Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Video Evidence

Tuesday 12 September 2000 Procedures Committee Committee business 8 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Item 12 is a report on a submission from Shelter about the use of video evidence. We expected that someone from Shelter would be here to speak to that submission, but that seems not to be the case—I am having a frantic look round the audience.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

No, although given the legal opinion in paragraph 6 of our paper, it might have been entitled to do so. We are invited to come to a decision about whether, or in what circumstances, non-interactive videos might be accepted as evidence. The legal opinion in paragraph 6 is that a video is, in effect, a document for our purposes, and that it is admissible.

Janis Hughes Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

I note the legal position, and I feel that video evidence would be acceptable, but there are a couple of points that we must consider. We have discussed video-conferencing at length, and that might be an option to suggest to people who consider submitting video evidence. I would be concerned about loss of interaction, because there would be no capacity for the committee to question the people who were giving evidence. In addition, if people would rather submit a video than attend a committee in person because of confidentiality issues, there is always the option of taking the evidence in private session.With regard to videos, I have a slight concern about authenticity. If someone is presenting video evidence, we have only their word that they are who they say they are. If someone were invited to come along, they would be sent a letter, which would authenticate who they were. I urge caution. We should consider ways round those problems, but they are a worry.

Gil Paterson SNP Central Scotland
link

I agree with much of what Janis said. Video evidence should be used sparingly. With some individuals, there is no chance that they would walk through the door to give evidence to the committee; we have all had experience of such individuals. Video evidence would give those individuals an opportunity to take part, just as does writing a letter, and I would accept video evidence in that context. However, if someone writes a letter but is capable of coming here—not necessarily here, but to a forum such as this—I get a bit worried.I am cautious about saying that video evidence is wrong or should be discouraged. In fact, in some cases, it should be encouraged—we should try to achieve a balance.

Donald Gorrie LD Central Scotland
link

Janis Hughes raised some important points. The paper suggests that a written transcript should be produced, which is fair enough—where that would be possible. Perhaps we could go without a transcript if producing one would cause problems for the people who submit videos. We could deal with authentication if Shelter, or whichever organisation was involved, were to produce a written transcript and say, "We guarantee that the people who have spoken to you are three old-age pensioners from the outer isles who could not get to Edinburgh. Their names are X, Y and Z."The more information we get, the better. Coming here is not a serious option for people who are frail or far away, or for children, but such people should not be prevented from speaking to us. It would be better if we could have the interaction of video-conferencing. In remote areas, that may be a problem, and a video would be better than nothing. We would be able to see people as they were speaking, and although we could not ask them questions, we would get an impression of their integrity. The use of videos should be encouraged.

Iain Smith LD North East Fife
link

There is no difference between a video and a written document. Written evidence is acceptable and there is no reason why video, audio or even computer disk evidence should not be acceptable, but for the difficulty that people will have in accessing that information. If someone wanted to see Shelter's evidence, they could read it in the Official Report or in the committee's report, because evidence is published. However, if evidence is given by video, it will not be published and therefore people will not necessarily be able to see, or check, the evidence that was given.Another problem with that particular medium is that the people who produce the video could manipulate it. One would have to be careful to watch out for little jerks of the head to ensure that the words are there and that a "not", or whatever, has not been sliced out of a sentence.Video images can be very strong. If the proposal to allow video evidence is accepted, I will feel a bit sorry for members of the Rural Affairs Committee regarding the videos that that committee will receive during its consideration of the Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill. Both sides will submit equally strong videos that make a particular case, and neither side's videos will be balanced or shed much light on the topic.The use of video evidence should be considered carefully, but I see no reason in principle why it should not be treated in the way suggested in paragraph 6 of the paper. It should be treated as a document. In other words, it should be treated as written evidence.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We have a fair amount of agreement. Videos are allowable, and it is desirable that people should be steered towards interactive video rather than pre-recorded, non-interactive video. Wherever possible, it would be appropriate for a video to be accompanied by a transcript. Where a video is sponsored or procured by an agency such as Shelter, which wants to present video evidence, that agency should authenticate the people who appear in the video. When individuals submit videos, all we want is a name and address, as that is what we would accept from someone who has written a letter. We want to be able to satisfy ourselves that the person is genuine and has genuine problems and points of view.

  1. Scottish Parliament Procedures Committee Tuesday 12 September 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Business Overview Committee business · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 34
  4. Conveners Liaison Group Procedure · 10
  5. Committee Procedures Committee business · 19
  6. Private Legislation Committee business · 19
  7. Non-Executive Bills Unit Committee business · 11
  8. Amendments to Motions Committee business · 15
  9. Manuscript Amendments Committee business · 24
  10. Timetables of Bills Committee business · 9
  11. Housing Stock Transfer Inquiry Report Committee business · 5
  12. Video Evidence Committee business · 8
  13. Security Staff (Powers) Committee business · 24
  14. Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body and Parliamentary Bureau Minutes (Publication) Committee business · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.