottish Water.Last year, we delivered a balanced budget and this year we are on track to do the same. However, that should not mask the fact that there are issues to do with annuality and resource accounting that make the budget extremely difficult for us as an investment agency to manage. Those issues were flagged up to your predecessor committee, which accepted what we said.More than ever, we want to be forward thinking and creative in our work, and to be encouraged to take measured risks in supporting economic growth in Scotland, but we operate in a financial environment that militates against that. Any support that the committee can give us in helping to get the relevant changes made at national level would be most welcome.We welcome the clarity of purpose that we have been given and we are working speedily to implement change and realise the planned efficiencies. We remain excited by the opportunity that is ahead of us and optimistic about the future. We welcome your questions.
In relation to clarity of purpose, I guess that you knew what was going to happen to the enterprise network across Scotland in the third week of September. What happened between the third week of September and 14 November, when the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth announced his budget?
I am not sure that I entirely follow your question.
It strikes me that that was quite a lengthy period. I take your point that you have had only two weeks to react to the budget statement, but you have had rather longer than that to deal with the changes to the network.
Absolutely. We have done preliminary work on how to effect those changes—it is hard to fire the starting gun until there is absolute certainty on the reform of the network. We are quite well advanced with many of the reforms to the local enterprise company structure, the reform of our industry groups and the reform of the services that we offer.
When can the committee expect to see the detail of the changes that will be made to the network as a result of the strategy announcement at the end of September?
We will make announcements on changes that affect our staff by 21 December. By January, we should be well advanced with our draft operating plan and the detailed budget for the coming year.
That will be after we have finished our budget consideration.
Regrettably so, but some major uncertainties exist—not least, the transfer values that I mentioned. We will transfer 1,200 staff. As well as the value of all those activities that are related just to skills, there is the matter of the business gateway. Those issues all have to be negotiated and finally agreed with the successor bodies.
You do not yet know how much of your budget will be taken away as a result of the setting up of the new skills agency and the transfer of responsibility to local authorities.
Those figures all have to be agreed.
Will they be agreed by Christmas? What is the expectation?
To an extent, that is not necessarily in our gift. Hugh Hall might have a better feel for when that is likely to happen.
It would be ideal if it happened by Christmas, but I do not want to put colleagues in other businesses under pressure. It is not in our gift when those negotiations conclude, although we have had some preliminary discussions with the Scottish Government about what the size of the transfer might be. However, we are involved in some detailed discussions on a few imponderables with regard to local regeneration and physical business infrastructure. For example, where does the responsibility of urban regeneration companies begin and end? Ideally, if we could get some clarity by Christmas, we would be able to firm up our budget and put a final draft business plan and resource allocation to our board at the end of January.
But the Government has decided to set up a skills agency. I presume that it has told you how much it wants to put into that.
The Government has told us which programmes should be transferred, although certain areas have still to be finalised. We will remain responsible for workforce development in our current managed companies, but we and the new skills body still have to agree finally on the precise definition of what that means. Although we know that Careers Scotland's activities and the four major national skills programmes will certainly transfer, and although we have a good idea of what their value should be, matters have still to be agreed.
We at Scottish Enterprise can say with some certainty that, with our fairly good grasp of the details, we would be able to—and would like to—agree the figures and clear everything by Christmas. The question is whether the embryonic skills agency and the other bodies will be in a similar position.
Thank you. That was very helpful.
One important point that I should clarify is that, in the Scottish Government's budget, Scottish Enterprise's budget covered all our existing activities, including those that will continue under us and those that will be discontinued. As a result, when we determine our budget allocations, we need to think about our future budget as if everything in it is continuing. That issue will need to be discussed with the new skills body.
I quite understand.
Although the fact that this spending round is very tight has had particular consequences, the approach that is being taken fits in with the Government's policy position that Scottish Enterprise should co-locate some of its work with other bodies. That is bound to have an implication for your current estate. In addition, some written submissions that we have received suggest that Scottish Enterprise will have to make efficiencies from its estate. What are your assets worth and what is your return on them? Do you plan to change anything in that respect? How do you see your needs with regard to having a place to park your staff and what are the implications for the budget?
We have already agreed—indeed, we have welcomed the opportunity—to co-locate, where it is sensible to do so, with council economic development offices and/or VisitScotland. As you rightly point out, such moves are subject to property availability and existing property commitments. We also have a programme of redeploying staff from our headquarters to operational offices as much as we possibly can.
Have you made any progress on co-location?
We have had very initial discussions. However, at this stage, the huge programme of reforms on which we are embarking relates to Scottish Enterprise's network and activities. Once we understand the operational models, we will examine how we might co-locate with other bodies.
There will be some scope to make efficiencies from co-location, but its biggest benefit is better connectivity and working arrangements between the various agencies. I do not think that it will generate significant savings per se. Instead, we will make savings through the enterprise networks review and through removing the governance of 12 local enterprise companies. For example, we will have to prepare only one set of financial statements, rather than 13. As we achieve better connectivity across our staff, we will be able to streamline the senior management structures and remove some corporate functions. That is where the real financial benefits will come from.
I presume that you also have assets and that, for example, you own property on which you get a return. Some of the material that we have seen has implied that you might want to dispose of that property or seek a better rate of return on it. If the intention is to get a better rate of return—and the rates for leasing property increase to maximise your returns—what impact will that have on developing business and new business start-ups?
We own assets, and we supplement our resource budget—as the figures in our submission show—with asset disposals. However, we recycle as well, acquiring and developing new assets. The process is on-going: we are always involved in economic development, and we will develop new assets in future years.
I accept that the process is on-going, but does the budget have fresh implications for it? Are you going to pay for restructuring or other costs by disposing of assets, or will you supplement any reduction in your budget by increasing the income that you receive from existing assets in order to maintain particular activities?
In many respects, we act as a developer. We acquire assets, work on them and then sell them on. That is a regular process. Off a lower budget base, our ability to acquire new assets and work on them might change, and over time it is possible that our ability to generate fresh gains will diminish. However, we are not an investment or a property-holding company. We exist to bring non-productive land or assets into production and get as much private sector leverage as we can.
So if that is not your core business, why are you continuing to do it?
In terms of business infrastructure, it will remain core. I said up front that improving the business environment through projects that have national or regional significance remains part of what we do.
Increasingly, our work is not about holding investments in order to make a financial return. There are RAB—resource accounting and budgeting—implications in holding on to assets, so we prefer to consider what we can dispose of readily from our whole non-operational asset base to meet commitments. There is a presumption in the budget that we will dispose of some assets and realise some income, and that element will rise over the three years. We will also retain some assets, because we have existing tenants and commitments and we are getting a return from rental schemes. Another area that we have explored is using our assets in a more innovative way by working with developers and others, as has happened in some of the regional development agencies south of the border. That would involve sweating our and the private sector's assets, perhaps through a special purpose vehicle. We are at the early stages in considering that, but we would like to probe it further. Can we deliver what we need to deliver in physical business infrastructure and other projects through innovative funding techniques? There is definitely scope for us to do that. It is done elsewhere, so we should be able to plagiarise.Another consideration is how to use property asset disposals to meet our budget commitments. If a significant project came along that required £15 million or £20 million, and we did not have the funding in our budget, we would look to realise some assets to fund it. That is how we will look at our assets over the three years.
I have some specific questions on the transfer of budgets to the skills agency and local government. The minister has made announcements about decentralisation and how the landscape will be decluttered, but a lot of us on the ground are not seeing that and are not convinced that it is happening.You spoke about voluntary redundancies. How are they to be financed, and have you any idea of the cost?In response to Brian Adam, you spoke about selling assets to support Scottish Enterprise. From what the minister has said, the reorganisation covers all of Scotland. Local economic development will come from the councils and the skills agency will be working, but if Scottish Enterprise sells an asset—I am thinking particularly about my constituency in Fife—it might be detrimental to overall economic development. We all have concerns about that.You talked about better connectivity and better working with partners. How will you achieve that?I am interested in what stage you are at in establishing which staff will move from the centre to the localities. I am interested in how you will reach agreement with local government, because that is important to me. Will you give local government and the skills agency the authority to deliver programmes? In other words, as well as the budget and staff, will those bodies be given the authority to deliver programmes?Finally, how will you ensure that the work that you do nationally supports regional and local economic development? That is important, because I would not like Scottish Enterprise to exist in isolation. Given some of the evidence that the committee has received, I am not convinced that the minister's aims will transfer to areas such as Fife—I am not in the comfort zone on that. I presume that many of my colleagues will have similar issues.I have asked many questions on the subject, but I have been told that they are for Scottish Enterprise to address, which is why I am asking you these questions today. I know that they are wide ranging, but they are on the crux of the matter. Where are you in the process and how will you ensure agreement?
Gosh—there were several questions there, but we will do our best to address them.You asked about the financing of the voluntary severance scheme. We have allocated no more than £25 million for that. The payback period will be less than three years and probably closer to two, which is not a bad period for a major restructuring programme. We have opened the consultation on the scheme and we are seeking volunteers. There are significant risks: we may not get sufficient volunteers or we may not get volunteers in the right places or with the right skills, in which case we will deny those volunteers the opportunity to take severance.Our reform and our ability to generate the savings that I identified earlier are entirely contingent on our ability to deliver the full number of voluntary severances, but there is no guarantee that we will be able to do that. The use of a voluntary scheme necessarily restricts our ability to realise savings. The consultation has started and we will have to wait for the outcome. It remains open until, I think, the end of February, so we have some time to wait before we see how the scheme pans out.On staff transfers, we are working on the exact staffing model that we want for the future. Some of the process is contingent on what happens with the severance scheme and on our ability to transfer people outwith a normal commuting distance. Some of the transfers will take a little more time to effect.On asset sales and authority, I see no diminution of our participation in consultation with business and public sector partners on wider economic benefit for Scotland. We are conscious of our responsibilities as an economic development agency for all lowland Scotland, which includes the cities and the rural areas. I find it hard to think of a single project in which we have engaged in an activity that has been to the detriment of a wider economic plan or policy.
I asked whether, in future, if you sell assets to support Scottish Enterprise's bigger projects, that could be detrimental to regional and local development. I was asking about the future.
We will continue to work closely with local government and other agencies in delivering our business, so there would be discussion and dialogue in the course of such a process.There is another issue on which we need to give you absolute assurance. As the cabinet secretary made clear in his announcement, Scottish Enterprise will continue to operate at national, regional and local level. We are committed to pushing as much of our business out to the front line as we can. The deals that we do in Fife energy park, in the BioQuarter and on the Clyde, for example, happen because we have people who have excellent relationships with local government and the other agencies. We expect that to continue. In addition, it will be reinforced through co-location. Funding issues mean that we want to work together to ensure that we get the best bang for the public sector buck.
I have no problem with continued support for Fife energy park; I am concerned about the stuff that falls outwith the priority areas.
One area on which we are holding discussions is regeneration. Large-scale projects such as Fife energy park and the BioQuarter—physical business infrastructure that will have a real impact on economic development—will be led by Scottish Enterprise. Local regeneration will be led by the councils; they are the best placed to do that.In the middle ground—urban regeneration companies are probably the best example—we will continue to work in partnership. For example, when we were negotiating the spend profile for Riverside Inverclyde for the next few years, we were keen to ensure that physical business infrastructure and economic development were built into the contract with the URC. We will continue with that commitment.
I think that what Marilyn Livingstone is driving at is this: if you have less money, and if your budget will reduce because of the transfers that you have acknowledged, something will have to give. Everything cannot be a priority.
Absolutely. Local regeneration is now firmly in the remit of local government. I said earlier that we would have to prioritise and that some of our decisions would be unpopular. However, we will no longer be responsible for local regeneration projects where the benefit is in civic amenities, retail or those kinds of things. We have been withdrawing from that kind of stuff for a number of years. The amount that we do is actually fairly minimal.
I am aware of that; you are telling us what we know. What I am trying to tease out is how we can be confident that the staff, the budget and the authority that is required will move with projects.
We still have to agree on the amount of budget that will transfer, on the requirement for existing projects and on who will complete them. Commitments to URCs still have to be agreed as well. The amounts are not yet finalised.
I was grateful for your earlier answer about which areas would not be priorities, but it would be helpful if you could go into more detail in response to questions from other members.
Of course. Sure.
Mr Perry said that some decisions would be unpopular. The budget figures are headline figures and do not take account of the money that we know will be moving out, but we are going from £465 million to £448 million—which, in real terms, means that we are probably going down to around £436 million. Can you give us an idea of what £30 million-worth of unpopular decisions might look like? We will not get exact answers this morning, but you must have some idea of the kind of things that will go.
To answer that, I will bring in Hugh Hall and Andy Downie shortly. As I have said, we have a commitment to realise about £10 million in efficiency savings. Of the remainder, I genuinely cannot tell you at this stage what will be prioritised. We have a forward pipeline of more than £500 million of potential projects that we could work on, and we are now in the process of prioritising them. Those projects are not commitments—they are projects that we could work on in the future. We will comfortably meet all the commitments that are currently in the pipeline, but we will have to figure out how the potential projects will fit in in the future, so I cannot give an example of a project that we know we will be unable to work on in the future.
As Jack Perry said earlier, we are considering our overall business plan. We have to manage a pipeline of projects over a span of more than a year, and an annualised budget creates problems for us. However, the focus over the next couple of months will be on developing a robust business plan and achieving a balanced budget. It is crucial that we balance our budget. It is a challenge, but we must take a long-term view of economic development over a three to five-year span rather than consider only an annual period.
Our commitments stretch out over many years.
There has been some debate in the committee about whether we have been given level 2 or level 3 data. The headline figure for Scottish Enterprise's budget for 2008-09 is around £448 million, and that is really all the breakdown that we have. Scottish Enterprise's draft budget for 2007-08 was broken down into seven or eight areas. There was money for growing business, skills and learning, global connections, management and administration, Careers Scotland—obviously, money for it was included under the skills and learning heading from 2003-04—and voted loans, and there was a non-cash budget. Should we expect more of a breakdown of how things might pan out before we vote on the budget?
In view of our timetable, providing such a breakdown would be desperately difficult. In a normal year, at this point we would just be embarking on developing our operating plan for the year commencing 1 April. Currently, we are trying to engineer profound reforms to the entire network. In addition, we have just been given our budget, and we are working through what it means for our operating plan, the efficiency savings that we can realise, and the transfers, which have not yet been agreed. We are trying to come up with a balanced budget within the timeframe that we have talked about, which goes beyond your timeframe for scrutinising the budget.Perhaps Andrew Downie would like to expand on what I have said.
That is indeed the position. We are doing things as quickly as we can, but inevitably we are dependent on other parties. We have the target of going back to our board at the end of January with a business plan for the three-year span and an annual plan.
I presume that the one point of certainty is that the Government has said which six industrial sectors it wants to concentrate on and therefore which industrial sectors its enterprise agencies will want to concentrate on. I presume that one can conclude that anything else will not be a priority.
We are clear that the Government has endorsed six national priority industries, but beneath those are a number of regional priority industries and enabler technologies that affect a number of regional and national key industries. The regional priority industries will therefore remain priorities for us.I should point out that a number of regional priority industries attract more spend than some national priority industries. We believe that the national priority industries, which will be increasingly focused on, and the regional priority industries have been endorsed. The term "regional priority industries" is perhaps unfortunate—we could look for better nomenclature. Basically, we are considering fields such as life sciences, in which Scotland has outstanding, world-class technologies. Scotland can play a leading role with such technologies in a worldwide market. I doubt that Scotland will ever be a worldwide leader in aerospace and defence, for example, but it can play a valuable role in their global supply chains. We have established real strengths in that area and we want to continue to be able to support those industries.
Good morning, gentlemen.There is one issue that I would like you to give me a wee bit of information about. How will the fairly substantial budget increases for roads, railways, ferries and social enterprises, the reduction in business rates and the increased spending on energy, for example, impact on Scottish Enterprise? You have, as you say, a very tight budget settlement. A fair bit of the budget is going into those other areas, which might well be areas in which you would have got involved in the past. I am interested to know whether that will make things a wee bit easier.
That is a good question. We have been encouraged, as regards the economic strategy, by an attempt to join up and align various branches of the public sector towards economic growth. The strategic forum recently held its first meeting—it brings together Highlands and Islands Enterprise, VisitScotland and ourselves in an effort to bring about that greater alignment of spend. If, in the follow through, the spend on transport, energy and the other things you mentioned can be aligned towards a common goal of economic growth, it has the opportunity to be very powerful. In the past, we have not had that alignment. There is now an opportunity to make it happen. In fairness—I am not making any political points on this—greater alignment of all branches of the public sector towards economic growth is something that we have talked about. During the currency of this budget, Scottish Enterprise will have less than 1 per cent of the Scottish Government's budget. We cannot be transformational on our own. We can get extremely good leverage for that money—we believe that the economic impact of what we deliver is probably about five times the amount that is put in—but even that cannot be transformational by itself if the rest of the public sector is not aligned behind growth. We welcome the move towards alignment, but a lot of hard work needs to be done to turn it into reality.
Thank you—that is very encouraging. You mentioned that you are co-locating with other public sector agencies and so on. How much do you expect to share back-room functions with those bodies?
There is a firm commitment from the cabinet secretary that we continue to have shared services and that we grow those. There is a presumption that we will continue to share services with the new skills agency. We have had discussions with VisitScotland and HIE in recent weeks about the ways in which we could do more in the shared services area. Scottish Enterprise already has things such as a network finance centre and a network human resources resource, so we have already been consolidating the back-office services. We will redouble our efforts to get as much out of that area as we possibly can.
I am interested in the proposition that you have at the same time—in relation to the governance of the network—a decentralisation and a removal of local enterprise companies that involves putting all their functions to the Scottish Enterprise board. To understand that better, I would like to know what the position is with regard to Atlantic Quay. Is the disposal of Atlantic Quay one of the receipts that is anticipated in the budget?
There is no intention to dispose of Atlantic Quay as a property. In any event—this might help to answer Mr Adam's question as well—we own very little in terms of operational assets. Pretty much everything is leased. We own one of our office buildings. We have a long-term lease commitment to Atlantic Quay. Although it is a very desirable property, we will see over time a significant reduction in the number of people who populate that office, and if surplus space becomes available we will sublet it. We talk about disposals of assets, but it is not our asset to dispose of: we would seek to maximise the value that we can realise in the event that surplus space becomes available. That has to be balanced with the availability of space in all our regional offices. Regarding your point about decentralisation, we have made a commitment to keep all 12 of our local enterprise company offices. They will continue to be responsible for the delivery of service to our customers, the delivery of our major projects, and the initiation and identification of projects and programmes to be delivered; so they continue to have an important role. What is changing is a lot of the governance and the statutory responsibilities that go with the complex legal structure in which we operated before. It would be wrong of me to say that the change has been welcomed universally, but many local enterprise company directors think that it will enable the new regional boards and industry boards to concentrate on areas in which they can really add value to the economy and to do fewer of the things that did not add much value but were extremely time consuming.
In the budget statement, the Government said that the changes to your budget"include a cut in direct capital funding in line with"your ability"to fund capital projects through receipts from asset sales and collaboration with the private sector."Can you give me a sense of the capital side of the budget reduction? Can you break that down?
The numbers are still to be finalised, but it appears that our net capital funding will be £52 million next year, and will decline in subsequent years. The figure is net of capital receipts—the property disposals that we mentioned earlier.
Are those property disposals that are already planned, or does the figure assume additional property disposals that you would not otherwise have made?
Part of our business planning process is to look at property disposals in subsequent years, over a three-year span. We also bring in additional income from other sources, including significant amounts of European Union funding that supplement our budget. The figure that I have given indicates the net capital position.
It is important to realise that the figure for capital funding is not capped. We can transfer resources from revenue, although we cannot transfer them in the other direction. We have a bit of flexibility.
You talked about the way in which you have acquired, developed and disposed of assets. Is it fair to say that the process of disposal and acquisition will be much more of a one-way street than it was in the past?
Not necessarily. It will depend on how the circumstances relate to our plans. As we have said to committees previously, one of the disadvantages of holding assets is that they have a resource cost. The valuations of assets and the costs of capital charges must be factored into our overall budget. However, we need to hold strategic assets and to develop our assets to support economic development.
An extremely perverse aspect of resource accounting and budgeting is that, as an investment agency, we are almost disincentivised from investing. It is interesting that bodies elsewhere in the United Kingdom have been taken out of resource accounting and budgeting.
So that remains a concern for you?
It is a major concern for us.
It is a huge concern. We have encouraged our staff to take what we call an investment-led approach to projects and programmes. They are to look at propositions in terms not of how much grant we will put in but of how much investment we will put in to get a potential return at the end of the day. In that way, we can recycle the public funding component. Given that we are dealing partly with market failure, it is not always possible to get returns, but the potential for doing so exists. Resource accounting and budgeting creates a disincentive, because if we hold an investment we face a holding cost, and if subsequently we sell the investment at less than acquisition value we take another hit. That is perverse and pushes us down the road of grant giving rather than taking an investment-led approach. Any support that the committee or the Parliament could give us in changing the rules or taking us out of the RAB envelope would be extremely welcome.
Another issue is our ability to retain and recycle future gains. If we have a windfall on a particularly good investment that was previously unbudgeted for, our ability to retain and recycle that is seriously limited. I accept that Governments have to make difficult and unpopular choices from time to time—we are not the only people who have to do that—but with a lower budget settlement, the flexibility to retain gains would be welcome and would provide better leverage for the sums that are invested in Scottish Enterprise.
We have given briefings on resource accounting to previous committee members. If the committee would like an opportunity to hear more about that issue, we would be delighted to offer a briefing.
I have sat through a lot of briefings previously.
So if we are suffering from insomnia—Laughter.
Keep going, Lewis.
On a slightly different issue—although we may return to that one—
We may.
The convener asked about cluster industries and the six national priorities. Intermediary technology institutes—or rather the ITI and its subsets—have made a significant contribution over the past two or three years. Do you regard them as a priority that could roll forward in spite of the much tougher financial climate?
All our activities are reviewed and monitored constantly to ensure that they are delivering what they were expected to deliver. The ITIs will be subject to the same budget scrutiny as all our other activities. We remain committed to the ITI project. However, I cannot tell you at this stage about the impact of this budget on their activities.
Brian Adam has a supplementary question on assets.
We are certainly interested in resource accounting and budgeting, but can you encapsulate in a few words why you should be the special case that you want to be? Is it that you cannot get the same return on your capital asset, given the nature of the business that you are involved in? Is it for some other reason?
It is not that we have concerns about our ability to raise returns. If we invest in an asset, and if—as Hugh Hall said—we take a charge in the year when we acquire the asset as well as an annual charge thereafter for every year we continue to hold the asset, we are effectively being asked to pay for the asset twice. Over time, as we acquire assets and continue to hold them, our built-up liability for annual resource charge also increases. We have to reserve some of our budget for that. If we do not have sufficient non-cash resource cover, that cover has to come out of cash resources, and we have to cut back on programmes to afford that. We are not necessarily asking to be a special case. Scottish Water was taken out of resource accounting and budgeting because it has a major investment programme. The NHS in England and Wales has recently been taken out of resource accounting and budgeting—it, too, has a large investment programme. The English regional development agencies have a pooling system for their resource accounting provision, whereby they can share any unused portions if one of them is over in any one year—but we have no one to pool with. To an extent, our ability to do the very investment activities that we would like to do is inhibited. As Hugh Hall mentioned, in the past couple of years we have often found ourselves with some quite attractive investment propositions but we have simply been unable to afford the holding costs of the asset. Instead, we have determined to give a grant. That might get the job done, but it minimises the potential return, or upside, that the taxpayer might have been able to get on the investment. That is the inhibitor.
My questions are mainly about the relationship between Scottish Enterprise and the foreseen expansion of the renewable energy industry. I know that that is not your main line, but it is bound to have an effect on your strategic planning.First, though, I will say a couple of words about where I am coming from. I was joint head of the international economics course at the University of Tübingen. Our economics department—I am not part of it; I was part of the humanities side of it—was reckoned by Der Spiegel to be the best in Germany, just as Baden-Württemberg was reckoned to be the best industrial region in Germany. That was achieved by concentrating in the 1980s and 1990s on the things that we in Britain were instructed were old hat—metal bashing, essentially. However, 24 per cent of gross domestic product there still lies in metal bashing, and it is paying off very handsomely. This would be the point where, from another point of autobiography—I wrote the history of North Sea oil—
Could we please hear your questions? I am sorry to be difficult.
Yes—sure. In 1993, I wrote the history of North Sea oil. In 1988 to 1990, I went down the Clyde and looked at the various places that were producing. Scott Lithgow in Greenock had the most sophisticated yard, which was capable of producing the most ambitious drill ship in the world. It is still in service—it is the Ocean Alliance. Up in Govan, a North Sea ferry was fitting out. Those are examples from two industries that have almost completely vanished. There was also the John Brown group at Clydebank, which produced rigs for the North Sea. Like everything else in Scotland, that yard is to become the site of a supermarket. Jim Mather expects 50 per cent of our energy to be taken from renewables by 2020. From that, we can postulate that an enormous expansion in the industrialisation of the country will be directed at that sector. Judging by what I saw, principally in Inverness, wave technology has reached the stage at which it is about to take off. The situation is similar to that of North Sea oil when the Montrose field came on stream in 1968. That means that we will have to move very quickly—within six or seven years—and with due consideration of the import of goods and all that sort of thing, remembering the disaster that that caused when the North Sea operation was set up in 1976.We will also have to work much more with continental companies, given that we no longer have the manufacturing resource to hand. With the exception of Aberdeen, nearly all the places that helped to manufacture for North Sea oil have disappeared. Scottish enterprise agencies, north and south, must represent the national interest in that collaboration. The sheer size of the industry that we expect to be developed will unquestionably bring a change in your orientation.What plans do you have over that six or seven year trajectory, to keep up? In other words, there is a sense in which you will have to become a renewables Statoil.
That is a very good expression. Your contribution ranged pretty widely; I will address a few of the points you raised. As you rightly said, the target is ambitious. We want to support it. Energy is one of the six key priority industries for us in the future. That includes not only the technologies that Scotland has in abundance in the extractive industries, which we need to get out and sell to the rest of the world—we have some effective examples of that—but renewables. You mentioned wave technology. Scottish Enterprise is an investor in Ocean Power Delivery—we are continuing to support that. In the main, the Fife energy park is about the manufacturing capabilities that will support renewable technologies in future. In addition, in conjunction with Rolls-Royce, Airbus and companies such as GKM, we are supporting the advance forming research centre that is looking at new materials. Initially, that will principally be done for the aerospace industry, but it will also have applications for related industries such as energy, with particular relevance to materials that will be required if we are to capitalise on the renewables opportunities.Advanced engineering is one of our priority enablers. We have a number of successes in that respect, one of which is the AFRC. Another is the Scottish manufacturing advisory service, which has got off to a cracking start. It is now recognised as having made a very positive contribution.The other area that we are working on at the moment is power networks. There is a real challenge with a distributed generation system, as opposed to a centralised generation system that takes power from the centre out to the rest of the country. The challenge in generating thousands of power sources is that our current grid and power networks cannot cope. Scotland has some outstanding technologies in this area, which is a relatively unsexy part of renewable energy. Not many other places are doing it. There is now a great opportunity for Scottish Enterprise to attract private sector investment into an organisation similar to the advance forming research centre. That would enable us to marry the technologies of our universities and attract private sector investment to make Scotland a real centre for this type of technology. Those are the kind of areas where we can leverage up our investment and help to support the agenda, which we agree is ambitious.
I have a brief supplementary on that.
As long as it is brief.
Very briefly, we are heading for an economic situation that is not the best possible one. The subprime mortgage problem will work through to an awful lot of the housing retail axis that has driven British economic development to date. Will the prices for industrial premises and housing premises in which you may have interests hold up sufficiently to enable funds to be transferred across to such sectors, which—I totally agree with you—are the future?
Gosh. If I could predict that with any certainty, I would not be doing this job. I pass. You are right: we are going through a period of significant uncertainty. We are not an investment-holding company; we do our work and sell on assets as and when we have done our development work on them. The last thing that I want to do is talk us into a recession, because that will not necessarily be the case, but we have operated through good times and bad and will continue to do so. It is unclear what the current situation's impact will be on residential and commercial property markets.
I have two final quick questions based on the evidence that you have given. I think you said that the payback on voluntary redundancies would be over two to three years.
Yes.
That, of course, is the period of the spending review. Is the logic of that that there will be no net saving to the organisation if the payback is over that period?
The savings would continue long beyond—
I am talking about over the spending review period.
No, the spending review period did not enter our calculations. It is simply the cost of 200 redundancies.
We hope to fund the redundancies from the current year's spend so that we get the benefit in the next three years. There will be a positive impact over the three-year period of the spending review if we can process and pay for those redundancies this year, and we have made provision to do that.
Given your earlier evidence, that is a big if.
Do you mean a big if that we will achieve the numbers?
Yes.
We went through a redundancy programme with directors and senior managers at the tail end of last year. We were pleased with the response that we had from our colleagues and we were able to generate the sort of numbers that we wanted. Early signs are encouraging. We are working hard to put the structures in place so that, over the Christmas holiday period, staff will be able to consider their future and where they fit into the new organisation. We hope that volunteers will come forward and we will be able to do the deals before the end of March, but there is no certainty about that; it is an imponderable. We will not hit the budget directly on the button; it may be a bit more or a bit less, but the budget gives the sort of figures that we are looking for. We want to maximise the amount of money that we spend this year, subject to affordability, so that we get the benefits in the three years following.
Yes, but "this year" is between now and April.
Yes, the end of March.
That would be a big challenge for any organisation.
It would.
How much does it cost to run the local enterprise companies and all the other things that you are sweeping away—and, therefore, how much will be saved?
I do not know whether we have with us the details of the split of the management and administration cost.
We do not have it available today but, as Jack Perry mentioned, we are retaining a regional presence so—
I am not asking that. We keep being told that the figures are significant, but we are never given them.
Let us be clear on a couple of things. The directors of local enterprise companies are all volunteers who have donated their time generously and freely. There is absolutely no cost saving in doing away with them, although we save quite a bit of their time on non-productive activities. There will be savings on the cost of servicing the statutory requirements of those companies. Those savings will be real, although they are not huge. A lot of the savings arise in our ability to delayer the management of the organisation—which is where the 200 redundancies largely come from—that services the local enterprise company network from Atlantic Quay as well as some positions in the local enterprise companies.
It would be helpful to have some written evidence on that.
We can give you the breakdown.
Will there be any impact on VAT charges because of the changes to the network? I read an article about that in The Herald.
That issue has been known about for a long time. The VAT concession was granted by HM Customs and Excise, as it then was, but we knew that, even if we did nothing, it was open to challenge and we could lose it at any time.When we looked at restructuring the network, we knew that there was a risk that changes to the legal structure might trigger a review of and challenge to that arrangement. At this stage, there has been no formal notification but there is a distinct possibility that the VAT benefit will be lost. I stress that that could have happened at any time within the past several years.
Okay, gentlemen. Thank you very much for coming along this morning. We will look to receive as much information as you can provide before the end of December, otherwise it will be difficult for the committee to come to a view on your budget because we do not know what it is or how it will work.If everyone is happy to keep going we will move right on to take evidence from Sandy Cumming, the chief executive of Highlands and Islands Enterprise, and Forbes Duthie, director of corporate services, and Sandy Brady, director of strategy, both of Highlands and Islands Enterprise. We are also joined by Peter Peacock for this part of the evidence session.Mr Cumming, do you want to make any opening remarks? If not, we will just move straight on to questions.
I will make some brief remarks, convener, if I may. Thank you very much for the opportunity to discuss these important issues. I do not intend to indulge in a history lesson, but I will say for the record that I have been involved with economic development in the Highlands and Islands since 1973 and that we have seen dramatic progress in our area during that time. It has been my good fortune to work for the Highlands and Islands Development Board and, currently, for the Highlands and Islands Enterprise network.Today, we are facing a period of significant change. I am excited by that change and the opportunity to create an integrated regional development agency that will prove its worth in 21st century Scotland. Our broad focus will be on three areas. We will support high-growth business and thus raise regional and local growth rates. Critically, we will retain a role in strengthening local communities, especially in the most fragile parts of our area, which, I might add, contain 90 inhabited islands that are very precious to us and an important part of Scotland. Finally, we will create the infrastructure and conditions to improve regional competitiveness.We understand the critical nature of structures and we believe firmly in decentralisation and the empowerment of our staff and local communities. That is at the heart of our organisation's success in the past years, and it will be at the heart of the new organisation.The area has made great progress during the past few years and, going forward, I see more success being built on a successful, dynamic and creative partnership involving the private and public sectors and, critically, the voluntary sector.I will be very happy to take questions.
Thank you very much. We will start with the budget. Before HIE loses an as yet unknown amount to the new skills agency, its budget will be cut by £54 million over the term of the three-year spending review. That will be pretty challenging by anyone's standard, will it not?
For the record, I should say that our normal budget provision—from the previous spending review—will be cut over the next three years by £40 million. I draw the committee's attention to our operating plan—the document has been in the public domain since spring this year. In our forward planning, we identified that the extra resource in this year's budget would not be available in the next three years. The organisation's planning has been based on a budget of grant-in-aid provision of—Forbes Duthie will keep me right—£89.9 million, plus resource accounting of almost £14 million. In any case, that is how we have been planning for the organisation.
My understanding is that the real-terms figure is £54 million over three years. Are you saying that that is not correct?
This year, we have a significantly enhanced budget. We welcome that and, as ever, we will invest that money wisely in the Highlands and Islands to achieve good, positive outcomes. However, we knew that in the order of £10 million of that budget was an uplift that we would not have in the future. It is important to say that we did not plan on the basis of having that extra £10 million in the next three years.
The figure is £40 million, then—this is like an auction. How will you cope with £40 million coming out of your budget? What will no longer be a priority? What will be cut?
One aspect that we have identified in recent years and which we are pretty well down the track of reviewing is the amount of money that we invest in property activity in the Highlands and Islands, which is about £15 million to £20 million in any one year and is probably too high. The modern Highlands and Islands economy is such that there is less market failure in some parts of the Highlands and Islands. We should stimulate the private sector to take more of a leading role in property development. Through several activities, we could reduce our spend on property by up to £10 million a year. That is an immediate, big way in which we could adjust our budget to reflect future provision.
What other spending will be cut? We cannot obtain that information from the Government, because it tells us that that is an operational matter for you, so we ask you for the evidence on what will be cut.
We are talking not so much about a cut as about matching the resource to the area's needs, which has always been our approach. We ask where we get best value for money and the best outcomes for the Highlands and Islands on growing high-growth companies, strengthening our communities and creating the infrastructure to enable the area to be a competitive region. I agree with Scottish Enterprise—we are at a critical stage of operational planning on how the budgets will be cut going forward. I am sorry that I cannot give you chapter and verse on that. The single biggest difference will be in the amount of money that we invest in property.
So by the time that the committee must approve the budget—or otherwise—we will not know your operational plan for the coming financial year.
I say with regret that you will not have the fine detail.
What do you mean by "the fine detail"?
I mean the amount of detail that is in our operating plan, which will become available in spring next year.
Will you give us some idea of the impact that you expect the co-location of your staff with those of other agencies locally to have on your need to maintain your current level of office space? What impact might that have on your budget?
I am committed to co-location and have been for some time, but I think that the committee would agree that co-location is not an easy task. I will give three examples of work in progress. We have committed ourselves to working in a new environment in Golspie in Sutherland, where Scottish Natural Heritage is to procure a new office. We will be co-located in that office alongside other elements of government, instead of having our own individual office.For the past year, we have been working closely with Orkney Islands Council on how we could co-locate in Orkney. We are close to an opportunity, which I hope that we can announce by Christmas, for our staff in Orkney to be co-located, under one roof and on one platform, with some staff who work in economic development in Orkney Islands Council and—I hope—with VisitScotland staff. I am excited by that opportunity.In Inverness, where most but not all of our core is located, we occupy Cowan house. Because we have dispersed staff from Inverness to outwith Inverness, we have some space, so we are negotiating with another public body on whether it can occupy a significant part of our office space. That is the direction of travel; I do not know whether that answers your question.
That is exactly what we are looking for. It would help the committee's work to have an idea of the cost implications of that activity in due course. As the convener said, having that information for the budget process would be convenient for us, but we accept that the timescales involved mean that that might not be possible.My next question relates to your other assets and your access to capital. What is your current asset base, what kind of return do you get on it, and what implications does it have for the budget? In response to a question from the convener, you indicated that your major savings will come from not investing £10 million a year in property. That implies that you have significant amounts of capital assets, on which you have returns. Do you have plans for appropriate disposal of any of those assets? Is it part of your core business to continue to manage that estate, bearing in mind the resource accounting and budgeting problems that Scottish Enterprise has encountered?
In responding, I will involve my colleagues as appropriate. The current valuation of the assets in our property portfolio is in the order of £40 million, which is a considerable amount of money. The reason why we hold those assets is largely historical, but it reflects market failure in almost every sub-economy in the Highlands and Islands. At the moment, we are examining critically whether there is a new way of proceeding and how much property we should own in the future. Instead of investing in a new building that we will own, can we get the private sector to do that, albeit with some assistance from us? I would also like to see whether we could get a social enterprise to own some of our assets. Is that a way forward, in the spirit of community enterprise? We are teasing out many of the options that exist. We need to conclude the exercise as part of our operational planning, so by January or February we need to bring a paper to the board that explains how the system will work in the future, in dialogue with our sponsor team.
Routinely, we sell between £4 million and £5 million-worth of assets a year and recycle the money back into our capital programme. We recognise that it is not HIE's long-term role to be a landlord. Once we have developed and let a property, we should let the market take it forward. That allows us to release and reinvest capital, to get the best out of our resources.As Sandy Cumming outlined, we have about £40 million-worth of property assets. We are considering how we can manage those in a more efficient—and tax-efficient—way. There are a significant number of capital allowances to which we cannot get access at the moment because of our tax position. We will put that issue to the board in January. More efficient management of our property assets would give us the opportunity to generate substantial income, either through rentals or through property sales. We are considering those matters as part of the overall budget process. However, like any business, we would do that anyway, to maximise our efficiency in the future.
The portfolio has been assessed property by property. We have considered which properties we want to retain strategically in the longer term—probably a minority of the total holding. As Forbes Duthie described, we have also identified those properties where we have a stable relationship with a tenant and where some form of disposal, either directly or through a property company, may be the way forward. We have proceeded property by property because we know that the value of properties depends on the part of the Highlands in which they are located. A property in Inverness has a different economic development value from an identical property in Wick or Thurso.
I have a practical question about budget realignment to local authorities and the new skills agency. What progress have you made on that? How are you reaching agreement on the issue? Will there be considerable movement of staff? How are you managing that? What point have you reached in the process?
We do not yet have the complete answer, but I am happy to share information on the work that is in progress. The enterprise networks review required us to introduce the business gateway model in the Highlands and Islands. We are doing that in partnership with local authorities. We have set up a joint task group, which has met once and will meet again soon. We have no doubt that the task of creating an identical business gateway model in the Highlands and Islands, which will be managed and delivered by local authorities, will be completed in early 2008.Budgetary and staffing implications follow from that. On staffing, let me share with the committee that, in Highlands and Islands Enterprise, our staff tend to be multidisciplinary. We can seldom identify people who do solely one job; people do a range of tasks. Going forward, we will need to tease out how many staff we will need to transfer across to deal with functions such as the business gateway, which might currently account for only part of someone's job rather than the whole of it. I do not know whether I have managed to bring that out fully, but that is one of the tasks and challenges that we face.On the new skills agency, we are in a similar position to that of Scottish Enterprise. Our chairman, Willie Roe, is part of the shadow board that has been set up. The programme management board that has been set up is populated by our skills director and one of our senior Careers Scotland people. Their contribution will ensure that the model going forward very much takes account of the needs of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland. Of that, I have no doubt.We believe that there is clarity about some aspects of the changes—for instance, we are in no doubt that we will no longer be involved in the national training programmes, which will be the responsibility of the new body—but we need much greater clarity on whether we will have a role in workforce development. We need to move forward on that.Another skills issue is the need for regionally strategic skills development. For example, I would argue that the UHI Millennium Institute—the critical importance of which I have highlighted to the committee on previous occasions—is in the bag of regional competitiveness. I believe that the new HIE going forward should continue to play a leading role in such transformational projects.Another debate concerns whether HIE will have a role, acting in partnership with others, as a delivery body for the new skills agency in the north of Scotland. In that debate, the cabinet secretary, the shadow board and the programme board are very much considering our involvement, but we do not yet know the answer. I am sorry that we do not have the complete details. We know the minimum, and we are trying to work out how many staff will actually transfer across.
It is interesting that HIE is a bit unclear about where workforce development will sit. In their evidence, the witnesses from Scottish Enterprise seemed to think that workforce development would sit with them. The committee probably needs to seek clarity on that.
Let me come back on that. I have no doubt that we will have a continuing role in growing companies in the Highlands and Islands and that we will play into the skills component of that. That is my interpretation of the decision. I welcome that decision, as it makes sense in terms of account management. However, in addition, we are involved in many other workforce development activities. We work with key bodies such as the Construction Industry Training Board to consider the needs of Highlands and Islands industries in the round. The issue is whether such activities are considered as workforce development. We need to get into the fine detail of interpretation.
HIE's written submission states that its budget for 2008-09 will be £91.8 million. It also states:"To this total will be added an estimated £16.5m in receipts".I have some questions about that. First, what will that figure be for the subsequent year? Is the 2008-09 figure particularly high? Will receipts go up or down? Secondly, how do those receipts break down into the categories of property sales, loan repayments, European funding and what the submission describes as "other sources"?
I ask our finance director, Forbes Duthie, to deal with that.
I am happy to answer that.The £16.5 million is derived from property sales, loan income, investment returns and European income. Going forward, we expect that the level of additional income that the organisation generates will be maintained at around £16.5 million. Of that total, property income accounts for about £9.3 million and loan income for just under £1 million. The other major contributor is European income, which accounts for about £5 million. We very much see that continuing in future years. In the previous year, loan income was somewhat higher because we had a number of non-recurring loans that we put into a particular sector and which were subsequently repaid. However, loan income will be stabilised going forward.
If I heard correctly—I am happy to be corrected—HIE has made £9 million from property sales in one year and hopes that that will remain the case going forward. Did I not just hear that HIE owns about £40 million-worth of assets overall?
Sorry, I clarify that of the £9 million from property, half comes from property sales and half comes from rental income. There are two strands—I consolidated the figure.
My next question is similar to one that I asked Scottish Enterprise. We have had a more comprehensive breakdown of the budget in the past for HIE than the one that we have now. The headings from the previous year's draft budget included "Growing Business", "Skills and Learning", "Global Connections", "Strengthening Communities", "Management and Administration" and "Non-cash budget". Can you give us a breakdown like that for the next three years, within the obvious constraints that we know about?
Not at this stage, I am afraid. As I explained earlier, we are constructing the new organisation with three particular thrusts. Therefore, going forward, we will not have the breakdown, but we must identify very quickly the amount of money that, on a budgeting basis, we intend to invest in those three areas, which are high-growth businesses, strengthening local communities and improving regional competitiveness. Those are the three areas that we will bring back to the committee in due course, once our board has had the opportunity to review the proposed allocations.
The operating plan process does not involve only a top-down approach from the core of HIE; the plan is compiled with input from the local area teams on how they see the mix of those three broad activities locally. We consider the plan from their perspective as well as from a core perspective and try to bring the two together. We are hoping to finalise the operating plan so that we can put it to the HIE board at its February meeting.
HIE's budget will go from £103 million to £91 million and then down to £88 million. We have heard about the three main areas that HIE will focus on, but what will it not focus on?
The single biggest change is that we will not focus so much on property acquisition at our own hand. Following that, we will take a hard look at the emerging priorities. Our clear evidence this morning is that we will invest in key industries in the Highlands and Islands, support fragile communities in the Highlands and Islands and address key local regeneration issues. I will give three examples. The first is the situation in Caithness in light of the rundown of Dounreay. How will we flex our budget to take account of the emerging situation there? The second is the Moray 2020 plan that we already have in place—how will we achieve that? The third is the need, which we will never lose sight of, to achieve sustainable growth in the Western Isles. How can we continue to find in our budget the resource to enable the Western Isles to achieve sustainable growth? Those are big issues, which we must interweave in our budget planning.
I have a follow-up question to Gavin Brown's questions. The letter that we have received from the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth indicates that both HIE and Scottish Enterprise will be monitored on the basis of"three areas—capital income and expenditure (net investment), operational expenditure and management and administration expenditure".Those three areas alone are specified—I am sure that you have seen the letter—in a written description of how you will be monitored by the Government. How do those three areas fit with the three areas that you identified in your response to Gavin Brown?
I think that the three areas that you mention fit in with our relationship with Government. We can manage the business according to those criteria. However, I must also manage the business in a way that gives people reassurance and helps them to understand—this is where the management systems need to be redeveloped—what our approach will mean for building sustainable growth in Orkney, Shetland or the Western Isles. How much will the agency, after its reconstruction, invest in those areas? We must have a sophisticated management system that addresses the three key areas that the Government is asking us to report on in relation to our budget. However, beneath that it must also be possible to examine how we spend our money on the three priorities that I mentioned and on individual economies. For example, what does our investment mean for Argyll and the islands? That is where we are going. We do not see any problem with our ability to report on those areas.
One might see that as consistent with Mr Perry's evidence that there are national priorities and regional priorities—in fairness to Jack Perry, he said that Scottish Enterprise wanted to find a better word than regional. You have described pan-Highlands and Islands priorities and specific priorities for geographic areas, such as Argyll, below that.
Absolutely. I give the example of engineering. It may not be listed specifically among the key sectors, but from my perspective the engineering sector, particularly in Caithness, is one of our greatest assets. We must try to work with the engineering companies in that area to give them the opportunity and capacity to become powerful engines of growth once the Dounreay rundown starts to happen. We will focus where we see opportunity.
Okay. Thank you. The problem for us in scrutinising the budget is that we do not have any numbers behind that.
I accept that.
The best figures that we have suggest that, over the three-year period, Scottish Enterprise's budget will be cut, in real terms, by 14.2 per cent, and HIE's budget will be cut, in real terms, by 20.7 per cent. Do you have a view on why HIE's budget will take a much bigger hit over the three-year period?
I do not have a view on that. There has been a need to make provision for resource accounting within Scottish Enterprise, which has been virtually impossible for the organisation to deal with over the past three years. As you will be aware, we have secured a resource accounting figure of £14 million. I would not say that we have got it easy, but we will have an easier time living within that than Scottish Enterprise will have. I think that there has been an equalisation of the challenge, which is appropriate.Would I rather have an extra £40 million? Of course I would. However, going forward, we need to be smarter about how we create economic impact in the Highlands and Islands. That is what this is about.
Are you concerned that that disproportionately big hit will have a particular impact on some of the more far-flung communities? Proportionately, the role of the local enterprise company is even greater in the Highlands than elsewhere in Scotland, and changing HIE's structure may have an impact. Are you concerned that the budget cut may have a disproportionate effect in some areas?
I cannot give you absolute assurance on that because we are still mid-process in our operational planning. We are into our third round of European funding, and it is critical that we ensure not only that, in partnership with the local authorities and with the investment that will be made available to us over the next three years through the spending review, we get the best impact particularly in the fragile areas of the Highlands and Islands, but that we enable the growth of the Highlands and Islands economy going forward. Sandy Brady may want to add to that.
It is important to understand that we are aiming to raise the economic growth rate of the region as a whole. Nevertheless, we are an agency that works at the local level as well as at the regional level, and we cannot take the whole of the Highlands and Islands forward unless we are able to take forward the constituent parts of it. The nine local economies face different challenges, and we must ensure that the resources do not simply follow where the greatest opportunities lie. Sometimes we must balance that with looking at where the greatest challenges lie—in places such as the Western Isles, our many island communities and the sparsely populated communities of the north and west coasts. We will continue to be active there, with teams on the ground trying to take those areas forward. We believe that, if all the areas of the Highlands move forward at their respective paces, the region as a whole will move forward and make a bigger contribution to the Scottish economy.
You have identified a potential saving of £10 million or so on property acquisition in the next financial year. I presume that that will roll forwards. If I recall correctly, the income from properties that you have developed and sold on is of the order of £4 million to £5 million a year. How does the £10 million reduction compare with your overall property development budget? What are the implications of your no longer acquiring, developing and re-selling property for your income three years hence?
The broad figures are that, instead of investing up to £20 million, we will kick out £10 million. You are absolutely right to say that we currently have a rental income of just over £4 million. Should we choose to dispose of a significant amount of our estate, that would have an impact on the contribution of rental to our income. That contribution will be less than £4.5 million in the future; the question is whether it will be £1 million, £2 million or £3 million less. As part of the financial planning going forward, Forbes Duthie is factoring that into our operational planning right now.
Will you be able to give the committee any information on that before the end of the year?
Sorry, no. We have to present the whole operating plan to our board and, as Sandy Brady said, that will be done in the early part of next year.
Good morning, gentlemen. It is good to get some good news this morning. I am glad to hear that you do not recognise the description of yourselves that appeared in The Press and Journal yesterday. According to the headline, you were going to suffer a £100 million hit. I am glad that you have clarified that the reduction will be £40 million, not £100 million.
Hallelujah!
Absolutely. The article also mentioned centralisation, which was touched on earlier today. Are you planning to centralise any of your services within the Highlands and Islands? Will HIE make a proportionately greater saving from the abolition of the LECs than Scottish Enterprise? Your budget is a quarter of Scottish Enterprise's budget, yet you have almost as many LECs.
Centralisation is often identified with Inverness. That disappoints me, because the hallmark of our agency—particularly in the past seven years—has been to counter that trend. We have centralised our financial processing not in Inverness, but in Benbecula. Technology and management processes allow us to do that, and we are determined, as the executive management team of the organisation, to continue in that direction. However, while we have been very successful in that area, there is a threat. A lot of the activity that we carry out in Benbecula consists of dealing with national training programmes. I am concerned that I will need to convince the new skills body not only of the need to continue to carry out the national training programmes administration in the Western Isles, but of our desire to grow the capacity of the Western Isles to have more jobs. I register that concern with the committee—we could lose those jobs if a different policy is adopted by skills development Scotland. We really are committed to decentralisation: wherever it is possible to do so, we will decentralise. In percentage terms, there are fewer staff working in Inverness than there were when HIE was set up. The direction of travel from the Government has been clear, and we have to—and we will—go further on that. My colleagues will give you an appropriate answer to the question about LECs.
We do not have figures for the savings—given that we have a similar number of LECs to Scottish Enterprise, we will benefit more from that reduction than Scottish Enterprise will. However, it is hard to quantify that saving, given the nature of the work that is involved, staffing and the work of servicing the committees and boards. However, in percentage terms, given the overall budget, you are correct—the saving for us will be a proportionately larger saving.
I am glad to hear that, and I am pleased that you have confirmed that HIE is a body that is into decentralisation—and not centralisation, as was stated in the press. I will ask you the same question that I asked Scottish Enterprise. To what extent do you think that the reduction in your budget will be balanced by the increase in budgets for road, rail and ferry services, social enterprise and energy, and the reduction in business rates for small businesses? Previously, you might have put some of your funds into those areas, but now that funds are available for them, you will not need to do that. You might be able to do other things. Will that reduce the problem created by the reduction in your budget?
Absolutely. I have to admit that the success that the Highlands and Islands region has enjoyed over the last 30 to 40 years is not solely due to our agency. HIE has been good, but it has not been that good, as some members will confirm, although I would like to believe that it has played a critical role. The region's success is about the power of the combination of investments that have been made. I said to colleagues today that one of our real success stories in the past 10 years has been the emergence of Lifescan Scotland in Inverness. My organisation will probably claim total credit for that, but it could be argued—and a fair person would do so—that the decision to create a first-class regional hospital in Inverness was one of the main reasons why Lifescan Scotland went there. Economic development is about taking every single opportunity in the round. Our role is to be extremely creative and innovative and to work with partners and—critically—the public, private and voluntary sectors in order to make the biggest impact in the Highlands and Islands. The future will be different, but it can still be successful—I have no doubt about that.
A good example is the renewable energy sector, in which we have invested quite a lot in the past five to 10 years. Given that the sector is growing—as we heard earlier—we are hopeful that other major national sources of funding will drive the industry forward in the Highlands and Islands.We put money into the European Marine Energy Centre in Orkney, the Arnish yard and the fabrication works at Vestas-Celtic Wind Technology near Campbeltown, and it would be great to see their capacity grow. We will not necessarily have to fund that growth, but we want those organisations to grow because they are drivers of the future in the Highlands.
I have a supplementary question on the dissolution of the LECs and its consequences. Will it result in the loss of any jobs outwith Cowan house, in places such as the Western Isles, Argyll or Caithness?
It almost certainly will. It would be wrong for me to say that it will not because we are going to slim down the organisation. The budget is clearly being reduced—the figure that I am giving the committee today is a £40 million reduction over three years.The organisation's staffing will reduce through a number of factors, but primarily through transfers. We know that Careers Scotland staff will transfer to the new agency. We have yet to determine the implications of setting up the business gateway or how many staff will move from Highlands and Islands Enterprise to local authorities. Likewise, given the uncertainty about some aspects of skills development Scotland, it is unclear how many of our employees who work on skills will move to the new agency.As we made clear in our written evidence, we propose to introduce a voluntary severance scheme, as Scottish Enterprise has done, which might slim down the agency by up to 50 staff. Like Jack Perry, we have to determine which people we can sign off under the severance scheme. To make the organisation successful, we need to have the best people in the right locations. In answer to your question, I cannot say today that there will not be reductions outwith Inverness. We will slim down in Inverness, but I think that the cuts will be made throughout the Highlands and Islands.
That is pretty sobering for those of us who represent constituencies in the Highlands and Islands.
Thank you for your courtesy, convener, in letting me ask some questions. To return that courtesy, I will be happy to share the figures that I have on the matter with Dave Thompson.I want to pin down Sandy Cumming's response to Lewis Macdonald's final question, so that I am clear about it. At present, HIE has offices in Orkney, Shetland, Caithness, the Western Isles, Argyll, Lochaber, Aviemore, Moray and Inverness. None of those offices will be exempt from your search for 50 voluntary redundancies, and those voluntary redundancies will be over and above the transfers.
Correct.
On both points?
Yes.
The in-year adjustment that you mentioned for 2007-08 is obviously more than £10 million; you said that you will not get £10 million next year and that you are budgeting for that. How much is the in-year adjustment this year? How much additional cash are you getting above your base budget?
We will invest in the order of £118 million this year. On top of that, we have a resource budget of about £14 million. I do not know whether that answers your point, but that is certainly the figure that we are moving towards as we get to the end of the financial year.
In the figures for 2008-09 that you supplied in your written submission, the £14 million of resource cover, which is equivalent to the money that you mentioned in resource cover for the current year, is held within the total of £91.8 million, whereas this year you have £118 million plus resource cover of about £14 million. Actually, the comparable figure to £103 million in the current year would be £118 million plus £14 million. Is that fair?
I understand that point of view. We have additional income in the current financial year, which Forbes Duthie will be happy to explain. We have—
I understand that. I am just trying to establish what the headline figure is. Your actual spending this year, compared with the £103 million in the figures that we have, would be £118 million, and on top of that you have resource cover of about £14 million.
Indeed. Correct.
Actually, I now realise that my figures are an underestimate.Did you also have an in-year allocation in addition to your base budget in the previous financial year, 2006-07? Is it a fairly common pattern in recent years that you have had in-year additions to your budget for one reason or another?
Yes, indeed.
Of roughly the same order?
No, not as much.
Is that principally because of the Caithness money this year, which relates to the rundown of Dounreay?
No.
Is it for something else?
We were able to secure the additional resource for a targeted programme of capital projects that was agreed by the Government at the time. We are progressing those projects this year. During the course of the year, our board made a commitment that, going forward, we would try to find £12 million in addition to the normal resource to help with the regeneration of the Caithness economy.
Okay.I want to focus on the impact on HIE's activities of the proposed changes. I have known Sandy Cumming for many years and I recognise that he is one of life's eternal optimists, who will always try to do the best in any situation. Even he says that HIE's activities will be "significantly adjusted" in the future. The submission goes on to say:"HIE faces a significant challenge".In response to Lewis Macdonald and to others, you have indicated that an easy option would be to reduce your property spend by £10 million. If that is an easy option, it rather begs the question why it was not done before. What other programmes will you have to trim significantly? I presume that the 50 members of staff you will lose have been hard at work on focused pieces of work. Those 50 people represent a significant portion of your core staff. Their removal must have impacts on people and on businesses in the Highlands and Islands. Could you describe what those impacts might be?
Our present staff have had the capacity to enable us to invest £117 million or £118 million this year. From an efficiency and effectiveness point of view, it goes without saying that if we have a smaller sum to invest, we will not need the same number of staff. That is difficult for us as an agency, because we regard ourselves as an exemplary employer. We have won a number of awards for being a good organisation to work for.At the end of the day, what is at stake is economic development in the Highlands and Islands. The success of our agency is about the quality of the people who work for us and our capacity to meet new challenges. We must continually refresh the organisation's skills base. As we move forward, we must think hard about whether we have enough skills capacity to meet the challenge of growing high-growth companies in the Highlands and Islands. New training investment is an area that requires deep consideration.I apologise, because I know that you asked me what programmes apart from property would have to be trimmed, but we cannot provide you with another significant one-off example today. A large chunk of the reduction in spend will come from property—it is the big one.
I want to pick up an issue that Marilyn Livingstone raised. In your submission, you say that your base budget this year was £103 million, which will go down to £91 million and then £88 million, at which level it will hold steady. You say that further transfers will be made, for the reasons that you have set out. In broad terms, what order of figure are we talking about? Is it £2 million, £5 million, £10 million or £15 million? Can you give us a feel for the amount that will be transferred, particularly for the business gateway? Although you do not operate the business gateway at the moment, your submission says that"broadly comparable services are provided by Local Enterprise Companies".Under the new arrangement, responsibility for those services will be transferred to local authorities. What order of costs are we talking about? I will not hold you to the detail of what you say.
We are talking about a range. There is a worst-case scenario and a best-case scenario, depending on one's point of view.
It depends which side one is on.
Indeed. At the moment, I firmly believe that a minimum of about £15 million will be transferred.
A minimum of £15 million?
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Nov 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 28 November 2007 Committee business · 1
- Budget Process 2008-09 Evidence session · 389
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.